Advertise on podcast: Sincerely Supernatural Podcast

In the 1970s, reports of mysterious cattle mutilations in eastern Montana raised disturbing questions. But what if the cattle weren't the only unexplained phenomenon in the region?This week on Sincerely Supernatural, I'm joined by my brother, who has extensive knowledge of the cattle mutilation reports from eastern Montana. We dig into the strange circumstances surrounding these cases and explore reports of UFO sightings and Bigfoot encounters in the same area during the same time.But the conversation takes an even darker turn.Could these events have a biblical connection? We examine the possibility that the fallen angels described in Genesis 6:4 were attempting to create hybrids—and consider a disturbing theory that cattle may have been targeted for their DNA.We also discuss other explanations people have proposed for cattle mutilations and the possibility that seemingly separate mysteries could be connected.Are we looking at unrelated paranormal encounters—or pieces of a much bigger mystery?Join us as we investigate the reports, explore the theories, and look at these strange events through a biblical lens.Show Links:Book: Mystery Stalks the Prairie by Keith Wolverton - Movie: Endangered Species Subscribe to Sincerely Supernatural for more discussions about unexplained encounters, UFOs, cryptids, demonic activity, and the mysteries that challenge our understanding of the world.Have a strange experience or a story you'd like to share? Email us at [email protected].#CattleMutilations #UFO #FallenAngelsSincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Watch us on YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

What if the remains of Noah’s Ark really are sitting in the mountains of Turkey?A recent re-discovery has once again brought the controversial Durupınar formation into the spotlight. But this story goes back much further than the latest reports. In 1959, a Turkish airline pilot photographed a strange formation from the air—and nearly two decades later, Ron Wyatt claimed he had identified it as the remains of Noah’s Ark.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we dig into the history behind the discovery, the aerial photograph, the reported dimensions of the formation, and why some researchers believe it could match the biblical account of the Ark.We also get into one of the bigger questions surrounding the story: If this really is Noah's Ark, what would that mean?Noah's Ark Links:Jonathon Gray Ark presentationJonathon Gray Ararat Valley PresentationSincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠Youtube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we're reading more true paranormal stories submitted by our listeners and viewers— and these encounters get seriously unsettling.A Hat Man appears in someone's shower.Something starts knocking from inside the walls.A camper hears trees being pushed over in the woods by something that shouldn't be there.A dark figure stands outside a kitchen window, watching.And in one of the creepiest encounters, someone hears a voice whisper their name from inside a closet.Are these encounters explainable, or are some things harder to dismiss?We'll walk through each story and discuss what may have happenedSincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

In 1975, Travis Walton disappeared in the Arizona wilderness after his coworkers said they witnessed him being struck by a beam of light from a strange object.He wouldn't be seen again for five days.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we break down the infamous Travis Walton abduction story—from the strange object witnessed by the logging crew, to Walton's disappearance, his eventual return, and the extraordinary account he gave of what happened to him.Was Travis Walton telling the truth? Was there another explanation? And what should we make of the evidence surrounding one of the most famous alleged UFO abduction cases in history?Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

My wife had just gone to bed when she saw something in her bedroom that she still can't explain.A dark figure known as the Hat Man appeared in the room as she was trying to fall asleep.Was it a paranormal encounter? A nightmare? Sleep paralysis? Or something else entirely?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, I sit down with my wife and talk about what she experienced, what the Hat Man phenomenon might have to do with sleep, and why so many people report seeing frightening figures while falling asleep or waking up.We also dive into nightmares, sleep paralysis, shadow people, and strange experiences that happen in that unsettling space between being awake and asleep.And the biggest question: Why does the Hat Man keep showing up in people's bedrooms?Listen to the story and decide for yourself.Today's Links:The Shadow Man Twilight Zone Episode: https://youtu.be/sD2KNFCrOMc?si=htSwHvX4aLzs7PcnSincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

In this episode we're reading stories submitted by our listeners and viewers—and one of them involves a haunting that kept getting harder to explain.A man began having strange encounters at a friend's house. On multiple occasions, he heard what sounded like something stomping up the basement stairs. Then the basement door would suddenly fly open.But that wasn't the only thing happening. At other times, he heard strange pitter-patter footsteps moving across the basement floor, almost like children running around barefoot.What was happening in that basement?We'll get into that story, along with several other listener and viewer encounters that may leave you questioning what could be happening in places where nobody should be.#ghost #paranormal #ghoststory Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

There is a 911 call, police body-camera footage, security footage, videos from the area, reports of a fireball in the sky, and a strange circular mark reportedly found in the family's backyard. Angel Kenmore described the beings as having grayish-green skin, unusually long limbs, huge eyes, and large mouths. But one detail is especially disturbing: when Angel made eye contact with one of the creatures, he said he became completely paralyzed—almost like sleep paralysis. Then things got even stranger.The family reported hearing footsteps on the roof, whispering coming from the backyard, and eventually a scream after they began praying. Was this a UFO encounter? Something interdimensional? A misidentified event? Or something far stranger? In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we break down the 2023 Las Vegas encounter, the evidence surrounding it, the infamous 911 call, and what Angel and his family say they experienced that night. Today's Links: Angel's video explanation containing all other videos Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

The Giant of Kandahar is one of the strangest stories to emerge from the war in Afghanistan. According to the account, a U.S. military unit encountered a massive red-haired giant in a remote cave—and it took sustained gunfire to bring it down.But is the story true?In this episode, we break down the story of the alleged Kandahar Giant, the military personnel who reportedly encountered it, the claims surrounding its removal from Afghanistan, and the accounts that surfaced years later.Then we take a deeper look at something even stranger: the connection between the Kandahar Giant and ancient stories of giants, the Nephilim, the Rephaim, and the mysterious six-fingered giant described in 2 Samuel 21.Could these stories be completely unrelated legends—or is there something older hiding behind them?Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

What if the person you see isn't really the person you think it is?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read some of the creepiest viewer-submitted paranormal stories we've received — including a terrifying encounter with a possible mimic in the woods, a mysterious woman who appeared outside a home and later inside it, a frightening sleep paralysis experience involving a dark shadow figure, and a terrifying Goatman encounter from childhood.Are these experiences ghosts, mimics, shadow people, cryptids, or something else entirely?You decide.#Paranormal #Mimic #GhostStories #SincerelySupernatural #TrueScaryStories #SleepParalysis #Goatman #shadowpeople Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

Roswell didn't end with the crash.In Part 2, we examine the eyewitnesses whose stories never changed—including Glenn Dennis, Jesse Marcel Jr., Frankie Rowe, Sheriff George Wilcox, and Lt. Col. Philip Corso. Why did so many witnesses describe the same strange beings? Why were people allegedly threatened into silence? And could the aftermath of Roswell have influenced the rapid technological advances that followed?From military intimidation and alleged recovered bodies to Area 51, fiber optics, integrated circuits, and one of the most controversial theories surrounding the Roswell Incident, this episode explores the evidence, the testimony, and what it could mean from a biblical worldview.Whether you're a skeptic or a believer, this conversation asks one question:What really happened after Roswell?Be sure to watch Part 1 before diving into this episode.This episode's Links:Frankie Rowe InterviewGlenn Dennis InterviewThe Day After Roswell bookSincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on ⁠YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

On July 8, 1947, the U.S. Army announced it had recovered a "flying disc" near Roswell, New Mexico. Just hours later, the story changed.In this episode, we reconstruct the events of the Roswell Incident day by day—from Mac Brazel's discovery of mysterious debris, to eyewitness reports, Jesse Marcel's investigation, the famous press release, and the military's sudden weather balloon explanation.Was Roswell simply a misunderstood military project, or did something extraordinary happen in the New Mexico desert?This is Part 1 of our investigation into one of history's most famous UFO cases.In Part 2, we'll examine the eyewitness testimony, Project Mogul, the alleged alien bodies, and what happened after the military took control of the scene.If you enjoy well-researched investigations into UFOs, Bigfoot, paranormal events, and unexplained mysteries from a biblical perspective, subscribe for new episodes every week.What do you think happened at Roswell? Let us know in the comments. Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more! Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show. Find us on ⁠Spotify and Apple Podcasts! Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by: THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

A late-night drive past Moore's Creek Battlefield takes a terrifying turn when a man spots what appears to be a bloody soldier standing beside the road. Moments later, something unseen leaps into the bed of his truck. Was it the ghost of a fallen soldier? A terrifying cryptid? Or something far stranger lurking around one of North Carolina's most historic battlefields? Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read true stories sent in by listeners from across the country. From ghostly apparitions and shadow people to unexplained creatures, strange lights, and terrifying encounters in the middle of the night, these firsthand experiences left us with more questions than answers.Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ c152 Soundstripe

Two fishermen. One river. Two terrifying encounters.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we investigate two eyewitness reports from New Jersey's Musconetcong River involving a mysterious humanoid creature with the head of a praying mantis.Both witnesses describe an eerie atmosphere, intense eye contact, and something that shouldn't have been possible—including a creature that appeared to cloak itself and disappear.Could these encounters be evidence of an undiscovered cryptid... or do they point toward something far stranger?Episode Links:Mantis man paintingMars and Devon Island Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ Soundstripe

In 1955, two families in rural Kentucky claimed their farmhouse was surrounded by strange, glowing creatures unlike anything they had ever seen. What began as a reported UFO sighting quickly became one of the most famous—and bizarre—encounters in American paranormal history.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we explore the Kelly-Hopkinsville Goblin encounter, the eyewitness testimony, the mysterious creatures, and the terrifying events that unfolded throughout the night.Was it a misunderstanding, a close encounter, or something far stranger? Watch and decide for yourself.#HopkinsvilleGoblins #KellyHopkinsville #UFO #Aliens #Paranormal #Cryptids #SincerelySupernaturalShow Links:Drawings and PhotosKnee High Mischief Trailer Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more!Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to ⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠ and let us know if you'd like your story shared on the show.Find us on YouTube!Sincerely Supernatural is written and produced by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Logo and graphic design by Seth and Hudson Evanoff. Sound design by Seth Evanoff. Music by:THRLL ‪@thrll‬ Karl Kasey ‪@WhiteBatAudio‬ Soundstripe