Advertise on podcast: You Can't Scare Me!

Rating

★★★★★

from

22 reviews

Description

Listen closely... Do you hear that? OH MY GOD! It's Mario, Bob, Brandon and (sometimes) Rachel venturing through all 62 of the original Goosebumps books by "Jovial Bob" R.L. Stine! Join them for magic hares, "Who's there?"s and jump scares in this super chill episodic podcast that they'll be sued for if they're not careful! Did I mention they also compare the books with their TV show counterparts? No? Well I just did! ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠

Unlock You Can't Scare Me! podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details

Email contact information

Direct podcast contact details

Listeners

Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details

Podcast Insights

Social media

Check You Can't Scare Me! social media presence

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from You Can't Scare Me! podcast

Goosebumps The Musical

2026/08/05

Don't be such a donut! On this episode of YCSM, Brandon plays fart.mp3, Mario catches a killer brown-handed, and Bob finds a new iPhone case!(00:00) Introduction (08:30) Mario Recaps Gaston Leroux's Original Phantom of the Opera (58:58) Brandon Recaps Phantom of the Opera Films (1:15:27) Garfield The Musical (1:19:04) History of Goosebumps The Musical (1:29:15) Track Summary ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Phantom of the Auditorium

2026/07/07

I’m da Phantom baby! On this episode of YCSM, Mario forgets about anime, Bob injects Knuckles, and Brandon performs a musical number!(00:00) Introduction (10:34) Mario's History Lesson (52:23) Judging a Book by Its Cover (1:06:00) Mario’s Chapter Summary (1:32:26) Bob’s Chapter Summary (1:46:28) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (2:11:20) TV Episode Discussion (2:22:33) Overall Review (2:35:02) Goodreads Reads ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Return of the Mummy

2026/04/27

NOT a scarab! On this episode of YCSM, Bob dies, Mario spit-takes, and Brandon tests his audio levels!(00:00) Introduction (6:22) Mario's History Lesson (31:40) Judging a Book by Its Cover (58:48) Bob’s Chapter Summary (1:15:11) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (1:40:13) Mario’s Chapter Summary (1:53:16) TV Episode Discussion (2:05:35) Overall Review (2:13:34) Goodreads Reads ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Ghost Beach

2026/03/15

Peace be with you and this is podracing! On this episode of YCSM, Devious Vacuum is full of loose soda, Brandon thinks about Iori Yagami, Bob wonders what mako tastes like, and Mario embraces being a huge weird pervert! (00:00) Introduction (2:56) Mario's History Lesson (12:50) Judging a Book by Its Cover (51:25) Dvac’s Chapter Summary (1:50:15) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (2:02:34) Mario’s Chapter Summary (2:18:23) Bob’s Chapter Summary (2:35:29) TV Episode Discussion (2:48:40) Overall Review (2:55:59) Goodreads Reads ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

More & More & More Tales to Give You Goosebumps

2025/12/25

Merry Christmas! On this episode of YCSM, Brandon goes caroling, Mario loves his dog, and Bob gives the gift of editing! Merry Christmas! (00:00) Introduction (12:28) Judging a Book by Its Cover (23:53) Mario’s Chapter Summary (1:06:12) Bob’s Chapter Summary (1:33:50) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (2:28:31) Overall Review (2:33:26) Bad Two Sentence Horror ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Go Eat Worms!

2025/12/05

I’m don’t love it! On this episode of YCSM, Mario calls RFK Jr an idiot to his face (not a joke), Bob learns every way to pronounce “papier-mâché”, and Brandon struggles to pronounce “Jacobus” correctly! (00:00) Introduction (03:17) Mario's History Lesson (35:52) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (56:43) Mario’s Chapter Summary (1:31:59) Bob’s Chapter Summary (1:53:52) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (2:16:03) TV Episode Discussion (2:30:24) Overall Review (2:36:22) Goodreads Reads ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

The Scarecrow Walks at Midnight

2025/10/31

It’s a Stine Crime! On this episode of YCSM, Bob uses examples for credit, Brandon becomes a witch and curses himself with extra warts, and Mario’s Grandma won’t let him jack it! (00:00) Introduction (05:23) Mario's History Lesson (22:21) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (52:42) Bob’s Chapter Summary (1:16:02) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (1:37:11) Mario’s Chapter Summary (1:58:37) TV Episode Discussion (2:16:52) Overall Review (2:27:24) Goodreads Reads ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Deep Trouble

2025/10/13

Water in the fire WHY?! On this episode of YCSM, Brandon gets caught up in the crossfire, Bob steps on some fire coral, and Mario discovers Cthulhu! (00:00) In the Laboratory of Dr. Weird (00:35) Introduction (03:26) Mario's History Lesson (21:05) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (43:07) Bob’s Chapter Summary (1:07:16) Brandon’s Chapter Summary (1:28:40) Mario’s Chapter Summary (1:45:23) Overall Review (1:57:14) Goodreads Reads ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

The Goosebumps 2023 TV Series - Eps 1 and 2

2025/09/13

We need that Heimlich! On this special bonus episode of YCSM, Mario jams on an egg sandwich, Brandon says goodbye to Ganon, and Bob rots in hell! (00:00) Introduction (21:09) Episode 1: Say Cheese and Die! (1:44:00) Episode 2: The Haunted Mask (2:20:46) Overall Review ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Monster Blood II

2025/08/09

Cuddles, no! On this episode of YCSM, Mario gives expert testimony, Bob deploys Fart_with_Reverb.mp3, and Brandon rewrites Goosebumps in iambic pentameter! (00:00) RIP George Lowe (01:26) Introduction (04:05) Mario's History Lesson (19:16) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (46:21) Brandon's Chapter Summary (1:15:11) Mario's Chapter Summary (1:44:18) Bob's Chapter Summary (1:56:05) Overall Review ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ ⁠Here’s a video version of this podcast!

Why I'm Afraid of Bees

2025/06/16

R.L. Stine gaslights children! On this episode of YCSM, Bob finds a cursed audiobook, Mario discovers bugs at work, and Brandon spends half the podcast adding reverb to clips of Nicolas Cage screaming! (00:00) Introduction (05:35) Mario's History Lesson (22:24) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (46:54) Legal Problems ft. Josh Moniz (52:39) Mario's Chapter Summary (1:24:14) Bob's Chapter Summary (1:53:17) Brandon's Chapter Summary (2:31:38) Overall Review ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ Video version of this podcast: https://youtu.be/TqV0JZwyH5Q

One Day at HorrorLand

2024/12/31

It's a Hoops Party! On today's YCSM, Mario discovers the magic of the Game Dot Com, Brandon learns how to use an umbrella from the Backstreet Boys, and Garfield slides into Bob's DMs! (00:00) Introduction (04:15) Mario's History Lesson (29:57) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (57:26) Bob's Chapter Summary (1:17:28) Brandon's Chapter Summary (1:35:08) Mario's Chapter Summary (2:01:42) TV Episode Discussion (3:13:44) Overall Review ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ Video version of this podcast: https://youtu.be/z3JpPK1xfRA

You Can't Scare Me!

2024/10/16

bröther may i have some spööks? On this episode of YCSM, Brandon ponders how one throws a bee, Mario wants Mothman and Slenderman to kiss, and Bob discovers what mud monsters are really made of! (00:00) bröther may i have some spööks? (03:24) Mario's History Lesson (14:43) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (37:58) Brandon's Chapter Summary (1:13:03) Mario's Chapter Summary (1:26:37) Bob's Chapter Summary (1:46:39) TV Episode Discussion (2:12:44) Overall Review (2:19:15) Podcast Updates! ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ Video version of this podcast: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnR99ZpK04M

The Werewolf of Fever Swamp

2024/07/09

Bad dog! On this episode of YCSM, Bob has a bad dream, Brandon writes a sentence guaranteed to give you a migraine, and Mario gets a phone call! (00:00) Dog Mess Express (04:53) Introduction (09:24) Mario's History Lesson (29:23) "Judging a Book by Its Cover" ft. Brandon (58:30) Chapter Summary Discussion: Mario (1:22:29) Chapter Summary Discussion: Bob (1:50:02) Chapter Summary Discussion: Brandon (2:28:13) TV Episode Discussion (3:17:10) Overall Review ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ Video version of this podcast: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ETsFZmR6Ck

Piano Lessons Can Be Murder

2024/04/15

HANDS! BEAUTIFUL HANDS!! On this episode of YCSM, Mario lets out an exasperated sigh, Bob can't find his Brain Grain™ cereal, and Brandon can't stop screaming! (00:00) Introduction (04:39) Mario's History Lesson (20:08) Cover Discussion (29:28) Bob's Chapter Summary (54:31) Brandon's Chapter Summary (1:33:04) Mario's Chapter Summary (1:49:04) TV Episode Discussion (2:20:26) Overall Review ⁠Support us on Patreon!⁠ Video version of this podcast: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYT6yhNJULc

Podcast reviews

Read You Can't Scare Me! podcast reviews

5 out of 5

22 reviews

★★★★★

nickie_cage 2026/04/28

Listener Beware! You're in for a REALLY good podcast!

The amount of research and work that goes into the production of these episodes (the cultural context of the various books' release dates, the variati...

★★★★★

embeey4 2025/07/04

Love the show

Love it but the only complaint is the slow rate of episode production, so given 15 episodes over three years—if that keeps up it’ll be nine years befo...

★★★★★

dubbs654 2025/01/27

The Best Goosebumps Pod

I’ve listened to all the available Goosebumps podcasts out there and this is BY FAR the very best one. They have the perfect balance of summary, comme...

★★★★★

K#132 2024/07/27

What a great show!

I really appreciate the new features showing off the different covers and other visual information. The hosts are a hoot!

★★★★★

leylougan 2023/12/25

Spooktacular Fun!

Goosebumps was a big part of my childhood so it's great fun to experience them again with the lovely hosts of You Can't Scare Me! I love hearing about...

★★★★★

My Name is Grant 2022/05/01

Monster buds

You could read 3 Goosebumps books in the time it takes to listen to one episode but you’d have much more fun with the podcast.

★★★★★

Thnikkafan 2021/11/10

Good stuff!

This show is fantastic and I can’t wait to hear more of it. No idea if it’s going to be biweekly, monthly or released whenever, but I’m definitely her...

check all reviews on apple podcasts