
Advertise on podcast: Not On Record Podcast
Rating
5from
This podcast has
238 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
Possibly Correct MediaExplicit
Yes
Date created
2021/04/29
Latest episode
2026/11/02
Average duration
36 min.
Release period
8 days
Description
Criminal Defence Lawyer Joseph Neuberger and YouTube personality, legal researcher and host of the UnTrue Crime podcast Diana Davison, sit down and discuss the aftermath of their case loads and what really goes on behind the scenes. A behind the scenes inside look into the real court room drama.
Unlock Not On Record Podcast podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Not On Record Podcast podcast
REWIND | Should Juries Be Removed From SA Trials?
2026/11/02
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
In this REWIND, Joseph Neuberger and his co-host react to proposals reported at the time in Scotland to pilot judge-only trials in rape cases, and to a "pilot scheme" in England giving court staff, police and prosecutors specialized trauma training and giving complainants independent sexual violence advisers. Quoting the President of the Law Society of Scotland, they argue that juries are a safeguard of a fair trial, question claims that juries routinely rely on rape myths, and warn against measuring the justice system by conviction rates. They also discuss Quebec's specialized court project, the loss of peremptory challenges in Canada, legal aid underfunding, and why protecting other people's rights protects your own. Recorded in 2023; some of the programs discussed have since changed.
Topics
- ⚖️ Judge-only rape trials proposed in Scotland
- 🏛️ England's specialist court "pilot scheme"
- 👥 Why juries matter to a fair trial
- 📊 Conviction rates vs. the presumption of innocence
- 🍁 What it means for Canada and Quebec
EP#232 | Hidden Reasons to Lie: How Courts Weigh Credibility in Sexual Assault Cases
2026/10/26
In Episode 232 of Not On Record, criminal defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger and Yuvika Johri look at how courts handle motive to fabricate in sexual assault cases. They walk through the Ontario Court of Appeal's decision in R v JC (2021 ONCA 131) and its two rules: the rule against ungrounded common-sense assumptions and the rule against stereotypical inferences. They also cover R v JL (2018 ONCA 756), R v Nyznik (2017 ONSC 4392), R v Batte (Ont CA, 2000), R v LL (2009 ONCA 413), and the recent R v EO (2026 ONCA 575), where the court dismissed an appeal from convictions over non-consensual slapping during otherwise consensual sex. This is commentary and analysis, not legal advice.
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
EP#231 | Drunk, Drugged or Incapable? Sexual Assault Law; USA vs Canada
2026/10/19
EP#231 | Drunk, Drugged or Incapable? Sexual Assault Law; USA vs Canada
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
Neuberger & Partners
HIGHLY EXPERIENCED AND SKILLED TORONTO
Criminal Defence Law Firm
https://nrlawyers.com/
In Episode 231 of Not On Record, criminal defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger is joined for the first time by Yuvika to examine the Jane Doe civil lawsuit against Cornell University and a fraternity chapter arising from 2024 allegations of sexual assault. Using the case as a backdrop, they compare New York’s approach to capacity to consent where voluntary intoxication does not itself establish incapacity unless the complainant is unconscious or physically helpless with Canada’s broader framework under Criminal Code section 273.1 and leading decisions such as R v GF (2021 SCC), R v Alrawi (2018 NSCA 10), and R v Ryu (2025 SCC 34). The discussion covers the practical differences for sexual assault prosecutions, myth-based reasoning, and why these distinctions matter, while carefully distinguishing allegations from established facts.
EP#230 | Eight and a Half Years in Prison: Sean Parker on His Case and the UK Justice System
2026/10/12
EP#230 | Eight and a Half Years in Prison: Sean Parker on His Case and the UK Justice System
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
Should an accused person testify in their own defence, even when cross-examination could expose them to difficult questions?
In Episode 230 of Not On Record, hosts Joseph Neuberger, Michael Bury and Diana Davison speak with British artist, writer and musician Sean B.W. Parker about his book, Magnolia Graffiti, which chronicles his experience of conviction, imprisonment and the British criminal justice system.
Parker discusses his account of the allegations against him, the decisions made during his trial, his reasons for not testifying, and the challenges of maintaining his innocence while incarcerated. He also reflects on his experience with the appeals process and the personal impact of spending eight and a half years in prison.
The conversation explores broader questions about criminal defence strategy, jury selection, cross-examination, sexual assault proceedings and the difficulties faced by people who maintain their innocence following conviction.
The hosts conclude with a discussion of the decision to testify in one’s own defence, including why explaining a speech impediment to a jury may be an important consideration when preparing an accused to give evidence.
In this episode:
- Sean Parker’s book, Magnolia Graffiti
- His account of the allegations, trial and conviction
- The strategic decision not to testify
- Speech impediments and the challenges of cross-examination
- Jury selection in the UK and Canada
- Maintaining innocence while incarcerated
- Appeals and the criminal justice system
- Lessons for criminal defence lawyers and accused persons
Guest: Sean B.W. Parker
Book: Magnolia Graffiti
Subscribe to Not On Record for discussions about criminal law, courtroom strategy, controversial cases and issues affecting the Canadian justice system.
EP#229 | 18 Months in Prison for The Wrong Username
2026/10/05
18 Months in Prison for The Wrong Username
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
## Description
How can one tiny difference in a digital username lead to an innocent man spending 18 months in prison?
In Episode 229 of Not On Record, Joseph Neuberger, Michael Bury and Diana Davison examine the extraordinary case of R. v. Klayme, 2026 NSCA 59, in which the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal ultimately found that Brandon Klayme was factually innocent and should never have been charged.
The investigation began with a Kik username containing two underscores. Police records instead pursued a username containing only one. That small discrepancy sent investigators down the wrong digital trail, ultimately leading them to Klayme. Despite searches of his devices producing no evidence connecting him to the alleged communications, the case proceeded and resulted in a conviction and an 18-month prison sentence.
The episode explores digital tunnel vision, the danger of treating digital evidence as infallible, the importance of investigating exculpatory evidence, and the enormous consequences when an investigative theory becomes institutional truth.
The discussion also examines comments about sexual-assault trials, cross-examination, the presumption of innocence, the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, support measures for complainants, and concerns about expanding the use of CCTV testimony.
A powerful episode about wrongful convictions, digital evidence, due process and why the safeguards of the criminal justice system matter.
EP#228 | When Judges Apply Two Standards: The Appeal Court Response
2026/09/28
Not On Record | EP#228 | When Judges Apply Two Standards: The Appeal Court Response
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
In Episode 228 of *Not On Record*, Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison examine **R. v. Hornsby, 2026 ONCA 604**, a significant Ontario Court of Appeal decision dealing with credibility assessment and “uneven scrutiny” in a criminal trial.
The Court of Appeal quashed convictions on all counts and ordered new trials after finding that the trial judge applied different standards when assessing the accused and complainant’s evidence. The judgment provides a useful framework for identifying flawed credibility analysis, including disproportionate attention to minor inconsistencies, treating detail as evidence of credibility for one witness but evidence of fabrication for another, relying on stereotypes or generalizations, failing to grapple with material weaknesses, and effectively reversing the burden of proof.
Joseph and Diana also discuss why detailed written closing submissions matter, how lawyers can build the record for an appeal, and why credibility analysis must be conducted carefully and independently for each count.
Not On Record | EP#227 | Judge Cross-Examines Accused, Conviction Overturned
2026/09/21
EP#227 | Judge Cross-Examines Accused, Conviction Overturned
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
Can a trial judge cross-examine an accused? A recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision raises that question in dramatic fashion.
In Episode 227 of Not On Record, Joseph Neuberger, Michael Bury and Noriana discuss a 2026 Ontario Court of Appeal decision in which a sexual assault conviction was overturned because the trial judge’s conduct created a reasonable apprehension of bias.
The judge questioned the accused extensively after the Crown had already completed its cross-examination, with seven pages of transcript devoted to the judge’s questioning. The Court of Appeal found that the questions went far beyond simple clarification and amounted to cross-examination. Even more significantly, the trial judge relied on evidence that emerged from her own questioning when assessing the accused’s credibility and reliability.
The episode examines the limits of judicial intervention, reasonable apprehension of bias, the importance of an impartial trial, delayed allegations, credibility assessments, memory, and what defence counsel can do when they believe a judge has crossed the line.
The case is a fascinating reminder that justice must not only be done, but must also appear to be done.
EP#226 | The Lindsey Clancy Trial: When Morality Collides With the Law
2026/09/14
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
The discussion looks at the unusual legal position now facing the defence, including a motion asking the judge to enter an acquittal following the hung jury. We examine how reasonable doubt works, why a jury cannot simply substitute its personal morality for the law, and the important differences between the Massachusetts approach and Canada’s law on not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder.
Joseph also draws on his 19 years sitting on the Ontario Review Board and his experience handling mental health cases to explain psychosis, command hallucinations, postpartum depression, infanticide and what actually happens when someone is found not criminally responsible.
The episode also addresses the evidence surrounding Clancy’s alleged suicide attempts, the role of her reported mental illness, her civil action against physicians, and why finding someone not criminally responsible is absolutely not a “get out of jail free card.”
A difficult case raises difficult questions, but the legal system still requires jurors to apply the law, even when the facts are emotionally overwhelming.
Subscribe to *Not On Record*, leave a comment, and let us know what you think.
This discussion is for informational purposes and is not legal advice.
EP#225 | The Affidavit Trap: A Dangerous New Trend
2026/09/07
**Sponsored by EasyDNS**
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: **notonrecord**
In Episode 225 of Not On Record, criminal defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger and Michael Bury examine a little-discussed legal issue that could have major consequences in sexual assault trials. Can Crown counsel cross-examine an accused on what was omitted from a section 276 affidavit, effectively turning defence strategy into evidence? Joined by articling student Noriana, they explore solicitor-client privilege, the purpose of section 276 applications, key Supreme Court of Canada decisions including R. v. Darrach, R. v. Goldfinch, and R. v. J.J., and why this emerging courtroom tactic could have significant implications for fairness, trial strategy, and future appeals.
EP#224 | He Never Touched Her… So Why Was It Sexual Assault?
2026/08/31
**Sponsored by EasyDNS**
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: **notonrecord**
Can a person be convicted of sexual assault without any sexual intent? In Episode 224 of *Not On Record*, criminal defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison examine the Alberta Court of Appeal’s decision in **R. v. Roan, 2026 ABCA 260**, exploring how Canadian law defines sexual assault through the protection of a person’s sexual integrity rather than sexual motive. They also discuss the Ontario Court of Appeal’s decision in **R. v. SSD, 2026 ONCA 579**, and its application of the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in **R. v. Berg**, reinforcing the importance of the reasonable doubt standard, the proper application of **W.(D.)**, and why judges must provide clear, consistent reasons for conviction. This episode examines two significant appellate decisions that highlight fundamental principles of Canadian criminal law and the safeguards that protect the integrity of the justice system.
EP#223 | Bail Granted… But You Still Can’t Go Home?
2026/08/24
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
Ontario has introduced sweeping new bail regulations requiring cash deposits before many accused persons can be released, even after a justice has granted bail.
Criminal defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger explains what has changed, why many lawyers believe the new rules create a two-tier justice system, and why the Criminal Lawyers’ Association and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association are challenging the legislation.
Topics include:
• Ontario’s new cash bail requirements
• Sureties and how bail works
• Charter rights and the presumption of innocence
• Reverse onus provisions
• Overcrowded jails
• Public safety versus constitutional rights
• Why critics argue these reforms punish poverty instead of crime
Is this meaningful bail reform, or simply the illusion of public safety?
EP#222 | Fifty Shades of Consent: When BDSM Becomes Criminal
2026/08/17
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
How far can consent go?
In this episode of Not On Record, Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison return to an issue they have discussed several times: the complicated intersection of BDSM, sexual consent and Canadian criminal law.
For people involved in BDSM and alternative sexual communities, consent can be highly structured. Partners may negotiate boundaries in advance, use safe words or colour systems, communicate exactly what acts they are comfortable with, and even put their agreements in writing.
So what happens when someone later complains?
Joseph discusses two current cases involving clients who had established specific communication systems for consent, yet were still charged with sexual assault. The central question is whether negotiated consent systems have any legal protection when the criminal law is applied after the fact.
EP#221 | Why Didn’t Police Investigate? The Case That Exposed a Broken System
2026/08/10
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
In Episode 222 of Not On Record, Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison examine a question that clients ask repeatedly: “Why am I being charged when the police never investigated my side of the story?”
The discussion focuses on the distinction between taking a complainant’s statement and conducting a full, objective investigation.
Joseph and Diana walk through a real case in which the accused provided police with detailed information about the events, including potential witnesses, receipts, locations, CCTV footage, phone evidence, dash-cam footage and other information that could potentially confirm or contradict the allegations.
Yet many of those investigative avenues were not pursued.
The episode explores:
• What grounds police need before laying a criminal charge
• Whether taking a complainant’s statement can constitute an “investigation”
• Why police may not conduct follow-up interviews
• The importance of CCTV and other time-sensitive digital evidence
• What happens when police seize a phone but don’t promptly extract the evidence
• How the defence can attempt to preserve and obtain evidence police haven’t collected
• When third-party records, including medical records, may become relevant
• Why an accused person’s request for police to investigate potentially exculpatory evidence matters
• The role of Crown counsel in reassessing whether there is a reasonable prospect of conviction
• The consequences of failing to conduct an objective investigation
• Why proper investigations ultimately protect both accused people and genuine victims
Not On Record REWIND | Finally A Win For Men
2026/08/03
Sponsored by EasyDNS
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
https://easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: notonrecord
A landmark acquittal may reshape how Canadian courts view domestic abuse. Joseph Neuberger and Michael Bury break down a historic sexual assault trial involving allegations made during a high conflict divorce, where expert evidence established that the accused was an abused husband suffering from trauma caused by coercive control.
The discussion explores how this evidence was admitted, why it mattered, how it influenced cross-examination, and why the judge ultimately rejected the complainant’s credibility. They also explain the legal test for admitting expert evidence, the importance of challenging stereotypes surrounding male victims, and why rigorous research into false allegations is long overdue.
Not On Record REWIND | When Children Are Told What to Remember
2026/07/27
In this Not On Record REWIND, Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison revisit two extraordinary acquittals that highlight the importance of credibility, reliability, and the presumption of innocence in Canadian criminal courts.
The discussion examines a high-conflict family law dispute involving allegations of parental alienation, implanted memories, and nine criminal charges that resulted in complete acquittals. They also analyze a separate sexual assault case where the trial judge went beyond reasonable doubt and expressly rejected the complainant’s testimony while accepting the accused’s evidence.
The episode explores why criminal trials exist to determine guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, not to vindicate allegations, and discusses growing concerns over false accusations, specialized courts, and the need for rigorous academic research into wrongful allegations.
Podcast reviews
Read Not On Record Podcast podcast reviews
el Boominator 2021/12/27
A rare voice of reason
A clear and refreshingly non-polemical reality check in a sea of inaccuracies, agendas and outright gas-lighting. Due process is not a political or ge...
C.M. Talbert 2021/07/27
Happy to see Diana Davison finally has a podcast!
I’ve known since 2013 that Diana has a truly exceptional worldview and set of talents. Excited for the podcast and anything she’s working on in the fu...
em😊1999 2021/05/26
Great new podcast
Thoughtful discussion of important issues and very entertaining.
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Not On Record Podcast relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.737261991
The Eric Metaxas Show
Metaxas Media

4.725741047
The Dana Show with Dana Loesch – Politics & Culture Commentary
Dana Loesch – Conservative Political Commentary

4.913561982
Wholesaling Inc with Brent Daniels
Find distressed properties for pennies on the dollar and turn them for huge profits!

4.619822887
All Ears English Podcast
Lindsay McMahon and Michelle Kaplan

4.672722000
Timcast News
Timcast Media

4.75941763
Ruthless Podcast
Josh Holmes, Comfortably Smug, Michael Duncan and John Ashbrook

4.662942000
The Dr. Laura Podcast
Dr. Laura Schlessinger & SiriusXM

4.723982000
Everything Everywhere Daily
Gary Arndt

4.834901999
Conservative Review with Daniel Horowitz
Blaze Podcast Network

4.92010947
The Wright Report
Bryan Dean Wright