Advertise on podcast: Crimes and Consequences

For more than forty-five years, Richard Phillips lived under a sentence that told him he would die in prison. Outside, his children grew up, Detroit changed, and the man whose testimony had helped convict him of murder died without ever facing charges for the killing. Phillips kept insisting that he was innocent, but insistence could not overcome a jury’s verdict. His appeals brought brief openings, then reversals and more years behind bars. When he finally walked out at seventy-one, the question was no longer simply whether an innocent man had been imprisoned. It was how a story with contradictions at its center had survived for nearly half a century—and why evidence that could expose those contradictions had taken so long to matter. Behind Phillips’s conviction lay the murder of twenty-one-year-old Gregory Harris, a witness with his own reasons to talk, and a truth the justice system would spend decades failing to uncover.

For more than forty-five years, Richard Phillips lived under a sentence that told him he would die in prison. Outside, his children grew up, Detroit changed, and the man whose testimony had helped convict him of murder died without ever facing charges for the killing. Phillips kept insisting that he was innocent, but insistence could not overcome a jury’s verdict. His appeals brought brief openings, then reversals and more years behind bars. When he finally walked out at seventy-one, the question was no longer simply whether an innocent man had been imprisoned. It was how a story with contradictions at its center had survived for nearly half a century—and why evidence that could expose those contradictions had taken so long to matter. Behind Phillips’s conviction lay the murder of twenty-one-year-old Gregory Harris, a witness with his own reasons to talk, and a truth the justice system would spend decades failing to uncover.

For nearly three decades, wherever Shirley Winters went, tragedy seemed to follow. Children died, homes burned, and a grieving mother repeatedly emerged from the ashes. But was Shirley the victim of unimaginable misfortune, or the woman responsible for it? When a toddler's mysterious death in 2006 prompted investigators to reopen decades-old cases, they uncovered a chilling pattern of suspicious fires, buried secrets, and murdered children. This week on Crimes & Consequences, we unravel the disturbing case of Shirley Winters, a mother whose darkest secrets followed her long after the flames went out.

In August 2013, 20-year-old single mother Amber Smith went out for drinks with a friend in Fort Collins, Colorado, never imagining the night would end in unimaginable violence. Hours later, police discovered her naked, bound with duct tape, brutally beaten, and abandoned in a secluded park. She had been violently sexually assaulted, strangled, and left with life-threatening injuries. Miraculously, Amber survived, but her attacker disappeared without a trace. For four years, she lived with the terrifying knowledge that the man who nearly killed her was still out there. When a DNA breakthrough finally exposed his identity, the truth was more horrifying than Amber could have imagined. Her attacker hadn't simply escaped justice—he had found his way back into her life, becoming someone she trusted with her darkest memories.

On the northern edge of Amarillo, Texas, the land stretches outward beneath an enormous sky. There are few natural barriers to slow the wind as it sweeps across the Panhandle, carrying dust through cattle yards, oil fields, church parking lots, and neighborhoods built along a rigid grid. Amarillo has long been a place defined by powerful institutions: ranching, football, evangelical Christianity, and Pantex, the nearby government facility where nuclear weapons have been assembled and dismantled. The city’s association with Pantex earned it an unsettling nickname—Bomb City. In the late 1990s, however, another kind of volatility was developing inside Amarillo. It could be seen in restaurant parking lots and high-school hallways, in the insults shouted from passing cars, and in the lines teenagers drew between themselves. On one side were the young people who seemed to fit comfortably inside the city’s established culture: athletes, cheerleaders, popular students, and the young men commonly called “white hats” because of the collegiate baseball caps many of them wore. On the other were punks, skateboarders, artists, Goths, and others whose clothes and music announced that they had no intention of fitting in. Brian Deneke belonged to the latter group--Brian's mohawk hair was like a target on his back. And one sad day in December 1997, the conflict between these groups came to a head and resulted in tragedy.

In the fall of 2019, Tiffany Hill was trying to build a safer life for herself and her three children in Vancouver, Washington. The thirty-five-year-old former Marine had spent years learning how to remain composed under pressure, but the danger she now faced was not something she could leave behind on a battlefield. It followed her into restaurants, appeared on her phone, shadowed her daily routines, and eventually became the subject of police reports, court hearings, and increasingly urgent pleas for protection. Tiffany knew the man she feared better than any detective, prosecutor, or judge ever could, and as the weeks passed, she became convinced that his behavior was escalating. She did what people in danger are told to do: she documented it, reported it, sought protection, and repeatedly asked authorities to listen. By November, the question was no longer whether Tiffany was frightened. The question was whether anyone could keep enough distance between her and the person she feared before that distance disappeared altogether.

On the morning of May 5, 2009, police entered a quiet suburban home in Columbia, Illinois, and discovered a scene that seemed almost impossible: Sheri Coleman and her two young sons, Garett and Gavin, had been strangled in their beds, while threatening messages were spray-painted across the walls. Their husband and father, Chris Coleman, was miles away at the gym but investigators soon began questioning whether the threats that had terrified the family for months were really the work of a mysterious enemy. Behind the image of a devoted husband, father, former Marine, and security chief for a prominent televangelist lay a secret relationship, a marriage in crisis, and a trail of digital and forensic evidence that prosecutors said exposed an elaborate attempt to manufacture an alibi for murder. In Thou Shall Not Kill Your Wife And Kids we unravel the Chris Coleman case; from the ominous threats and horrific discovery inside the Coleman home to the affair, investigation, courtroom battle, and the evidence that ultimately sent Coleman to prison for the murders of his entire family.

In 1974, Paul John Knowles embarked on a violent, cross-country crime spree that would leave a trail of murder from Florida to the Pacific Northwest. Charming, handsome, and dangerously unpredictable, Knowles used his easy confidence to gain trust; earning him the chilling nickname “The Casanova Killer.” In this episode of Crimes & Consequences, we follow Knowles from his troubled beginnings and repeated escapes from custody through the months of violence that made him one of the most notorious American serial killers of the 1970s. We examine the victims, the crimes investigators could confirm, the murders Knowles claimed as his own, and the dramatic manhunt that finally brought his killing spree to an end.

Before Florence Hildreth’s name appeared in police reports and courtroom records, it belonged to a woman whose life was measured in familiar places, ordinary routines, and the people who knew her. Then something happened that transformed those everyday details into evidence and left investigators trying to understand not only how Florence had died, but what had been unfolding beyond the notice of those around her. The answers would emerge slowly, through conflicting accounts, carefully examined clues, and questions that became more unsettling the longer they remained unresolved. At the center of it all was Florence—a woman whose story deserved to be remembered as more than the crime that brought her life to an end.

In 1974, Paul John Knowles embarked on a violent, cross-country crime spree that would leave a trail of murder from Florida to the Pacific Northwest. Charming, handsome, and dangerously unpredictable, Knowles used his easy confidence to gain trust; earning him the chilling nickname “The Casanova Killer.” In this episode of Crimes & Consequences, we follow Knowles from his troubled beginnings and repeated escapes from custody through the months of violence that made him one of the most notorious American serial killers of the 1970s. We examine the victims, the crimes investigators could confirm, the murders Knowles claimed as his own, and the dramatic manhunt that finally brought his killing spree to an end.

On a warm Saturday morning in July 2006, Sarah Walker began what should have been an ordinary day at work. At forty years old, she had built a successful career selling homes in the rapidly growing communities north of Dallas, and that weekend she was scheduled to spend the day at a model home in McKinney, Texas. The work was familiar: greeting prospective buyers, answering questions, and helping strangers imagine a future inside a house that was not yet theirs. By early afternoon, however, the quiet model home would become the center of a homicide investigation that would stretch across years and ultimately become a death-penalty case. What happened to Sarah Walker would leave her family grieving, challenge investigators with a complicated trail of evidence, and eventually bring a man named Kosoul Chanthakoummane into a courtroom where the question of what happened inside that house would be examined in painstaking detail.

In the summer of 1988, Philadelphia was shaken by the murder of four-year-old Barbara Jean Horn, a little girl whose disappearance would become one of the city's most haunting mysteries. For years, detectives searched for the person responsible, following leads through the streets of Kensington and questioning countless people who might have known something about what happened that July afternoon. Nearly six years later, their investigation led them to Walter Ogrod, a quiet Philadelphia man whose name would become permanently intertwined with Barbara's death. What followed was a case filled with disturbing evidence, a controversial confession, competing versions of what happened, and a courtroom battle that would stretch across decades. At its center was a question that seemed, at first, to have a simple answer—but would prove anything but simple: What really happened to Barbara Jean Horn? SOURCES:  1) Supreme Court of PA decisions 2) U.S. Supreme Court decisions 3) Commonwealth of PA District Attorney's Office Documents 4) NBC10 Philadelphia, "Who Killed Barbara Jean?" 5) Philadelphia Inquirer Articles 6) "The Trials of Walter Ogrod" by Thomas Lowenstein

In the summer of 1988, Philadelphia was shaken by the murder of four-year-old Barbara Jean Horn, a little girl whose disappearance would become one of the city's most haunting mysteries. For years, detectives searched for the person responsible, following leads through the streets of Kensington and questioning countless people who might have known something about what happened that July afternoon. Nearly six years later, their investigation led them to Walter Ogrod, a quiet Philadelphia man whose name would become permanently intertwined with Barbara's death. What followed was a case filled with disturbing evidence, a controversial confession, competing versions of what happened, and a courtroom battle that would stretch across decades. At its center was a question that seemed, at first, to have a simple answer—but would prove anything but simple: What really happened to Barbara Jean Horn?

The Washington Woodsman transports us back to the Pacific Northwest of the 1970s and 1980s, an era when hitchhiking was commonplace, dense forests seemed endless, and young women could disappear without a trace. This episode examines the disturbing case of Warren Leslie Forrest, a Washington State Parks employee whose intimate knowledge of remote recreation areas and forest roads allegedly allowed him to hunt in plain sight for decades. Through documented evidence, survivor testimony, and courtroom records, we trace the investigation that ultimately exposed a pattern of abduction, sexual violence, and murder spanning generations. We also explore the remarkable courage of the women who survived, the families who never stopped searching for answers, and the landmark 2023 trial that finally delivered justice—while leaving investigators convinced that Forrest's true number of victims may never be known.

On a cold December morning in 1929, the Lawson family gathered on their farm outside Germanton, North Carolina, surrounded by the familiar rhythms of rural life. Christmas had arrived with the promise of family, faith, and a brief respite from the hardships of farm work. Only weeks earlier, Charlie Lawson had done something few families in the area could afford—he purchased new clothes, bought Christmas gifts, and arranged for a professional family portrait. It was a picture that captured an ordinary American family at what appeared to be the happiest moment of their lives. Within hours on Christmas Day, however, that photograph would become one of the most haunting images in American history, and the quiet Lawson farm would become the center of a mystery that has endured for nearly a century. *correction: James is identified as being 16 years old, when he was really only 4. Apologies for the error. SOURCES:  1) Website of author, Trudy J. Smith 2) "The Meaning of Our Tears" by Trudy J. Smith 3) "White Christmas, Bloody Christmas" by Trudy J. Smith and M. Bruce Jones