Advertise on podcast: Bauerle

Today, once again we discuss the Nancy Guthrie abduction, including with former Erie County District Attorney John Flynn. At this point, now that Nancy Guthrie has been missing for over two weeks, what is your interest level in this case? Tired of hearing about it or have you grown more intrigued as more time has passed?

Erie County District Attorney John Flynn joins the show to discuss all the latest in the Nancy Guthrie case, the new video released by Savannah Guthrie recently, the process investigators are going through testing the glove found for DNA, and more.

On the program today, we get an update on a fatal bus crash that happened in Pembroke last August, we ask if you've ever seen an adult meltdown in public, and a couple Valentine's Day related topics, what is your body count, and where do you go to meet people, especially ones that align with your beliefs and values?

Today, there were some new developments in the Nancy Guthrie abduction case, such as the discovery of a pair of gloves near Nancy Guthrie's home that bore resemblance to the ones worn by the masked individual captured on her doorbell cam before she went missing, a second video taken near Guthrie's home was released showing a person wearing a backpack and grey sweatshirt similar to the ones in the aforementioned doorbell cam footage. To react to these new developments, we speak with former Special Agent in charge of the Buffalo Office of the FBI Bernie Tolbert, Defense Attorney Paul Cambria, and former Erie County District Attorney John Flynn join the show.

Shortly before the recording of this podcast, more security footage was released pertaining to the abduction of Nancy Guthrie. This particular footage was captured at a home in Tuscon, AZ near the home of Nancy Guthrie shortly before 2 a.m. on February 1st, 2026, that showed a man wearing a grey jacket and backpack similar to the one worn by the masked individual at Nancy Guthrie's front door before she was taken. We discuss this latest development in the case with former Erie County District Attorney John Flynn, and more.

Criminal defense attorney Paul Cambria joins the show to discuss the detention recently of Carlos Palazuelos in relation to the Nancy Guthrie abduction. Palazuelos was detained for a few hours before being ultimately released, and later claimed he didn't know who Nancy or the Guthrie family was and that he wasn't involved with the kidnapping. We discuss that detention, if there could be any recourse for the detainee, and other facets of the case.

Bernie Tolbert, former Special Agent in Charge of the Buffalo Office of the FBI joins the show to discuss the discovery of a pair of gloves that resembles those worn by the masked subject captured on Nancy Guthrie's doorbell camera the night she went missing. The gloves were found near Nancy Guthrie's home, one of which was reportedly discovered only a mile and a half away from the home. We discuss this discovery and what the next steps are for the FBI.

On the show today, we continue to bring you all the latest developments in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, and we speak to former Erie County DA John Flynn on that front, and to round out the show, what are song song lyrics you misheard over the year?

Former Erie County District Attorney and current partner at Lippes Mathias LLP John Flynn joins the show to discuss the latest details in the Nancy Guthrie case, including the video of the masked subject in front of her front door released by the FBI, the man detained for questioning, the searches of Annie Guthrie's home, and more.

The FBI released still pictures and a video of a masked individual in front of Nancy Guthrie's door the night she vanished from her Tucson, AZ home. What did you make of this revelation, do you believe it will help significantly in regard to a resolution of this case?

Alex Stone, who has reported on the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie for ABC News, joins the show to give us the latest on the case, including the still images and video released by the FBI that shows an armed and masked subject in front of Nancy Guthrie's front door the night she went missing.

On the show today, we hear from meteorologist Andy Parker on the potential for freezing rain tomorrow in Western New York, former Erie County District Attorney John Flynn on the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, and cybersecurity expert Arun Vishwanath about the controversial Ring doorbell Super Bowl commercial regarding their 'Search Party' feature, which sparked the conversation about lost pets. Ever lost one? If you were able to find them, how did you do it?

Former Erie County DA and current partner at Lippes Mathias, LLC joins the show to discuss the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, as today, February 9th, is a deadline that is contained in an alleged ransom note sent to news outlets. We discuss all the available facts of the case, the videos that have been released by Savannah and family pleading for their mother's safe return, answering any questions you may have, and more.

Cybersecurity expert Arun Vishwanath joins the show to discuss a Ring Doorbell commercial during the big game yesterday that turned some heads, and not in a good way. The ad touted Ring's 'Search Party' feature, which can enable participating outdoor ring cameras to begin looking for potential matches if a person reports a lost dog in the Ring app. Vishwanath breaks down the feature, and why it has struck so many as controversial.

Today, we continue to talk about the mysterious disappearance of Nancy Guthrie. We haven't learned much new information between yesterday and today's show, but now that you've had a couple days to ruminate on the facts of the case, what is the most plausible theory to you about what happened to Nancy Guthrie? Do you believe we will have a happy ending in this case?