Advertise on podcast: CASES OF THE FBI

During the early 1960s, Boston investigators confronted a series of murders that challenged conventional investigative methods. This episode examines the emerging role of behavioral analysis, interagency information sharing, and the difficulties of linking crimes across jurisdictions. We explore how investigators approached the case before modern forensic technologies could help resolve crucial questions.

In 1988, eight-year-old April Tinsley disappeared from Fort Wayne, Indiana, launching a murder investigation that would last three decades. As the killer taunted authorities with disturbing handwritten messages, investigators sought behavioral insights and forensic evidence to identify the suspect. This episode examines the role of FBI assistance, criminal profiling, and interagency cooperation in a case that seemed impossible to solve. Discover how advances in forensic genetic genealogy finally helped investigators identify John D. Miller in 2018.

In 2009, nineteen-year-old Edric Hinton was shot and killed outside a Lansing, Michigan, apartment complex, leaving investigators with few answers and no recovered murder weapon. Years later, information from a confidential informant reportedly led detectives to a shotgun buried underground, creating a potential breakthrough in the investigation. This episode explores how firearms examination, federal tracing resources, and cooperation between investigative agencies can help reconstruct a homicide years after the crime. Discover how physical evidence can transform a long-dormant investigation into a case with identifiable suspects.

On December 11, 1978, armed robbers stole nearly $6 million in cash and jewelry from Lufthansa’s cargo terminal at JFK Airport, launching one of the most notorious organized crime investigations in American history. An abandoned getaway van, insider information, and connections to New York’s criminal underworld helped investigators reconstruct the operation. We examine how federal investigators pursued Jimmy Burke’s criminal network, the importance of Henry Hill’s cooperation, and the evidence that eventually led to convictions in related cases. Why were authorities able to identify major suspects while securing so few convictions for the robbery itself?

In 1960, eight-year-old Gloria Kowalewicz was abducted and murdered in Chicago, beginning a homicide investigation that would remain unresolved for more than six decades. In October 2026, investigators announced that modern forensic evidence had identified former Chicago homicide detective Thomas McInerney as their suspect. How do investigators reconstruct a murder when witnesses have died, evidence has aged, and the suspected killer once worked in law enforcement? This episode examines the investigative methods, forensic breakthroughs, and extraordinary challenges of solving a case in which the suspect was once part of the profession responsible for finding killers.

: In 1969, a teenage girl was murdered in an Oakland hotel room, and a fugitive previously placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list became a suspect. Despite years of investigation, authorities could neither apprehend Taylor Morris Teaford nor identify the victim. When the FBI joined the renewed investigation in 2020, modern forensic techniques and investigative genetic genealogy helped uncover a crucial family connection. This episode explores how federal and local investigators worked together to restore Joanne Burdick’s identity and why the search for answers continues

During Prohibition, Al Capone became one of America’s most notorious organized crime figures, yet federal authorities struggled to secure a major conviction. Investigators from the Treasury Department pursued his financial records while other federal efforts targeted organized crime in Chicago. Their work culminated in a landmark income tax evasion prosecution in 1931. This episode explores the federal investigative strategy that ended Capone’s criminal career.

In October 1986, 23-year-old Teresa Ann Houck left the Baltimore club where she worked and was never seen alive again, found shot to death in Druid Hill Park just hours later. Investigators had physical evidence but no identified killer, and the case went cold for nearly four decades. Then a routine DNA database search produced the match prosecutors say finally gave the case a name. This episode looks at how forensic databases and investigative persistence can bring an unsolved homicide back to life.

For years, bombs appeared across New York City while police struggled to identify the man responsible. Then psychiatrist James A. Brussel examined the bomber’s letters and behavior and produced a remarkably specific portrait of the person investigators should be looking for. The hunt for George Metesky became one of America’s most famous early examples of behavioral profiling—but the real breakthrough also depended on records, painstaking detective work, and a crucial investigative lead.

"FBI Profiler" isn't an entry-level job — it's the end of a long, competitive road that starts with becoming a special agent, surviving Quantico, and working real cases for years before anyone even gets a shot at the Behavioral Analysis Unit. This episode lays out the real path to NCAVC, from selection through the small number of desks available at the top. The steps to get there are public knowledge; the odds of actually making it are not. We fill in the decade of work that television always skips.

Jana Monroe broke ground as the first female FBI agent in the Behavioral Science Unit, consulting on roughly 850 homicide cases over her career, including work connected to Jeffrey Dahmer and the Rogers family murders. Drawing on her book Hearts of Darkness and recent interviews, this episode explores what profiling actually looked like inside the Bureau — crime-scene analysis and victimology used to narrow a suspect pool, not psychic insight into a killer's mind. It's a firsthand account of the real work behind a role Hollywood has spent decades getting wrong.

On May 20, 2012, a gang fight inside a privately run Mississippi prison holding federal immigration inmates spiraled into a multi-hour riot. Twenty-four-year-old Senior Correctional Officer Catlin Carithers, called in on his day off, was beaten to death on a roof after inmates rigged food carts into a makeshift ladder to reach him. This episode traces how federal investigators worked the aftermath, ultimately building cases against inmates who assaulted staff, held the carts steady, and destroyed surveillance cameras to cover their tracks.

The legend goes that gangster "Machine Gun" Kelly coined the term "G-Men" when he begged federal agents not to shoot during his 1933 arrest — but the real story is a lesson in institutional myth-making. This episode traces how J. Edgar Hoover's Bureau and a cooperative press turned a routine capture into a branding coup months after the fact. It's a case study in how authority, narrative control, and media complicity combine to shape public memory long before anyone had a Twitter account.

his episode uncovers the chilling case of Helen Golay and Olga Rutterschmidt, two elderly Los Angeles women who befriended vulnerable, homeless men under the guise of charitable support. Behind the charitable facade, the duo took out millions of dollars in life insurance policies before staging fatal hit-and-run accidents in dark alleys to collect massive payouts. From the initial suspicions raised by overlapping insurance claims to the secret holding-cell recordings that brought them down, we trace how a web of calculated greed turned into one of the city's most ruthless murder schemes.

When an active serial killer deliberately crosses state lines and alters their operational methods, local law enforcement often loses the trail. This investigative breakdown reveals how the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit utilizes VICAP (Violent Criminal Apprehension Program) to link geographically separated cold cases. Learn the federal tracking strategies, cross-jurisdictional intelligence sharing, and behavioral link analysis needed to catch mobile offenders practicing predatory drift.