
Advertise on podcast: Cryptid Cocktail Party
Rating
4.6from
This podcast has
192 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
Cryptid Cocktail PartyExplicit
Yes
Date created
2023/01/29
Latest episode
2026/10/26
Average duration
55 min.
Release period
8 days
Description
Join Dave and Sarge as they have a few drinks, share a few laughs, and take a dive into the world of cryptids, aliens, and conspiracies!
Unlock Cryptid Cocktail Party podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Cryptid Cocktail Party podcast
The Great New England Vampire Panic
2026/10/26
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we conclude our paranormal tour by covering ALL of New England and the Vampire panic that swept the region in the 18th and 19th centuries. Man, we really made a habit out of falling into random fits of mass hysteria out here haven't we? Anyways, this story has it all: Vampires, grave desecration, and even Bram Stoker and H.P. Lovecraft make an appearance. So sit back, grab a blood bag, and enjoy!
Check out Wondrous One Shots from Dungeon In A Box and get 10% off your first month by clicking here or us the code "cryptids" at check out.
Buy Dave a drink for his birthday:
Venmo: @cryptidcocktail
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
Haunting at the Lizzie Borden House
2026/10/19
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are continuing with our inadvertent ghost tour of Massachusetts and covering Lizzie Borden and her supposed haunted house! We cover the crime, the weeks old stew, and the alleged ghosts that now haunt her former home. So sit back, make sure your soup is at a safe temperature, and enjoy!
Check out Wondrous One Shots by Dungeon In A Box and get 10% off you first month here
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Haunting of the USS Salem
2026/10/12
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are keeping on theme with our water based haunts and talking about one of Americas most haunted ships, the USS Salem. This ship has what can only be described as shit ton of ghosts with even more stories to go with them so sit back, turn out the lights, and enjoy!
Check out Wondrous One Shots from Dungeon In A Box and get 10% off your first month here
Get tickets to Bands Will Make Her Dance on October 22nd here
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
Ghosts of Boston Harbor: The Color Coded Trio
2026/10/05
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week were setting sail...kind of. Were really just going to be bouncing around Boston Harbor while Sarge tells the chilling tales of three ghosts known as The Lady In Red, The Lady In Black, and The Lady In White, who have been known to haunt this infamous body of water for sometime. Enjoy!
This episode is brought to you by Wondrous One Shots from Dungeon In A Box. If you ever wanted to play DnD but don't know where to start, this is for you. Head to Dungeon In A Box and recieve 10% off your first month with the code "CRYPTIDS" and checkout or use the link here!
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Dead Internet Theory
2026/09/21
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Theory! This week we are discussing the internet and why its a post apocalyptic hellscape and why you shouldn't trust anything or anyone on it. It's the worst! So sit back, question everything, and enjoy listening to us ramble on at length about The Dead Internet Theory. Enjoy...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
Cryptid Cocktail Party Reacts: Mike Warnke "Do You Hear Me?" with Gabe DeWitt of Killed By A Yeti
2026/09/14
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week were doing something a bit different. We have talked about Mike Warnke a few times in the past couple weeks so we figured, why not see what hes about? So we invited our buddy Gabe of Killed By A Yeti to do just that by forcing him to watch Mike Warnke's entire stand up special "Do You Hear Me?" in full. Guys...its not good. Enjoy!
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Satanic Panic: Dungeons and Dragons Part Two
2026/09/07
This week, Sarge wraps up his series on the Satanic Panic and the crusade against Dungeons and Dragons by diving deeper into Patricia Pulling and her Anti-Dungeons and Dragons activist group, Bothered About Dungeons and Dragons or B.A.D.D (if you're nasty!) We also discuss The Pulling Report, a scathing hit piece aimed at Patricia and her organization by reporter Michael Stackpole which eventually leads to their very welcome downfall. So...roll for initiative and enjoy!
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Satanic Panic: Dungeons and Dragons Part One
2026/08/31
This week, Sarge is taking the reins and steering us straight towards adventure! For the next two weeks he will be our humble episode master, taking on us on a journey filled with demonic forces, evil creatures, and bored housewives. The endgame? Regaling us with the story of how Dungeons and Dragons got all mixed up in the Satanic Panic. So strap in and start breaking B.A.D.D. while we discuss The Satanic Panic: Dungeons & Dragons!
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Melon Heads of Connecticut (feat Megan Goetz)
2026/08/24
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by comedian and organizer of the SureKill Comedy Festival, Megan Goetz, to discuss the infamous Connecticut urban legend...the Melon Heads. These creepy little bulbus brained bastards have been terrorizing the roads of Connecticut since the '60s with some saying it dates back even further to 1600s. We cover everything from their tragic origins, to sightings, as well as their Midwest cousins, we got it all so...enjoy!
To find out more about about the SureKill Comedy Festival, check that out here
And give them a follow on Instagrem: @surekillcomedy
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Kentucky Meat Shower (feat. Kirsten Michelle Cills)
2026/08/17
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are not only graced with Sarges presence once again, but we also are joined by comedian Kirsten Michelle Cills to discuss one of Sarges all time favorite stories...the 1876 mystery of the Kentucky Meat Shower!
Follow Kirsten:
Instagram
YouTube
TikTok
Check out Sarges good pals new Etsy book shop and Instagram as well!
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
Interdimensional Swap: Supernatural Japan (Yurei: Japan's Vengeful Ghosts)
2026/08/07
Welcome back to another installment of Interdimensional Swap! For this one we are bringing you an episode from one of my (Dave) favorite paranormal podcast...Supernatural Japan! Long time listeners of the show know that I love anything to do with Japanese folklore and this checks all my boxes when it comes to that stuff. Well researched, perfect delivery, and Kevin is such an amazing and knowledgeable hosts. Trust me when I say that you will love it.
In this episode of Supernatural Japan, we explore the mysterious world of Yūrei, Japan’s legendary ghosts and restless spirits. Discover the origins of Yūrei in Japanese folklore, the traits that set them apart from Western ghosts, and the cultural beliefs that have shaped their stories for centuries. From vengeful spirits seeking justice to tragic souls unable to move on, we examine some of Japan’s most famous Yūrei tales and their lasting influence on horror films, ghost stories, and popular culture. Join us as we uncover the haunting legends behind Japan’s most iconic supernatural beings.
Listen Supernatural Japan on Spotify
Listen Supernatural Japan on Apple
Follow on Instagram
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
New Bigfoot Lore Just Dropped (feat. Chris Cullari of Scared All The Time)
2026/08/03
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! Sarge is still in Norway so I have enlisted the help of our good friend Chris Cullari from Scared All The Time to do something a bit different than our normal formula. Instead of telling him a story, I figured we would take the opportunity to breakdown and react to what is easily the wildest Bigfoot call-in story we have ever heard. Enjoy.
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Hodag (feat. Kaydra Brannan of Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast)
2026/07/27
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, with Sarge being in Norway and all, we have Kaydra of Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast filling in as our special guest co-host to discuss one of the best cryptid hoaxes we have ever come across...The Hodag. This thing went from lumber camp folklore to nationwide headlines to basically a national treasure all thanks to a dude who was just being a little goofy goof. So sit back, grab a hot dog, and enjoy!
Find where to check out Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast HERE
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Shirime, Enko, and Akaname: Japan's Gnarliest Yokai (feat. EYENINE)
2026/07/20
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by friend of the show Mike Dionne (EYENINE) to discuss three of Japan's grossest yokai. We discuss the Shirime, a pervert Yokai that loves showing you its eye butthole. Then we got the Enko, a regional type of Kappa that also has a craving for butthole orbs. And finally, the Akaname, a dirty little freak that loves licking toilet seats. So sit back, don't get your hopes for a mature discussion, and enjoy!
Pre-Order EYENINE & DC The Midi Alien - Fast Radio Bursts here
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
The Sigbin (feat. Mike Bishop aka Blothar the Berserker of GWAR)
2026/07/13
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by Mike Bishop, aka Blothar the Berserker of GWAR, to discuss the Sigbin, a nightmare creature from Filipino folklore that is way more messed up than I could do it justice describing it here. So I won't. Just trust us when we say that its horrifying, but also a good time.
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
Podcast reviews
Read Cryptid Cocktail Party podcast reviews
CReedaB 2026/07/15
Bummed.
Wanted to love this. Love it in theory. In practice, they don't seem to have a full grasp on anything they're discussing. They often conflate cryptids...
AmysBirdHouse 2026/06/01
Cryptids with that North East flair!
Cryptids and conspiracies, with a heaping helping of truth. This show is edgy and fun, with great pacing and banter. I’m loving it!
Jotter182 2026/05/14
Mmmeh
They seem cool, but they just present things they don’t believe, and don’t really seem to have any conviction. They’re just laughing it up often, and ...
KAparafan 2026/01/20
Obsessed
I love this podcast! I introduced a friend after you did the Copenhagen NY episode. We’ve been to all the locations mentioned in it and are very famil...
Schloop Jon B 2025/12/29
One of my fav shows!
Wish I could give more stars! Sarge and Dave are the best!
Vonbon88 2025/11/18
Love !
I’m all caught up and wish I had more. I love the banter between you guys and the laughter you bring. One of my favorite podcasts for when I need a pi...
Retired O3E 2025/11/06
Fun show
I truly enjoy listening to this show each week. Dave and Sarge bring a unique sensibility to talking about crypto’s and other topics. Plus they remind...
manda_tee 2025/11/05
Cryptid Cocktail Party Rocks!
This podcast is the most fun to listen to, between the topics, the laughs and the opening song, I’m hooked!
mightyquinninwky 2025/10/28
One of the best…
One of the best cryptid/paranormal pods available! Do yourself a favor pour an adult beverage and enjoy the ride!
Jennyjennjen457 2025/08/16
Such a good time
If you’re thinking about it, stop thinking about it. Just a fun time.
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Cryptid Cocktail Party relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.611665506
The Bulwark Podcast
The Bulwark

4.711501391
Matt and Shane's Secret Podcast
Matt McCusker & Shane Gillis

4.82547180
Smosh Reads Reddit Stories
Smosh

4.975217750
Small Town Murder
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman

4.71297595
Bulwark Takes
The Bulwark

4.8583398
Didn't I Just Feed You
Stacie Billis and Meghan Splawn

4.4503509
Warfare
History Hit

4.8296841993
Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast
Fantasy Football

4.712841550
True Crime All The Time
Emash Digital

4.8160181996
Watch What Crappens
Ben Mandelker & Ronnie Karam