Advertise on podcast: It Just Makes Sense

Halloween parties, wedding merch, and a $35 Taco Bell order. Just another week on It Just Makes Sense, Chit Chat. Sam and Jeff recap their latest adventures, from a party game that tests Jeff’s loyalty to Josh Allen to a first-time dab experience that takes a turn. They debate when brunch actually starts, vent about diet culture and rising prices, and compare notes on a wedding with its own merch stand. Plus, strong opinions on Love Is Blind, a divided reaction to The Substance, and a roundup of thrillers and TV shows keeping them entertained. Come for the weekly catch-up; stay for the friendly insults and wildly unnecessary arguments.

Jealousy, obsession, and a friendship turned deadly. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff explore the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, a young Job Corps student in Knoxville, Tennessee, whose classmate Christa Pike became convinced she was trying to steal her boyfriend. They trace the escalating bullying, the brutal attack, and the chilling confession that followed then discuss Pike’s life behind bars and the difficult questions surrounding capital punishment. With candid reactions and some strong opinions, the conversation asks: Where do accountability, justice, and cruelty collide?

A Facebook firestorm, a social media breakup, and strong opinions about what’s worth watching just another week on Chit Chat with Sam and Jeff. Sam explains why The Social Reckoning inspired her to deactivate Facebook, kicking off an unfiltered conversation about online outrage, misinformation, and political hypocrisy. Then we’re catching up on Buffalo fall markets, mansion tours, Weight Watchers wins, and Jeff’s workplace team-building day that could’ve used better food and fewer presentations. Plus, we trade movie and TV reviews, debate whether Real Housewives is getting too mean to enjoy, and discuss Sam’s latest questions about the Gypsy Rose Blanchard case. From local outings to Bravo overload, this episode delivers plenty of opinions and our usual easily distracted energy.

What looked like a random carjacking unraveled into a chilling family betrayal. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff recap “Mommy’s Little Sex Dungeon” from Mother, May I Murder?, exploring the murder of Ron Whitehead and the investigation that led detectives into his own home. A missing handgun, suspicious text messages, and a palm print expose a plot involving his wife, Velma, her teenage son, and his friend. Along the way, we unpack life insurance money, a shocking double life, and a mother’s manipulation with plenty of disbelief and our signature unfiltered commentary. Betrayal doesn’t get much closer to home.

This week, the girls are CHATTY and absolutely nothing is off-limits. We dive into the latest Gypsy Rose Blanchard drama, debate a shocking, botched execution in Tennessee, and get into a heated discussion about just how much research a podcast host should actually be doing. (Spoiler: apparently, not enough.) Then it's time for the personal chaos: Ozempic woes, weight fluctuations, questionable shortcuts, and a nostalgic trip back to The Swan. We dish about The Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip, recap a snack-filled THC hangout that involved an alarming amount of popcorn and ice cream, and debate everything from Dolly Parton classics to the latest movies and TV shows. Plus, we review Verity, gush over Dungeon Crawler Carl, discuss Netflix's A Different World revival, and somehow circle back to true crime before signing off. It's messy, it's unfiltered, it's a little unhinged—and naturally, there's plenty of shade to go around. Grab your snacks, pour your favorite mocktail, and come chit chat with us

Six wives. Four deaths. One story that just keeps getting stranger. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff unpack the Thomas Randolph case featured in The Widower: Till Death Do Us Part. From a supposed home invasion to life insurance payouts, murder-for-hire allegations, and courtroom twists, we follow the red flagsand the detective who refused to let them go. Expect plenty of disbelief, unfiltered commentary, and a case that takes “till death do us part” to a whole new level.

In 2004, 14-year-old Max de Vries vanished during a family trip to Aruba after going jet skiing with a man his family had met at their resort. The man returned. Max didn’t. From fresh scratches and shifting explanations to later allegations, troubling witness accounts, and a case that authorities initially ruled an accident, this story raises far more questions than it answers. More than 20 years later, Max’s disappearance remains unsolved and his mother is still seeking justice. We also discuss recent true-crime news and the systems that too often fail survivors and families looking for answers. Listen now, then tell us: Do you believe Max’s disappearance was an accident—or something far more sinister? Content note: This episode discusses the disappearance of a child, alleged sexual abuse, sexual violence, and attempted murder

Sam worked all weekend staring at spreadsheets, integrations, and corporate nonsense while trying to preserve a single ounce of sanity. Sam said, “That’s cute,” then went to a bungee-cord workout class where she was allegedly twerking, flying, and giving senior-citizen aerial aerobics to Tina Turner. No notes. Ten out of ten. Olympic behavior. Meanwhile, there was golf. There was a Bills win. There was a weed delivery. There were DoorDashed Blizzards. And there were so many DoorDash charges that corporate security said, “Girl, are you being scammed?” No, babe. Just emotionally vulnerable with access to an app. We also drag lovingly, and of course our latest watches: American Horror Story: Jessica Lange is back, looking expensive, and the plot is apparently being held together with a cigarette and a prayer.Willy Wonka’s Golden Ticket: whimsical, high-budget, psychologically destabilizing reality television. Why are they making families betray each other in Candyland?The Love Hypothesis: cute enough, but not “cancel your plans and text your ex” good.Line of Fire: government agents, bad acting, next.Three Pines: murder, curling, electrocution, Canada said, “Let’s give them drama.”Charades: rich teenagers behaving like nobody has ever told them “no,” which, frankly, tracks.And finally, we face the shameful truth: the New York Times says there are 100 essential TV shows from this century, and we have apparently watched three. Maybe four on a generous day. Sue us. Listen now and tell us in the comments: What “classic” TV show have you still never watched—and why are you pretending you’re going to start it soon? Untitled-October-1-2026-1.docx

This week with Sam and Jeff, a lunch at Pita Gourmet becomes a full-blown five-alarm emergency, Sam and Jeff recap an unforgettable Bills game complete with free drinks, beer sabres, mysterious season-ticket-holder encounters, and a halftime act that was not One Direction. They also get into fall golf, a two-day tournament, a dishwasher delivery, Dad’s 70th birthday, Dog Days in Kenmore, questionable movie choices, true-crime content, and the ongoing search for a restaurant Jeff can safely enjoy. Expect chaotic stories, Buffalo adventures, honest pop-culture takes, and plenty of laughs.

A pipe crashes through a windshield, leaving Barbara Kendhammer fatally injured and her husband, Todd, accused of staging the scene. With conflicting stories, disputed forensic evidence, no clear motive, and new expert testimony, this 48 Hours case raises one unsettling question: was it murder, or a tragic accident? Listen in, then tell us what you think.

No true crime this week, please direct all complaints to someone who cares. Sam and Jeff are serving up birthday dinners, sponge-candy cheesecake, Bills-induced heart palpitations, a leaky ceiling, reality-TV chaos, questionable gut-health choices, and a job applicant who talked herself straight into the trash. It’s messy, mouthy, and exactly the kind of chit chat you came for. 🎙️✨

Sam and Jeff unpack the humbling chaos of starting a new job, returning to therapy, and redefining a sobriety journey without erasing years of growth. Then it’s pure weekend mayhem: solo Kacey Musgraves, rhinestone theatrics, flooded Buffalo streets, Toronto adventures, thirty-five dumplings, a CN Tower showdown, dog-sitting dreams, and wildly different approaches to quality time. They close with book, movie, true-crime, and reality TV takes plus the gloriously specific reason their next companion trip is headed to Oklahoma.

Sam and Jeff examine the death of Jorge Torres Jr. and the case against Sarah Boone, whose claim that a game of hide-and-seek ended in a tragic accident unraveled after investigators found disturbing videos on her phone. The episode follows Boone’s shifting account, the couple’s documented history of domestic violence, the evidence presented at trial, years of legal delays and attorney changes, and the self-defense argument raised by the defense. The hosts discuss the difficult questions surrounding abuse, accountability, intent, and whether Boone’s life sentence fits the crime.

This week on Chit Chit, Sam and Jeff spiral deliciously through Real Housewives rumors, drag show memories, Buffalo stadium hot takes, taco festival chaos, early-2000s boy band nostalgia, streaming recommendations, celebrity losses, and the Lindsay Clancy trial. It’s gossipy, unfiltered, a little unhinged, and very much giving “two friends with microphones and zero filter.” Tune in for the Bravo takes, the Buffalo complaints, and the kind of side conversations that somehow become the whole episode.

A 15-year-old boy, Alex Rodda, was found murdered after meeting 18-year-old Matt Mason, a man he had been secretly communicating with online. This episode explores the role of social media, grooming, hidden relationships, a frantic search by Alex’s loved ones, and the evidence that led to Mason’s conviction. It also raises difficult questions about police response, online cruelty, sentencing young offenders, and what justice should look like in cases involving teenagers.