Advertise on podcast: Go Get 'Em

The ALDS is here, and C-Mac is previewing all the keys to the upcoming series against Tampa! Can the Yankee bats stay hot against the Rays, and is Gerrit Cole the right choice to start game one? Plus, X-factors for the series, debating if Aaron Judge should be on the roster, how the lineups will look against the Rays' likely starting pitchers, and C-Mac's confidence level in the Yanks getting past the division champs and into the ALCS.

C-Mac is popping champagne as the Yankees roll through Boston in the Wild Card Series to get back to the ALDS! Chris breaks down the game two win from Yankee Stadium, from Max Fried's strong outing to the lineup continuing to hit from top to bottom, punishing Boston pitching with an equal mix of small ball and home-run power. Plus, the youngsters continue to come through, Aaron Boone pushed all the right buttons, and is this team primed to beat Tampa Bay? EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS Intro: Welcome to a Wild Card victory! The Yankees sweep the Red Sox with back-to-back nine-run performances and brilliant situational hitting. 5:20: Sonny Gray's performance under the bright lights of Yankee Stadium and the electric crowd reactions. Did Chad Tracy pull him too early? 14:38: Breaking down Max Fried's start and concerns over Trent Grisham's lackadaisical defense in center field. 20:47: Questionable management from Chad Tracy with his decision to pull Sonny Gray and intentionally walk Ben Rice to load the bases for Cody Bellinger. 23:56: Third base coach Luis Rojas's terrible two-out send that killed a potential momentum swing. 26:08: Rickie Ricardo joins the show to discuss Spencer Jones' game-changing hustle and to preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays. 39:36: Austin Wells flips the script on his regular-season struggles with four crucial RBIs in the Wild Card series. 51:03: Final thoughts on the unmatched magic of playoff baseball and why this Yankee team is built to make a deep World Series run.

C-Mac is celebrating LIVE from Yankee Stadium after Cam Schlittler once again owned the Red Sox in playoff action, moving the Bombers to within one win of the ALDS! Chris is joined by Shaun Morash to break down Schlittler's dominance, Ben Rice's big night at the plate, the homegrown youngsters coming through with the bat, and how the Yankees are set up the rest of the series. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS Intro: Live from Yankee Stadium with initial reactions to the Yankees' 9-0 Wild Card Game 1 shutout over the Red Sox. 2:37: Shaun Marash joins the show to praise Cam Schlittler's masterful curveball and his stress-free, 117-pitch performance. 7:46: The game breakers - Ben Rice hits two massive home runs, including the grand slam that turned a close game into a laugher. 12:50: The "Young Blood" steps up - How homegrown talent like George Lombard Jr. (three hits, two runs), Anthony Volpe, and Spencer Jones powered the lineup. 15:03: Roman Anthony's wrist injury and a heavily depleted Red Sox bullpen. 27:18: Rickie Ricardo drops by to declare the Red Sox on the ropes and call for a two-game sweep. 38:22: Aaron Judge missing from pre-game field introductions, roster decisions, and setting up the rotation for Game 2 against Max Fried.

The Yanks will once again host their bitter rivals in the Wild Card Series this week. Will they beat Boston for a second straight season and reach the ALDS? Chris McMonigle breaks down all the keys to this series, ponders how the roster will look, and gives his thoughts on the starting pitching matchups and how Boston's rotation can impact how Aaron Boone constructs the Yankee lineup. Plus, the latest on the health of Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, Ryan Weathers, and more. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS Intro: Season Wrap-Up & Silver Linings - The Yankees fell short of the division crown to the Rays, but a 93-68 record and the emergence of homegrown talents like Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler provide massive momentum. 08:00: Game 1 Starter & Series Keys - Why Cam Schlittler got the nod for Game 1 over Max Fried or Gerrit Cole, and why the Yankees' elite starting rotation is the ultimate key to advancing. 18:00: Defending Aaron Boone’s masterful navigation of a depleted bullpen this season and previewing his dugout clash with Boston manager Chad Tracy. 24:00: A tough conversation on the captain's calf strain. We discuss why Judge pushing to play puts Boone in an unfair spot and why leaving him off the Wild Card roster is likely the painful but necessary call. 33:00: Roster Construction: Projecting a 10-pitcher staff and debating the bench. Plus, why Giancarlo Stanton’s undeniable playoff magic and Trent Grisham's clutch at-bats deserve roster spots over a defensive replacement like Ryan McMahon. 55:00: Game 1 Lineup Projections: Breaking down the optimal starting nine to face Red Sox lefty Payton Tolle. This includes the case for starting Jazz over Volpe at second base to capitalize on much-needed home-run power. 1:21:00: The Ladder of Revenge - Overcoming the anxiety of a three-game "crapshoot" series and looking ahead to a potential dream playoff path against the Red Sox, Rays, Astros, and Dodgers.

Aaron Judge intends to play in the Wild Card Series, which is a far cry from Aaron Boone's previous comments. Is there a miscommunication between the manager and the captain? C-Mac has some strong thoughts on Judge's approach to his own injury updates, if he should try to push it and play against Boston, and whether the Yankees would be better off without Judge at less than 100 percent. Meanwhile, Clarke Schmidt is no longer a Wild Card Series option due to a biceps injury. Is the Yankee bullpen strong enough for a playoff run? Plus, debating what the series against the Rays potentially showed in terms of who deserves what role in the playoffs. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 1:25 - Bright spots from the recent series, focusing on Carlos Rodon's strong start and Lombard's impressive defensive and offensive output. 9:40 - The Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone disconnect: Analyzing Judge's frustration over Boone publicly detailing his "moderate" calf strain. 26:01 - The playoff lineup dilemma: Debating the risks of playing an injured Judge versus relying on Ben Rice or Paul Goldschmidt against left-handed pitching. 31:41 - Evaluating potential postseason roster returns for Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham as late-game pinch-hit options. 33:04 - The argument for leaving Ryan McMahon off the playoff roster despite his recent grand slam and five-RBI game. 39:57 - Wild Card rotation strategy: Weighing whether Cam Schlittler or Max Fried should take the mound for Game 1. 57:51 - Bullpen concerns mount as Clarke Schmidt hits the 15-day IL with biceps tendinitis, exposing the front office's failure to acquire relief help at the deadline. 1:09:37 - Defending Aaron Boone's managerial performance and the team's achievement of winning 92 games despite Judge missing three months of the season.

What is going on with the Yankee captain? Chris McMonigle breaks it all down as well as the series in Arizona and the playoff picture.

It's hold-your-breath time in Yankees Universe as Aaron Judge exited Wednesday's game with lower right leg tightness. Is it time to panic?? C-Mac reveals his level of concern, and how careful the Yankees need to be until the playoffs. Plus, who will fill the shoes of Judge in his absence, and how long could that absence be? Chris also dives into the Twins series as a whole, including another extra innings loss, the game-ending play involving George Lombard Jr., and if the division is officially out of reach. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS Intro: A gut-punch loss and the reality of the Rays taking the division. 11:58: Breaking down Aaron Judge's early exit and his cryptic injury updates. 21:44: Evaluating George Lombard's defensive struggles at shortstop. 30:30: Ryan McMahon's offensive drop-off and building an infield vs. Boston's lefties. 42:23: Positives on the mound: Max Fried's bounce-back start. 45:55: Defending the Yankees' playoff clinch champagne celebration. 1:04:52: "Shill or Shame" segment: Shilling for Bellinger, shaming Ramos. 1:16:25: Pitching preview for the upcoming series in Arizona.

Did Cam Schlittler just cement his Cy Young case?? Chris McMonigle reacts to another dominant outing by the Yankee ace, and discusses why he needs to be the game one starter of a playoff series. Plus, Gerrit Cole is in a brutal slump. Should fans be concerned? And the Rays don't seem to lose, putting a significant dent in the Bombers' division hopes. Is it time to focus on health and being prepared for a Wild Card Series against the Red Sox? EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 3:08 - AL East Race Update: The Rays sweep the Astros, holding onto a daunting four-game lead in the loss column with 13 games left in the season. 6:21 - Unpacking Cam Schlittler's historically great season, his sub-2.00 ERA, and his fiery, old-school mentality when facing rival fans. 24:00 - Reflecting on the somber September 11th atmosphere, Carlos Rodon's strong start, and Ben Rice's pivotal strikeout challenge that shifted the game's momentum in game one. 35:14 - Analyzing the controversial decision to sit top hitters Rice and Garcia against a lefty starter, and evaluating Gerrit Cole after he surrendered seven home runs over his last two starts. 49:03 - Breaking down the 2-0 victory backed by Schlittler's arm and home runs from Rice and Wells in game three. Plus, a deep dive into Aaron Judge's current timing at the plate since his return. 57:19 - Shill or Shame: Handing out the weekly honors—shaming Gerrit Cole's home run woes and shilling for Cam Schlittler's brilliance on the mound. 1:00:00 - Looking Ahead: Playoff clinching scenarios, upcoming pitching matchups against the Minnesota Twins, and why Yankees fans should enjoy popping champagne for a postseason berth.

What a return for Anthony Volpe! Chris McMonigle reacts to Volpe's grand slam and 5 RBI night to lead the Yankees to a sweep of the Rockies. Does this mean the Yankees will have a tough decision to make when Anthony Volpe returns? Plus, Chris reveals if he has any concerns about Max Fried after his laborious start, and just how real are the Yankees' chances at the division after gaining a game on the Rays? EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 6:54 - Anthony Volpe’s unforgettable return from the minors. Shifting to second base, Volpe delivers a 3-for-4 night, an opposite-field grand slam, five RBIs, and earns a goosebump-inducing curtain call. 27:33 - Examining the Yankees' homegrown talent up the middle, punctuated by Spencer Jones securing the everyday center field job with a three-hit performance. 34:04 - A deep dive into Max Fried's alarming velocity drop. Exploring why a 3-4 mph dip on his fastball is a massive concern for the Yankees' championship rotation. 46:10 - The "Shill or Shame" segment. Praising Volpe's massive game while shaming Jasson Dominguez following continuous defensive struggles and a sudden demotion to AAA. 52:23 - Previewing the emotionally heavy September 11th series against the surging New York Mets. Breaking down the pitching matchups—Rodón, Cole, and Schlittler vs. McLean, Thornton, and Scott—and mapping out the path to catch the Rays.

Chris McMonigle reacts to Judge's first game back in 99 days, from how he looked in his three at-bats to how the Yankees will ease him back into being an everyday player. Will he be able to knock the rust off in time? Plus, reactions to another Cam Schlittler masterpiece, if Heliot Ramos' big home run can finally get him going, and the concern level for Jazz Chisholm after leaving the game in the ninth inning with a thumb injury. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS Intro - Aaron Judge returns! Breaking down the 5-3 win over the Rockies and the Yankees' current playoff positioning. 4:22 - Reflecting on the 84 games without Judge and why the pitching staff and Aaron Boone deserve credit for keeping the team in the race. 10:12 - Analyzing Judge's first at-bats back, his bat speed, and the team's load management plan for the final 18 games. 18:32 - Cam Schlittler's dominant performance and why he is the undisputed AL Cy Young favorite. 23:59 - Offensive frustrations against a struggling pitcher and the fallout from Jazz jamming his thumb sliding into second base. 27:00 - If Jazz hits the IL, should Anthony Volpe get called up to play second base?

Gerrit Cole allowed back-to-back-to-back home runs to start Sunday's series finale against the Padres. Chris McMonigle sounds off on Cole's rocky start, the offense struggling against Michael King, and the wasted opportunity to gain a game on the Rays. Plus, are the Red Sox right back in the mix for the top Wild Card spot? C-Mac also touches on Trent Grisham's injury, Aaron Judge's looming return, and much more. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 00:00 - The Yankees lose the series to the Padres and fall four games behind the Rays. A look at the upcoming schedule and the math required to close the gap in the division. 5:00 - Analysis of the Yankees' urgency and overall bullpen management. The offense continues its frustrating trend of getting leadoff runners on base but failing to deliver clutch hits when needed. 15:30 - Trent Grisham suffers a grade two hamstring strain. With Grisham sidelined, Spencer Jones is firmly cemented as the starting center fielder. 23:00 - Game 1 late-inning breakdown. Will Warren pitches well out of the bullpen, but Aaron Boone is questioned for pitching Paul Blackburn instead of closer David Bednar in a crucial tied game. Boone is also heavily criticized for failing to challenge an out call when Spencer Jones attempted to steal third base in the 10th inning. 36:00 - A discussion on managing the bullpen down the stretch as Clarke Schmidt prepares to return. 46:00 - Gerrit Cole gives up three first-inning home runs to Fernando Tatis Jr., Jake Cronenworth, and Manny Machado. Cole settles down to pitch into the seventh, prompting a discussion on why it is more concerning when he loses his effectiveness suddenly mid-game rather than starting poorly. 1:03:00 - A minor league update on Anthony Volpe, who hit five home runs in his last five Triple-A games. 1:07:00 - Aaron Judge's return strategy and why there is no set number of at-bats he needs to feel comfortable. The episode wraps up with fan comments, addressing why the Yankees should not fear the Red Sox catching them in the standings and the absolute necessity of sweeping the upcoming series against the Colorado Rockies.

Chris McMonigle reacts to a thrilling Yankee win to take the series against the Halos and gain a game on the Rays. From the single-filled rally in extras to Cam Schlittler's continued dominance, C-Mac covers it all, including the continued Spencer Jones vs. Trent Grisham debate, the pitching staff's workload with the playoffs approaching, and much more. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 7:21 – Cam Schlittler’s virtuoso performance and his case for the Cy Young. 14:26 – Early offensive struggles, bad luck, and Cody Bellinger's solid series. 19:48 – The 10th inning breakdown and dismantling the "take a strike" philosophy. 23:31 – Austin Wells' biggest hit of the year and trade deadline comparisons to Adley Rutschman. 26:24 – The Spencer Jones vs. Trent Grisham debate for the starting center field job. 38:18 – Evaluating Gerrit Cole's 6th-inning fatigue and concerns about bullpen trust. 49:59 – Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s improved at-bats and passing the eye test. 52:43 – Aaron Judge’s impending return and a deep dive into the Rays' difficult remaining schedule.

The Yankees made a statement by taking three of four from the Red Sox, including a beatdown in Sunday's series finale. Chris McMonigle celebrates the huge victory, what it means for the postseason, and what it says about how far this Yankee team can go in October. Plus, looking at the Yankees platoon identity moving forward, praising Heliot Ramos for finally coming through with a big hit and Will Warren for his masterful start, while the offense showed encouraging signs across the board. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 3:36 - Breaking down the standings impact: The Yankees move four games up on Boston, which is essentially five games thanks to securing the tiebreaker. 6:14 - Reacting to the Red Sox broadcast calling Jazz Chisholm a "bush league" player for stealing bases while up six runs. 10:04 - Analyzing Aaron Boone's heavily debated platoon strategy. The decision to sit hot left-handed hitters like Luis Garcia and Ben Rice in favor of righties like Paul Goldschmidt and Ramos against left-handed pitching ultimately pays off. 29:23 - Carlos Rodon's start unravels after a poor baserunning decision and terrible send at third base involving Amed Rosario. 39:28 - Concerns over Max Fried's Saturday start, specifically a noticeable drop in his fastball velocity down to 92-93 mph. 45:36 - Praise for Paul Blackburn and the bullpen for escaping late-inning jams to secure the victory. 52:41 - Will Warren delivers the best start of his young career in a massive spot, retiring 13 consecutive Red Sox batters after allowing a leadoff double. 1:04:51 - Ramos crushes a critical three-run home run on a 1-2 breaking ball. 1:12:20 - Tampa Bay Rays update: The Rays sweep the Padres by rallying against Mason Miller in the ninth inning to stay five games ahead of the Yankees. 1:18:52 - Looking ahead to the West Coast road trip against the Angels and Padres. Plus, predictions that Aaron Judge will return to the lineup for the upcoming homestand against the Colorado Rockies.

C-Mac reacts to the Yanks grabbing the first game of a massive four-game set against the Red Sox, led by Cam Schlittler dominating Boston once again. Plus, Cody Bellinger and the bullpen come up big, and debating the lineup decisions that paid off, like playing Paul Goldschmidt at first base. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 6:58 - Cam Schlittler's dominant, though walk-heavy, outing 9:16 - How Austin Wells rescued the second inning with two perfectly timed ABS challenges 25:17 - Cody Bellinger unleashes a perfect game-saving throw from left field to nail the runner at the plate in the seventh inning 32:54 - Praise for the trusted bullpen trio of Headrick, Blackburn, and Bednar shutting the door in a tight game 35:03 - Previewing tomorrow's doubleheader featuring Carlos Rodon and the return of Max Fried 47:19 - A reality check for negative fans: Comparing the Yankees' resilient, injury-riddled season to the last-place Toronto Blue Jays

The Yankees picked a bad time for their offense to regress to its earlier form, musting very little against the Astros in their series finale, losing another game in the loss column ahead of a monster series with the Red Sox. C-Mac is back from vacation and ready to sound off on everything surrounding the Yanks, from the battle between pushing for the division and thinking bigger picture, to the latest on Aaron Judge and his preference to skip a rehab assignment. Plus, Luis Garcia Jr.'s continued tear, George Lombard Jr.'s struggles in the field, and whether Brian Cashman missed the boat with his lack of bullpen moves at the trade deadline given the injury to Fernando Cruz. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 6:17: An analysis of George Lombard's puzzling defensive collapse, marked by six errors in six consecutive games. 12:38: Debating Trent Grisham's outfield defense versus his clutch offensive production. 16:34: How Jazz is transforming the offense with his speed and small-ball execution despite ongoing inconsistencies at the plate. 24:18: The Yankees are operating with a dangerously thin bullpen following Cruz's elbow injury. 26:56: Re-evaluating the trade deadline. Brian Cashman's failure to acquire bullpen arms is actively hurting the team. 40:00: Aaron Judge plans to skip rehab assignments and return directly to the major league lineup, potentially during the upcoming homestand against Colorado. 1:00:36: Looking ahead to the biggest series of the year against the Boston Red Sox, starting with Cam Schlittler on the mound. 1:06:05: Breaking down the devastating blow of Giancarlo Stanton's latest injury and the financial realities of his contract buyout.