Advertise on podcast: Evan & Tiki

J.J. McCarthy is getting his shot with the Giants, but could his success become a nightmare for the Minnesota Vikings? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash revisit their original predictions for when McCarthy would make his first start, with Shaun coming closest to getting it right. But the bigger question is whether Minnesota gave up on its former first-round pick too quickly and whether getting traded was exactly the wake-up call McCarthy needed.

The Giants' quarterback controversy is heating up as fans debate whether John Harbaugh made the right call benching Jameis Winston for J.J. McCarthy! Evan Roberts questions how Harbaugh handled the announcement inside the locker room, while Tiki Barber explains why the decision might not be as dramatic as it seems. With the Giants sitting in first place, is Harbaugh making a brilliant proactive move or risking a winning formula?

John Harbaugh is rolling the dice on J.J. McCarthy, and the first-place Giants are putting their division lead on the line! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber originally preferred Jameis Winston, but both admit McCarthy brings an exciting unknown to an offense desperately searching for answers. Can his mobility revive one of the NFL's worst rushing attacks, or is Harbaugh taking an unnecessary risk with a team trying to win now?

We aired Hal Steinbrenner, Brian Cashman, and Aaron Boone's end of year press conferences. React to Knicks banner night, and the Giants reportedly name a new starting quarterback.

The Knicks raised their championship banner, received their rings, and then immediately lost their season opener to the 76ers. But Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber aren't sounding the alarm. Evan, a proud Knicks hater, admits the loss didn't even bring him joy because the celebration was so much bigger than the game. With OG Anunoby, Mikal Bridges, and Karl-Anthony Towns struggling, the question becomes how long Knicks fans can ride the championship high before another loss actually starts to hurt. The emotional ceremony also leads Evan to a heartbreaking realization about Joe Namath and the Jets' fading connection to their last Super Bowl championship. Plus, Tiki explains why the Knicks may have been emotionally drained, the guys debate when a championship hangover becomes a legitimate concern, and Josh Hart's brutally sarcastic comments about the Knicks' 0-1 start raise questions about the urgency needed to defend their title.

Hal Steinbrenner is pointing the finger at the Yankees' offense after another disappointing October, but Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone aren't taking the fall. Steinbrenner makes it clear that the players deserve most of the blame for the team's postseason collapse, while confirming Cashman's extension and defending his decision to stick with Boone. With another championship opportunity wasted, is Yankees ownership holding the right people accountable? Evan and Tiki break down the biggest takeaways from Steinbrenner and Cashman's press conference, including Aaron Judge's health, Giancarlo Stanton's uncertain role, and the organization's plans for 2027. Plus, Boone faces tough questions about the Yankees' inability to beat elite postseason opponents, pushes back against Anthony Rizzo's criticism, and admits he still hasn't proven himself at the highest level.

Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman face the media, and their answers leave plenty for Yankees fans to be furious about. Steinbrenner puts the blame on the players while defending Cashman and Aaron Boone, but Evan Roberts isn't buying the excuses. From Hal's response to Aaron Judge's demand to go all in to Cashman's bizarre claim that Giancarlo Stanton finished the season healthy, Evan and Tiki Barber dissect a frustrating day for the Yankees. Evan also unloads on Boone's disastrous postseason lineup decision and questions why nobody in the organization is being held accountable. Meanwhile, the Giants are reportedly turning to J.J. McCarthy as their starting quarterback against Houston. Tiki warns that the move could backfire against the Texans' pass rush, especially with the Giants still fighting for a playoff spot. Plus, callers weigh in on the Yankees' leadership, and Jalen Brunson delivers a memorable reminder about never leaving games early.

Evan and Tiki analyze the recent press conference where Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman addressed the Yankees' disappointing season. They also discuss the reported quarterback change for the Giants, moving from Jameis Winston to J.J. McCarthy. Additionally, the conversation touches on Garrett Wilson's unexpected fandom for the Brooklyn Nets and the Knicks' opening night loss. (00:01:55) Yankee Presser Reaction (00:05:15) Giants Quarterback Change (00:09:25) Yankee Fan Callers (00:14:55) Yankees Strikeout Problems (00:18:30) Salary Cap Discussion (00:22:50) Analytics vs Instincts (00:26:55) Garrett Wilson Nets Fan (00:32:45) Knicks Season Opener (00:36:25) Small Market Comparisons

Hal Steinbrenner is facing tough questions about the Yankees' future, and his response isn't sitting well with everyone. With Brian Cashman reportedly receiving a new contract despite another season without a championship, frustrated Yankees fans are questioning whether ownership is too comfortable with the status quo. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber take aim at Steinbrenner's reluctance to address a potential MLB lockout and the proposed salary cap, including one reporter's pointed question about how a cap would actually benefit Yankees fans. Plus, a passionate caller rips the Yankees' reliance on analytics, sparking a debate about whether the numbers are really to blame for their postseason failures. The conversation also shifts to the Giants' offensive struggles without Jaxson Dart and why their inability to stay ahead of the chains continues to haunt them. And Garrett Wilson earns some unexpected love from Evan after revealing his Brooklyn Nets fandom!

Hal Steinbrenner's defense of Brian Cashman has Yankees fans fired up, and Evan Roberts isn't buying the lack of accountability. How can Steinbrenner blame the players while insisting the man who assembled the roster continues to do a great job? Evan and Tiki Barber break down the contradictions from the Yankees' press conference, the franchise's repeated failures, and why the same approach keeps producing disappointing results. Plus, the Yankees' strikeout-heavy lineup comes under fire as Evan argues that Cashman needs to prioritize hitters who put the ball in play. The conversation also shifts to the Giants, where a reported quarterback change from Jameis Winston to J.J. McCarthy raises questions about Winston's struggles, the team's predictable running game, and what John Harbaugh hopes to accomplish with a new starter.

The Giants are reportedly making the switch to J.J. McCarthy, and Tiki Barber thinks John Harbaugh might be making a major mistake. With the Giants sitting at 3-2-1 and firmly in the playoff race, is throwing McCarthy into the fire against the Texans' dangerous pass rush really the smartest move? Tiki explains why Houston's defense could expose the young quarterback's inexperience and why Jameis Winston might still give the Giants their best chance to win. Evan Roberts and Tiki debate the timing of the quarterback change, McCarthy's thrilling comeback against the Saints, and whether the Giants should have waited until after the bye week. With a division title suddenly within reach, the Giants are taking a gamble that could have major consequences for their season.

Aaron Boone faces a brutal line of questioning about the Yankees' continued postseason failures, and even he admits he hasn't proven himself at the highest level. After another October disappointment, Boone is challenged on why his teams consistently struggle against elite competition and whether he's capable of finally delivering a championship. His response? The Yankees still have to prove they can get over the hump. Boone also pushes back against Anthony Rizzo's criticism of the organization's repeated failures, defends his leadership style and refusal to publicly embarrass players, and addresses the Yankees' offensive struggles. Plus, why he believes the Brewers and Rays have an athleticism advantage, whether the hitting staff needs changes, and how the Yankees plan to avoid another disappointing October in 2027.

Hal Steinbrenner is putting the blame squarely on the Yankees' players after another October disappointment, while Brian Cashman gets an extension and Aaron Boone appears safe. Despite spending more than $300 million on payroll, the Yankees still haven't delivered another championship, and Steinbrenner faces tough questions about why the same leadership continues to get opportunities. Is ownership holding the wrong people accountable?

Hal Steinbrenner is doubling down on Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone, and Yankees fans may not like what they're hearing! During a revealing postseason press conference, Steinbrenner defends his leadership group, blames the players for another disappointing October, and insists the Yankees had a championship-caliber roster. Meanwhile, Cashman confirms he's agreed to a new contract despite the team's continued failure to deliver another World Series title. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber listen as Steinbrenner and Cashman face tough questions about accountability, clubhouse culture, and criticism from Yankees legends CC Sabathia, Anthony Rizzo, and Joe Girardi. Steinbrenner also responds to Aaron Judge's call for ownership to go all in, refuses to embrace his father's public approach to holding players accountable, and explains why Boone isn't responsible for the team's postseason collapse. With the offense under fire and the same leadership remaining in place, the biggest question is whether the Yankees are truly willing to change or simply expecting different results.

The Knicks are officially defending champions, but how long will their championship glow protect them from criticism? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate when fans should start worrying about a potential championship hangover following their opening-night loss to the 76ers. With Josh Hart sarcastically calling the Knicks the worst team in the NBA, the guys examine when the celebration ends and the pressure to repeat begins.