Advertise on podcast: They Remade It: The Movie Comparison Podcast

It's once more time to kick off the Halloween season at "They Remade It" with a less-than-great movie that many remember fondly, "I Know What You Did Last Summer"! Did you know it got a legacy sequel last year, just like it's best friend "Scream" did? Does the lega-sequel do the original film justice? And just how many Scooby-Doo actors can we fit into horror movies? Also in this episode is a review of the new "Resident Evil" film, a review of the recent "Silent Hill" game, a brief argument about "Scream", and what makes a slasher killer legacy worthy. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 26:35 - 33:58 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, dramatic thrillers are back on the docket as the original "Manchurian Candidate" is compared to it's early aughts remake. One takes a slightly satirical look at the Red Scare, while the other is a more serious approach to the War on Terror and corporate influence in politics. Does one happen to handle it's material better than the other? And between Lansbury and Streep, who is more wickedly vile in their roles here? Also in this episode is a long diatribe on "Coyote vs. Acme", John MaGiver and a carton of milk getting shot, a discussion on music in dream sequences, and we learn Stu and Jacob's activation phrases. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 21:49 - 33:15 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, it's time to talk swords and sandals once more as the Hyborian Age is revisited by Stuart and Jacob? You've heard of Conan, but how familiar are you with the character of Red Sonja? What of these twin movies 40 years apart, which holds up and displays better sensibilities? And why is Arnold in the 1985 one but NOT just playing Conan? Also in this episode are some unfortunate news about a now-lost podcast episode, far too many references to Robert Altman's "Popeye", CGI versus practical puppets once again, and a deep exploration (kinda) of the modern day Red Sonja comics. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 15:15 - 22:10 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob dive into horror before October has even arrived to discuss the merits of Hollywood's most famous and enduring monster. One movie with a creature large in size, the other large in scope, but which towers above the other in terms of quality? How do character arcs and motivations add to (or detract from) the pictures' overall quality? And why did there have to be giant bugs? Also in this episode are ruminations on both "Spider-Man: Brand New Day" and "The Odyssey", a discussion of whether Kong is a gorilla or an "ape-esque creature", more complaints about prolonged runtimes, and almost just as much talk about Godzilla as there is talk about Kong himself. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 26:00 - 33:22 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob not only discuss sports again after a long hiatus on the topic, but they bring back in wringer Adam Sandler to make the whole thing complete. Now they've both stated before that they aren't the biggest fans of the Sand-man's comedy, but will they change their tune watching his first feature and comparing it with his latest? What of the unfortunate bevy of dead stars from the first film that can't appear in the sequel? And why does Rob Schneider exist? Also in this episode is a prolonged discussion of a secret movie on Apple TV that Stu likes more than anyone else does, talks about humor that's aged like milk, the why of Sandler, and Stu and Jacob plan their own celebrity golf partners. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 23:35 - 31:56 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob once more take a look at heists and romance as they compare the two versions of "The Thomas Crown Affair". How does changing something as simple as a bank robbery to an art heist make a world of difference in the intrigue? And what of the connections between McQueen/Dunaway and Brosnan/Russo? Join the two as they dissect character dynamics, pacing, and endings of both films. And what of the Oscar winning song "Windmills of Your Mind" - does it hold up? Also in this episode are bits on "Undertone" and "Disclosure Day", a debate about endings and their relation to theming, heists of dinosaur bones and the Nevada Simpson's house, and a movie Stuart watched but cannot for the LIFE of him remember the name of. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 30:39 - 39:19 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this enchanting episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob go all the way back to Disney's first full-length animated feature and compare it against the recent box-office debacle that was 2025's "Snow White". What happens a charming and beautiful fairy tale adaptation receives a 21st-century reimagining with over-politicization? Why the hell did Dopey NEED to speak at all, was it really that important? And while we're on that topic, why is Disney CGI still so atrociously ugly after a decade of these live-action remakes? You know what, I'm getting ahead of myself, just listen for yourselves. Also in this episode are thoughts on the recent "Backrooms" feature, praise for proper costuming, a HUGE tirade against the current state of Disney and other corporations, and Stuart and Jacob's cute little dwarf names. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 35:00 - 41:24 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this very spicy episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob embark on a journey through time and morality as they compare two adaptations of a Buddhist parable turned horror story: the hauntingly beautiful "Onibaba" from 1964 and its modern reimagining, "The Dreadful," set during the War of the Roses. There are some hot takes flying back and forth in this one, something that hasn't been seen for quite a while on the program, so be sure to tune into this one! And maybe check out the movies beforehand as well, prior to listening. Haven't mentioned that enough. Because if you AREN'T... what are you doin'? Also in this episode are a prolonged "video game corner" with the hosts, when black and white as a choice is the most evocative, symbolism run amok, and a Nostalgia Critic rant asking why the 100 Acre Woods gang is so disrespectful to Rabbit. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 18:40 - 28:38 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob turn the volume up to 11 as they dive into the world of rock mockumentaries with a comparison of the iconic "This Is Spinal Tap" and its long-awaited sequel "Spinal Tap II." What makes the original such a funny, comedic staple in the genre and how do the aging rockers of the legasequel compare? How many cameos are too many? And how, most importantly of all, does the music compare? Also in this episode are thoughts on the new Super Meat Boy game, that upcoming "Pressure" movie for some reason, discussions on Documentary Now, and a little music quiz for Stuart to suffer through. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 24:21 - 32:17 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob go through yet another musical as they're looking at two takes on Victor Hugo's classic novel. One of them isn't even a musical, huh?! Yes, similarly to previous topic "The Phantom of the Opera", there are non-musical versions that have been eclipsed by the ones with songs. How do things hold up? Is the story better to watch when people aren't belting out tunes? How is Liam Neeson against Hugh Jackman? And is Russell Crow's singing really that bad? Also in this episode are thoughts on recent films like "Hoppers" and "Project Hail Mary", talks about the struggles of adapting classic literature that neither of them have read, musical analysis from non-professionals, and "The Man in the Iron Mask" on Broadway?! All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 25:50 - 33:14 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob tackle the tumultuous terrain of marital discord with a comparison of two adaptations of "The War of the Roses." Danny DeVito's dark comedy from 1989, and Jay Roach's more modern and very slightly lighter take. Are these features too dark? How many antics are too many? Will this episode lead to Stuart and Jacob getting a separation drafted up with their attorneys? Tune in and find out! Also in this episode are discussions on "Resident Evil: Requiem", discussions on when dark comedies are too dark, the truth behind Olivia Colman's EpiPen, and a brief synopsis of "Jack the Bear". All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 19:55 - 27:35 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob delve into the realms of time travel with a comparison of two adaptations of H.G. Wells' classic tale, "The Time Machine". There are plenty of differences in how motivations are captured, but what of the characters? And how do the machines and the set designs differ? And what of the Uber-Morlock?! Also featured in this episode is an up-top gaming corner with "Abiotic Factor" and "Crisol: Theater of Idols", magnetic rings versus holograms, the influence of Planet of the Apes on future "future Earth" stories, and the alluring nature of ancient Egypt. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 17:52 - 28:42 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob kick off season 9 (yes, 9!) of the show with a thrilling comparison of two dystopian action films, with the original transporting us to the far off year of 2017. The duo dives into the absurd creativity of the original, and put it up against a much more realistic (at least by today's standards) take on what our modern day looks like. I mean hey, ultimately both of these are reflections of their times in certain ways, that's what makes a compelling dystopian story! But the more the entertainment landscape changes, the more it stays the same... Also featured in this episode are bits and bobs about Fallout's season 2, the effectiveness of Arnold's image, game shows vs reality shows, and the monster that is Dynamo. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 27:13 - 34:53 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]

Stuart and Jacob have made it through yet another year, but they aren't done talking yet! They have the whole of 2025 to go over, and they have some thoughts on a range of topics (and maybe a rant or two as well). Throughout the course of this longer than average episode, they discuss varying aspects of the year, reviewing The Oscars , upcoming releases, a few of the individuals that were lost, and they reflect on their favorite (and least favorite) films that they saw this past year. Happy Holidays, and to a prosperous new year! ---------- Socials ---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on [email protected]

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob are joined by special guest Hannah as they take on a decade spanning musical, with examinations of the 1982 and 2014 films (and the Disney produced, made-for-TV 1999 version). Charm is explored and nostalgia expounded upon as they look upon the many memorable performances of 1982m, look at how they were done on television with a smaller budget, and then jump all the way ahead to modern times to view a story that could be anything OTHER than Annie! Why does this musical endure for audiences, and how do you iterate on what many consider to be a timeless tale? Is there a place for the whimsical in a world that feels increasingly sterile? And just how many times can one mention "Little Girls" before it gets weird? Also featured in this episode are a brief dive into "Winter Burrow", praise for Carol Burnett and Albert Finney, Jamie Foxx's germaphobia, and some collar-tugging enjoyment of Punjab. All this and more on They Remade It! Plot Synopsis Timestamps: 16:35 - 28:06 ----------Socials---------- @theyremadeit.bsky.social on Bluesky [email protected]