
Advertise on podcast: Winning The TBI Case
Rating
4.9from
This podcast has
26 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
Tom CrosleyExplicit
No
Date created
2025/07/24
Latest episode
2026/10/30
Average duration
30 min.
Release period
28 days
Description
“Winning the TBI Case” with Tom Crosley is a podcast created exclusively for plaintiff attorneys handling traumatic brain injury (TBI) cases. Each week, veteran trial attorney Tom Crosley shares insights from over 15 years of brain injury litigation and 60+ trials—covering not just what worked, but why. Episodes dive into emerging trends, cutting-edge neuroscience, recent verdicts, and real courtroom strategies you can use. Get practical tips, expert interviews, and real-world analysis to help you win your next TBI case. New episodes drop every Tuesday, so you can make TBI Tuesday’s with Tom a regular part of your commute to the office.
Unlock Winning The TBI Case podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Winning The TBI Case podcast
Jury Selection in a Mild TBI Case with Robert Hirschhorn (Part 1)
2026/10/30
“If you can’t get the essence of your case to a jury in 30 minutes, then you have got to go back to the drawing board.” – Robert Hirschhorn
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This Episode
Tom is joined by Robert Hirschhorn, attorney and trial consultant from CEB Jury & Trial Consultants to talk about the keys to successful jury selection in a mild TBI case.
Picking a Jury For Your Case
Jury selection in a mild TBI case starts with a difficult challenge: your client looks normal. The headaches, the brain fog, the mood changes, the lost enjoyment of life – none of it shows up on imaging. So how do you find jurors who will believe what they can’t see?
Jury consultant and attorney Robert Hirschhorn has spent more than 40 years helping trial lawyers answer that question. In this conversation, Robert explains how voir dire has changed since COVID, why 45-60 minutes is enough (and more may hurt you), and the one tool he calls “the 11th commandment” of jury selection.
Key Takeaways
Robert is direct about the goal: 80% of your voir dire time should be spent identifying jurors who distrust invisible injuries, not building rapport. He covers:
Why your client should not be in the courtroom during jury selection
The difference between picking a liability jury and a damages jury
Why scaled 0-10 questions provide better information about potential jurors
If you’ve ever walked out of jury selection worried you talked too much about money, or missed the juror who was never going to buy your case, this conversation will reshape how you plan your next voir dire.This is Part 1 of a two-part series. In Part 2, Robert returns to discuss jury selection in a severe TBI case.
Connect
Connect directly with Robert Hirschhorn at https://www.cebjury.com/about-us
Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram.
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Representing the Incapacitated Client with Price Johnson
2026/10/15
“Most probate lawyers don’t know anything whatsoever about personal injury. They’ve never handled a personal injury case, don’t know how to, and don’t understand why you’re doing what you’re doing at all, and that can be dangerous.” – Price Johnson
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This EpisodeTom is joined by Price Johnson, a Dallas probate attorney, and CPA who is the kind of specialist trial lawyers call when a severely injured client may lack the capacity to sign a contract or approve a settlement.
Protecting Your Client, Your Contract, and Your Fee
A severely injured TBI client walks through your door with a loved one by their side. The injury is clear. The case is real. But the client cannot sign your contract. What do you do? When do you act? And who is your client?
Price Johnson walks through the practical realities of representing clients whose capacity is in question. He covers the three paths available to attorneys in these situations. He explains the “incapacity trap” that can turn strong damages proof into a procedural problem. And he reveals the specific reason why calling a probate specialist should happen earlier than most trial lawyers think.
What’s at Stake
At stake is more than procedure. In a contingency case, how do you protect your fee when a probate judge later gets a say in whether it was reasonable? Price walks through:
The reason why one-third contingencies rarely get challenged
Why higher contingencies do get challenged
Why getting your engagement fee approved up front protects both your client and your firm
If you’ve ever worried about whether your contract will hold up or your fee will survive probate court scrutiny, this conversation is for you.
Connect
Connect directly with Price Johnson: 214-468-9000
Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram.
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 24: Representing the Incapacitated Client
Host: Tom Crosley Guest: Price Johnson Runtime: 39:37
[00:00] Price Johnson (cold open): Most probate lawyers don’t know anything whatsoever about personal injury. They’ve never handled a personal injury case, don’t know how to, and don’t understand why you’re doing what you’re doing at all. And that can be dangerous.
[00:13] Announcer: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it — that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling.
[00:48] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today we are joined by Dallas attorney Price Johnson. Price is a CPA and a lawyer and represents business clients in business litigation. A significant portion of his practice is probate issues and probate litigation. And in particular, he helps personal injury lawyers deal with guardianship and probate issues that arise in their cases.
What I’ve invited him on the show to talk about today is what we TBI lawyers need to be aware of when representing severely injured clients. In some cases, our client may lack capacity even to sign the original attorney-client contract. What do we do? How do we spot those issues? When do we act? At some point we might need court approval for certain activities in the case, including settlement. And so Price is the kind of lawyer that lawyers like me call when we have these issues in our cases. Price, how are you doing this morning?
[01:50] Price Johnson: Tom, I’m great this morning. Thanks for having me on. It’s a privilege to be here with you.
[01:55] Tom Crosley: What I’d like to do — for an audience that extends beyond the borders of the state of Texas — is frame the issue for us. When we have a more serious TBI case, let’s say we’ve just gotten it in to sign it up. What do we need to be aware of to make sure we’re doing it right?
[02:15] Price Johnson: It’s a can of worms. There are a lot of things to do, and probably the most important thing I think a personal injury lawyer handling TBI cases can do is find out as many facts as possible. The place I would generally start is to try to find out what your client’s capacity is.
Keep in mind, in my probate world — unlike the personal injury world, where so much of what we rely on is common law, where we go look up court cases and they tell us what the rules are, sometimes even the elements of our causes of action and claims — much of this is codified. It’s an old area, and a lot of it’s codified. So when I use terms like “incapacitated,” those are literally defined terms.
So the first thing you want to make sure of is: who’s your client? Just as in any case, right? You want to make sure who your client is, because without a client, well, you don’t have a case, right, Tom? You don’t have a client to work for. So the first thing you’re going to do is try to figure out who the client is. And if the injured party that you’re trying to ultimately represent is incapacitated, you’ve got to find somebody with authority to hire you.
[03:27] Tom Crosley: What is the significance to us TBI lawyers that probate codes exist, and that the law in probate is typically code-based as opposed to stare decisis–based?
[03:43] Price Johnson: Well, one nice thing about it is some of these things you can look up — they’re actually rules, statutes that exist. For example, we all tend to rely on case law, or in my area, statutes, but also case law that interprets those statutes.
But where I would tell you to be very, very careful — particularly, for example, you and I are in Texas — is the Rules of Civil Procedure. Lawyers come to me all the time and go, “Well, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 151 or 152” — which I refer to as the dead plaintiff and dead defendant rules — “say this. They say I can just go file a suggestion of death, a motion for scire facias, serve the heirs, and I’m good.” Well, those are rules. They’re not statutes or case law, and they absolutely conflict with the statutes and case law, and you will walk right into a malpractice claim and no client. So there are pitfalls and traps to be aware of.
And to go back to a question you were asking me a moment ago — trying to figure out who your client is — obviously in a TBI case, you’re presuming that your client’s not deceased. Not yet, and hopefully won’t be. So you’re not going to end up with, for example, an administrator or an executor of an estate, because that only happens when someone’s dead, right? What you’re going to have is possibly someone with a power of attorney, possibly a guardian of the estate.
Then there comes the trick: how many of us have powers of attorney right now, while you and I are competent and have capacity? Most don’t. Most lawyers don’t, most people don’t — just like most people don’t have wills. So what are the odds that your fellow TBI lawyers out there are going to have someone walk in and say, “My husband, my son, my daughter, my parent, my whomever was seriously injured. They’re in the hospital with a TBI, or they’re in a coma right now and they can’t communicate because they don’t have capacity. But here, I’ve got this power of attorney.” I’m guessing that doesn’t happen for you a lot, does it, Tom?
[05:51] Tom Crosley: No, not at all. Probably never.
[05:53] Price Johnson: And so the trick then becomes: well, if they don’t have capacity right now, they can’t sign a power of attorney. So then you get into whether they qualify for a guardianship or not. And is the guardianship the right move — where you’re at least temporarily, possibly permanently, stripping the rights from that individual that has the TBI and vesting them in someone else? That’s certainly an option, but that takes time. It’s a process.
And then, of course, in Texas we do have the next friend rule — Rule 44 in Texas. It also depends heavily on what the relationship is between the person coming to you and the injured party that lacks capacity. So there are a lot of different things you look at, but that’s where I would suggest everybody start: what are the facts of the capacity? How long is it expected to last? Are they going to come out of this in a week, hopefully, or is it unknown? How severe is it? Is it potentially permanent? And then what steps should we be taking, and who’s the party coming to you? What is their relationship with this person? That will help us figure out what the avenues are.
[06:55] Tom Crosley: Let’s use a few case examples. Often I’ll get hired later in the process — maybe a referring attorney gets me involved. And so I had one case where it had already been going for maybe two years by the time I got involved. The wife was severely injured and was in a coma for 30 days. And while she was in a coma, her husband signed the personal injury contract with the lawyer, individually and as next friend of his wife. I was concerned about that, because she lacked capacity. Her r
Setting Up the TBI Case for Success: The First 6 to 18 Months
2026/08/13
One of the most common mistakes I see is lawyers screening for TBI will simply stop at asking the question, “Were you knocked unconscious?” – Tom Crosley
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This Episode
Tom Crosley lays out a practical timeline for developing a TBI case during the critical first 6 to 18 months. He explains how better intake questions, four specific symptom-tracking tools, and consistent symptom documentation can establish an early foundation while helping attorneys avoid gaps that may later create problems with proof.
Building the Foundation of a TBI Case
The success of a case often depends on decisions made in the earliest days, long before depositions, expert testimony, or trial. In this episode, Tom explains why the first six months matter enormously and what lawyers need to do during the first 18 months to shape the medical and legal framework of the entire case. Using a real case example, Tom demonstrates what can happen when persistent brain injury symptoms are not adequately documented early. He then walks through his approach to identifying potential TBI cases, tracking symptoms, and supporting accurate medical documentation.
Key Insights for Trial Lawyers
Go Beyond Loss of Consciousness: Intake forms should explore memory, confusion, altered mental status, acute symptoms, and what others observed immediately before and after the injury.
Create a Written Symptom Record: Vague descriptions such as feeling “foggy” or “not myself” may not adequately capture what a client is experiencing. Written symptom questionnaires can help clients organize their symptoms and communicate them more accurately to their treating physicians. Tom recommends the following four symptom forms:
Philadelphia Head Injury Questionnaire (PHIQ)
CDC Acute Concussion Evaluation (ACE)
Rivermead Post-Concussion Symptoms Questionnaire (RPQ)
Headache Impact Test (HIT-6)
Avoid Gaps in Medical Documentation: Persistent symptoms need to reach the treating physician. Long periods without meaningful documentation can make an otherwise legitimate injury significantly more difficult to prove later.
Know When to Expand the TBI Workup: For clients with persistent symptoms, Tom discusses when to consider advanced neuroimaging and whether a neuropsychological evaluation is warranted.
Reassess as the Case Develops: As the case progresses into the 12-to-18-month window, repeat neuropsychological testing or neuroimaging may help document whether the client’s condition has improved, remained stable, or changed over time.
For Trial Lawyers: Build the Foundation Early
This episode is for trial lawyers who handle serious injury cases but may not regularly litigate TBI cases. Tom’s message is simple:
Start early
Ask better questions
Document symptoms
Make sure those symptoms are reaching treating physicians
Continually evaluate whether the developing medical evidence supports the TBI case
The goal is not to overbuild every potential brain injury claim. It is to recognize legitimate TBI cases early enough to develop the medical and factual record needed to accurately demonstrate the client’s injury when the case reaches trial.
Connect
Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 23: Setting Up the TBI Case for Success: The First 6 to 18 Months
Crosley Law | Aired: August 13, 2026 | Runtime: 29:37 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley
[0:00] Tom Crosley: One of the most common mistakes I see is lawyers screening for TBI will simply stop at asking the question, “Were you knocked unconscious?”
[0:11] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials, not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling.
[0:46] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley, and today I’d like to talk about how to set your case up for success in the first six months. Because let’s face it, a lot of times a TBI case at trial will only do as well as the foundation that was laid in the early days of that case. Let me tell you what I mean. At trial, we often think about expert witnesses, neuropsychological testing, how well did we prepare for depositions, how well did we pick our jury, but all of that is less important than how well we set our case up for success in the early days. The quality of the intake, the questions we ask our clients at the beginning, the way the client’s symptoms are documented, all those steps taken in the first six months of a case will often determine how successful that case is at trial two or three years later. So I’m speaking now to lawyers that may handle serious injury cases but don’t handle a high volume of TBI cases, and I’m going to provide some tips on how I usually set these cases up for success early. The central point is this: in a TBI case, especially a mild TBI case, the first six months matter enormously, and the first eighteen months or so often define the medical and legal architecture of the entire case.
[2:13] Tom Crosley: Let me begin with a case example about the problem with being too late to recognize your case as a TBI case. Several years ago, I was referred a case involving a young college-aged woman who’d been in a serious intersection collision. This was not a minor crash. She had been unconscious for briefly a minute or two. She had some bleeding on the scalp. She had a laceration. She even had a small spot of bleeding within the brain. She was taken to the hospital in an ambulance. In the hospital, the CT scans showed some abnormality, but a few weeks later she had an MRI, and by that time the blood seen on the CT was gone, and the MRI was read as normal. And the doctor told her, “Hey, look, I know you’re having these symptoms, but it’s probably all gonna go away in six weeks or so,” and no follow-up appointment was ever made, and then I get the case two years later. And so I, first thing I do is I meet with the client, and I learn that she’s still got memory trouble. She’s got headaches. Sometimes the headaches are so bad that she has to go into her boss’s office where she works in a copy center at the university, and she has to lay down on the couch and turn off the lights because these are migraine-type headaches.
[3:32] Tom Crosley: She didn’t used to have these before the crash, and so this was a life-changing injury for her. The problem is she hadn’t seen a doctor about it in almost two years. And so when I got involved, I certainly encouraged her to go back to the doctor and start reporting these symptoms. The problem with it was the defense took it all as lawyer-generated medicine. “Hey, this client was fine. She didn’t really need to go to the doctor again until Crosley got involved and started representing her on the case.” That wasn’t fair, but that’s what we were dealing with in that case. She had all these post-concussion symptoms. She had classic post-concussion syndrome that, in her case, was unresolved after two years and would likely be permanent, but it wasn’t adequately documented in the medical records. So when there is a long period of time with little or no meaningful documentation about the brain injury symptoms, that creates a problem for our proof. She had seen other doctors in that span of time. She had been to doctors for routine medical care visits, but none of these other symptoms that she was supposedly having were documented, and certainly not documented in a way that supported the full picture of what she was experiencing.
[4:48] Tom Crosley: In that case, I had to rely on friends, family members, coworkers to help explain that these symptoms were legitimate, they were real, they persisted all the time. But it sure would have been nice if there had always been a medical doctor checking in with her every ninety days or so and documenting her ongoing symptoms in a medical record. So from a litigation standpoint, the defense argument was very predictable. Hey, if these symptoms were real and they were significant, why was there nearly two years with no documentation of any TBI related symptom? That was a problem in the case. The case ultimately settled, but for less than it would have if we had set it up for success in the first six months. The gap in those records made the case much harder than it needed to be. Had I received that case weeks after the crash instead of more than two years later, the development of the case would have looked very different. As long as she remained symptomatic, she would have had someone encouraging her to follow up with her doctors and tell them what she was experiencing. Someone would have been tracking her symptoms. Someone would have been considering whether advanced imaging or neuropsychological testing was appropriate.
[6:05] Tom Crosley: Someone would have made sure the medical record reflected the
Exposing the Defense Expert Playbook with Dorothy Clay Sims
2026/06/26
Defense experts often rely on a familiar set of arguments in traumatic brain injury cases. The challenge for plaintiff lawyers is knowing how to identify those themes and effectively challenge them.
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
This episode is for plaintiff lawyers who want to recognize and dismantle the predictable defense expert playbook in TBI cases. Dorothy Clay Sims reveals the recurring tactics they use and shares the research methods to expose their weaknesses.
In this episode, Tom sits down with attorney Dorothy Clay Sims, author of Exposing Deceptive Defense Doctors and a nationally recognized authority on defense medical testimony. Drawing on decades of experience, Dorothy discusses the recurring strategies she sees in TBI litigation and the patterns that appear again and again in defense opinions. She also shares practical steps lawyers can take to identify weaknesses in those opinions and build a stronger case for their clients. Dorothy shares insights on:
Looking beyond the medical record to uncover critical evidence
Challenging imaging and neuropsychological opinions effectively
Researching and evaluating defense experts
Preparing for deposition with a strategic purpose
Avoiding common mistakes that can undermine a TBI case
Whether you’re new to TBI litigation or looking to sharpen your approach, this episode offers practical guidance for recognizing and responding to the defense playbook.
Connect
Connect directly with Dorothy Clay Sims: https://dorothyclaysims.com
Mentioned: Exposing Deceptive Defense Doctors
Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram.
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 22: Exposing the Defense Expert Playbook
Host: Tom Crosley Guest: Dorothy Clay Sims Runtime: 35:58
[00:00] Dorothy Clay Sims (cold open): What we found out recently in a case in California is the defense expert altered the test administration and/or changed our client’s answers 67 times during the examination.
[00:12] Announcer: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it is where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling.
When Dorothy Clay Sims discovered that defense experts were systematically lying about her brain injury clients, she made it her life’s work to expose their deceptive tactics. In this eye-opening interview, Dorothy shares the tools every trial lawyer needs to identify and challenge fraudulent medical testimony.
[01:18] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley. Today’s guest is Dorothy Clay Sims. She’s a lawyer who has spent decades studying how defense medical experts operate: how they write their reports, how they testify, tactics they use to minimize or deny injury claims. And if you’ve ever read a defense IME report and thought, “Oh, here we go again,” then this episode is for you.
We’re gonna walk through what Dorothy actually does for trial lawyers, when you should consider retaining her, what you can learn from her, and hopefully give a practical framework for researching a defense doctor and building a cross-examination strategy that’s clean, fair, and powerful. All of this without turning the courtroom into a boring medical seminar. So let’s get into it. Dorothy, how are you doing today?
[02:13] Dorothy Clay Sims: I’m good. How are you doing, Tom?
Tom Crosley: I’m doing great. So you and I have known each other for, gosh, a long, long time. Almost 20 years now — more than 15 years for sure. A lot of your background I’m familiar with, but we may have listeners who aren’t. So I wanted to start with: what drew you into studying defense medical testimony in the first place, carving out this niche in your law practice?
[02:42] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, my motivation, actually, it’s this guy right here. His name was David Hansford Sims. He was my brother. He had a very severe disability. He could not ever speak, communicate. He would sit for hours on end shaking a sock. And I saw how he was treated, and it really bothered me. And I felt like I wanted to represent disabled people.
And then the more I did it, the more defense reports I got, the more I realized these people are lying. And so one day, after 60 cases in a row where the same doctor said my clients were faking based on the MMPI, I went and met the creator of the MMPI, and I showed him the last report, and he started laughing. And I said, “What’s so funny?” And he said, “If this doctor had been my student, I would have failed him. This is not an appropriate interpretation of the test.”
I knew that they were lying — defense experts in general — but I didn’t know how. And so he actually became a friend of mine, and we spent hours together, and he would give me examples, questions to ask, and this is how they manipulated the science.
And I ended up doing a lot of brain injury work because there’s neuropsychological testing, and that is an area where I’ve seen incredible fraud. What we found out recently in a case in California is the defense expert altered the test administration and/or changed our client’s answers 67 times during the examination. It got so bad that during the cross-examination, the judge says, “Okay, you can stop. We know they did it all wrong.” We didn’t want to stop, but it was terrible. So the more I get into this, the angrier I get.
I spent several years taking all these tests myself, having physicals performed on me to understand how those are altered. And then I worked closely with my husband, who’s a physical medicine and rehab doctor, and he ran a brain injury clinic. And he watches the videotapes of the defense medical exams, looks at the report, and then he goes into the body of the report and lists everything they misrepresented based on the video. He’s done probably 700 of these. And when I asked him what percentage of the time the doctor actually accurately reflected what happened in the report — knowing that they were being recorded — the answer is zero.
[05:06] Tom Crosley: Some years ago, you wrote a book called Exposing Deceptive Defense Doctors. I actually bought that book, gosh, 20 years ago maybe. I don’t remember when it was published. But it was one of those three-ring binder books that was multiple volumes, very expensive for a young lawyer at the time. But I recall that book being instrumental in helping me approach defense IMEs. This was not brain injury cases; these were typically spine injury cases.
Dorothy Clay Sims: Right.
Tom Crosley: But since that time, it sounds like you’ve been doing a lot of work on brain injury cases.
[05:39] Dorothy Clay Sims: Yeah, and that book has had significant updates. It’s probably twice as long. I have a lot of references to diffusion tensor imaging — I know you had a piece on that. There’s a lot of politics going into articles that are written saying don’t use it. It’s unbelievable in that field what’s happening. But yeah, the book is longer and there’s a lot more updated information in it.
[05:57] Tom Crosley: I need to get it. So we had as a previous guest Stewart Casper, who you and I both know very well. And he and I talked about the concept of the citation cartel.
Dorothy Clay Sims: Yes.
Tom Crosley: So I’m assuming that’s a little bit of what you’re referring to in your previous comment just now.
[06:14] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, there is such a thing. And in fact, one of the problems we have is people are afraid to talk about it, especially professionals, because a certain number of defense experts are very litigious. But yeah, when you have a defense expert become the head of a journal, deciding what gets published and what doesn’t, and that individual doesn’t even allow an article published by the creator of a test that is being analyzed and criticized in that journal — they don’t allow the test creator to weigh in. It’s bad.
[06:41] Tom Crosley: I know you speak a lot around the country and even internationally, and I’ve heard you speak several times. You’re always very entertaining. Some of the examples you give are so incredibly outrageous as to defy belief.
Dorothy Clay Sims: Yes.
Tom Crosley: And I haven’t had those examples actually appear in my cases, because I’m usually dealing with pretty known quantities. I mean, I’ve had you do opposition research for experts. You provided packets of information. But what I’d like to hear is the normal — what are you doing for lawyers like me, either by helping us prep for these defense experts, or sometimes, I know, you’ll come in and do them yourself as part of our case? Help us understand what you’re doing when you don’t have this crazy outlier who’s lied on his résumé and put in degrees that he doesn’t have and things like
Defusing GCS in a Mild TBI Case
2026/05/27
“GCS is not looking at long-term outcomes. It’s looking at that little slice in time right after the injury happened in the acute phase.” – Tom Crosley
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This Episode:
Tom Crosley explains how the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) gets weaponized by defense attorneys in mild TBI cases. He breaks down what GCS actually measures, why it was created, and how to defuse defense arguments that use normal GCS scores to discredit legitimate brain injury cases.
Defusing the Defense Weapon
This is for trial lawyers who need to understand why a normal GCS score doesn’t mean their client wasn’t injured. Tom reveals how defense attorneys take one number from acute medical records and use it to undermine entire cases. He explains the historical context of GCS which was created in 1974 as a bedside tool designed for neurosurgeons to assess coma depth and decide on emergency surgery, not to predict long-term outcomes.
GCS measures three basic functions:
Eye opening
Verbal response
Motor commands
All tests that any elementary school student or family dog could pass. Tom provides the analogies and cross-examination techniques to expose how this acute triage tool has zero relevance to how patients function years later in life. By understanding what GCS actually measures (and what it doesn’t), you have the power to educate juries and neutralize one of the defense’s favorite, and often misleading, arguments.
Connect
Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 21: Defusing GCS in a Mild TBI Case
Crosley Law | Aired: May 27, 2026 | Runtime: 20:24 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley
[0:00] Tom Crosley: A GCS is not looking at long-term outcomes. It’s looking at that little slice in time right after the injury happened in the acute phase.
[0:09] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling.
[0:45] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. I’m Tom Crosley. Today I want to talk about the Glasgow Coma Scale, or GCS, and why it gets misused in mild traumatic brain injury cases. Here’s how this usually shows up in litigation. The defense will point to a normal GCS score in the EMS record or the ER record and say, therefore, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, this was not a significant head injury. There’s no good explanation for the symptoms that allegedly persisted because look, we have this normal GCS score on the day of. And so that’s the defense move. They take one number from the acute medical records and they try to use it to discredit the entire case. If nobody explains what the GCS actually measures, what it was designed for, then that defense argument can sound stronger than it really is. Jurors might hear normal neurological score and assume it means the brain was fine. But that is not what the Glasgow Coma Scale was designed to measure. So let’s talk about a little historical context. It was first introduced in 1974 in Glasgow, Scotland by two neurosurgeons.
[2:01] Tom Crosley: They were really looking for a common language for doctors to use as a bedside tool that would help them communicate about a patient’s level of consciousness after acute brain injury. And in particular, when it would become important to call a neurosurgeon. Because maybe the neurosurgeon might have to do some life-saving surgery. That was the original mission. How awake is this person? How responsive are they to simple commands? And are they getting better or worse? So that matters because it tells you the lane that this GCS tool was originally built for. Acute assessment in the minutes or hours following the injury. Bedside communication. Triage. Later, researchers began using GCS scores to correlate severity grading and long-term patient outcomes because GCS became very popular. It’s used worldwide. It’s been cited 37,000 times in the medical literature. So it’s definitely the most common neurological assessment tool in the acute phase. So you’re going to see it in your medical records. You’re going to see it in your cases. So with all that data, researchers who study long-term outcomes for TBI, ranging from severe to moderate to mild, will often look back at what was that early GCS score.
[3:22] Tom Crosley: And we learn in the mild category that long-term outcomes are not predicted by GCS score. We learn with moderate and severe injuries, long-term poor outcomes are more predictive based on GCS score. So let’s talk about the name itself because the name matters. If we’re teaching it to a jury, it is the Glasgow Coma Scale. Coma. It’s not the Glasgow Executive Function Scale. It’s not the Glasgow Working Memory Scale. It’s the Coma Scale. It is fundamentally a scale of responsiveness and depth of impaired consciousness. The lower the score a person has, then the more deep their coma. It’s measuring three domains. Eye response. Are the person’s eyes open spontaneously or are they closed? Are they out? And now if they are out, do they open in response to a verbal command? If not, do they open when we give them some noxious stimuli? For example, we rub their sternum. Does that make their eyes open? These are testing levels of depth of coma. Verbal response is the second of the three things they’re looking at. Are they oriented normally? Do they know where, in broad strokes, where they are, what year this is, what city they are in?
[4:44] Tom Crosley: Literally, those are the types of questions. Or are they unable to make any sounds because they’re out of it, they’re in a coma? Or are the sounds they’re making guttural and incomprehensible? That’s kind of what they’re looking for on the verbal side. When I see an abnormal GCS in a mild case where they lose a point or two points, it’s almost always on the verbal side. And it’s because the patient is confused. They’re not completely oriented. They might be asking the same question over and over again and not really responding to the examiner’s very basic questions. The third thing that GCS is looking at, remember number one, eyes, number two, verbal, number three is motor response. Can the person obey simple commands? So all the way from no motor response whatsoever, out completely cold, to extension or flexion in response to painful stimuli or trying to withdraw from pain. Again, that sternum rub can be useful there. Or can the person obey simple commands? So I’m typically seeing in the mild case four out of four for eye response, six out of six for motor response, and usually five out of five for a total score of 15 for the verbal response.
[6:01] Tom Crosley: Sometimes I’m seeing a four out of five on the verbal response because the person is clearly confused at the scene and keeps repeating themselves. All right. So what is that telling us? When I teach it in CLE, I will often put up a slide showing a doctor talking to a patient on an exam table. And that patient’s sitting there and he’s got his eyes open and the doctor’s holding a clipboard and a stethoscope around his neck wearing a white coat. And I’ll say, “This is what a normal GCS looks like.” And while that slide’s still up, I’ll tell the audience something like this. I’ll say, “You know, I don’t care how much I’m boring you right now. I could be the most boring speaker you’ve ever heard in your entire life. You could be on the verge of falling asleep, but if your eyes are still open, if you’re sitting in this room listening to me, you have a normal GCS.” And then I’ll say, “Do you know what else has a normal GCS?” And then I’ll advance the slide and it’ll be a picture of my dog, a chocolate lab. And that’s the part that gets the laugh. And it works because this point kind of hits home. My dog, his eyes opened spontaneously.
[7:16] Tom Crosley: Remember the eyes were category one. The second was verbal response, but it’s really testing is the patient oriented to time, place, and person. And so my dog knows where his food bowl is. He knows where his bed is. He can bark on command. So he’s kind of passing that one too. And then motor response. He can sit. He can shake hands. He can roll over. My dog can pass that one too. So how high is the bar to get a normal GCS? That’s my point. And that’s why this joke kind of hits home. I even got to do it once in a trial. I had a well-known and sneaky defense expert on the stand in trial in Houston. And he was harping on the normal GCS on day one for my patient. And here we are three years later and he’s trying to say this normal GCS somehow means that this patient should be well by now. And so I showed the slide, got the doctor to admit, “Yep, that’s a normal GCS.” Got him to admit that everybody in the courtroom, all the people on the jury, the people in the gallery, thos
A Radiologist’s Approach to TBI Case Evaluation – Dr. David Levey
2026/05/06
“What I’m looking for is: What is the correct diagnosis? What happened to this patient? Is he or she being treated correctly or properly? And that’s a concern of mine.” – Dr. David Levey
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
Tom is joined by Dr. David Levey, a diagnostic radiologist and forensic neuroradiology expert who evaluates traumatic brain injury cases for both plaintiffs and the defense. Dr. Levey walks through the detailed process radiologists use to evaluate imaging, medical records, symptoms, and clinical history when analyzing TBI cases in both medical and litigation settings.
What’s In This Episode
Dr. David Levey explains how radiologists evaluate traumatic brain injury cases and how imaging findings fit within the broader clinical and litigation picture. He also shares practical insight into the role imaging plays in TBI litigation and best practices for trial lawyers working with radiology experts.
Key Insights for Trial Lawyers
Radiologists Evaluate More Than Images: Forensic radiology involves an extensive analysis of imaging combined with medical records, symptoms, clinical history, and causation evidence in context.
“Normal” Scans and Imaging Do Not Rule Out TBI: There are times when traumatic brain injuries will not appear on routine CT imaging. MRI studies can reveal subtle abnormalities not visible on CT scans. Advanced imaging such as DTI, tractography, and volumetric imaging can provide additional detail and should always be considered alongside symptoms, testing, and functional changes.
Effective TBI Litigation Requires Collaboration: Radiologists often work closely with attorneys and other experts to help evaluate complex brain injury cases.
Dr. Levey pulls back the curtain on the detailed analytical process radiologists use to evaluate brain injury cases in both medical and forensic settings and shares how he works with both plaintiff and defense teams.
Preparation Matters
This episode is for trial lawyers who want a clearer understanding of how radiologists evaluate traumatic brain injury cases and how imaging evidence fits into litigation strategy. If you’ve ever struggled with “normal imaging” defenses or wanted insight into how to best leverage your radiology experts in TBI cases, then you’ve come to the right place.
Referenced and Mentioned
Dr. Levey and Tom reference tractography imaging beginning at time code 22:49 which can be seen on the video version of the podcast. Screenshots below for our audio listeners.
Connect
Connect directly with Dr. David Levey by visiting: www.expertradiologist.org
Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Winning the TBI Case — A Radiologist’s Approach to TBI Case Evaluation
Host: Tom Crosley Guest: Dr. David Levey Runtime: 37:08
[00:00] Dr. David Levey (cold open): Follow-up MRIs can be valuable, particularly in two cases. One, if you have found nothing abnormal on imaging structurally, right? Yet the patient is so abnormal. The family doesn’t recognize them anymore. Work’s not going well. The tasks they used to do, they can’t do them anymore. Well, you know something’s wrong.
[00:20] Announcer: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it — that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling.
[00:55] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today we’re gonna have an exciting episode. We’re gonna be talking about one of the most misunderstood areas in traumatic brain injury litigation, and that is brain imaging. Our guest today is Dr. David Levey, a diagnostic radiologist with a clinical practice reading brains and spines, and he also happens to serve as an expert witness from time to time in legal cases. About half of his work is on the defense side; about half is on the plaintiff side. So he’s one of those expert witnesses who is exactly what we want: science first, advocacy second. Somebody who does both sides and calls the balls and strikes like he sees them.
I wanted to start with a little bit about you and your background. What led you to go to medical school? How did you pick radiology as your specialty? Kind of bring us current to modern times.
[01:59] Dr. David Levey: Well, when I was 11, I read a book called The Defense Never Rests, and that was it. I was going to be a lawyer. And in the next few years, that evolved. I went to college, got two different bachelor’s degrees, really heading towards the neurosciences, and a master’s degree at UCLA before medical school. Then after medical school: internship, a trauma internship, four years of radiology at USC, and a fellowship. After 17 years coming out of the machine, I finally got my first job doing just that — neuroradiology, musculoskeletal imaging — here in Texas. That was the first job, and here I am.
[02:45] Tom Crosley: Tell us about how forensic neuroradiology — for example, in a brain injury case — differs from day-to-day clinical neuroradiology.
[02:53] Dr. David Levey: It’s extraordinary, the difference. I didn’t know about it until I started this 15 years ago. If you’re reading an MRI of the brain as a radiologist, you get the case; the case comes up. You get some clinical data. You may get some clinical information faxed to you. Some of it’s sketchy, some of it’s from the patient. You may get some nursing notes, from the PA or the doctor, but it’s variable. If you get 10 pages of notes, you’re really doing great. If you get a page or two, that’s acceptable too. Many of the diagnoses are fairly complete, and others may have “headache” or “head pain” or “trauma” — no date, no description, no time. You don’t have any idea.
So you are absolutely starting from the beginning and working your way through the brain MRI and trying to get that diagnosis. So you’re looking for everything under the sun. You can’t focus on trauma or anything. And that takes you X amount of time. You know, a brain MRI may take two minutes or two hours. I’ve had one take two days — spent two days on it, getting through it, it was so complicated. But it’s a finite experience.
But forensic radiology — you get reams of medical records and a number of opinions from everywhere. From the police report at the scene of the accident, all the way through the ER and the ICU and the consultants and surgery or not. Then the patient finally is released from the hospital and has all these follow-up appointments with many other experienced, seasoned experts: pain people, clinical psychology people, PM&R, et cetera. And the vast amount of information I can use to put a story together is what I think attracted me at first to this field. All the imaging available plus all the medical records together allows me to tell a story — not only with the radiology and the imaging, but the medical process and the path the patient took as well.
[04:57] Tom Crosley: Some radiologists that serve as expert witnesses don’t like to look at medical records. They just want to look at the imaging and dictate a report based on what they see. But it sounds like you like to look at the whole picture, including medical records. Why is that?
[05:10] Dr. David Levey: I think it’s important. I do like it, you’re right. But I also think it’s important. I think you’re missing something if you’re not doing that, because, first of all, from the correct diagnosis flows the correct treatment. I want to get involved with any patient — it doesn’t matter, defense, plaintiff, or whatever the situation is. What I’m looking for is: What is the correct diagnosis? What happened to this patient? And is he or she being treated correctly or properly? And that’s a concern of mine.
Because I see that if the radiologist who read the primary studies got it wrong, the whole crowd — medical, surgical, everybody — they’re following down the wrong pathway. And that’s the classic GIGO I see all the time: garbage in, garbage out. You get the wrong diagnosis, and there’s surgery in the wrong place, or no surgery where he needs it, or treatment that is inappropriate because the diagnosis was not made correctly in the beginning. So medical records really help with that. You hardly ever get that when you just get a case, read it, get a case, read it, like in a radiology practice.
[06:15] Tom Crosley: It sounded like your explanation of the difference between clinical radiology and forensic radiology was that sometimes, clinically, you might only spend a few minutes reading a brain scan, but if it’s forensic — meaning it’s going to be used in a court case — then you’re going to spend probably a lot more time. Is that what I’m hearing?
[06:35] Dr. David Levey: I do, and I see them over and over again, because it may take weeks to get the consultative report out. B
Inside an $8.1 Million TBI Verdict with Scott Blair
2026/04/14
“ The TBI alters the organic chemistry, the physical structure of the brain to the point where our personalities then get altered. Our spirit knows who we are. But you can’t get that person back… and I think jurors get that.” – Scott Blair
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This Episode:
Scott Blair shares how he built and tried a complex TBI case that resulted in an $8.1 million verdict.He explains the role of advanced neuroimaging, expert strategy, and objective evidence in overcoming common defense arguments. Most importantly, he provides practical guidance on how trial lawyers can strengthen their cases by understanding the medicine, telling the client’s story, and preparing for trial from day one.
Winning Complex TBI Cases
In this episode, Tom is joined by Scott Blair, founder of Brain Injury Law of Seattle, to break down the strategy behind a recent $8.1 million traumatic brain injury verdict. Scott shares how he approaches complex cases, from digging deep into the medicine to building objective evidence that makes it difficult for the defense to deny brain injury.
This conversation goes beyond theory. Scott walks through the real decisions that shaped the case, including expert selection, advanced neuroimaging, trial strategy, and how to handle common defense tactics in high-functioning TBI clients.
Key Insights for Trial Lawyers
Dive deep into the medicine: The strongest TBI cases are built by lawyers who understand the underlying medical science and work closely with the right experts.
Objective evidence changes the game: Advanced imaging, sleep studies, and vestibular testing can create converging proof that is difficult for the defense to dismiss.
High-functioning clients require a different strategy: Clients who continue working after injury often face skepticism. Demonstrating how their capacity has changed is critical.
Tell the employer early: Encouraging clients to disclose their brain injury can lead to documentation and accommodations that strengthen their case.
Neutralize defense narratives early: Address issues like travel photos or work performance before the defense raises them to reduce their impact at trial.
Use real-world functioning, not just testing: Speech-language pathology and real-world observations can be more persuasive than traditional neuropsychological testing alone.
Before and after witnesses are critical: Family members, especially spouses, provide powerful testimony about how the client has changed after the injury.
Visual evidence matters: Jurors respond strongly to clear visual representations of brain injury, especially when complex science is involved.
This episode is for trial lawyers who want to take their TBI cases to the next level. If you’re handling complex or high-value cases, Scott Blair’s approach offers a practical roadmap for building stronger evidence, overcoming defense strategies, and presenting a compelling case at trial.
Winning the TBI Case — Inside an $8.1 Million TBI Verdict with Scott Blair
Crosley Law | Runtime: 50:10 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley, Scott Blair
[0:00] Scott Blair: You know, what I told my client early on, because this is so typical of high-functioning people, they don’t want other people to know that they have a brain injury because it damages their employment reputation. They might lose their job. And it’s really important for us as plaintiffs, TBI lawyers, to tell our clients, no, do the exact opposite.
[0:20] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it? That’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. In this in-depth conversation, Tom Crosley welcomes Scott Blair to explore what it takes to win complex TBI cases that other lawyers won’t touch.
[1:12] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley. Today we are joined by Scott Blair, founder of Brain Injury Law of Seattle. For Scott, brain injury work is his passion. And for the last 25 years, he has proudly helped folks with brain injuries get the specialized treatment they need, and he has successfully litigated their claims in court cases time and time again. We’re really glad to have Scott here today because he’s going to discuss with us a very significant case he tried that yielded an $8.1 million verdict. I was hoping you could give us your background story. Talk about your life. What led you to law school? Then after law school, how did you end up becoming a brain injury lawyer?
[2:01] Scott Blair: I was not a very good student in high school. I kind of failed out and just didn’t really care about it and decided to travel the world. But when I did that and got back and went to college, I wanted to be a doctor and my first semester I took Biology and got a C in it. And the pre-med advisor, I’ll never forget, he came over and put his arm on my shoulder and said, Scott, I don’t think medicine’s for you. And so ended up gravitating to law school instead and off I went. But you know, I was doing PI work early on in my career and did a lot of the musculoskeletal stuff, which is great. It’s just that there’s kind of a ceiling in terms of what you can learn about medicine. What really projected me into getting into some of these oddball you know, esoteric medical issues like brain injury was a case I had where nobody could figure out how my guy became a quad, and I won’t spend a lot of time on it, but he had this rare condition from a post-injury tetanus shot that he got called Chronic Inflammatory Demyelinating Polyradiculoneuropathy. So CIDP for short. And it took me seven years working with a neurologist to establish causation and get that thing up. We ended up getting a very good result for this kid that no one else was going to touch.
[3:24] Scott Blair: And that case taught me a valuable lesson that really have to dive deep in the medicine. And so when I started doing TBI cases, I thought, oh my God. This stuff is fascinating as hell because, you know, musculoskeletal, you can only go so far with strains, breaks, and blah. With TBIs though, that stuff was just a total terra incognita, so to speak. And it just really stoked my curiosity. And every time you get into these cases, there’s something new and different, and you get some downright bizarre cases now and then. You know, you just don’t see any place else. They’re a great challenge trying to find how do you get the right experts for these things? You know, and for example, brain injuries, I’ve had two cases where it resulted in a loss of religiosity, for example, which is a really bizarre thing, but I was able to find a guy out of Northwestern University who actually has written papers on this. And so it’s a real thing. Mm-hmm. The challenge was how do you establish damages for a deeply religious family, who one member of the family is suddenly the whole sense of religiosity is gone. And it was. It’s that kind of stuff that is just really bizarre and interesting to me that drew me to TBIs.
[4:45] Scott Blair: I’m a geek. I really dig, you know, diving into the other things, the pituitary stuff. I think we got the first pituitary verdict, post-traumatic hypopituitarism verdict in the country. And that just kind of fell in my lap. And we wouldn’t have gotten that without really digging deep into the medicine.
[5:05] Tom Crosley: That’s interesting. I’ve not heard of the loss of religiosity. But as you were saying it started to make sense to me because a life-changing injury, especially a brain injury, becomes an existential crisis for the victim. And when you start to question your existence and how you’re going to live the rest of your life, I can see why it might lead one to, claim.
[5:28] Scott Blair: You know, actually, Tom, it results from damage to the area of the brain that allows for and facilitates deep beliefs in things. And religion happens to be one of those. And that’s why this neuroscientist from Northwestern basically wrote a paper on it because there is an organic basis for that. So if you see a case like that, there’s, you know. There is a basis for it. They’re rare, but they do pop up.
[5:57] Tom Crosley: Yeah. So I think there are three things that separate really great lawyers from good lawyers. One of them is being willing to learn the medicine inside and out. The second one is being willing to learn the client, and their experience inside and out. And a third one to me is having the guts to take the risk of saying no to a really good settlement offer and going to trial.
[6:20] Scott Blair: Well, you know, in this case in December that you mentioned, that’s pretty much everything we had to do on that case. And it was a fascinating case because my client you know, he contacted me. He was a senior managing software engineer for Adobe here in Seattle. Incredibly smart guy and making a lot of money, close to half a million a year, and he was still working. You know, he went in to a local medical day surg
TBI Defined
2026/04/02
“The better you understand the definitions of mild TBI, the better equipped you are to read the records, evaluate the experts, and keep your case grounded in sound medicine.” – Tom Crosley
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This Episode:In this episode, Tom Crosley explains how mild traumatic brain injury is defined using both the ACRM 1993 and updated 2023 frameworks. He breaks down the three primary pathways to diagnosing TBI and how those definitions show up in real cases. And finally, Tom provides the simplified jury presentation that keeps the focus on symptoms, causation, and long-term impact.
Understand the Framework
This is for trial lawyers who want a clearer, more practical understanding of how mild TBI is defined and how those definitions are used in real cases. Tom Crosley breaks down the definitions that form the backbone of every brain injury case. He explains the evolution from the 1993 American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine (ACRM) definition to the comprehensive 2023 update that created three distinct pathways to diagnosis:
Clinical signs
Symptoms with objective findings
Abnormal imaging (NOTE: most mild TBIs will not appear on routine scans)
If you’ve ever found yourself caught in a word play battle with the defense over terminology instead of focusing on the injury itself, this episode will help you reframe your approach.
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 18: TBI Defined
Crosley Law | Aired: April 2, 2026 | Runtime: 12:28 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley
[0:00] Tom Crosley: The case is not about the label. The case is about what the symptoms are and were those symptoms caused by the crash or the event, and what does the future hold?
[0:09] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case, strategy, science, and storytelling. Let’s join Tom as he breaks down the fundamental challenges of representing clients with invisible injuries.
[1:00] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today I want to talk about how mild traumatic brain injury gets defined, and this can become clunky in a hurry, and I don’t want it to turn into a word game instead of a useful discussion, so I’m gonna try to keep this simple and practical. Here’s the main point. Definitions matter, but they are not the whole case. A case does not rise or fall just because one expert wants to call it a mild TBI and another wants to call it something else. At the end of the day, the real questions are still the same. What happened in the traumatic event? What symptoms and impairments followed to your client as a result of that? Were those problems caused by the event? That’s where the case lives. How do these problems affect that person going forward in life? What does the future hold for this person? It’s not what label we attach to the injury. It was the injury caused by the event. So if a person develops headaches, dizziness, cognitive problems, balance trouble, light sensitivity, fatigue, irritability, an inability to function the way they used to function, those are always going to be real problems regardless of whether a defense expert wants to claim that it’s not a mild TBI.
[2:21] Tom Crosley: So why then do definitions matter? They matter for two reasons. First, the better you understand the definitions of mild TBI, the better equipped you are to read the records, evaluate the experts, and keep your case grounded in sound medicine. The better able you are to avoid getting sidetracked by defense wordplay and semantic games. Second, medical literature is built on definitions. Researchers define who counts as a mild TBI and who does not, and then they study recovery, prognosis, treatment, long-term outcomes based on that defined group. So if you don’t understand the definition that they’re using, you probably don’t fully understand the literature either. So before I go further, let me say one quick word about the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine, the ACRM, because we’re studying and relying upon the ACRM definitions here. The ACRM is a major interdisciplinary rehab organization focused on research and evidence-based clinical practice. Its brain injury work has long been considered mainstream for over three decades. When the ACRM publishes something on TBI, lawyers should understand that this is important and widely respected.
[3:43] Tom Crosley: It’s not some fringe view. So let’s talk about the 1993 ACRM definition of mild TBI, which for decades was the classic definition of mild TBI. It said that mild traumatic brain injury is a traumatically induced disruption of brain function shown by one of four things. Loss of consciousness, anywhere from zero minutes all the way up to 30 minutes. Beyond 30, it becomes moderate. Loss of memory around the event, so amnesia, as long as the amnesia resolves within 24 hours. If you have amnesia for more than a day after the event, they’re calling that moderate also. A fourth thing that will fit is focal neurologic deficits. It just means some kinda localized neurologic abnormality. Examples would include weakness or numbness on one side, facial droop, slurred speech, abnormal pupillary response, a visual field cut, impaired coordination in an arm or a leg. Those are pretty unusual, at least in my handling of these cases when I’m looking at medical records and we tend to see altered consciousness. Even if the person is not unconscious, we see altered mental status, dazed, confused, et cetera. Rarely do I see a documentation of a focal neurologic deficit, but it’s important to know what that means.
[5:02] Tom Crosley: So the 1993 definition mattered because it gave medicine kind of a common agreement point. The problem is, over time, that got messy. Different specialties started using different approaches. Sports medicine came up with its own definition. Emergency medicine came up with another. The American Academy of Neurology came up with a different one. The neurosurgeons came up with a different one. So the ACRM got together leading up to 2023 and said, “Hey, we need to fix this and have one universal definition that we can all kinda rely on.” It was an effort to bring more order and consistency to the diagnosis of mild TBI. You probably ought to read it. It’s six criteria. It’s three different pathways, but it’s really easy to get lost there. So I try to boil it down, and if I’m gonna teach it to a jury, I’m gonna try to boil it down as basically as possible. That’s what I’m gonna try to do for you in this episode. I’ll leave it to you to let me know whether I succeeded or not. But here’s how I boil it down. Under the 2023 framework, there first has to be a plausible mechanism of injury, some kind of event capable of transmitting force to the brain. It could be a blow to the head. It could be the head striking an object. It could be acceleration, deceleration from a crash.
[6:19] Tom Crosley: It could be a blast wave concussion type force. But once you have the plausible mechanism, there are basically three ways to get to the diagnosis. The first way is some obvious clinical signs. It’s the easiest one to understand. You have the injury event, and then you have obvious clinical signs of acute brain dysfunction. This route feels similar to the old 1993 definition. The second way of three that we get there without obvious clinical signs, we get there with symptoms plus objective support. So not every legitimate mild TBI comes with a nice clean witness account or a perfect ER note saying that the patient was definitely confused and repetitive at the scene. Real cases are often messier than that. Sometimes the person has the classic early symptoms, headache, dizziness, nausea, light sensitivity, brain fog, trouble concentrating, irritability. And sometimes those symptoms are backed up by objective findings on examination, such as abnormal balance, some kinda abnormal oculomotor testing, some kind of vestibular issue, an abnormal cognitive screen. So if you have some of those symptoms, two or more, and you have some kind of objective medical screen, then that is how you get there.
[7:38] Tom Crosley: The third way you get there is abnormal structural imaging. That means a CT scan usually done in the ER, which as we know in these cases is most often normal. The other way we get there is a structural MRI that shows some kinda intracranial abnormality that’s related to trauma. That’s the imaging route. So let me be very clear here. Positive imaging is not required to diagnose a mild TBI. It has never been. Most mild TBIs do not show up on routine CT or MRI, but when they do show up on CT or structural MRI, that supports the diagnosis directly. And a lot of times, depending on what the abnormality is, it may move it beyond the mild realm into the moderate realm. I’m gonna leave advanced neuroimaging for another episode and keep today’s focus on the core diagnostic framework for the 2023 ACRM definition. That’s the simplified upd
Neuropsychological Evaluations Demystified with Dr. Janyna Mercado
2026/03/12
“Every test you take today is going to tap into how a different part of your brain is working. Some tests will have more emphasis on different lobes of your brain than others. We’re going to be evaluating your memory, your attention, and your concentration ability.” – Dr. Janyna Mercado
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
What’s In This EpisodeThis episode is essential for TBI attorneys who want to move beyond basic neuropsychology knowledge into advanced tactics. Learn the strategic timing for neuropsychological evaluations, how to interpret validity measures, and why transparency about test limitations strengthens rather than weakens your expert testimony. Dr. Mercado shares insider tips that can transform your approach in the courtroom.
Advanced Testing Strategies and Courtroom Applications
In the second part of this two-part series, Tom Crosley continues his conversation with Dr. Janyna Mercado to reveal strategies for neuropsychological evidence in TBI cases. Dr. Mercado demystifies the evaluation process and explains the critical timing decisions that can make or break your case. This conversation provides expert witness insights to maximize neuropsychological evidence and avoid the common mistakes that undermine TBI cases.
Dr. Mercado’s practical insights reveal why successful neuropsychological evidence requires understanding both the science and the strategy behind telling compelling stories to juries and judges.
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 17: Neuropsychological Evaluation Demystified with Dr. Janyna Mercado
Crosley Law | Runtime: 29:48 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley, Dr. Janyna Mercado
[0:00] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So I will tell attorneys: these are not lie detector tests. They’re effort measures, they’re validity measures. They let us know a snapshot in that person’s day.
[0:11] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it? That’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials, not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case, strategy, science, and storytelling. In this conversation, Dr. Mercado breaks down the science behind cognitive testing.
[0:58] Tom Crosley: So my next subject I want to talk to you about is to help us demystify the process of a neuropsychological evaluation. Probably, unlike many of our listeners, I’ve actually done neuropsychological testing. I did it some years ago because I wanted to understand it better, because I figured the better I understood it, the better of an advocate I could be for my clients in court cases. But for those of us that haven’t gone through the process, can you teach us what’s important for us to know about how the evaluation process works?
[1:26] Dr. Janyna Mercado: First part of a neuropsychological evaluation should consist of a comprehensive clinical interview where the client will meet face to face and it’ll be about an hour to an hour and a half long process where we gather substructive information. Now, the assessment itself is the really fun part. And so, this is where we begin by selecting a battery that is very comprehensive. We select tests that will tap into every part of the brain function. And that’s typically what I tell clients: every test you take today is going to tap into how a different portion of your brain is working. Some tests will have more activity in different lobes of your brain than others, but we’re gonna be evaluating your memory, your attention, your concentration abilities. So, to demystify these tests, one of them is typically an IQ test that involves things like verbal comprehension abilities, working memory, processing speed. Then we have memory measures, and these are all standardized tests that are scientifically based. And we purchased them from Pearson from Riverside. There’s a variety of different publishers that you have to be a licensed psychologist to purchase these tests from. And then there is a whole realm of psychological testing that we do in addition to the cognitive testing.
[2:46] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So it’s a full day, it’s anywhere from four to six hours again with breaks. But when you send a client for neuropsychological testing, it is an entire day that they will be in clinic with the neuropsychologist taking a battery of tests.
[3:01] Tom Crosley: And if you’re on the defense side and the plaintiff has already submitted to neuropsychological testing, you know, before your involvement, are you able to do your own neuropsychological testing as a defense expert?
[3:13] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Most of the time I am. And when I do work as a defense expert, I always ask to do my own. I believe there is value in meeting a person face to face, doing my own evaluation to see if we get similar testing. Now, if they had recently been tested by a plaintiff’s attorney, I will ask for the raw data. And I will evaluate that because there’s something called practice effects. You never want to administer test back to back because it will inflate the results because they just recently took it. So I like to wait at least a year between my evaluations. And say, I got a case today and they were tested in 2023, I would definitely ask to retest them. But to answer your question, yes, I always ask to do my own IME when I’m hired by defense.
[4:01] Tom Crosley: Are they typically different tests than were done the first time, or do you sometimes use some of the same tests?
[4:05] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I use my own battery. So if it was a different battery and I see that other tests would be more appropriate, I will use different tests. If I want to mirror the battery to see if there’s any improvement or worsening of symptoms, I will sometimes use the same battery. So it really depends on a case-by-case basis.
[4:25] Tom Crosley: What are you looking for before you ever get into test scores in this clinical interview?
[4:31] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I’m looking for various things. So, number one, I do a full comprehensive from the beginning of life to the event that brought them into the clinic. I am looking for changes. I’m looking for when did symptoms begin. In the field of neuropsychology, onset of symptom presentation is critical for diagnoses. So to understand that from the individual directly. Also, I’d like to see if there’s consistency between what I’m being told and what is in the medical records. What have they been reporting to other providers? And if there’s any inconsistencies, and I have the privilege of having the records before my evaluation, then I get to address those inconsistencies in my interview and ask questions to clarify the matter for me.
[5:18] Tom Crosley: I’m sure there are times when you need to assess whether the patient is putting forth good effort, whether they’re being consistent or truthful or giving you reliable data. How do you do that? And what happens if there’s an allegation of exaggeration or malingering? What do you do in those situations?
[5:42] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Great question. So, every single test battery of these assessments that we administer, anytime I evaluate someone in a forensic setting we always administer at least three to four what we call performance validity measures, and symptom validity measures. One set of tests that is completely unique to the field of neuropsychology. This whole concept of poor effort or malingering comes up in these cases, as we know, are true. And actually, depending on what study you pick up and read, about a third of individuals involved in litigation will overreport symptoms for secondary gain. So it’s something that is very unique and very valuable to the litigation process, in my opinion. Every single battery ICA, you will always see performance and symptom validity measures. What do you do if I suspect that there’s overreporting, intentional over-reporting. There’s something I always do. If I’m hired by a plaintiff’s attorney, I will immediately pick up the phone and schedule a call with the attorney. And tell them we finished the testing.
[6:58] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I can’t tell you much, but I feel that your client is over-reporting symptoms. And this is why. And I just feel that transparency and honesty is best than to sugarcoat. And you know, I’ve had surprisingly, I’ve had some attorneys tell me: you know what, Dr. Mercado, I suspect that I don’t think I’m going to work with this client anymore. And instead of the attorney investing more time and hours and money into trying to prove up a case that, you know, and unfortunately, sometimes these are people with genuine injuries, which is really unfortunate. I think it needs to be addressed. And if they just had a bad day, then let’s reevaluate them in six months or a year.
[7:43] Tom Crosley: If that happens on the defense side, I’m assuming that you write a report that helps the defense prove that you think there’s exaggeration or malingering or that makes sense.
[7:55] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Yeah, defense welcomes those reports, as you can imagine.
[8:00] Tom Crosley: I always tell my clients before they go to their neuropsychologi
Neuropsychology’s Role in TBI Cases with Dr. Janyna Mercado
2026/03/10
“Individuals will walk into a courtroom or walk into our offices and they look like you and I. They don’t look like brain injury victims.” – Dr. Janyna Mercado
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
The Critical Role of Neuropsychology in TBI Litigation (Part One)
In the first of a two-part series, Tom is joined by Dr. Janyna Mercado, a clinical neuropsychologist who evaluates and testifies in traumatic brain injury (TBI) cases for both plaintiff and defense cases.
Dr. Mercado defines what neuropsychology is and how it differs from neurology and general psychology. She explains how neuropsychological testing measures cognition, memory, processing speed, and overall brain function. These neuropsychological evaluations often play a critical role in traumatic brain injury litigation. As a neuropsychologist, her role is to translate those complex findings into clear explanations for attorneys, judges, and juries. This helps them better understand what may be happening inside the brain, even when brain imaging appears normal.
In this episode, Tom Crosley sits down with neuropsychologist, Dr. Janyna Mercado to explain the role that neuropsychology plays in traumatic brain injury litigation. They discuss how neuropsychological testing evaluates the “working brain,” why mild TBI cases are often misunderstood, and how expert testimony can help juries understand invisible injuries. This first installment lays the foundation for understanding how neuropsychological evidence can strengthen TBI cases at trial.
Key Takeaways:
Function Over Structure: Neuropsychology examines how the brain functions, which is critical when imaging scans appear normal but cognitive deficits persist
Understanding the Full Medical History: Pre-existing conditions should not be ignored or hidden. When properly evaluated, a client’s medical and psychological history can help clarify how a traumatic event aggravated or worsened prior conditions
Teaching the Jury: Neuropsychologists translate complex brain science into understandable terms that help juries grasp what constitutes a mild traumatic brain injury
This conversation provides foundational insight for trial lawyers handling TBI cases. If you’ve ever struggled to explain a mild TBI to a jury or wondered when and how to involve a neuropsychologist, this episode is for you.
Stay Tuned…
In the second part of this conversation, Tom Crosley and Dr. Janyna Mercado dive deeper into neuropsychological evaluations, including how testing works, how experts analyze results, and trial strategies attorneys can use based on those results.
Subscribe and Stay Connected
Connect directly with Dr. Janyna Mercado at https://texasneuropsychinstitute.com
Are you ready to take your TBI practice to the next level?
Subscribe to: Winning The TBI Case newsletter at www.crosleylaw.com/podcast for exclusive case studies, resources, and trial strategies you won’t hear anywhere else.
Join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
The DTI Revolution in Mild TBI Litigation
2026/02/18
“DTI helps turn the invisible injury into something you can see and quantify, and more importantly, something your jury can see. ” – Tom Crosley
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
Breaking Through the “No Objective Evidence” Wall
What happens when your traumatic brain injury client has normal CT scans and normal MRI results, but clearly isn’t the same person they were before the accident? In this essential episode, Tom Crosley dissects how Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) is revolutionizing mild TBI litigation by making invisible brain injuries visible to juries. Tom walks through why this advanced neuroimaging technique is a powerful tool used to detect microscopic brain damage that standard imaging misses. He breaks down the complex science of how this technology is transforming “impossible to prove” concussion cases into compelling evidence of traumatic axonal injury.
Key Takeaways:
Science Made Simple: A jury-friendly explanation of DTI that anyone can understand
Why Defense Experts Can’t Call DTI “Experimental”: Clinical uses of DTI that undermine defense attacks
DTI Integration Strategy: Advanced neuroimaging as corroborating evidence that supports your case narrative
Whether you’re new to DTI or looking to refine your approach, Tom’s insights make this episode essential listening for any attorney handling mild TBI cases.
Mentioned: Episode featuring ACRM Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) definitions: Introduction of Winning The TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 15: The DTI Revolution in Mild TBI Litigation
Crosley Law | Aired: February 17, 2026 | Runtime: 22:09 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley
[0:00] Tom Crosley: Overwhelmingly, like 96-plus percent of the time, when there’s an admissibility challenge to DTI in courts across the country, courts have ruled that yes, it is admissible, and any criticisms of it go to the weight, not the admissibility.
[0:15] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. In this episode, Tom Crosley tackles the battleground issue that defines modern brain injury litigation, getting your diffusion tensor imaging evidence past aggressive defense challenges and in front of the jury. This is the episode that arms you with everything you need to defeat the no objective evidence defense once and for all.
[1:23] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley, and today I want to talk about diffusion tensor imaging, also known as DTI. And I wanna teach a little bit of the science that is reshaping how we lawyers prove brain injury cases. So if you try mild TBI cases, you’ve probably heard of DTI, maybe you’ve even used it, but a lot of lawyers still have only a fuzzy idea of what it is and how it actually helps us to prove a case, even when the CT or the standard MRI come back as normal. So in this episode, I’m going to focus on what is DTI in plain English, what does it measure in the brain, what does the scientific literature say about mild TBI and diffusion tensor imaging, and how does DTI fit into the proof of a mild TBI in litigation? So let’s start with the basics. DTI is not a separate machine. It is a way of running an MRI and processing the data so that you can look at the white matter wiring of the brain. So let’s think about how the brain is built. The gray matter is where the processing happens.
[2:40] Tom Crosley: Think of the gray matter as the cities. The white matter is the network of fiber tracts, the highways that lets those cities talk to each other. A conventional MRI gives you still photographs of the cities and the landscape. It shows big lesions, hemorrhages, tumors, gross structural anatomy. But DTI goes a level deeper, and it asks, “Is the wiring intact, or has the wiring been stretched, frayed, torn, or damaged?” And so it does that by looking at how water molecules move along the brain’s white matter. In healthy, tightly bundled fibers, water prefers to move along the length of the fiber. In injured or disorganized fibers, that directional movement breaks down and the water moves more randomly. An analogy I have often given is imagine a garden hose, and that garden hose is going to represent a white matter axonal tract within the brain. If the garden hose is long and straight and stretched out and normally functioning, water flows through it in a normal, predictable pattern. If that garden hose is torn, damaged, kinked, stretched, then the water flows through that garden hose in a disrupted manner, and you can compare normal versus disrupted, and you can draw conclusions from it.
[4:04] Tom Crosley: On a more microscopic scale, that’s essentially what is happening with DTI. There might be a neuroradiologist out there that says my explanation is too simple, but I think it works, and I’ve certainly taught it to juries that way. So DTI turns this motion or movement of water molecules along axons, it turns it into a number called fractional anisotropy. FA is what they call it. High FA means water is moving in an ordinary, orderly, directional way. It’s healthy wiring. Lower FA means the movement of water molecules is more random. It means the wiring is disrupted. It means the function isn’t normal. And so when you see reduced FA in specific white matter fiber tracts in the brain, that is a red flag for traumatic axonal injury. That’s the microscopic shearing and stretching and tearing of axons that happens in many TBIs, especially with rotational forces or acceleration-deceleration-type injuries that are all too common in motor vehicle crashes. So in lawyer language, when we explain it to a jury, I would say DTI is a way to measure whether the brain’s wiring has been damaged.
[5:24] Tom Crosley: It’s looking for frayed cables within the wiring. So why does DTI matter in mild TBI cases, and why do we care so much about it? I think the best answer is that mild TBI cases live in that frustrating space where the CT scan is normal, the standard MRI is normal, but the client is clearly not the same person. There’s something going on, and the defense keeps saying, “Hey, there’s no objective evidence of brain injury.” Well, we have to remember traumatic axonal injury is often microscopic. It doesn’t show up as a big white spot or a dark lesion on a routine MRI, but it can absolutely disrupt how the brain functions from day to day. And think about the NFL CTE cases when they were all first diagnosed. It was always on autopsy after death with slides and a microscope. These were changes in brains that were affecting behavior but couldn’t be visualized in vivo. So we know that microscopic changes to the brain can occur at a level below our machinery to detect, and we know that can result in poor outcomes and poor function.
[6:41] Tom Crosley: So back to DTI gives you a way to visualize those microscopic changes in the white matter tracts. It gives you a way to measure them using FA and other types of computer-based metrics. It gives you a way to map those changes to specific cognitive functions. Let me give you an example. The corpus callosum, the information superhighway that connects the two halves of the brain, that’s the big bridge between the two hemispheres. Damage there can line up with processing speed problems, with multitasking problems. Frontal white matter tracts, those support executive function, planning, judgment, impulse control. Temporal and limbic connections tie to memory and emotion. And so the research shows that in many mild TBI patients with persistent symptoms, DTI finds reduced FA in exactly these kind of tracts. So those changes are associated with problems in attention, memory, processing speed, and executive function. In other words, for we trial lawyers, DTI helps turn the invisible injury into something you can see and quantify, and more importantly, something your jury can see, because we all know the old adage that a picture is worth a thousand words.
[8:00] Tom Crosley: I want to add a clarification. So earlier I talked about how low FA is a red flag for traumatic axonal injury. I don’t want you to be caught off guard if an expert report talks about regions of FA not too low, but instead are too high. And so, when white matter is disrupted, the directional organization often breaks down, leading to this low FA that we talked about earlier. That’s the familiar pattern. Low FA means disrupted wiring. But abnormal can mean abnormal in both directions. The research shows that some patients with mild TBI have regions where the FA is significantly higher than normal. In a recent systematic review of the mild TBI literature, hundreds of studies and tens of thousands of patients, most studies found FA differences reported lower FA in the injured group, but a meaningful minority reported higher FA. Elevated FA is a recognized part of the DTI literature too. So why would a brain show FA that is too high? One rea
John Sloan: Finding the Emotional Truth in TBI Cases
2025/11/25
“Jurors don’t decide cases on the facts… They decide the case based the emotional content and whether they can connect with our client’s story.” – John Sloan
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen each week as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
Uncovering the Core of a Client’s Story
In this episode, Tom is joined by veteran trial lawyer, John Sloan, a nationally respected litigator with more than 150 jury trials under his belt. John brings four decades of insight to a deep and candid discussion about what truly moves juries in traumatic brain injury cases. Together they explore how to get beyond surface-level facts, uncover the emotional core of a client’s story, and present before-and-after witnesses in a way that makes the jurors feel the loss that TB clients live with every day. John also shares his experience with the Trial Lawyers College and how it has shaped his approach to storytelling and client connection, and why getting to know clients in their everyday environment is non-negotiable.
Key Takeaways
The critical importance of visiting clients in their homes to understand the real impacts of their injury
Why medical documentation can make or break your case
Why mild TBI clients often deny their own symptoms and how to handle that effectively
How a lay witness can be more powerful than even the best neuroimaging
The reason why specialized trial education can help litigators to better hear the hidden meaning behind what clients are saying.
Trial lawyers will walk away from this episode with actionable strategies to strengthen their next TBI case and elevate their courtroom storytelling.
Winning the TBI Case — Finding the Emotional Truth of TBI Cases with John Sloan
Crosley Law | Runtime: 32:28 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley, John Sloan
[0:01] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it? That’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. In this episode, Tom welcomes veteran trial lawyer John Sloan for an insightful discussion on the art and the heart of trying traumatic brain injury cases. Over four decades of courtroom experience and more than 150 trials to his name, John shares what he’s learned about connecting with juries, uncovering the emotional truth behind every case, and the power of truly listening to clients.
[1:11] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley. Today, we are joined by trial lawyer John Sloan. John, how are you? Doing well. Thanks for having me, Tom. Now I’m excited to have John on the program today. John is a lawyer’s lawyer. He’s been a trial lawyer for decades. He was involved with the faculty of the Trial Lawyers College. We’re going to talk a little bit about that. His firm is the Sloan Firm with 15 lawyers and three different offices. And John, what I’d like to start with is, tell us about your law practice, what it’s been like, and in particular, your focus on TBI cases.
[1:56] John Sloan: So I graduated from law school in February of 1980. One of the first cases that I worked on was a case that my boss had been hired to handle, and we were defending a guy for a charge of murder. So my first trial, been sworn in for five weeks, was a murder case. Yeah, and so you can imagine how nerve-wracking that was. And so the first three years of my practice was in Henderson, Texas, and I tried everything from boundary line disputes to divorces to murder cases over that period of time. I got to try one trucking case and absolutely didn’t know what I was doing. But my client had a brain injury and that kind of got me interested in doing that kind of work. I ended up representing a lawyer several years after that who also had a brain injury, and actually tried my first brain injury case in 1993, in Scurry County, Texas.
[3:16] John Sloan: So I’ve been trying those cases ever since, of course, along with a bunch of other different kinds of injury cases, and particularly interested in TBI cases. I see them, as most lawyers should see them, in a lot of the car wreck and truck wreck cases that we have at our firm. I’ve tried over 150 cases in my career, I haven’t had a trial yet this year, but I’ve got two set in December that I hope will get tried, so.
[3:53] Tom Crosley: Well, I hope at least one of those two goes for you, John. And for your sake, I hope they don’t both go to trial at the same time. It’s, you know, when it rains, it pours, and sometimes that’s true. Yeah.
[4:04] John Sloan: Back-to-back trial settings are not a good thing.
[4:08] Tom Crosley: Hey John, tell us about your role with the Trial Lawyers College, what you’ve done as faculty in that organization, how you teach lawyers to be better trial lawyers.
[4:18] John Sloan: Okay. I was a student at the Trial Lawyers College in 1998. And then four years after that, I was fortunate enough to be asked to be on the teaching staff. And then in 2008, I was asked to be on the board of directors. And in 2014, I became president of the organization of the alumni, what we call the Trial Lawyers College, and then ended my term on the board June of this year. So it’s been a long journey. The Trial Lawyers College has a unique way of teaching. We don’t have, we don’t hand out a seminar book when people show up for one of our courses. It’s a lot of show me rather than tell me we should do and involves getting people up on their feet, getting them to work on the various trial skills that we all know about. Fundamentally involves the lawyers getting to know themselves. Some have described it as an archaeological dig into who each of us are. The Trial Lawyers College, instead of trying one case 150 times,
[5:39] John Sloan: you try 150 cases 150 times. Because each story is unique, each client is unique. And we’ve got to find the emotional truth of our cases, in order to relate that to a jury. You know, jurors don’t decide cases on the facts. They don’t decide cases on what are the 10 most important facts in our case. They decide the case based on the emotional content and whether they connect with our client, with our client’s story. The aim of the Trial Lawyers College is to find that common ground. Find that area where the juror connects with our clients, and with our story. And it also involves being our authentic selves.
[6:28] Tom Crosley: Let’s dive into that and how that philosophy would lead over into your handling of a TBI case. Help us layer that a little bit more with you said that the jury doesn’t decide the case based on the facts.
[6:46] John Sloan: TBI case, as you know, and as I’ve heard you say on your podcast before and your guests say, I think the most important witnesses are those who know your client and have known your client forever. Because they’re the only ones that really can relate to the jury the differences in that person from before and after the incident that caused the traumatic brain injury. Yeah, experts can be important, and certainly in today’s world of trying a TBI case, three Tesla MRIs and the other diagnostic tests certainly are important. But the first one that I ever tried I had a neuropsychologist, which was a absolutely brand new expert to me at the time. And I had the guy’s wife, and his uncle and a co-worker that came and testified. And that made all the difference. So in a TBI case, using the training that I’ve had at the Trial Lawyers College, it’s very important to get to know the client, obviously. Mm-hmm, to use that to find out the emotional truths of that person’s story.
[8:07] John Sloan: As you know, many TBI clients have no self-awareness whatsoever. You know, I’ve had people in my office with their family, and I’ll ask the guy or woman, you know, do you ever feel like you’re foggy upstairs? Do you have short-term memory loss? Are you irritable? All the signs and symptoms of a traumatic brain injury. Person who’s actually injured is going to sit there and say, No, I don’t have any of those things. And the family will be in the background going, Yes he does. Yes he does. So and you know too often we get so wrapped up in everything that we have to do that we don’t do the work that we need to do to really know our clients. I think every plaintiff’s lawyer oughta be visiting in their client’s home. See if they’ll let you enjoy a meal with them, or go there on a Saturday morning or a Sunday afternoon after they’ve been to church and just sit around and talk to the family. I just think that makes all the difference in our ability to present the case.
[9:21] Tom Crosley: I agree. I agree completely with that. I mean, I tell lawyers all the time that before you go try the case, go visit the client at home. Sometimes you’ll see something on the mantel or on the wall that you end up talking to them about, that is something you bring up in the trial. Absolutely. And they behave differently, I think, sitting in their living room than they do sitting in your conference room. Yeah, I agree. Okay, so let’s focus in on how many TBI ca
Making the Invisible Visible: Special Recap Episode
2025/11/11
Introduction of Winning The TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling
Imagine standing in a courtroom, representing someone whose life has been forever changed by an injury no one can see. No broken bones visible on X-rays. No scars to photograph. Just a person who looks perfectly normal on the outside, but whose brain and the very essence of who they are, has been fundamentally altered.
This is the world Tom Crosley introduced us to twelve episodes ago. “Traumatic Brain Injury trials are some of the most complex and contentious litigation scenarios that you can encounter as a trial lawyer,” he explained, setting the stage for a journey through one of law’s most challenging frontiers.
TBI Trial Strategy Fundamentals & Advanced TBI Case Strategies with Keith Mitnik
Keith Mitnik joined the conversation early to share a profound truth that shapes everything in TBI litigation: You need two completely different skill sets to succeed.
“People either step in and try them and don’t truly know the science,” Keith observed, “or they know the science in their sleep, but they don’t know how to try a case with it. It takes both to do them right.”
This isn’t your typical car crash case involving a herniated disc. This is a whole different universe of knowledge. And here’s where it gets interesting—Keith revealed that when medical bills are minimal compared to the damages you’re seeking, sometimes the boldest move is not presenting them at all.
“Insider information gets in our way,” he explained. “We know we like to present medical bills. We know not presenting them may be unusual. Guess who doesn’t: the jury.”
Sequencing the Evidence
Tom then pulled back the curtain on one of the biggest mistakes lawyers make in TBI cases: telling the story in the wrong order.
“Have you ever watched a movie where the twist at the end completely changed how you saw everything that came before it?” Tom asked. “Trying a TBI case is a lot like that.”
The strategy is surgical in its precision: Build a wall of evidence before the jury ever meets your client. Prove the injury is real before the defense gets a chance to argue it isn’t. Win half the battle in your first two or three witnesses, drilling the point home so sharp and so early that momentum carries you through.
How Expert Witnesses Build a Wall of Evidence
But evidence alone doesn’t win cases. connection does. Tom revealed that while experts might be the brain of your case, before-and-after witnesses are its heart and soul. These are the people who knew your client before the injury, who can paint the picture of what was lost. They translate MRI scans and medical terminology into something jurors can see, feel, and understand.
“When done right,” Tom emphasized, “they push jurors from understanding to truly caring. And that’s what wins cases.”
The Power of Before-and-After Witnesses and Introducing the Plaintiff for Maximum Impact
Here’s where the strategy gets almost paradoxical: In most TBI cases, Tom doesn’t let the jury see his client until deep into the trial, perhaps the 17th witness out of 20.
“Timing is everything,” he explained. “You do not put the plaintiff on the stand until the jury is primed to see their injury and not just in medical terms, but in human terms.”
By the time the plaintiff finally appears, the jury has been educated, emotionally invested, and prepared to truly see the invisible injury that has upended this person’s life.
How to Tear Apart the Defense’s “Junk Science” Experts
Episode eight brought us into the trenches of cross-examination, where Tom laid out his systematic approach to destroying defense experts in what he calls “junk science witnesses.”
The strategy starts in discovery, trapping them early. Then comes the methodical dismantling:
Expose their bias as paid witnesses
Use their own words against them
Transform their “normal limits” argument into a weakness
Remind the jury that biomechanical engineers aren’t doctors
Follow the money trail to expose the hired gun relationship
“Nothing kills credibility faster than a hired gun in the hip pocket of the defense lawyer,” Tom noted with satisfaction.
TBI: Not Everyone Recovers
Then came the bombshell research every TBI lawyer needs to know. Tom shared groundbreaking data that destroys the myth that everyone recovers from brain injuries:
“Only 27% of patients with post-concussive syndrome recovered after three months.”
Let that sink in. And it gets more powerful: If symptoms persist beyond a year, patients are more likely than not permanently injured. And if symptoms last three years? The study found zero recovery after that point.
This isn’t opinion. This is science. This is ammunition.
The Multiplying Effect of Injuries with Steven Gursten
Steven Gursten brought another crucial insight in episode ten, explaining how multiple injuries don’t just add up—they multiply human suffering.
“Two plus two does not equal four in the human body,” his favorite doctor testified. When you have multiple injuries, people’s problems go up by multiplication, not addition. This reflects where we are today with medical literature and science—understanding the cumulative, synergistic effect of trauma on the human body.
The All-or-Nothing Nature of TBI Cases with Steven Gursten
Steven also pulled no punches about the harsh reality of TBI litigation: These cases are incredibly difficult to settle.
“80 to 90% of plaintiff lawyers out there are afraid to take these cases,” he revealed. “They settle them for basically nuisance dollars because they’re afraid they’ll going to get no-caused.”
The message is clear: You must have a track record of trying these cases for insurers to take you seriously. If you don’t, you’re just another lawyer they can lowball into submission.
Mastering TBI Science with Stewart Casper
Our journey culminated with Stewart Casper, who has spent over two decades building what might be the most comprehensive TBI research database in the legal world. Labeled a “nerd” for his dedication, Stewart has systematized knowledge gathering into an art form.
Every weekend, he receives automated searches from PubMed for traumatic brain injury, mild traumatic brain injury, diffusion tensor imaging, and symptom validity. He categorizes everything into two buckets: What can be used for impeachment, and what’s educational.
“Not many people have the patience to both study this stuff and index it as I do,” Stewart admitted. But that patience—that systematic approach to staying current—is what separates the warriors from the wannabes in TBI litigation.
The Path Forward
After twelve episodes, the message is crystal clear: TBI litigation isn’t for the faint of heart. It demands a rare combination of scientific mastery and storytelling brilliance. It requires the courage to leave medical bills on the table when they don’t serve your narrative. The wisdom to keep your client hidden until the perfect moment. The preparation to systematically destroy defense experts. And the commitment to stay current with ever-evolving science.
But for those willing to master both sides of this coin—the science and the story—the opportunity is immense. Because behind every “invisible” injury is a very real person whose life has been forever changed. And they deserve a lawyer who knows how to make the invisible visible, who can transform medical data into human truth, and who won’t settle for nuisance value when justice demands so much more.
This is the world of TBI litigation. This is what winning looks like.
Connect With Us
Have a topic idea or question for Tom? Email us at [email protected]
If today’s recap reminded you why this work matters, share it with a colleague facing similar battles. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results.
And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 13: Making the Invisible Visible: Special Recap Episode
Crosley Law | Aired: November 11, 2025 | Runtime: 14:02 | Speakers: Keith Mitnik, Narrator, Steven Gursten, Stewart Casper, Tom Crosley
[0:01] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. Let’s join Tom as he breaks down the fundamental challenges of representing clients with invisible injuries. Welcome to a special recap episode of Winning the TBI Case. Over the past 12 episodes, we’ve explored the strategies, science, and storytelling techniques that separate winning traumatic brain injury cases from those that fall short. Today, we’ll revisit the key insights shared by Tom Crosley and his guests, from the fundamentals of TBI litigation to advanced trial tactics that have helped secure multi-million dollar verdicts for brain injury victims.
[1:25] Narrator: Let’s begin with episode one, where Tom introduced us to the unique challenges of TBI litigation.
[1:30] Tom Crosley: Traumatic brain injury trials are some o
Stewart Casper: Mastering TBI Science
2025/10/21
“I said, this is really interesting stuff. It’s not just broken bones or a sprain of a neck. This is something really, really fundamentally interesting, and it would require a lot of hard work, which I was prepared to do as a young lawyer.” – Stewart Casper
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen each week as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
Mastering the Science
Stewart Casper has spent over 40 years becoming one of the most respected names in traumatic brain injury litigation. His reputation isn’t built on victories alone, it’s built on an unparalleled commitment to mastering the evolving science of brain injury. For two decades, Stewart has systematically read, curated, and indexed every significant piece of TBI research, creating a resource he generously shares with trial lawyers nationwide.
In this episode, Tom sits down with Stewart to explore the insights that have shaped his legendary career. We start with where it all began when Stewart attended a brain injury conference in 1980 where he heard the term “diffuse axonal injury” for the first time. We then fast-forward to 2014 when he discovered neurometabolic cascade research that fundamentally changed how TBI litigators counter defense experts. Stewart’s career, spanning from that first brain injury conference to today’s cutting edge science, reveals what it takes to truly master TBI science in this ever-evolving and complex field.
Key Takeaways
Stewart’s systematic process for staying current with medical literature and creating a searchable database
What the “citation cartel” is and how defense neuropsychologists manipulate perceived credibility
Tactical advice on MMPI misuse by defense experts and how to demand raw data exchanges
Why blood biomarkers and objective neuroimaging represent the future of TBI litigation
Advice for lawyers interested in TBI litigation
Mastering TBI Science with Stewart Casper
Narrator: Stewart Casper has been a plaintiff’s lawyer for more than 40 years. He is nationally known for his handling of traumatic brain injury cases and has earned a reputation for unparalleled devotion to staying current with the scientific literature.
For over two decades, Stewart has systematically read, curated, and indexed every significant piece of TBI research, creating an invaluable resource he generously shares with trial lawyers nationwide.
In this episode, Stewart’s insights showcase why he is considered a living legend in TBI litigation and his practical wisdom to help any lawyer elevate their practice.
Tom Crosley: Welcome back to winning the TBI case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley. Today we are blessed to be joined by Connecticut trial lawyer and Living legend Stewart Casper. How are you, Stewart?
Stewart Casper: That’s quite an introduction. I am fine, Tom. Thank you for that.
Tom Crosley: You know, I have often said, Stewart, maybe you’ve heard me say it, but if the AAJ TBI Group had a physical library—like a brick and mortar building—your name be on the side of it.
Stewart Casper: Well, thank you. But, um, I’m a little compulsive about it, as you know.
Tom Crosley: All right, and we’re gonna get into that. And what we are referring to, folks listening, is that Stewart is the industry leader in the TBI litigation field for staying on track with the medical literature, staying on track with the science, reading the latest articles, discussing them for the rest of us, helping the rest of us understand what they mean and how to use them in our cases.
And so we’re gonna cover some of that in today’s podcast. But first, Stewart, I’d like to talk about you, your, uh, tell us your path to becoming a TBI lawyer. What got you started in this process in the first place?
Stewart Casper: That’s an interesting question. The backstory is interesting. I was a very young lawyer. I was, um, perhaps in my first or second year of practicing law, and I attended, I think was my first then ATLA education program put on by the Traumatic Brain Injury litigation group. Or it wasn’t a group at that point. It may not have been. It was, the educational program was on traumatic brain injury. It was a two-day program in Boston.
I remember as a young lawyer thinking, “Well, why don’t I go to that?” And it was really, really stimulating. It was, um, I think the first time I had heard the term “diffuse axonal injury,” And it was, at that time I heard about MRI, except it was in the early stage of MRI. So I’m talking 1979, 1980. So, and the acronym at the time was NMR and the myth was—could have been myth, it could have been true—that the radiologists didn’t want the acronym to turn into “No More Radiologists.” And at the time it was far from true, but maybe today with artificial intelligence, we’re getting closer to that point. That’s, it’s interesting.
So the bottom line was, I said, “This is really interesting stuff.” It’s not just broken bones or a sprain of a neck. This is something really, really fundamentally interesting. And that it would require a lot of hard work, which I was prepared to do as a young lawyer. If you look—at the time I was looking to create a niche for myself, and that was the niche. And you know, I would have been successful at doing that. I’m grateful for that experience and grateful for the path.
Narrator: That early exposure to cutting edge brain injury science shaped Stewart’s entire career. While other doctors were content to rely on treating doctors and basic medical knowledge, Stewart made a different choice. He decided to become a true student of the science.
That commitment would pay off decades later when he discovered research that would change how we all litigate TBI cases.
Stewart Casper: And it was around 2014, I came across an article that was published in Continuum. Continuum is the educational arm of the American Academy of Neurology. And that Continuum article talked about the neurometabolic cascade, really dividing it. And it was an article that was designed to be about diagnosing and treating sports concussion. You know, a concussion is a concussion. Some are more violent than others, but there isn’t a separate, um, there isn’t a separate pathophysiology for getting hit on the football field and have it being concussed and a separate pathophysiology for, getting a concussion in a wreck.
And so, I was just sort of amazed that I came across this article and I think it was 2014. And it turns out it wasn’t the first one that I had missed. A couple of earlier papers that Dr. Christopher Giza from UCLA was a co-author of, and I’m reading that article and the lights and sirens are going off. I said this concept of the neurometabolic cascade really addresses that issue of why the immediate aftermath of a concussion is not the most consequential time for a concussion; that it can occur days, weeks, and months later because the whole concept of the neurometabolic cascade has to do with the secondary pathophysiologic effects of the brain injury. The things like the flooding of the glutamate and the electrical changes in the brain. And as the imbalance in the different substances in the brain create a snowballing effect, and there’s no way to tell when it is going to resolve.
Tom Crosley: Let me interject with a question or comment. So you said something I thought was important. It certainly was a signpost for me as a listener. You said you’re reading this article in Continuum, which is the publication of the American Academy of Neurology in circa 2014, and you had a lights and sirens moment where these alarm bells are going off in your head and you’re connecting the dots.
What precisely was it that you thought was important about that article and that thought process, for our listeners?
Stewart Casper: Well in the experience of handling a number of concussive brain injury cases, and I actually, I think it was actually Michael Kaplan, New York, who used that frame, a “concussive brain injury” as distinct from a concussion or as distinct from a traumatic brain injury. Um, and I like that. I like that idea from Michael. But we were consistently dealing with the citation cartel and the defense experts who claimed that everyone got better and that the worst point in time after a concussion was immediately after the concussion; immediately after the trauma. And it was, uh, Dr. Giza and Dr. Kutcher from Chicago, who framed that 2014 paper in Continuum who said, “Well, that’s, there’s a primary injury, there’s a secondary injury, and this is what happens.”
Narrator: Stewart’s discovery of the neurometabolic cascade research changed how plaintiff attorneys could counter defense experts who claimed everyone recovers in 90 days. But Stewart’s contribution to TBI litigation goes far beyond reading a single groundbreaking article.
For over 20 years, he’s been systematically curating and indexing every significant piece of TBI research.
Tom Crosley: Stewart, you’ve been known to read and archive every peer reviewed study on brain injury. Uh, how do you approach digesting such a massive body of literature?
Stewart Casper: The predominant way I have for doing that is having a standing search at the National Library of Medicine, PubMed, and the terms I search are “traumatic brain injury,” “mild traumatic brain injury,” diffusion tensor imaging” and, “symptom validity.” And I get an email every weekend and it gives me the top 20 publications that fulfill
Steven Gursten: The All-or-Nothing Nature of TBI Cases
2025/10/14
“ Half of these guys are still calling it post-concussion syndrome and think you still need a loss of consciousness to have a brain injury.” – Steven Gursten
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen each week as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
When Settlement Offers Stay Stubbornly Low
In the conclusion of their two-part series, Tom continues his conversation with Michigan trial attorney Steven Gursten. They discuss tackling one of the most frustrating challenges in TBI litigation: getting cases settled for fair value when insurance companies consistently mis-evaluate them.
Steven shares the reasons why mild TBI cases demand a completely different playbook for both damages presentation and settlement strategy. He explains some of the proven tactics that catch defense lawyers off guard and lead to substantial settlements for his clients.
This insightful conversation explains why TBI cases are fundamentally all-or-nothing propositions and what you can do to stack the deck in your client’s favor.
Whether you’re facing your first mediation on a brain injury case or looking to refine your approach, Steven’s systematic strategies offer practical wisdom for achieving results that reflect the true value of your client’s traumatic brain injury.
Key Takeaways
Steven’s unconventional approach to presenting economic damages in TBI cases
The Sponsorship Theory – A powerful negotiation strategy that leverages the defense’s own experts against them
How regular communication with TBI clients helps prevent confusion, distrust, and doubt from creeping in when settlement offers come in low
The creative deposition tactic that changes negotiation dynamics before mediation begins
Why having a trial track record is essential for settlement leverage in TBI cases
The All-or-Nothing Nature of TBI Cases with Steven Gursten
Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley, and today we’re joined by Steven Gursten. He’s a nationally recognized trial lawyer, and Steve is Michigan Auto Law.
So I’d like to talk a little bit about, uh, trial tactics. And in particular I want us to discuss economic damages. So past medical expenses, future medical expenses, and brain injury cases.
And there’s two concepts I’d like to explore with you. One is, uh, that a lot of times the past medical expenses are relatively low in these cases. We might have $20,000 or $30,000 in medical expenses in the past, yet be asking for $10 million. Um, what are you doing with that issue? I’ve heard of some lawyers say, yeah, I’m just non-suiting past meds. I’m not even seeking that anymore because I don’t want that low anchor. Do you have an opinion on that?
Steven Gursten: Yeah, I do. I do believe it’s an incredibly low anchor. Uh, I think it hurts us. For me in Michigan, it’s, uh, I have an even more practical reason, which is, up until recently, everything was no fault. So it wasn’t even admissible. Everything was being paid by the person’s own no fault insurer. It wasn’t part of the case that you could ask for as part of the damages.
So, um, but I do think all these cases, the past medical is going to be misleading and it’s going to be a low anchor. Make sure you get permission in writing to not bring those, ’cause otherwise, if you lose, you’re gonna get a potential malpractice letter, or at least a letter from the grievance commissioner, you know, saying, why didn’t you bring ’em?
But I think if you have that talk with your client in terms of tactics and strategy, you’re almost always better served not bringing the past medical in these cases. The other thing I might add is I am getting away from life care plans in large part. And what I’m starting to do is make more of a general transferring of risk type argument in my closing arguments. And by that what I mean is I don’t wanna spend a day of the juror’s time focusing on the cost of toilet paper rolls or, you know, all the stupid things that defense lawyers do to tie you down on these life care plans and bore the jury. ‘Cause the jury’s bored, they’re getting annoyed, and it tends to go to the defense’s benefit. What I think you’re better off doing is taking a step back and saying, “Look, right now, please understand we can never come back to court. And you have heard from the treating doctors how much more susceptible, how much more at risk my client, John, is for an utterly catastrophic future. ‘Cause please know, in 10 years, if he’s diagnosed with dementia, if he has to be warehoused in a medical facility because of Parkinson’s or all these things that he is now so much more vulnerable and susceptible to because of this brain injury, we can never come back. So 100% of the risk, 100% of the risk of an utterly devastating future, lies only on John’s shoulders today. And that isn’t right, and it isn’t fair. So what we’re asking you to do is to transfer at least some of that risk of an utterly catastrophic future. To at least transfer some of that also onto the shoulders of the defendant trucking company, which is fair because they’re the ones after all, that ran the red light and caused all these injuries and put John in this position.”
And what I have found from both trials and focus groups is that if you get away from the life care plan and just get back to basic concepts of fairness—of what is fair, what is right—that you are much more likely to have the jury add an extra couple million dollars in some cases onto their verdict, because of the potential devastating future that every client with A TBI now faces.
So you just now need to make sure as a plaintiff lawyer, that you’ve got doctors that will support and give testimony based on the peer-reviewed journal articles that are out there today talking about things like significant increased risk. But if you do that, I just think it’s an easier concept for juries. You’re not spending a full day or a day-and-a-half with a life care planner on the witness stand boring the bejesus outta the jury. And I think it’s a much easier—again, it goes back to what I was saying with chronic pain. It’s an intuitive reframing of damages that is intuitively fair to people and makes sense for them.
Tom Crosley: Is there an increased risk threshold? You think you’ve got a clear to be able to get that into evidence?
Steven Gursten: I’m a little reluctant to talk about the law in all 50 states, but I’ve seen it in enough states where the case law on things like toxic tort exposure on environmental, uh, exposure cases. We have really, really strong case law and what those cases basically say—and it is analogous to brain injury—is you don’t need to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the client is going to have dementia, let’s say in 10 or 20 years.
What you do need is a doctor to be able to say that they are now at a significantly increased risk compared to the general population because of this injury. And in many cases, depending on who your doctor is, Tom, they will say within reasonable medical certainty because the, there’s enough medicine out there and science out there that talks about that about.
So, you know, and again this is today. What’s it gonna be in three to five years from now with where they’re going with genetic testing and epigenetics and, you know, the APOE four gene couplet now and all these different things that they’re discovering that could have a huge role in our brain injury cases.
So as long as you’ve got that kind of evidence, whether forensic or through the treaters, you’re okay making it. And I have won in court, and I’ve never lost in court making that argument.
Tom Crosley: That’s great. That’s great. Yeah. And if you can show a doubling of the risk of, say, dementia; we all, if we all live long enough, we’re all gonna get dementia, almost all of us. And if we double that risk, then the dementia level we would have in our eighties becomes dementia in our sixties. And so that’s a way that I’ve tried it in, in cases where we build up a life care plan that has very little in cost between age 35 and 55, and then enters, you know, a significant cost beginning in around age 60 for in-home healthcare assisted living things.
And the argument we’re typically making is, you know, John, to use your example, John’s brain at age 60 is gonna be like it would’ve been in his eighties because of this injury.
Let me ask you though, about life care plans some more, so future meds, some more. Here’s one of the—I see these cases going two different ways and I’ve done a bunch of them.
Uh, one way is where I can prove some kind of early onset dementia or long-term negative health effect that’s going to cost medical dollars in the future. And then I’m working up a really nice life care plan around that concept. But also just as frequently—more frequently, in fact—the life care plan won’t address future medical needs, or at least no significant medical needs. Maybe it’s headache prophylaxis or something like that.
And so sometimes we, we have underwhelming future medicals in these cases as well. Especially if it was a mild injury, I can’t show a bleed within the brain or the other things that tend to make it more likely to be early onset dementia. So what are you seeing in those cases and how are you handling it for future medical?
Steven Gursten: Very similar to past medical. I’m not bringing them. I had thi
Podcast reviews
Read Winning The TBI Case podcast reviews
C.J.Aug 2026/01/30
Every episode is a must-watch
This podcast has been a gold mine for learning! As a new attorney, it not only fuels my passion for TBI trial advocacy, but also educates me on how to...
Scooter0410 2025/12/07
Thank you
Thank you, great content. Much needed podcast that many lawyers on both sides of docket need.
Zeb Snyder 2025/09/03
Mandatory Listening for PI Attorneys
This podcast is a great resource for personal injury trial attorneys who want to deepen their knowledge of how to handle TBI cases. Listen to this pod...
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Winning The TBI Case relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.518808383
American Scandal
Audible

4.689571234
Get Sleepy: Sleep meditation and stories
Slumber Studios

4.79026375
Life is Short with Justin Long
Audible

4.714149353
Bad Friends
Bobby Lee & Andrew Santino

4.7133275
10 to Life
Annie Elise

4.76763467
Criminology
Emash Digital & Mike Ferguson, Mike Morford

4.87554989
The Dr. John Delony Show
Ramsey Network

4.512669676
RedHanded
RedHanded

4.959992000
Legal AF by MeidasTouch
MeidasTouch Network

4.7292862000
The Michael Knowles Show
The Daily Wire