Advertise on podcast: Keystone Cold Cases

Amatulah “Amy” McLaughlin had already experienced far more than any child should. There had been previous allegations of abuse, and her mother, Ciara, had been ordered to complete parenting classes. Yet somewhere along the way, this family fell through the cracks. And then, on Halloween night, Amy’s life was tragically cut short. Her mother initially claimed that Amy’s death was an accident. But as investigators dug deeper, the evidence told a very different story.

Behind the grand walls of the Pen Ryn Estate lies a history shrouded in mystery, tragedy, and whispers of the supernatural. Beneath its imposing beauty lurk chilling legends and reports of unexplained encounters that have left visitors questioning what might still haunt the grounds. What secrets does this historic estate hold, and are the spirits said to linger there simply stories—or something far more unsettling? Join us as we step inside the eerie history of the Pen Ryn Estate.

From restless spirits and haunted locations to eerie folklore passed down through generations, ghosts have captivated people across the globe for centuries. In this episode, Cait and Chelsea are traveling around the world to explore chilling ghost stories, supernatural encounters, and the cultural beliefs that shape how different societies understand the afterlife. Whether you believe in spirits or think there’s a logical explanation for the unexplained, these haunting tales might just leave you wondering what happens when we cross over.

Some taverns have stories. Others have secrets. In this spooky episode, we step inside McCoole’s Tavern at the Red Lion Inn and the Trum Tavern—two historic Pennsylvania landmarks where the past may still linger in the shadows. Strange encounters, unexplained happenings, and chilling tales have followed these old buildings for generations. What happened behind their doors? Who—or what—might still be there?

In this Spooky Season episode, we’re heading to Western Pennsylvania for two chilling tales rooted in local folklore and legend. First, we explore the story of the Witch of Monongahela—a mysterious figure whose legend has haunted the area for generations. Then, we turn to the skies above Pittsburgh and the eerie story of the Ghost Bomber, a B-25 that splash landed on the river and disappeared underneath the surface and was never recovered. Two stories, two very different legends, and plenty of questions about what may—or may not—be lurking beyond the ordinary.

It's officially spooky season! What happens when a seemingly harmless bite becomes a race against time? Rabies is one of the deadliest viruses known to humans, and once symptoms appear, survival is extraordinarily rare. In this episode, we’ll explore the terrifying history of rabies, the strange symptom known as hydrophobia, how the virus affects the brain, and why this ancient disease continues to haunt our imaginations—and our world.

In June 2015, 22-year-old Jasmaine Smith vanished after attending her sister’s high school graduation party in Farrell, Pennsylvania. As we explore her disappearance, we’ll also examine the tragic case of 18-year-old Alesha Bell—and the man whose connection to both cases may hold the key to what happened to Jasmaine.

Every morning, millions of Americans head to work expecting to come home at the end of the day. Teachers, nurses, delivery drivers, clerks, mail carriers—ordinary people simply doing their jobs. But some never make it home. Not because their jobs were dangerous, but because someone else decided they wouldn’t.

Patrick Ryan seemingly had no reason to disappear. His apartment suggested he left unexpectedly, his vehicle was still outside, and more than 30 miles away, his body was discovered. His family questioned the official cause of death from the beginning, while his manner of death remained undetermined. Then, 17 years later, an anonymous tip surfaced—one that suggested Patrick’s death may have been far more sinister than anyone realized. What really happened to Patrick Ryan?

In April 2004, 23-year-old Alonzo Brooks attended a party in rural Kansas and never made it home. After an initial search turned up nothing, his body was discovered nearly a month later in an area that had already been searched, raising troubling questions about what really happened. Decades later, the case was reopened, an autopsy determined Alonzo's death was a homicide, and investigators continue to seek answers. In this episode, we examine the mysterious circumstances surrounding Alonzo Brooks' death, the allegations of racial violence, and the relentless pursuit of justice by his family.

This month, we're stepping away from cold cases and taking a little detour into the world of real estate—because sometimes, the strangest stories aren't about the people who lived in a house, but the house itself! From homes shaped like castles, mushrooms, and spaceships to underground dwellings, converted churches, and interiors that will leave you saying, "What were they thinking?"—there's no shortage of bizarre places people actually call home. We're taking a look at some of the weirdest, wildest, and most unusual homes we could find. Some are fascinating, some are jaw-dropping, and some might make you wonder who thought, "Yep...this is exactly where I want to live." So, grab your imaginary real estate agent and come house hunting with us as we explore homes that prove there's truly no such thing as *normal* when it comes to where people choose to live!

In April 2022, Johnstown, Pennsylvania, was shaken by the brutal murders of 61-year-old Lionel Mickens and 36-year-old Britney Rummell. The two were found shot to death inside Mickens’ Pine Street home, along with his rescue dog, Daniel. Investigators determined that both victims had suffered multiple gunshot wounds and quickly ruled out the possibility that they had killed one another. Despite leads and evidence sent for testing, no one has been arrested or charged in connection with the murders.

She was only 8 years old. And her killer was never caught. 3rd grader Debbie Makel should have grown up. She should have had birthdays, dreams, and a future. Instead, her life was stolen—and the person responsible vanished into history. For years, Debbie’s case has remained unsolved. No justice. Just silence. Someone out there knows what happened. Someone has carried the truth for decades.

On a quiet June morning in 1912, the small town of Villisca, Iowa, woke up to a nightmare that would never be forgotten. Eight people were found murdered in their beds. The killer was never caught. The suspects were many. The theories are endless. This week on Keystone Cold Cases, we step inside the Moore home and explore the haunting mystery of the Villisca Axe Murders. A crime that shocked a nation… and a case that still refuses to be solved.

Picture a quiet February morning in western Pennsylvania. There's still snow on the ground, and the roads through Lawrence County are lined with bare trees and old farmhouses. It looks like any other winter morning. Inside one of those farmhouses, 26-year-old Kenzie Houk is asleep in bed. She's eight months pregnant, close enough to her due date that she and her fiancé were counting down the days. Downstairs, life is moving along like normal. Her two little girls are getting ready for school. Her fiancé has already left for work. His 11-year-old son is helping the girls get their coats on before walking one of them to the bus stop. Nothing seems out of the ordinary. But before that school day is over, Kenzie will be found dead.