Advertise on podcast: You Are Not the Jellicle Choice sponsors by Hug House Productions

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from You Are Not the Jellicle Choice podcast

2026: I Saw Macavity Storm the Capitol (with Sarah Margaret)

2026/09/30

This year, we turn some tables. And the film, as always, turns on us. GO FOLLOW SARAH MARGARET AND READ FIDDLEHEAD FERN AND BLADELANDS! sarahs website do you know how hard it was for me to not just say "sarahs madamewebsite"@sarahmargs on blueskybladelands also on bluesky

JELLICLE: FOR GOOD (the shows not ending unfortunately. this is a wicked for good joke title.)

2025/12/12

it's WICKED........ 4 GOOD things we talked about in this episode: pearl closing shotmadame morrible cage dress thingog bad bitch draculaura with also a cage dress thing20khz episode on wicked for goodthat van gogh moviesundayyyyyyyyyyyy... by the blueeeee.... purple yellow red waterrrrr..............

2025: A Repulsive Opacity (with Josh Rubino)

2025/09/30

This year we're back with sweet Joshy and we're all SAD!!!!!!!!! until we get to some headcanons that are "kinda silly."

The Madame Web (2024) Special

2025/06/27

actually ellen. thats not true. i did invite you. ask anyone. Intro/Outro music credits: "Toxic," Lo-Fi cover by Lofi Fruits https://youtu.be/7bEAfubZV1Q

The Wicked (2024) Special

2024/12/30

a stoned lifelong wicked hater and a sober lifelong wicked lover meet on one fated night to discuss................. wicked the movie part one the film (2024). cynthia erivo more like........ simpin'-ya foreverivo. sorry

2024: All These Cats Are Dead (with Katie Chin)

2024/09/30

This year, we bring you a new guest: Katie Chin, improv comedian extraordinaire, and voice of Grace Chen on VALENCE. And Katie brings us a new reading of this film: these cats aren't asking to die, because they are already dead, and have been dead the whole time. OKAY

2023: Incel Grizabella (with Josh Rubino)

2023/09/30

Guess what's still a bad movie? It's Cats (2019)! This year for our most worst tradition, we are joined by our most best boy, Josh Rubino, whose Gus the Theater Cat impression is perfect. (Content warning: Wil is NOT sober. Drug mentions throughout!) Credits:Co-hosted by Anne Baird, Josh Rubino, and Wil Williams.Edited and sound designed by Wil Williams. Website and Transcripts can be found at HugHouse.Productions/JellicleChoice. Follow us on Twitter at @NotTheJellicle. Support this show and more at Patreon.com/HugHousePods.

2022: Cats Imitates Life

2022/09/30

We don't want to do this. But we're not cowards and can't help but commit to the bit. So we watched Cats (2019) again. Credits:Co-hosted by Anne Baird, Katie Youmans, and Wil Williams.Edited and sound designed by Wil Williams. Website and Transcripts can be found at HugHouse.Productions/JellicleChoice. Follow us on Twitter at @NotTheJellicle. Support this show and more at Patreon.com/HugHousePods.

2021: The Weed Made Me Right

2021/10/01

Episode NotesIn this, the first episode of You Are Not the Jellicle Choice, we try to understand why we're doing this, talk way too much about buttholes, and ultimately descend further into hell while discussing Cats (2019) at length. Mentioned in the episode: "Why the Music in Cats (2019) is Worse than you Thought" by Sideways (Youtube) Credits: Co-hosted by Anne Baird, Katie Youmans, and Wil Williams.Edited and sound designed by Wil Williams.Music by Komiku. Website and Transcripts can be found at HugHouse.Productions/JellicleChoice. Follow us on Twitter at @NotTheJellicle. Support this show and more at Patreon.com/HugHousePods.