Advertise on podcast: The Surreality Podcast sponsors by Erica

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from The Surreality Podcast podcast

Watch Love, Actually with Erica and Jess (Erica's first time!)

2025/12/24

Send us Fan Mail Jess is in town, which means it's time for another watch-along! Join us as Jess shows me the holiday classic Love, Actually for the first time.

Surreal Shore-Wicked For Good, and Lizzie Mcguire Aaron Carter Special.

2025/11/30

Send us Fan Mail

Surreal Shore Diablo Cody special!

2025/11/07

Send us Fan Mail Honest to blog...we suffered through 4 hours of Diablo Cody's writing.

I Love New York episode 3- Big Ballers with Jess & Aaron

2025/09/03

Send us Fan Mail

I Love New York- The Mangeant ft. Mock of Love!

2025/08/29

Send us Fan Mail Check out Mock of Love ft. Ashley & Andy everywhere you listen!

I Love New York premiere

2025/06/30

Send us Fan Mail I'm baaaaackkk!!!! To get back into the swing of things, I decided to dive into the first season I Love New York! This season has some iconic moments, and an incredible lineup of contestants. And who can argue against the star power of Tiffany "New York" Pollard!? Enjoy!

Surreal Shore- The Wrestler & Black Swan

2025/05/02

Send us Fan Mail

Surreal Life Fame Games Finale with Jess & Alex

2025/04/15

Send us Fan Mail

Catching up with Mark Cronin

2025/03/20

Send us Fan Mail Surprise! This week, Mark Cronin executive producer of The Surreal Life, Flavor of Love, Rock of Love, Megan Wants a Millionaire, and BEYOND was kind enough to let me interview him about our favorite shows! Mark lets us know how the Surreal Life came to fruition, some behind the scenes dirt, and more! Without Mark, we wouldn't be here today. Enjoy!

The Surreal Life-Fame Games Episode 9 with Heather 3

2025/03/14

Send us Fan Mail This episode has it all! Superfans, a Mark Cronin appearance, and possible cheating! I'm lucky enough to be joined by the WICKedly talented, Heather from Heather & Steven Get Into! Enjoy!

The Surreal Life-Fame Game episode 8

2025/02/28

Send us Fan Mail

The Surreal Life-Fame Games episode 7 with Andrew Cahak

2025/02/13

Send us Fan Mail The A list and B list is GONE FOREVER, it is now every celeb for themselves.The Fame Gamers must compete in a Celebrity reverse telethon. After Vanilla Ice has his daily temper tantrum, Andrea goes into a tailspin realizing she doesn't have any famous friends to dial. Check out Andrew over at Life Was Peachy and Unstable Shapes!

Fame Games episode 6 with Amanda and John from Pod & The City!

2025/01/30

Send us Fan Mail

Surreal Life Fame Games episode 5 feat. Movies That Made Us Gay!

2025/01/17

Send us Fan Mail This week I was lucky enough to have Pete & Scott from Movies That Made Us Gay come on over and talk about Fame Games episode 5- V for Variety. Very fun episode talking about everything from rubber chicken shots, to Rupaul's Drag Race. Enjoy!

BONUS- Babes in Toyland (1986) with Jess!

2025/01/05

Send us Fan Mail If you are worried that you won't enjoy this since Christmas has passed, don't worry. Even the writers of this movie have no idea if it's a Christmas movie or not.

Podcast reviews

Read The Surreality Podcast podcast reviews

5 out of 5

22 reviews

★★★★★

kris10dids 2025/10/24

SO GOOD

erica is just the best and her guests are amazing too!

★★★★★

czechmate05 2025/09/10

So much fun

I never even watched these shows back in the day and I still love this podcast. It’s so much fun and Erica is the best hostess.

★★★★★

ericmooredoodles 2025/08/31

Thank you!

I’m 32 and obsessed w a lot of the indie films you cover i first saw as a teen. Great analysis and lotta fun too.

★★★★☆

TaffyDavenport 2024/09/15

Needs More Celebrity Rehab

Subbed for the Celebrity Rehab episodes, but they’re few and far between.

★★★★★

April4thebooks 2024/04/25

Such a fun listen

Great recaps, interesting opinions and viewpoints. Erica is always ready to share a great show or guest we want to know more about

★★★★★

ggg2008 2023/12/16

5 stars!

I look forward to all your recaps, rock of love, the surreal life and everything in between! I’m a WWE fan also and also love listening to you and whe...

★★★★★

poolpiy 2022/11/02

My new favorite

I throughly enjoy this podcast and the host. Throwback entertainment is my jam and this is the best one I’ve found on here by far

check all reviews on apple podcasts