Advertise on podcast: Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia

Rating

★★★★☆

3.7

from

153 reviews

Description

Welcome to Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia, a true crime podcast hosted by Holly and Hailey. Join us each week as we dive into murders, missing persons cases, and other spooky and paranormal happenings in the mountains of Appalachia.

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia podcast

Twelve Tribes Pt. 2

2026/04/09

Join us for part 2 of our discussion on the twelve tribes. Support the show

Twelve Tribes Pt. 1

2026/04/02

Join us this week as we talk about a group operating in Appalachia, specifically along the Appalachian trail. Are they a cult or just a friendly group of like minded people? Support the show

Mamie Thurman Pt. 2

2026/03/05

Part 2 of the Maimee Thurman case! Support the show

Mamie Thurman Pt. 1

2026/02/26

Y'all this episode may be cursed! We lost the original audio, rerecorded on zoom, and Hailey's computer almost bit the dust. This is one of the most interesting cases we have covered in a while so thanks for bearing with us! Support the show

Anjette Lyles

2025/12/11

This month we discuss female serial killer Anjette Lyles. Whatever you do, don't let her make you a drink. Support the show

The Brinkley College Ghost

2025/11/06

Join us for this months episode about Brinkley College. We discuss its history and its hauntings! Support the show

ANNOUNCEMENT!!!!!

2025/10/02

AHHHHH!!!!! We are taking a leap! Listen in to hear about our new project! Support the show

The Lizard Man

2025/10/02

Happy 5 year anniversary to us!!! Thank you all for joining us for this weeks episode as we talk about the legend of the Lizard man. Support the show

Mary Shotwell Little Part 2

2025/09/25

Join us for the final part of the Mary Shotwell Little story. Support the show

Mary Shotwell Little Part 1

2025/09/18

This week we dive into the disappearance of Mary Shotwell Little. Support the show

The Signal Mountain Murders

2025/09/11

Join us this week as we discuss a triple homicide out of Tennessee. Support the show

Baby in the Closet

2025/09/04

Join us as we discuss a developing case out of Kentucky. Support the show

The Case of LaLurie

2025/08/21

Join us this week for another case from Hailey's travels to New Orleans. We discuss the horrific case of LaLurie. Support the show

The Alford Plea

2025/08/14

Join us this week as we talk about the case that brought about the Alford Plea. Support the show

Jazz it Out

2025/08/07

Join us this week as we take it to New Orleans to discuss the axeman murders in the early 1900s. Support the show

Podcast reviews

Read Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia podcast reviews

3.7 out of 5

153 reviews

★★★★☆

meatball1223 2025/09/02

A Berea Kentucky Fan

Just finished listening to your UFOs of Tennessee episode as I drove from Lebanon TN to Berea KY haha yall are hilarious! Started listening last year ...

★★★★★

MrsStrait2122 2026/03/08

Obsessed

Just found you guys by accident really and I am obsessed! Started from episode one working my way through!!! ❤️

★☆☆☆☆

Mayday_1988 2026/02/18

Ignorant host

Macon Georgia is not Appalachia!

★★★★★

Bri and Kat 2026/01/29

I am obsessed with this podcast

Hello holly and Hailey I just wanted to let yall know I love your podcast I listen to it everyday while I am at work I also got my childhood best frie...

★★★★★

Uhhhhhhh321 2025/12/06

It’s Cool

I like this show and it pisses me off that people leave negative comments. I love these ladies!

★☆☆☆☆

Goldie Stardust 2025/11/21

Vapid

subjects sound good but they never get to them. They have no business having a podcast.

★★★☆☆

Lindsey-Durden 2025/06/20

Too much nonsense

I like the podcast because it’s about Appalachia, but goodness they spend 15-20 minutes talking about nothing. I try to never leave bad reviews, but I...

★★☆☆☆

Wordgirl90 2025/07/17

Wanted to like this

I really wanted to like this podcast but it’s hard to follow. If one could just tell the story without the other interjecting “mmhmm, oh, yeah, ok, ye...

★★★★★

stopxmotion 2025/06/24

Good.

I don't mind the talking about random things in the beginning. What they need to stop doing is interrupting a story once they begin for 10 more minute...

★☆☆☆☆

rossticle 2025/03/18

Mostly banter. Not much content

I wanted to like this but I listened to a 36 min episode and they just talked about random stuff for the first 14 mins. The hosts seem nice and funny...

check all reviews on apple podcasts