
Advertise on podcast: The Murder Men
Rating
4.4from
This podcast has
58 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
Johnny Mitchell and Matthew CoxExplicit
Yes
Date created
2026/02/17
Latest episode
2026/11/14
Average duration
95 min.
Release period
4 days
Description
True crime experts Johnny Mitchell and Matthew Cox take you inside the dark, twisted world of serial killers and expose the wildest murder conspiracy theories!
Unlock The Murder Men podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from The Murder Men podcast
The Killer That Inspired SAW | Toy Box Killer
2026/11/14
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell dive into the disturbing case of David Parker Ray, the infamous Toy Box Killer, whose elaborate trailer, recorded instructions, and horrific crimes drew chilling comparisons to the Saw movies.
Download PrizePicks and use code MURDERMEN to get $25 instantly in Packs after opening your first $5 Pack! 18+ in eligible areas. Terms apply. Collect responsibly. PrizePicks. Run Your Game.
Protect your personal information with Incogni! Visit https://incogni.com/murdermen and use code MURDERMEN to get 60% off Incogni annual plans.
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - The David Parker Ray Case
04:30 - Inside the Infamous Trailer
10:12 - Ray’s Background and Early Life
15:28 - An Unexpected Barbie Confession
18:13 - Military Service, Marriages, and Travel
23:44 - Jill’s Disappearance and Family Allegations
30:38 - His Daughter’s Role in the Investigation
35:01 - The Accomplices and Marie Parker Case
43:02 - Inside the Trailer’s Surveillance Setup
45:08 - Isolation and Control
49:09 - Missing Persons and Unanswered Questions
54:39 - Jesse’s Involvement and a Daring Escape
1:00:31 - The Escape That Exposed Everything
1:02:09 - New Evidence Raises More Questions
1:13:13 - Accomplices and Legal Consequences
1:15:17 - Plea Deals and Sentencing
1:18:45 - Ray’s Final Days and Ongoing Investigation
1:20:38 - Final Thoughts
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
When Karens Fail to Outsmart Cops
2026/11/10
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell react to outrageous bodycam footage of entitled Karens arguing with police, resisting arrest, and turning routine encounters into complete chaos.
Watch the original video here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQ4gKeG_Lv8
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction to Karens vs. Police
02:08 - Jamie's Traffic Stop Escalates
09:32 - Jamie's DUI Investigation
15:18 - Jamie Faces Additional Charges
20:22 - Apartment Noise Complaint Goes Wrong
27:11 - Impaired Driver and Angry Girlfriend
30:48 - Ohio Traffic Stop Escalates
35:03 - Airport Passenger Causes a Scene
43:32 - Terry's Airport Outburst Continues
46:05 - Terry's Arrest and Charges
47:05 - Christina's Bar Outburst
56:24 - Walgreens Karen Confronts Police
1:02:16 - Skyler's Traffic Stop and False Claims
1:05:46 - Disruptive Airline Passenger Confronts Officers
1:10:52 - Parking Lot Confrontation Escalates
1:17:28 - Karen Faces Legal Consequences
1:21:27 - Impaired Driver With Baby in Car
1:29:33 - DUI Penalties and Repeat Offenses
1:34:28 - DWI Arrest and Alcohol Dependency
1:44:44 - Suspicious Driving Leads to Traffic Stop
1:48:12 - Sobriety Tests and Breathalyzer
1:51:29 - Driver Attempts to Leave Traffic Stop
1:52:19 - Final Charges and Closing Thoughts
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Inmates Break Down Ted Bundy’s Escapes & Fatal Mistakes
2026/11/07
Taking care of your health just got easier – start here with Zocdoc: https://zocdoc.com/murdermen #sponsored
Download the Kalshi app at https://kalshi.com/ and use code MEN to get $25 when you trade $25.
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell of The Murder Men examine Ted Bundy’s troubled past, his crimes across multiple states, and the investigation that ultimately brought him to justice.
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - Ted Bundy Introduction
06:26 - Bundy’s Childhood and Family Background
12:32 - Education and Early Career
15:38 - College Years and Seattle Connections
19:00 - Relationships and Personal Struggles
26:02 - Bundy’s Early Cases
30:11 - The Volkswagen Beetle and Prison Stories
33:25 - Lake Sammamish and the First Clues
40:13 - A Girlfriend’s Tip and the Move to Utah
45:14 - Carol’s Escape and Testimony
49:09 - Bundy’s Cases Across Colorado and Utah
58:12 - Traffic Stop Leads to New Evidence
1:00:16 - Bundy’s Arrest and Conviction
1:04:10 - The Courthouse Escape
1:08:12 - Bundy’s Second Escape and Move to Florida
1:15:19 - The Chi Omega Sorority House Case
1:17:45 - Florida Investigation and Bundy’s Capture
1:21:10 - Forensic Evidence, Sentencing, and Confessions
1:30:19 - Bundy’s Final Confessions
1:33:40 - Bundy’s Final Days and Family
1:37:30 - Old Man Jim’s Story and Prison Life
1:45:21 - Prison Visits and Biggie Burger
1:46:58 - Closing Remarks
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Killer Grandma’s Deadly Scam Exposed | Dorothea Puente
2026/11/03
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell uncover the story of Dorothea Puente, a Sacramento boarding house operator who preyed on vulnerable residents, exploited their finances, and hid a disturbing pattern of disappearances behind her reputation as a caring elderly woman.
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - Dorothea Puente: The Elderly Criminal
03:26 - Puente’s Early Life and Fraud
13:07 - Barroom Scams and Theft
15:03 - Puente’s Criminal History
18:16 - Running Boarding Houses in Sacramento
26:22 - A Suspicious Disappearance
30:07 - The Pen Pal and Missing Pensioner
34:10 - The Social Security Scheme
40:27 - The Backyard Investigation
45:08 - Questions About Her Nephew’s Involvement
46:50 - A Missing Tenant Sparks an Investigation
53:04 - Puente’s Trial and Convictions
1:00:19 - The Historic Boarding House
1:01:19 - Case Wrap-Up and JFK Theory
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Rich Killer Realizes She's Been Caught 8 Years Later
2026/10/31
Our listeners get up to 30% off their entire order at https://Undrdog.com #ad
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell react to the shocking case of Amy Vilardi, a South Carolina woman whose family's mysterious deaths remained unsolved for eight years until investigators reopened the case and uncovered new evidence that threatened to expose the truth.
Watch the original bodycam footage here - https://youtu.be/hALTeHQ_wh0?is=63Ko8Nshtc8f_32R
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - Halloween Special: South Carolina Family Case
04:00 - A 911 Call Reveals a Family Tragedy
08:17 - Amy and Ross Face Questioning
15:34 - Amy Requests a Lawyer
20:49 - The Case Reopens Eight Years Later
25:00 - A Forgotten Video Reveals New Clues
30:44 - Detectives Question Amy Again
37:45 - Roxy Reveals Amy’s Family Tensions
40:40 - Friends Reveal Warning Signs and Financial Clues
45:28 - New Evidence Leads Detectives to Ross
53:18 - Investigators Follow the Money
57:23 - Ross Walks Away Without Answers
1:00:19 - Debating the Missing Money and Legal Consequences
1:04:08 - Amy’s Conviction and Ross’s Pending Trial
1:08:24 - Disputed Evidence and Unanswered Questions
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
13 Year Old Realizes His Twin Brother Just Killed Someone
2026/10/27
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell of The Murder Men break down the shocking case of 13-year-old identical twin brothers linked to the murder of their Ohio neighbor, examining the evidence, police interviews, and investigation that followed.
Watch the bodycam footage here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hMPrQyGJk3A
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - Introducing the Case and 13-Year-Old Suspect
02:30 - The Initial Investigation
11:07 - DNA Evidence and Neighborhood Interviews
16:42 - Suspicion Falls on Sheila’s Brother
18:47 - Detectives Question the Twins
27:49 - Investigators Request DNA Samples
30:30 - DNA Testing Raises Questions
34:50 - Detectives Interview the Brothers
37:22 - DNA Results Reveal New Leads
45:38 - Twins Brought in for Questioning
48:32 - Rebecca Demands a Lawyer
1:00:10 - Separate Interviews Begin
1:05:32 - Hunter Identifies Levi’s Watch
1:09:21 - Levi’s Story Raises Questions
1:14:28 - Journal and DNA Evidence
1:16:24 - Identical Twins Complicate the Case
1:20:11 - Levi’s Interview Takes a Turn
1:23:21 - Phone Evidence and Case Outcome
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6’9" Genius Who Hunted College Students | Edmund Kemper
2026/10/24
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell explore the case of Edmund Kemper, a 6’9” highly intelligent serial killer who targeted college students, examining how his charming personality concealed his disturbing behavior and allowed him to avoid suspicion.
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
00:00 - Edmund Kemper’s Crimes and Public Persona
00:13 - Show Introduction
03:43 - Kemper’s Personality and Family Life
15:23 - Kemper’s Troubled Upbringing
19:14 - Early Warning Signs
27:28 - Kemper’s First Crimes and Arrest
31:37 - Release and Lack of Supervision
35:36 - Targeting Hitchhikers
38:00 - The First Two Victims
45:09 - Iiko’s Final Ride
51:50 - Sealed Records and Missed Warning Signs
57:23 - Cindy Schall and the Santa Cruz Case
1:00:12 - Gator Hunting in Florida
1:02:22 - Police Investigation Raises Concerns
1:08:21 - Kemper’s Final Crimes and Escape
1:15:31 - Confession and Arrest
1:20:30 - Trial and Life Sentence
1:23:11 - Life Behind Bars and Parole
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Family Discovers Missing Dad's Head Inside Garbage Bag
2026/10/20
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell investigate the case of Richard Andrews, a Washington grandfather whose disappearance leads detectives to uncover troubling family secrets, suspicious behavior, and conflicting accounts.
Watch the bodycam footage here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ2fLSJCO9o
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/@theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/@InsideTrueCrime
Chapters:
03:49 - A Grandson’s Shocking Secret
06:00 - Police Stop a Confused Driver
14:27 - A Call to His Mother
15:22 - Isaiah Is Released
17:45 - Debate Over Police Procedures
22:28 - Richard Is Reported Missing
33:34 - Cassie Points to Isaiah
38:35 - Discovery at Richard’s Shop
41:52 - Signs of a Cover-Up
47:55 - Anthony Confronts Isaiah
52:52 - Missing Evidence Raises Questions
57:22 - Isaiah’s Troubling Past
1:01:54 - Isaiah Explains His Mental State
1:04:01 - Family Interviews Raise Questions
1:11:59 - Detectives Interview Cassie
1:17:09 - Growing Family Suspicions
1:20:51 - New Evidence and an Alleged Confession
1:25:38 - Isaiah’s Guilty Plea and Sentencing
1:32:16 - Flash Cards and Testing
1:32:40 - Menendez Brothers and the Justice System
1:33:28 - Final Thoughts and Outro
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
How the Hillside Stranglers Tricked Their Victims!
2026/10/17
Taking care of your health just got easier – start here with Zocdoc: https://zocdoc.com/murdermen #sponsored
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down how the Hillside Stranglers, Angelo Buono and Kenneth Bianchi, impersonated police officers to gain their victims’ trust and carried out a series of crimes that shook Los Angeles in the late 1970s.
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Chapters:
00:00 - Introducing the Hillside Stranglers
03:01 - The Cousins’ Backgrounds
12:30 - Fake Police Credentials and Deception
15:06 - Bianchi Moves to California
21:04 - Bianchi and Buono’s Operation
26:03 - The Operation Falls Apart
30:32 - The First Victims
34:59 - Life Behind Bars
39:01 - The Case and Capital Punishment Debate
45:12 - Death Penalty and Appeals
55:11 - Kristen Wexler’s Story
56:40 - Prison Stories and Accountability
1:00:14 - Prison Feud and Unexpected Reunion
1:03:18 - Evidence and the Growing Investigation
1:08:13 - New Developments in the Case
1:15:16 - The Cousins Split and Bianchi Moves
1:19:17 - Washington Investigation and Trial
1:27:58 - The Case’s Aftermath
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Baby Snatcher Caught After Cutting Baby From Womb! | Lisa Montgomery & Taylor Parker
2026/10/13
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down the disturbing cases of Lisa Montgomery and Taylor Parker, two women whose elaborate pregnancy deceptions led to shocking crimes, and examine the investigations, motives, and legal questions surrounding their cases.
Subscribe to our Spotify and leave us a review - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
How Police “Caught” Wayne Williams | Atlanta Child Murders
2026/10/10
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell examine the Atlanta Child Murders case, exploring Wayne Williams’ background, the investigation, and the evidence surrounding his involvement. The Murder Men debate his guilt and the questions that continue to surround the case decades later.
Visit https://prizepicks.onelink.me/LME0/MURDERMEN and use code MURDERMEN and get $150 if you win your first $5 lineup! #ad
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Chapters:
00:00 - Wayne Williams’ Guilt Debate
02:02 - Williams’ Background and Ambitions
12:22 - Recruiting Young Performers
15:07 - Williams’ Early Legal Troubles
18:06 - Atlanta Case and Community Concerns
25:24 - Key Evidence and Investigation
30:10 - Witness Testimony and Evidence
32:45 - KKK Investigation and Surveillance
37:15 - Bridge Stakeout and Wayne Williams
45:21 - Classism and Social Divisions
46:52 - Fiber Evidence and Unanswered Questions
53:09 - Williams’ Trial and Evidence
1:00:24 - Sitcom Prank Idea
1:02:29 - Williams’ Testimony and Verdict
1:09:57 - Reopened Case and DNA Testing
1:15:28 - Final Thoughts and Highlights
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Husband Kisses Wife Goodbye After Poisoning Her Drink
2026/10/06
Download the Kalshi app at https://kalshi.com/ and use code MEN to get $10 when you trade $10.
Upgrade your wardrobe with timeless essentials that actually lasts. Shop Quince with free shipping and 365-day returns at https://quince.com/murdermen
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down the case of Colorado dentist James Craig, who was accused of poisoning his wife Angela Craig’s protein shake as investigators uncovered a trail of suspicious evidence and hidden motives.
You can watch the full video they're reacting to here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29PVkF6hcnw
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction & Case Overview
07:01 - Dentist Case Begins
11:24 - Key Evidence & Arrest
25:02 - Police Interview
30:33 - Admission & Growing Suspicion
33:17 - Motive & Insurance
45:38 - Phone Evidence
47:36 - Search History & Online Orders
59:56 - Surveillance Footage
1:02:24 - New Evidence & Charges
1:09:42 - Trial & Sentencing
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Alex Murdaugh Gets a Retrial—What Happens Next?
2026/10/03
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down Alex Murdaugh’s overturned conviction, the controversy surrounding his original trial, and what to expect from his upcoming retrial.
Scammers don't ask permission, they're gone before you notice. Coveron monitors your identity and accounts and helps you recover if fraud actually happens. Head to https://coveron.com/themurdermen and use code THEMURDERMEN to get protected. #ad
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Chapters:
00:00 - Murdaugh Case Overview
02:58 - Family Background & Wealth
13:17 - Boat Night Timeline
15:10 - Boat Incident
20:29 - Legal Fallout
28:22 - Family Case Developments
31:00 - Forensic Evidence
37:33 - Prior Cases & Questions
45:17 - Financial Misconduct
46:42 - Fraud & Lifestyle
1:00:19 - Insurance Scheme
1:05:11 - Trial & Motive Debate
1:11:50 - Conviction & Sentencing
1:17:55 - Jury Misconduct Allegations
1:22:47 - Retrial & New Testing
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Secret Killer Leads Cops Into Her $3M Murder Mansion
2026/09/29
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell react to bodycam footage surrounding the disappearance of Craig Thetford in rural New Mexico as investigators uncover conflicting stories and suspicious details involving his wife, Deana Thetford.
You can watch the video Matt & Johnny are reacting to here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6CXNbzKlks&t=1s
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Chapters:
00:00 - Missing Husband Case
00:56 - Case Overview
07:57 - Initial Welfare Check
15:51 - Officers Leave the Property
16:26 - Second Welfare Check
27:07 - Dena's Troubling Past
31:00 - Marriage and Relationship Discussion
34:01 - Gun Rights Discussion
36:05 - Investigating Dena's Story
46:12 - Cash and New Details
48:55 - Growing Suspicions
1:00:21 - Dena's Disappearance
1:01:40 - New Tip Emerges
1:03:09 - Family Interview
1:06:58 - Property Search and Discovery
1:18:43 - Major Case Breakthrough
1:21:03 - Charges and Investigation
1:23:36 - Plea and Sentencing
1:33:47 - Humor and Hypotheticals
1:34:18 - Consequences and Commentary
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
How Israel Keyes Fooled the FBI!
2026/09/27
Scammers don't ask permission, they're gone before you notice. Coveron monitors your identity and accounts and helps you recover if fraud actually happens. Head to https://coveron.com/themurdermen and use code THEMURDERMEN to get protected. #ad
Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down how serial killer Israel Keyes used calculated planning and cross-country travel to evade the FBI, leaving investigators with unanswered questions about the true extent of his crimes.
Follow us on all socials!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod
Email us here - [email protected]
Subscribe to The Connect: With Johnny Mitchell - https://www.youtube.com/ @theconnectpod
Subscribe to Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime - https://www.youtube.com/ @InsideTrueCrime
Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39
Chapters:
00:00 - Israel Keyes Case Overview
01:12 - Childhood and Upbringing
08:50 - Criminal Methods and Planning
15:05 - Early Life and Military Service
16:34 - Criminal History and Relocations
19:31 - Moving to Alaska
30:09 - Life and Work in Alaska
32:45 - Bank Incidents and Hidden Kits
38:11 - The Vermont Case
45:10 - Missing Evidence in Vermont
49:44 - The Alaska Investigation
58:39 - Cruise Alibi and Timeline
1:00:12 - The Ransom Photo
1:01:51 - FBI Investigation and Arrest
1:11:57 - FBI Interviews and Confessions
1:15:19 - Samantha Koenig Case Update
1:15:49 - Potential Additional Cases
1:28:03 - Keyes' Final Days
1:30:16 - The Mysterious Drawing
1:30:40 - Keyes' Final Message
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Podcast reviews
Read The Murder Men podcast reviews
Taterzzzz3227 2026/11/09
Not for information
Johnny says he knows WA state well and then pronounces every town wrong but with such confidence. And that’s how the rest of it goes too
fromteeg 2026/11/05
I like it
I like it a lot
Deeznutz775 2026/10/27
Deez putos
Love these guys ol plugs McGee has a much better solo show but Johnnys is ummm ok if ur into sub par interviewing
Poison deeds 2026/10/08
Keep Going I’m Almost Finished
Love hearing Matt & Johnny converse with each other. Love dark humor. Love true crime. ❤️❤️❤️ don’t listen if you’re soft or a Karen
Sky g. D 2026/10/07
Its a commentary show
There is nothing new about this podcast. They are giving commentary on you tube videos that already have commentary. There are some funny moments but ...
MichaelZAlex 2026/09/24
Disappointed
Sounded interesting at first but there is no research done on these cases.
MissMelissaMoney 2026/09/16
:)
Just started listening and I’m hooked. Don’t ever stop!
Jersey Girl in Vermont 2026/09/05
Terrible
I tried….
cindyw2510 2026/08/16
Superb!
If you want more women stop cursing so much and stop taking Gods name in vain. Otherwise great podcast. You two are awesome together. Keep up the grea...
J0kerA 2026/07/26
Great show
These guys take true crime to another level interweaving their own criminal experiences with jail time and overlaying it with the events they are disc...
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on The Murder Men relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.6908522
You Can Heal Your Life ™
Hay House

4.41164993
Extratime
Major League Soccer

4.8815227
ArtCurious Podcast
Jennifer Dasal/ArtCurious

4.9328581397
REAL AF with Andy Frisella
Andy Frisella

3.99071574
20/20
ABC News

4.91366715
The Learning Leader Show With Ryan Hawk
Ryan Hawk

4.92110505
the bossbabe podcast
Natalie Ellis

4.3387182001
The Megyn Kelly Show
SiriusXM

4.947999419
The Shawn Ryan Show
Shawn Ryan

4.5185359
Who, When, Wow!
Tinkercast | Wondery