Advertise on podcast: What Exit? The New Jersey History Podcast

This episode brings us into the Pines during Prohibition, when the Barrens are again sought to be used as a corridor. A visitor from Chicago works with a widow from North Jersey to contain the presence to stop it from growing and attracting unwanted visitors to the Pines. Eastern State Penitentiary, The Royal Pines Hotel, Lucy the Elephant, and bootleg booze all make an appearance. #folklore #prohibition #newjersey #pinebarrens #jerseydevil [email protected]

Is it pork roll or Taylor Ham—and why does anyone care this much? In this episode, we dig into New Jersey’s most stubborn breakfast argument, tracing the history of the product, the law behind its name, and the cultural muscle memory that keeps the fight alive. **The episode art features a "Fat Jovo," from Jovo's Deli in Brick, NJ. Email me: [email protected] #PorkRoll #TaylorHam #NewJerseyHistory #FoodHistory #NJFoodCulture

This episode explores how “ya sista’s ass” functions as a multipurpose interjection whose meaning depends entirely on tone, timing, and shared cultural understanding. We look at pronunciation, regional accent, in-group language, and why phrases like this rarely appear in dictionaries or archives—despite being used daily for generations. Drawing on family oral history, the episode traces the phrase’s likely mid-20th-century roots and examines how language is passed down not through books, but through kitchens, cars, and everyday life. Email me: [email protected] #NewJerseyHistory #RegionalLanguage #OralHistory #NortheastCulture #LanguageAndMemory

This is part of our ongoing "New Jersey Foodways" series, where we explore New Jersey's rich food culture. Many of the diners we think of as “local” were never built on site. In this episode, we explore New Jersey’s role as the center of prefabricated diner manufacturing, the companies that built them, and the Greek immigrant families who gave them permanence. From O’Mahony, Silk City, and Kullman diners to real, still-operating examples across New Jersey, this episode looks at diners not just as restaurants, but as manufactured buildings designed to move.

For nearly a century, the American Republic quietly honored an obligation it never named. The office of the presidency changed hands repeatedly, from the generation that fought the Revolution through the age of internal fracture, yet the payments continued. Each envelope carried the same phrase: for services rendered. This episode follows the final years of a man in the New Jersey Pine Barrens who walked where the nation could not. As the country turned its attention to mass armies and open battlefields, the obligation ended not with debate, but with neglect. By the opening decades of the twentieth century, the presence in the Pines no longer frightened in the old way. It functioned. It kept outsiders hesitant and questions unanswered. When the nation began outlawing what it could no longer manage openly, there were already places where authority arrived late, if at all. The story had prepared the ground. The Jersey Devil was not created by panic. It endured because it was useful. ChatGPT was used to generate the show artwork- the research, writing, and recording are all original work. Email me: [email protected] #JerseyDevil #NewJerseyHistory #PineBarrens #AmericanFolklore #ProhibitionEra #HauntedHistory Bibliography John McPhee, The Pine Barrens (1967) U.S. Presidential Papers, 1789–1865 (National Archives; Library of Congress) William Livingston Papers (New Jersey State Archives) Burlington Gazette (1870s) Atlantic County Pilot (1880s) Camden Post (1890s) Charles B. Skinner, Myths and Legends of Our Own Land (1896–1900) New Jersey and Pennsylvania Newspaper Archives (1909) Proceedings of the New Jersey Historical Society (early 20th century) New Jersey State Police Annual Reports (1910s–1920s) U.S. Treasury Department Reports (1919–1925) Nelson Johnson, Boardwalk Empire (2002)

In 1779 New Jersey, a wounded young dragoon named William Van Mater is drawn into a hidden war in the Pine Barrens. As Loyalist raiders, Hessian deserters, and George Washington’s secret operatives converge, Van Mater becomes the unlikely handler of an unfinished supernatural force that history will one day call the Jersey Devil. Artwork: ChatGPT. Research, writing, and narration are my own. #JerseyDevil #NewJerseyHistory #PineBarrens #RevolutionaryWar #AmericanFolklore #HiddenHistory [email protected] Bibliography Franklin, Benjamin. Poor Richard Improved. Philadelphia, 1733–1758.Livingston, William. The Papers of William Livingston, 1742–1790. Trenton: New Jersey Historical Commission.McPhee, John. The Pine Barrens. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1967.Sabine, Lorenzo. Biographical Sketches of Loyalists of the American Revolution. Boston, 1864.Washington, George. The Papers of George Washington, Revolutionary War Series. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.

Every legend begins before it has a name. In the years after Monmouth, the Pine Barrens became a place where fear traveled faster than soldiers, and where stories formed in the spaces armies never touched. This episode traces the moment when the corridor through New Jersey began to change — and when the thing that would one day become the Jersey Devil first entered the landscape. [email protected] Sources available upon request.

Have you heard of William van Mater, a young 18-year-old from Monmouth County...? In 1779, the war in New Jersey didn’t just happen on battlefields — it moved along roads, into homes, and through the lives of ordinary people in Monmouth County. This episode tells the story of Lewis Fenton, the violence tied to the “Pine Banditti,” and the events that changed how people lived that summer — from Crosswicks to Longstreet’s Mill. We close by reading the original historical documents from the time. [email protected] #NewJerseyHistory #AmericanRevolution #MonmouthCounty #PineRobbers #PineBarrens #HistoryPodcast *Thumbnail designed by ChatGPT; all research and recording are original work.

This episode steps back into Revolutionary-era Monmouth County, where the war didn’t always look like armies or battlefields. It lived in night raids, stolen goods, fear inside households, and men who disappeared into the Pine Barrens. We follow the story of Jacob Fagan, the raid on the Dennis family near Manasquan, the retaliatory ambush that ended his life, Governor William Livingston’s proclamation against “robberies, violences and depredations,” and the infiltration work of dragoon John Van Kirk that led to the Rock Pond ambush in 1779. This is the story of how fear became policy — and how the phrase “robbers in the Pines” entered the historical record long before it became legend. [email protected] #NewJerseyHistory #AmericanRevolution #PineBarrens #MonmouthCounty #ColonialAmerica #HistoryPodcast

The Pine Robbers of New Jersey’s Pine Barrens have been remembered as Loyalist raiders, coastal banditti, neighborhood criminals, and near-folklore figures who vanished into cedar swamps and sand roads. But the record tells a far more complicated story — one shaped by fear, geography, wartime desertion, and the language communities used to describe the men who moved “in the space between” armies during the American Revolution. This series explores what people believed about the Pine Robbers, what they feared, what later generations remembered, and what the surviving letters, court records, newspapers, and official reports actually show — including references in the New-Jersey Gazette, Governor William Livingston’s correspondence, and accounts of efforts to “take the robbers in the Pines.” We follow the history with care, separating legend from documentation, and standing as close to the record as it allows. [email protected]

This episode is set in the Pine Barrens of New Jersey during the American Revolution — a landscape of hesitation, rumor, fear, and uncertainty long before the legend of the Jersey Devil took shape. Episode 3 of our Before the Devil Had Wings series traces how empty roads, ferries, supply routes, and quiet warnings created a protected corridor through the Pines, and how George Washington used caution, memory, and silence to shape movement during wartime New Jersey. We follow ferrymen, merchants, clergy, laborers, and guides whose choices — practical, reluctant, patriotic, and deeply human — helped preserve the mystery of the Pine Barrens. Before the Jersey Devil myth, before wings and hooves and Leeds-family folklore, the land itself carried the fear. [email protected] #NewJerseyHistory #PineBarrens #JerseyDevilOrigins #AmericanRevolution #FolkloreHistory

Why are there Christmas trees on New Jersey beaches? Most people assume it’s a recent tradition, but the story goes back much further. In this episode, we explore the surprising history of beach Christmas trees in New Jersey, tracing their roots from early Moravian Christmas practices and German traditions, through Victorian culture influenced by Queen Victoria and Prince Albert, to New Jersey’s role in growing Christmas trees commercially. We follow how Christmas trees moved from private homes into public spaces, onto boardwalks after World War II, and eventually into the sand itself during Operation Christmas Tree in 1963, when discarded trees were used to rebuild dunes and protect the shoreline. After Superstorm Sandy in 2012, forgotten ornaments resurfaced, helping inspire the beach Christmas tree tradition many people recognize today. This episode blends documented history with careful storytelling to show how ordinary people, quiet traditions, and repeated acts of care turned a simple holiday decoration into a lasting part of New Jersey’s winter shoreline. [email protected] https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/local/beach-christmas-trees-tradition-2026-jersey-shore/4319174/ #NewJerseyHistory #HolidayTraditions #JerseyShore #ChristmasHistory #PublicHistory Bibliography Forbes, Bruce David. Christmas: A Candid History. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2007. Nissenbaum, Stephen. The Battle for Christmas. New York: Knopf, 1996. Moravian Archives. “Moravian Christmas Traditions in Early America.” Bethlehem, PA. Illustrated London News. December 1848. Engraving of Queen Victoria and Prince Albert decorating a Christmas tree. Long Beach Island Historical Museum. “Operation Christmas Tree, 1963.” Press of Atlantic City. “Atlantic City Boardwalk Gets First Christmas Tree in 152-Year History.” 2022.

 Traditions don’t survive because they’re explained. They survive because they’re recognized. And I don’t know of any group that has more honorary members than Italian-Americans. Every Christmas Eve, Italian-American families gather for the Feast of the Seven Fishes. The tradition feels ancient, immovable. But where did it actually come from, and how did it take root in New Jersey? In this episode, we explore the real history behind La Vigilia, Italian immigration, regional foodways, and how a once-practical ingredient like baccalà became the emotional centerpiece of Christmas Eve. Along the way, we move through grocery stores, fishmongers, and kitchens, tracing how memory, restraint, and recognition survive long after language and habit begin to fade. This is not a how-to episode. It’s a why-we-still-do-this episode.Because sometimes tradition doesn’t need explaining.It just needs to be noticed. [email protected] #SevenFishes #ItalianAmericanHistory #NewJerseyHistory #ChristmasEveTraditions #FoodAndMemory Bibliography Gabaccia, Donna R. We Are What We Eat: Ethnic Food and the Making of Americans. Harvard University Press, 1998. Cinotto, Simone. The Italian American Table: Food, Family, and Community in New York City. University of Illinois Press, 2013. Montanari, Massimo. Italian Cuisine: A Cultural History. Columbia University Press, 2006. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. “Questions and Answers About Abstinence and Fast.”

Join me for a mixture of fact and fiction. Before America ran on Dunkin’, early Dutch settlers in New Jersey ran on oliekoek and hot chocolate. Fried dough and thick cocoa. Not treats. Fuel. This episode traces the long, practical history of doughnuts in New Jersey, from Dutch winter kitchens in 17th-century Pavonia to bakeries, taverns, and early coffee culture, and finally to the rise of Dunkin’ Donuts as statewide infrastructure. Along the way, we examine what made fried dough last, why it spread, and how New Jersey turned a seasonal survival food into something ordinary enough to depend on. The episode closes with a fictional coda, grounded in historical context, exploring how food traditions move through families, places, and habits long after their origins are forgotten. #NewJerseyHistory #FoodHistory #DoughnutHistory #DutchAmerica #NewJerseyCulture Sources Sophie D. Coe and Michael D. Coe, The True History of Chocolate— Background on early hot chocolate as a thick, functional food. Michael Janofsky, “Foodways in Early New Netherland”— Dutch cooking traditions carried into early New Jersey. Andrew F. Smith, The Oxford Companion to American Food and Drink— Reference for doughnuts, frying traditions, and early American foodways. New Jersey State Archives, Colonial Probate and Tavern Records— Evidence of cookware, frying, cocoa, and everyday food in colonial New Jersey. Asbury Park Press advertising archives (1964–1974)— Documentation of early Dunkin’ Donuts locations in New Jersey.

Winter changed how people lived in early New Jersey. In Dutch-settled communities along the Hudson River and the Palisades, Christmas week was understood as a time when routine loosened, burial was delayed, and vigilance mattered. This episode explores how people organized their lives around uncertainty, not because they believed in ghosts, but because they believed attention was a form of responsibility. Through a restrained narrative set in 1680 and documented Dutch Reformed church records from places like Bergen, Hackensack, Communipaw, and Paulus Hook, we examine why winter and Christmas were treated as moments when the world grew thin. #GhostsOfHistory #NewJerseyHistory #NJHistory #ColonialNewJersey #DutchNewJersey #ChristmasHistory #HudsonRiverHistory