Advertise on podcast: Crimes and Consequences

There are cases that unfold in chaos, where nothing makes sense from the beginning, and then there are cases like this one, where everything seems to make sense far too quickly. It begins in the quiet of an ordinary apartment, with a single moment that fractures a life and sets a story into motion before anyone realizes what’s being written. In the hours that follow, investigators will find just enough to believe they understand what happened, and a jury will later agree. But beneath that certainty, something else is already taking shape—something unseen, untested, and waiting years to be discovered.

On the highways that cut through the American Midwest, where headlights stretch into darkness, and exits blur past without memory, a predator moved unnoticed for years. Larry Eyler didn’t look like a killer; he blended in, a quiet man drifting between Indiana and Illinois, offering rides to young men who would never be seen again. Their bodies would later be found miles apart, scattered across counties and backroads, each discovery raising questions no one yet knew how to connect. It wasn’t until the pattern emerged—too late for many—that investigators realized they were chasing not separate crimes, but a single, methodical force moving along the highways themselves. And even after his arrest, the full truth of what Eyler had done would remain buried, waiting until the very end to surface in a confession that revealed a scale of violence far greater than anyone had imagined.

Behind the nursery rhyme lies a crime scene that still refuses to sit still. In the summer of 1892, inside a quiet home in Fall River, Andrew and Abby Borden were found brutally murdered—struck down in broad daylight with a hatchet. No forced entry. No robbery. Just blood, heat, and a house that held more tension than anyone wanted to admit. In this Members Only episode, we go beyond the rhyme and into the record: The real estate transfers that shifted power inside the family—and may have lit the fuse. The “stepmother problem” that wasn’t just emotional, but financial. Lizzie’s behavior before and after the murders—calm, contradictory, and at times, deeply unsettling. The investigation that stumbled through social bias and missed opportunities. And the trial that asked a question America wasn’t ready to answer: What if the monster didn’t look like one?

Before six children died inside a burning home on Victory Road, there was a man who had spent decades constructing a life where power flowed in one direction—toward him. Mick Philpott wasn’t just a father. He was the center of a chaotic, benefits-funded household built on manipulation, domination, and fear.In this Early Release episode of Crimes & Consequences, we follow the timeline from control to catastrophe—through the investigation, the courtroom, and the unraveling of a man who believed he could outmaneuver everyone, including the truth.

Some crimes don’t just shock you—they linger, like smoke you can’t quite wash out of your clothes. On a late summer day in 2005, in a patch of woods most people in Charlotte drove past without a second glance, a man was found burning—alive, conscious, and desperate to be heard. Before the flames took everything, he pointed to another man and made a chilling accusation. What followed wasn’t just a murder investigation, but a case that would twist through courtroom battles, forensic controversy, and a conviction that didn’t hold. Because this story isn’t only about what happened in those woods—it’s about whether the truth, even when spoken by a dying man, is ever as simple as it seems.

On the morning of October 12, 1978, the Chelsea Hotel looked like it always did after a long New York night, with its hallways dim, its air heavy, and its secrets still clinging to the walls, but behind the door to Room 100, one of the most infamous mysteries in rock-and-roll history was waiting to be found. Inside, twenty-year-old Nancy Spungen lay bleeding on the bathroom floor, her life ended by a single stab wound, while just feet away, her boyfriend—Sex Pistols bassist Sid Vicious—stumbled through the room in a haze of drugs, shock, and confusion. What happened in those final hours would become more than a tabloid scandal or a punk-rock tragedy; it would become a case suspended somewhere between love story, crime scene, and cultural collapse, where every witness had a different version, every answer seemed to raise a darker question, and the truth, if anyone ever knew it, may have died inside that room. SOURCES:  1) "Please Kill Me: The Uncensored History of Punk" by Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain 2) "Why We Love the Chelsea Hotel" -- The New York Historical Society 3)Punk Rock Romeo and Juliet: Sid Vicious and Nancy Spungen -- Crime Library 4) Sid Vicious Accused of Murder -- Rolling Stone 5) Flashback: Nancy Spungen Found Dead at Chelsea Hotel -- Rolling Stone 6) The Arrest of Sid Vicious -- History Daily Podcast by Wondery 7) Sid Vicious Biography Page 8) Sid and Nancy: A Punk Mystery -- The Independent 9) 16 Truly Disturbing Moments That Made Punk Rocker Sid Vicious of the Sex Pistols Live Up to His Name 10) My New York: Sid and Nancy -- The New York Post

Behind the greasepaint and forced smile of Pogo the Clown lived one of the most prolific serial killers in American history. For years, Gacy appeared to be the model citizen. He hosted elaborate neighborhood parties, entertained children at hospitals dressed as a clown, and built a successful contracting business employing local teenage boys. But beneath the floorboards of his house on Summerdale Avenue, a horrifying truth was waiting to be uncovered. When fifteen-year-old Robert Piest vanished in December of 1978 after speaking with a contractor about a job, investigators began tracing his final movements. The trail led directly to Gacy’s door, and ultimately to the discovery of a crime scene unlike anything American law enforcement had ever seen. As detectives dug beneath the crawlspace of Gacy’s home, they uncovered a mass grave that would expose 33 murders, the largest number of confirmed victims attributed to a single killer in U.S. history at the time. This final episode of the 3 part investigation contains disturbing details and is intended for mature audiences.

On the morning of October 12, 1978, the Chelsea Hotel looked like it always did after a long New York night, with its hallways dim, its air heavy, and its secrets still clinging to the walls, but behind the door to Room 100, one of the most infamous mysteries in rock-and-roll history was waiting to be found. Inside, twenty-year-old Nancy Spungen lay bleeding on the bathroom floor, her life ended by a single stab wound, while just feet away, her boyfriend—Sex Pistols bassist Sid Vicious—stumbled through the room in a haze of drugs, shock, and confusion. What happened in those final hours would become more than a tabloid scandal or a punk-rock tragedy; it would become a case suspended somewhere between love story, crime scene, and cultural collapse, where every witness had a different version, every answer seemed to raise a darker question, and the truth, if anyone ever knew it, may have died inside that room. SOURCES:  1) "Please Kill Me: The Uncensored History of Punk" by Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain 2) "Why We Love the Chelsea Hotel" -- The New York Historical Society 3)Punk Rock Romeo and Juliet: Sid Vicious and Nancy Spungen -- Crime Library 4) Sid Vicious Accused of Murder -- Rolling Stone 5) Flashback: Nancy Spungen Found Dead at Chelsea Hotel -- Rolling Stone 6) The Arrest of Sid Vicious -- History Daily Podcast by Wondery 7) Sid Vicious Biography Page 8) Sid and Nancy: A Punk Mystery -- The Independent 9) 16 Truly Disturbing Moments That Made Punk Rocker Sid Vicious of the Sex Pistols Live Up to His Name 10) My New York: Sid and Nancy -- The New York Post

Behind the greasepaint and forced smile of Pogo the Clown lived one of the most prolific serial killers in American history. For years, Gacy appeared to be the model citizen. He hosted elaborate neighborhood parties, entertained children at hospitals dressed as a clown, and built a successful contracting business employing local teenage boys. But beneath the floorboards of his house on Summerdale Avenue, a horrifying truth was waiting to be uncovered. When fifteen-year-old Robert Piest vanished in December of 1978 after speaking with a contractor about a job, investigators began tracing his final movements. The trail led directly to Gacy’s door, and ultimately to the discovery of a crime scene unlike anything American law enforcement had ever seen. As detectives dug beneath the crawlspace of Gacy’s home, they uncovered a mass grave that would expose 33 murders, the largest number of confirmed victims attributed to a single killer in U.S. history at the time. This second episode of the 3 part investigation contains disturbing details and is intended for mature audiences.

In the quiet winter of 1994, the small town of New Haven woke to a mystery that would refuse to fade. On the morning of April 3, a young convenience store clerk named Heidi Allen unlocked the doors at D&W Convenience Store just as she had countless times before. Customers came and went, the coffee brewed, and the ordinary rhythms of a Sunday morning settled in. Then, sometime between one routine moment and the next, something went terribly wrong. Within hours, the register sat open, Heidi’s car remained in the parking lot, and a handful of chilling clues hinted that whatever had happened inside that small roadside store had unfolded in seconds. What followed would consume investigators, divide a community, and leave a question hanging in the cold air for decades: how does someone simply vanish in the middle of a normal morning? 1) Heidi Allen's Page on The Doe Network 2) Heidi Allen's Page on The Charley Project 3) People v. Gary Thibodeau 4) People v. Gary Thibodeau 5) Gary Thibodeau Looks to Have Conviction Overturned 6) Gary Thibodeau, convicted of kidnapping Heidi Allen in 1994, dead at 63 7) Thibodeau's death offers no closure for either side 8) Judge Denies Thibodeau Motion for New Trial 9) State’s Highest Court Turns Down Thibodeau’s Attempt For New Trial

Behind the greasepaint and forced smile of Pogo the Clown lived one of the most prolific serial killers in American history. For years, Gacy appeared to be the model citizen. He hosted elaborate neighborhood parties, entertained children at hospitals dressed as a clown, and built a successful contracting business employing local teenage boys. But beneath the floorboards of his house on Summerdale Avenue, a horrifying truth was waiting to be uncovered. When fifteen-year-old Robert Piest vanished in December of 1978 after speaking with a contractor about a job, investigators began tracing his final movements. The trail led directly to Gacy’s door, and ultimately to the discovery of a crime scene unlike anything American law enforcement had ever seen. As detectives dug beneath the crawlspace of Gacy’s home, they uncovered a mass grave that would expose 33 murders, the largest number of confirmed victims attributed to a single killer in U.S. history at the time. This episode contains disturbing details and is intended for mature audiences.

In 1924, two wealthy, brilliant University of Chicago students set out to commit what they believed would be the perfect crime.Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb believed themselves intellectually superior and beyond ordinary moral restraint. Inspired (and deeply misreading) the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche, they convinced themselves that rules applied to other people.It became the first true Trial of the Century. A national referendum on free will, punishment, privilege, youth, psychology, and whether the state should answer killing with killing.Were Leopold and Loeb supermen?Or were they privileged, deluded young men who mistook intelligence for immunity?🎙️ Join us as we dismantle the myth.

In the late 1920s, a series of brutal and seemingly senseless attacks began to unfold across the city. Victims ranged from women to children. Some were stabbed. Others were strangled. Newspapers soon gave the unknown attacker a chilling name: “The Vampire of Düsseldorf.” Behind that name was Peter Kürten, a man whose crimes were as calculated as they were grotesque. Raised in a violent and deeply disturbed household, Kürten developed dark fantasies early in life—fantasies that would eventually erupt into one of the most terrifying crime sprees in European history.

In 1924, two wealthy, brilliant University of Chicago students set out to commit what they believed would be the perfect crime.Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb believed themselves intellectually superior and beyond ordinary moral restraint. Inspired (and deeply misreading) the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche, they convinced themselves that rules applied to other people.It became the first true Trial of the Century. A national referendum on free will, punishment, privilege, youth, psychology, and whether the state should answer killing with killing.Were Leopold and Loeb supermen?Or were they privileged, deluded young men who mistook intelligence for immunity?  Join us as we dismantle the myth.Because intelligence without empathy is not superiority. It’s danger.

On a humid summer night in 1990, in the quiet town of Atwater, an elderly couple was gunned down inside their own home—and within hours, the shock gave way to something far more dangerous: certainty. Police zeroed in on a group of local teenagers, and before long, one name rose above the rest—Tyrone Noling. He was 19 years old. What followed wasn’t just a murder investigation; it was a chain reaction of interrogations, shifting stories, and a prosecution built on testimony that would later unravel. In this episode, we step inside the case that sent a teenager to death row—and ask how a conviction can survive long after the truth begins to crack.