Advertise on podcast: Two Girls, One Haircut

Have you ever been so excited for Halloween that you planned all the spooky festivities, bought way too much candy, and then realized you're already mentally decorating for Christmas? Yeah... us too. It's the Two Girls One Haircut Season 1 Finale, and Jessie and Kiki are going out with a scream! We're celebrating Halloween with horror movie hypotheticals, childhood nostalgia, questionable survival instincts, neighborhood grievances, and a shocking amount of hostility toward Tootsie Rolls. Because nothing says Halloween like two sisters who love spooky season but are also considering putting up their Christmas decorations on November 1st. This week, Binkie joins us for some truly unhinged Halloween Would You Rather questions, we revisit the trick-or-treating glory days of the '80s and '90s, and we discover that surviving a horror movie might actually be easier than surviving another Halloween in Kiki's neighborhood. 🎃 In this episode: 🔪 Final Girl Energy (or Lack Thereof): Michael Myers vs. Ghostface, Freddy Krueger vs. Pennywise, haunted hotels, creepy basements, and which sister is absolutely sacrificing the other to survive. 🏚️ Neighborhood Nightmares: Rogue trick-or-treaters, unauthorized backyard traffic, inflatable bounce houses, and why Halloween might finally turn us into the old ladies yelling, "GET OFF MY LAWN!" 🍬 The Great Halloween Candy Debate: Candy corn defenders, Tootsie Roll haters, full-size candy bar legends, and why handing out raisins should be a criminal offense. 💰 The Price Is Fright: Binkie tests our knowledge of classic Halloween candy prices, from penny candy to modern-day inflation. Spoiler alert: We're apparently old AND broke. 👻 Halloween Nostalgia & Real-Life Scares: Homemade costumes, terrifying babysitting experiences, strangers at the door, haunted houses, and the childhood Halloween memories that probably explain a lot about us. 🕷️ Decorations, Drama & Questionable Taste: Twelve-foot skeletons, inflatable everything, couples costumes, and our firm belief that your Halloween decorations should have a theme. Whether you're a horror movie fanatic, a Halloween nostalgia junkie, someone who starts decorating for Christmas before the pumpkins are rotten, or just here for two sisters arguing about things that absolutely do not matter, this one's for you. One season. Too many opinions. Zero regrets. (Okay, maybe a few.) 💜 And don't worry—we're not disappearing forever! We're coming back with a special holiday episode in December, and Season 2 officially kicks off March 10, 2027! Until then, catch up on your favorite episodes, share us with your friends, and follow along for updates, new merch, and whatever trouble we get into during the break. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday during our regular season! 🌙 Shop Ren Paper Co.: https://reynpaperco.com/ Check out the illustrated 2027 Lunar Calendar and use code TWOGIRLS20 for 20% off your order. The conversation doesn't stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today's episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, questionable opinions, and behind-the-scenes chaos. Happy Halloween, and thanks for surviving Season 1 with us! 🎃💜

Would you publicly call out a small business for refusing to sell you a $15,000 mechanical bird? Yeah... us too. This week on Behind the Pod, Jessie and Kiki are taking sides in Kelly Clarkson's bizarre Birdgate controversy, and somehow a discussion about celebrity privilege, customer service, and Pretty Woman turns into a full-blown sisterly disagreement. One of us is Team Kelly. The other thinks everyone needs to calm the hell down. And honestly? The bird might be the only innocent party. Eventually, we remember we're supposed to be discussing A Court of Frost and Starlight, Sarah J. Maas's ACOTAR holiday novella that gave us approximately 200 pages of winter solstice, questionable gift-giving, Feyre's paintings, and Nesta being an absolute delight. (That last part is sarcasm.) 🎙️ In this episode: 🐦 Kelly Clarkson's Birdgate: A $15,000 singing bird, a Brooklyn boutique, and whether being Pretty Woman'd is grounds for a public takedown. ❄️ ACOTAR's Unnecessary Christmas Special: Did A Court of Frost and Starlight actually need to exist, or did Sarah J. Maas just owe somebody a book? 🎨 Feyre's Motherfucking Paintings: An artistic obsession, homemade Christmas gifts, and the uncomfortable realization that Jessie might actually be Feyre. 🎁 Secret Santa in Prythian: Who gives the best gifts, who has the biggest budget, and why Cassian basically invented the iPod Shuffle. 🌙 Our First (Very Real) Sponsor: Ren Paper Co., a gorgeous illustrated lunar calendar, a minor entrepreneurial meltdown, and an urgent request for the coven to assemble. Whether you're here for the ACOTAR gossip, the celebrity drama, or just two sisters arguing over things that absolutely do not matter, this episode has something for you. Come for the bird. Stay for the books. Buy a calendar so Kiki doesn't spiral. 🌙 Shop Ren Paper Co.: Check out the illustrated 2027 Lunar Calendar and use code TWOGIRLS20 for 20% off your order. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn't stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today's episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for more laughs, questionable opinions, and behind-the-scenes chaos.

Have you ever been so invested in a fictional relationship that you forgot you were supposed to be reading for fun? Yeah... us too. We've officially made it to A Court of Silver Flames, the fifth book in Sarah J. Maas's A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR) series, and apparently all it took was 10,000 stairs, 17 chili peppers worth of smut, and one extremely angry Archeron sister to push us over the edge. This week, Jessie and Kiki are officially Team Nesta. We're talking about why Nesta might be the most relatable character in Prythian, why Rhysand has gone from dreamy High Lord to a walking red flag, and why everyone in the Inner Circle suddenly seems to have forgotten how trauma works. And because we can't leave well enough alone, we're getting into Cassian's questionable relationship decisions, the Valkyrie girl gang, Feyre's pregnancy drama, and that juicy Azriel bonus chapter that has us questioning everything about Elain, Gwyn, and the mating bond. Oh, and somewhere along the way, we discuss an escaped neighborhood emu, magical swords named Bitch Please, and whether there's actually such a thing as too much fantasy smut. Spoiler alert: apparently there is. In this episode: 🔥 Team Nesta Forever: Trauma, healing, female friendships, and why everybody needs to leave this woman alone. 🚩 Rhysand's Red Flag Era: Secret pregnancies, controlling behavior, and the High Lord who needs to mind his business. 🌶️ Cassian, Smut & Stairmaster: The romance, the excessive spice, and approximately 10,000 unnecessary steps. ⚔️ The Valkyrie Girl Gang: Gwyn, Emerie, friendship bracelets, and the sleepover we desperately want an invitation to. 🦇 The Azriel Bonus Chapter: Elain versus Gwyn, Rhysand's spectacular cockblocking, and our predictions for who ends up with whom. 💀 That Ending, Though: Magical artifacts, questionable sacrifices, and why nobody in Prythian can seem to stay dead. Whether you're a hardcore ACOTAR fan, a Nesta apologist, an Azriel enthusiast, or someone who just wants to know why everybody is so damn horny, there's a seat for you at this very chaotic book club. Because apparently the only thing more exhausting than climbing 10,000 stairs is dealing with the Inner Circle. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn't stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today's episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and sisterly chaos!

Have you ever watched the news and thought, “Surely we can't get any more ridiculous than this”? Yeah... us too. This week on Behind the Pod, Jessie and Kiki are picking up where our Netflix The Widower discussion left off, except somehow we've gone from six suspicious marriages to the death penalty, botched executions, hurricane hysteria, and the very questionable decisions people make when bad weather rolls into town. We're diving into the shocking case of Christa Pike, the Tennessee death row inmate who survived a lethal injection, and asking some pretty uncomfortable questions about capital punishment, the justice system, and whether the government should be in the business of executing anyone. Things get even more disturbing when we discuss plans to broadcast a military execution. But don't worry, we still find time for our usual nonsense. There's a 1990s Michael Keaton thriller, a passionate argument about why people buy milk and bread before a storm, and an entire neighborhood that apparently values its giant Halloween skeletons more than basic hurricane preparedness. And then we have some news. After more than 60 episodes, we're getting ready to wrap up Season One of Two Girls One Haircut. Before anybody panics, WE ARE NOT BREAKING UP. We're just taking a little time to work behind the scenes, dream up what's next, and figure out how to make this little podcast of ours even better. We're talking future plans, new ideas, a holiday special, and why sometimes you have to step away from the microphone to make something bigger. In this episode: 💀 Death Row Gets Complicated — Christa Pike's botched execution and our very strong opinions about capital punishment. ⚖️ When Justice Goes Too Far — The controversy over public executions and the uncomfortable questions nobody wants to answer. 🎬 A Little 90s Nostalgia — Michael Keaton, Pacific Heights, and why men in scary movies make terrible decisions. 🌪️ Hurricane Prep for Idiots — Empty bread shelves, perfectly untouched Halloween decorations, and the great French toast conspiracy. 🎃 The Skeletons Are Not Safe — Why your 15-foot Halloween decorations might become your neighbor's problem. 🎙️ It's Not You, It's Us — Our big Season One announcement, what's coming next, and why this is definitely not goodbye. Whether you're here for the true crime, the unfiltered opinions, the unnecessary tangents, or just to hear two sisters argue about absolutely everything, we've got plenty to talk about. Because apparently the world is getting crazier, hurricane season is getting weirder, and even your favorite podcast hosts occasionally need a vacation. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn't stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today's episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, questionable opinions, and sisterly chaos!

Have you ever looked at a couple and wondered, “How in the hell did THAT guy get someone to marry him?” Yeah... us too. But imagine finding out he managed to do it SIX TIMES. And four of those wives are dead. This week on Two Girls One Haircut, Jessie and Kiki are diving into Netflix's true crime documentary The Widower: Till Death Do Us Part, featuring Thomas Randolph, the so-called Black Widower whose marriages seemed to come with a suspiciously high mortality rate and an even higher number of life insurance policies. We're talking questionable charm, mysterious deaths, murder-for-hire allegations, courtroom chaos, and one man's seemingly endless ability to convince women that he's husband material. Seriously, ladies. WHAT WAS THE APPEAL? But before we get to the actual murder investigation, we've got a few important marital questions of our own. Like what constitutes an unforgivable betrayal? Is marrying someone five times a red flag or proof that they believe in love? And how rich would a man have to be for you to overlook the mysterious deaths of his previous three wives? In this episode: 💍 Six Wives, Zero Common Sense? — The baffling romantic history of Thomas Randolph. 🚩 Red Flags or Just Beige? — When suspicious behavior should send you running. 💰 Till Death Do Us Part (and Pay Out) — Life insurance, suspicious deaths, and the financial side of a very deadly love story. 🔎 The Black Widower — Murder-for-hire allegations, undercover operations, and a legal saga that seemingly never ends. 💀 Marriage Is Hard. Murder Is Harder. — Our completely hypothetical discussions about marital grievances and questionable spouse behavior. 🤦‍♀️ And Because It's Us... — Health insurance hell, Batman's nipples, a husband's secret paper-towel collection, and a spectacular number of completely unnecessary tangents. Whether you're a true crime junkie, a Netflix documentary obsessive, happily married, or just wondering how some people manage to find six spouses when you can't even find one decent date, this episode is for you. Because apparently love is blind. And in Thomas Randolph's case, it might also need a really good life insurance policy. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn't stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today's episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, questionable opinions, and sisterly chaos!

Have you ever gone on a relaxing mountain getaway and immediately started planning how you’d defend yourself from a hypothetical murderer? Yeah... us too. This week’s Behind the Pod starts with a few true-crime updates and somehow ends with us debating whether Jessie can still defend the family now that she has apparently lost all of her butt strength. In between, we’re recapping our little mountain escape — including the Mexican restaurant baked potato covered in what appeared to be actual mold, the moment all three of us silently decided we could no longer eat anything on the table, and why sometimes the greatest comfort while traveling is simply knowing exactly what your Chick-fil-A is going to taste like. Then there’s the group of eight mysterious people at lunch who we spent an unreasonable amount of time trying to identify, our decision to actually walk over and ask them who they were, Mom’s concern that the enormous lawn guy might return to murder us, and the realization that Kiki may now be significantly easier to kidnap than she once was. And because apparently that wasn’t enough, we finish with a Make-A-Wish volunteer event, IKEA furniture, a white mini skirt, an analog clock, cursive handwriting, and several moments that made us question whether civilization is going to make it. In this episode, we get into: The latest Patrick Clancy and JP Miller case updatesWhy we packed a baseball bat for a mountain vacationThe baked potato we will never emotionally recover fromWhy sometimes a chain restaurant is exactly what you needOur completely unnecessary investigation into a group of strangers at Chick-fil-AMom deciding Jessie can no longer protect the familyThe great butt-muscle debateA Make-A-Wish furniture build that became a generational crisisAnd several conversations that probably should have stayed in the group chatIf you like your true crime updates mixed with family vacations, food disasters, irrational fears, people-watching and sisters arguing about things no one else would ever think to discuss, welcome back to Behind the Pod. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and things we probably should have kept in the group chat.

Have you ever loved a book series so much that you felt personally entitled to complain about it for an hour? Yeah... us too. This week, Jessie and Kiki are finally tackling A Court of Wings and Ruin, the third book in Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses series — and after taking approximately six painstakingly long months to finish it, we have some thoughts. We’re talking about the parts we loved, the parts that nearly broke us, and the approximately 4,000 characters and High Lords we were apparently expected to remember without a spreadsheet. Did Tamlin actually redeem himself? Did Rhysand really need to die just to come back five minutes later? Why is Nesta the nosiest person in Prythian? How did nobody realize Elain was having visions? And perhaps most importantly: why does absolutely no one in this world communicate before going into battle? In this episode, we ask the important questions: Is Tamlin redeemed… or did he just do one decent thing?Why did Rhysand have to die if we were just going to immediately undo it?How did Elain go from wandering around like a haunted Victorian child to stabbing the King of Hybern?Is Nesta secretly the nosiest woman in all of Prythian?Are Lucien and Elain ever going to stop making us uncomfortable?Do we ship Elain with Azriel, Mor… or possibly both?Why does Feyre insist on “yes, and”-ing every single dangerous situation?Could literally one person have communicated their battle plan beforehand?And after all of that… who in Prythian needs therapy the most? We also get into the final battle, Amren’s sacrifice, Mor’s reveal, Nesta and Cassian, Lucien and Elain, Tamlin’s questionable redemption arc, and our increasingly unhinged theories about where the ACOTAR series could go next. Whether you’ve read ACOTAR five times, just finished A Court of Wings and Ruin, or remember approximately three characters and a guy we keep calling Reese’s Pieces, you are among friends here. This is not your comprehensive ACOWAR literary analysis. This is two sisters who love the series enough to talk shit about it. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and things we probably should have kept in the group chat.

You know how sometimes you start researching something because you want answers... and somehow end up with even more questions than you started with? Welcome back to the Lindsay Clancy rabbit hole. After wrapping our main episode, Kiki apparently decided she had not sufficiently tortured herself with this case and came prepared with an entire list of things that still do not make sense to her. And Jessie, unfortunately, encouraged her. This week on Behind the Pod, we're digging further into the unanswered questions, disputed evidence, internet theories, strange details, and contradictions surrounding the Lindsay and Patrick Clancy case — while repeatedly reminding ourselves that a weird detail is not the same thing as evidence. We talk about everything from Patrick's behavior after the deaths and the questions surrounding the timeline to the DNA evidence, the medications, the infamous internet searches, the 60 Minutes interview, the “male voice,” and one particularly eerie comment Lindsay reportedly made from the hospital that stopped both of us in our tracks. And somewhere along the way, Kiki realizes she may need to get off True Crime TikTok for her own mental health. In this episode: The Patrick Clancy details Kiki still cannot make sense ofThe internet's biggest theories — and which ones don't hold upWhat the actual DNA and fingerprint evidence does and doesn't tell usWhy grainy surveillance footage might have created an entire conspiracy theoryLindsay Clancy's psychiatric treatment and conflicting accounts of her mental stateThe disputed “male voice”The hospital comment that genuinely creeped us outWhy unanswered questions do not automatically equal guiltThe uncomfortable ethics of consuming true crimeWhy we keep coming back to the failures surrounding Lindsay's mental healthcareAnd the sentence every person in this case apparently needed to hear: Read the room.Because beneath all the theories, TikToks, courtroom clips, and internet detective work is a devastating story about three children, a family destroyed, and a woman who had repeatedly sought help before everything went horribly wrong. And yes... we're officially banning Kiki from researching this case after midnight. Probably. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, opinions, and whatever rabbit hole we fall into next.

Have you ever watched one interview, thought, “Okay, now I understand,” and somehow ended up three hours later watching body-language experts, courtroom testimony, TikToks, conspiracy theories, and people arguing in the comments? Yeah... us too. This week, Jessie and Kiki are talking about the Lindsay Clancy case following Patrick Clancy’s recent 60 Minutes interview — and somehow, the more we watched, the more questions we had. We start with the case itself: Lindsay Clancy, the deaths of her three children, her reported mental health struggles after childbirth, the postpartum psychosis defense, and the mistrial that left the case unresolved. Then we get into the interview. Patrick’s grief. His decision to forgive Lindsay. His new marriage. The pregnancy announcement. The things 60 Minutes asked — and the things we really wish they had asked. And, of course, the internet’s reaction to all of it. But this conversation quickly becomes about something bigger: What is grief supposed to look like? How much should we judge someone’s behavior after unimaginable trauma? What does postpartum psychosis actually look like? And how easily can a few unanswered questions turn into an entire online conspiracy theory? Because Kiki has a confession to make: she fell straight into the rabbit hole. And now she has to eat a little crow. In this episode: The Lindsay Clancy case and September 2026 mistrialPatrick Clancy’s 60 Minutes interviewLindsay Clancy and the postpartum psychosis defenseThe questions we wish 60 Minutes had askedWhy Patrick Clancy’s behavior has become such a focus onlineGrief, trauma, memory, and why there is no “normal” reactionThe difference between asking legitimate questions and creating a conspiracy theoryHow True Crime TikTok can absolutely wreck your perception of a caseThe evidence, unanswered questions, and why Jessie keeps saying, “SHOW ME THE DATA”Plus: suspicious Google searches, survival fantasies, emergency purse supplies, sick cats, sick kids, and why apparently we are now “two judgmental bitches”Whether you’ve followed the Lindsay Clancy case from the beginning, just watched the 60 Minutes interview, or have absolutely no idea why your TikTok suddenly thinks you’re an amateur criminal investigator, come sit with us. We’re not promising answers. We do, however, have approximately 47 questions. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, opinions, and whatever rabbit hole we fall into next.

Have you ever lost enough weight that literally nothing in your closet fits anymore… but according to the BMI chart you’re still just “overweight”? Yeah... us too. This week’s Behind the Pod starts with Jessie nearly throwing up from laughing after Professor Binky turns one unfortunate burp-snort into his own personal remix. And somehow, it gets more chaotic from there. After realizing four pairs of jeans no longer fit, Jessie and Kiki are talking about the very real problem nobody warns you about when you lose a significant amount of weight: you have absolutely no idea what size you are anymore. Between the two of us — plus Dad — we’ve lost more than 250 pounds on GLP-1 medications, which means a lot has changed since the last time we talked about them. So we’re getting into it. We talk about the good, the bad, the expensive, and the deeply weird parts of GLP-1 life: changing sizes every five minutes, nausea, fatigue, skin sensitivity, acne showing up approximately 25 years late, finding the right dose, and realizing three people in the same family can have completely different experiences on the exact same type of medication. Then there’s the other side of it: insurance companies changing coverage, people suddenly losing access to medication that helped them lose 70, 80, or 100+ pounds, and the bizarre amount of judgment people still seem to have about how somebody else loses weight. Because apparently now we’ve moved from fat shaming to GLP-1 shaming. Cool. Love that for society. We also discuss the awkwardness of people noticing your weight loss, why Kiki's natural response to a compliment is apparently “please never speak to me again,” and the strange experience of looking at old pictures and realizing you genuinely forgot what you used to look like. In this episode: Losing more than 250 pounds between three family membersThe complete collapse of our wardrobesGLP-1 side effects nobody warned us aboutWhy different doses affect everyone differentlyWeight-loss compliments and why they make us deeply uncomfortableGLP-1 shamingInsurance companies making absolutely no senseThe stress of losing access to medicationMaintenance after major weight lossAnd Kiki officially becoming… just overweightProgress. Whether you’re on a GLP-1, thinking about one, supporting someone who is, or simply wondering why your closet suddenly contains 47 things you technically own but cannot wear… Welcome to the glamorous side of weight loss. Apparently the reward for losing 100 pounds is buying all your clothes again. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and behind-the-scenes chaos. And please, for Kiki’s sake, rate the podcast five stars before she personally checks the analytics.

Have you ever tried to force yourself into a cozy fall mood while it’s still 90 degrees outside, only to accidentally spend $69 on a meditation app you forgot you signed up for? Yeah... us too. This week, we are doing what any emotionally stable adults would do: aggressively manifesting fall. We’re kicking things off with a Fall This or That that immediately turns into arguments about Halloween vs. Thanksgiving, chili vs. soup, football, pumpkin spice, scary movies, oversized sweatshirts, and whether Practical Magic or Hocus Pocus deserves the ultimate fall crown. Then we get into Practical Magic 2, which Jessie loved, Kiki found aggressively mediocre, and somehow still managed to make both of us want Sandra Bullock’s face, Nicole Kidman’s hair, and the entire Practical Magic house. Speaking of that house... we have notes. We also discuss the absolute lawlessness of movie theaters, people who cough directly into the atmosphere, why Kiki is apparently willing to fight strangers during a movie, and the fact that Jessie managed to miss the funniest scene in Practical Magic 2 because she had to pee. Then things get slightly more existential. Kiki explains why September gives her a very specific sense of impending doom, Jessie basically says, “That sounds made up,” and Professor Binky attempts to diagnose the situation from across the room. Meanwhile, we’re decorating for fall, planning a girls’ trip to the mountains, debating how early is too early for Christmas, romanticizing apple orchards, preparing for pumpkin patches, and pretending Georgia is capable of giving us actual sweater weather. In this episode: Practical Magic 2Fall This or ThatThe great chili-is-soup debateWhy September feels vaguely threateningFall decorating without going full HalloweenScary movies, Harry Potter & cozy seasonPumpkin patches, apple orchards & our upcoming mountain tripMovie theater etiquette... or the lack thereofAnd the $69 Headspace subscription that derailed the entire episodeWhether you’re already wearing a sweatshirt in weather that absolutely does not require one, lighting a fall candle at noon, or staring outside wondering when the leaves are finally going to get the memo... Welcome to fall. Or, as we like to call it in Georgia: Hotumn. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and behind-the-scenes chaos.

We finished talking about the Idaho murders. Except… obviously we didn’t. This week on Behind the Pod, Jessie and Kiki are still stuck on all the things The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare left them thinking about — starting with the absolutely chaotic way information was communicated after the murders and the fact that some students learned what happened through a university notification before anyone on scene had even told them. Then there’s the decision to tear down the house before Bryan Kohberger ever went to trial, which sends both of us into another round of: WHO THOUGHT THIS WAS A GOOD IDEA? We also get into the question Kiki cannot let go of: Why that house? Why those students? Was someone specifically targeted? And does knowing “why” actually give a family any real closure? From there, the conversation somehow turns into whether either of us should ever be allowed on a murder jury, reasonable doubt, how documentaries can completely change the story depending on what they show you, and why Kiki would apparently spend the rest of her life personally searching hundreds of miles of Idaho countryside for missing evidence if Jessie were murdered. And because this is Behind the Pod, we eventually arrive at the most controversial question of the entire week: Why are people so obsessed with golden doodles? Yes. After an hour-plus discussing one of the most disturbing murder cases in recent history, this may be the take that gets us canceled. Because true crime is temporary. Doodle discourse is forever. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and sister chaos.

Have you ever watched a true crime documentary and thought, “I understand that trauma makes people do weird things... but I still have QUESTIONS”? Yeah... us too. This week, Jessie and Kiki are talking about Netflix’s The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare and the 2022 murders of University of Idaho students Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. And while this is a case most of us thought we already knew, the documentary left us with a whole new list of things to argue about. We walk through what happened that night, the incredibly short timeline of the murders, the evidence that eventually led investigators to Bryan Kohberger, and one of the most debated parts of the entire case: the surviving roommates and the hours that passed before anyone called 911. Kiki has questions. Jessie comes prepared with research on normalcy bias, freezing, dissociation, and other cases where people responded to terrifying situations in ways that seem completely irrational from the outside. And somehow we end up debating whether either of us would actually function during a crisis... or just barricade ourselves in a bedroom and hope for the best. Then we get into Kohberger himself: the knife sheath, DNA and genetic genealogy, his extremely questionable “stargazing” alibi, the lack of blood found in his car, his criminology background, his guilty plea, and the biggest unanswered question of all — why these four students? In this episode: • Netflix’s The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare • Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle & Ethan Chapin • Bryan Kohberger and the evidence against him • The surviving roommates and the eight-hour delay • Fight, flight, freeze and normalcy bias • DNA, 23andMe and genetic genealogy • The knife sheath and Kohberger’s alleged movements that night • Why we still don’t know who — if anyone — was originally targeted • The families’ search for answers • College roommates, absurdly fancy dorm rooms and why ours definitely did NOT look like that • Why Kiki’s DNA is apparently going to get Jessie arrested someday • And our promise to create Reddit accounts and avenge one another if necessary Whether you followed this case from the beginning, just watched the Netflix documentary, or somehow managed to avoid falling into the Idaho murders rabbit hole until now, come sit with us while we unpack the facts, the unanswered questions, and the psychology behind the parts of this case that are so difficult to understand. Because sometimes the scariest part of true crime isn’t just what happened. It’s realizing that none of us actually knows how we’d react if it happened to us. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and sister chaos.

Have you ever finished a true-crime documentary, kept talking about it for another hour, and somehow ended up questioning organized religion, the legal system, church governance, marriage, infidelity, social media—and whether you’ve officially become one of those people on the internet discussing somebody else’s tragedy? Yeah... us too. We’re back Behind the Pod because apparently one episode was NOT enough to unpack Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s Wife and the heartbreaking story of Mica Miller. This time, Jessie and Kiki dig into all the things we couldn’t stop thinking about after the main episode: JP Miller’s behavior after Mica’s death, the affairs, the people around him who seemingly knew what was happening, and the church leadership that was given opportunities to intervene—and didn’t. Which leads us to a much bigger question: when everyone sees the red flags, who is responsible for doing something about them? We get into the frustrating difference between something being morally wrong and actually being criminally prosecutable, whether someone can—or should—be held responsible when harassment and coercive control contribute to another person’s death, and why Mica documenting what was happening still wasn’t enough to protect her. Then, naturally, we take a hard left into church politics. Kiki breaks down why the structure of an independent, non-denominational church can look very different from denominations with outside governing bodies, Jessie questions what happens when the person behind the pulpit essentially answers to no one, and we both wonder how church elders can be presented with serious concerns and decide that protecting the institution is more important than confronting the person leading it. And somewhere in the middle of all of this, we have a horrifying realization: Are we the true-crime internet people now? Because watching a documentary criticize YouTubers, TikTokers, and strangers online for dissecting Mica’s case while literally recording a podcast about Mica’s case created a level of self-awareness we were not emotionally prepared for. In this episode: Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s WifeThe church elders and questions of accountabilityJP’s affairs and the people who allegedly knew about themCoercive control, harassment, and the limits of the legal systemWhether someone can be held responsible for contributing to another person’s suicideThe difference between criminal and civil liabilityOrganized religion vs. faith and spiritualityWhat happens when religious leaders have very little outside oversightJP’s extremely uncomfortable sermons about sex, lust, and marriageAnd the moment we realize we may have become exactly the kind of true-crime commentators we complain about Whether you watched Death of the Pastor’s Wife, followed the Mica Miller case before the Netflix documentary, have complicated feelings about organized religion, or simply enjoy listening to two sisters put on imaginary law degrees and argue about things they are absolutely not qualified to prosecute—this Behind the Pod is for you. Because sometimes the biggest question isn’t whether people knew something was wrong... It’s why nobody stopped it. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and behind-the-scenes chaos.

This week, Jessie and Kiki dive into Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s Wife, the story of Mica Miller, her marriage to pastor John-Paul “JP” Miller, and the disturbing events leading up to her death. Mica entered JP’s world as a teenager, and over the years he became her pastor, mentor, employer, and eventually husband. We talk about the enormous power imbalance at the center of their relationship, allegations of controlling behavior and harassment, the role religion played in Mica’s identity, and why leaving may have felt far more complicated than simply walking away. We also get into JP’s uncomfortable sermons about sex and marriage, Mica’s bipolar diagnosis and how it was later used against her, faith-based therapy, shame, coercive control, and the question at the heart of the documentary: If someone doesn’t physically cause a death, can they still bear responsibility for helping push another person to the breaking point? In this episode: Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s WifeMica Miller and JP MillerGrooming and power dynamicsReligion, marriage, and controlMental health and Mica’s bipolar diagnosisAllegations of stalking and harassmentWhy “just leave” is rarely that simpleAnd, somehow, Dolly Parton, TikTok’s “unalived” vocabulary, and our usual completely unnecessary side quests Whether you already followed the Mica Miller case or discovered it through Netflix, this episode is about much more than one marriage. It’s about what happens when faith, shame, control, and identity become so tangled together that freedom starts to feel impossible. And we’re not done — the conversation continues Friday on Behind the Pod. New episodes every Wednesday with Behind the Pod every Friday! The conversation doesn’t stop here! Head over to our website for show notes, bonus content, recommendations, and all the links from today’s episode. Then join our growing community on social media @TwoGirlsOneHaircut for even more laughs, hot takes, and behind-the-scenes chaos.