Advertise on podcast: Creepy Cases & Spooky Spaces with Cassi O'Peia

Today, we journey to Rawlins, Wyoming, to explore the Ferris Mansion. A home that stands as a silent witness to ambition, grief, and something that may have never fully let go - a place where history and the supernatural intertwine.

In What the Jury Didn't Hear, the finale of my three part series of The Peterson Files, we take deeper look into the trial of Scott Peterson. Focusing on the ignored witnesses, missing evidence, falsified police reports, we ask the question - Did Scott get a fair trial?

Part Two of my three-part series "The Peterson Files" begins the day the search ends and the questions multiply. When Laci Peterson and her unborn son, Conner, are discovered, a grieving nation turns its focus squarely on Scott Peterson - but suspicion is not the same as proof. From his arrest to a trial watched obsessively by the media, we examine the evidence, the inconsistencies, and the alternative theories that never fully disappeared. As prosecutors and defense attorneys clash in court, this episode asks a haunting question: was the verdict the result of undeniable guilt, or a case shaped by pressure, perception, and a story the public had already decided to believe?

In the first episode of this three-part series, we revisit the disappearance of Laci Peterson, a 27-year-old expectant mother known by friends and family for her warmth, creativity, and devotion to those she loved. Last seen on Christmas Eve in 2002, Laci was eight months pregnant and preparing for the arrival of her son. This episode explores who Laci was beyond the headlines, traces the timeline of her final known movements, and examines the early search efforts that captured national attention. It sets the foundation for a case that would soon become one of the most closely followed true-crime stories in America.

When an entire family disappears without a trace, theories multiply and questions outnumber answers. Joseph, Summer, and their two young sons vanished from their Southern California home in 2010. With no signs of struggle and only a bowl of popcorn left behind, investigators were left to untangle a web of strange clues, international suspicions, and a trail that went cold… until a shocking discovery in the desert changed everything. What really happened to the McStay family? And why did it take years for the truth to surface? Join me as I uncover one of the most haunting family disappearances in recent history.

Today, we journey to Tombstone, Arizona - a town frozen in time, where echoes of gunfights, revelry, and whispered secrets still drift down the dusty streets. At the heart of this legendary town lies the Bird Cage Theatre—a place where history and the supernatural intertwine. Equal parts saloon, theatre, gambling hall, and brothel, the Bird Cage Theatre opened its doors on Christmas Day in 1881, and quickly became one of the most infamous spots in the American West.

On June 22, 2013, a bright, spirited 18-year-old vanished from a house in Berea, Kentucky. In the years since, no arrests have been made, no remains have been found, and no clear answers have surfaced. Her case is cold - but far from forgotten. Who was Brookelyn Farthing? What happened the night she went missing leaving behind a puzzling trail of clues left behind, and her family who continues to fight for justice more than a decade later.

Season eight begins with diving into a case that has baffled investigators, spawned ghost stories, and stirred Cold War conspiracy theories for nearly seventy years. It’s the story of William and Margaret Patterson. A quiet, affluent couple from El Paso, Texas—respected business owners who simply vanished one day in 1957... leaving behind a house full of belongings, a confused community, and a trail of strange letters and shifting stories.

Join me as I take you on a fascinating journey through the Morris-Jumel Mansion, Manhattan’s oldest house, as I uncover the mansion’s rich history. From its origins as a grand estate in the 18th century to its role as George Washington’s headquarters during the Revolutionary War. Discover the captivating lives of its past living residents, and its current spirits. Subscribe and listen now for a trip back in time! 🎧✨ Become a Patron for bonus content, a merchandise discount, & More! www.patreon.com/creepycasesspookyspaces

In 1981, the small town of Keddie, California, was shaken by a brutal crime that left lasting scars on the community. Known as the Keddie Murders, this tragic event saw the brutal slayings of Sue Sharp, her teenage son John, and his friend Dana Wingate. The case remains hauntingly unsolved, with theories ranging from a botched robbery to a targeted attack. Join me as I delve into the chilling details of this creepy case, exploring the evidence, suspects, and the enduring impact on those touched by the Keddie Murders.

No. 14 West 10th Street, Greenwich Village, Manhattan, New York looks like any other beautiful brownstone on the row. With at least 22 deaths in the home, it has earned its title as one of the most haunted homes in America. Tune in now to hear all about this Spooky Space. Become a Patreon for bonus episodes and more! www.patreon.com/creepycasesspookyspaces

Tucked away atop the Black Hills Mountains in Jerome, Arizona sits the eerily beautiful Jerome Grand Hotel. What was once the town's hospital in the 1920s, the hotel was renovated and reopened in the 1990s. With over 9,000 souls crossing over to the spirit realm, it's no surprise the hotel is full of paranormal activity.

Kate Webster began her life of crime at an early age, ending up in prison for larceny at just 15 years old. No one could ever suspect she'd be capable of murder, until her former employer, Julia Thomas, went missing. Neighbors became suspicious when Kate began using the surname of Thomas, wearing the woman's clothing, and selling her possessions. Tune in now to hear how she was convicted of this creepy crime.

In this episode, we step back into the 70s to study the case of The Dating Game Killer. With his charming demeanor and good looks, Rodney Alcala proved to be a "wolf in sheep's clothing" as he was hiding a dark and twisted secret. Do you recognize any of the women in these photos? If so, contact Huntington Beach Police Department: 714.536.5947 https://abcnews.go.com/us/serial-killer-rodney-alcalas-photographs-recognize/story?id=75067205 Subscribe for bonus content & more!www.patreon.com/creepycasesspookyspaces

Take a trip with me, to New Orleans. The birthplace of Jazz, Crawfish Town...the spookiest place in the U.S. holds one of the spookiest spaces I have come across in my research. A Sultan, a harem, and a violent massacre that is still one of the biggest mysteries today. Tune in now to hear the spooky details.