Advertise on podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Rating

3.9

from

226 reviews

Description

The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle is sports talk with a pulse — loud, loose and unapologetically entertaining. Carton’s larger-than-life style and McMonigle’s no-nonsense perspective create a show that blends comedy, controversy and real debate. From Yankees and Mets drama to Giants, Jets, Knicks, Nets and whatever headline is dominating the day, nothing is too serious to laugh at or too big to challenge. Unfiltered and unpredictable, The Carton Show turns sports talk into an event.

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle podcast

Full Show: Steve Cohen Puts His Foot Down Over Mets Captain; Aaron Judge Thoughts On Brutal Winter

2026/02/17

Steve Cohens says the Mets will never anoint a captain; Robert Duvall RIP. All Star weekend was done rather well; However the Anthem was butchered. Steve Cohen owns one of two existing golden toilets. Does he actually use it? Tom Seaver's family selling off personal Mets items; Aaron Judge thoughts on brutal winter. Plus Carton claims to be the best free throw shooter in the building

Hour 1: Steve Cohen Says No Captain On His Watch!

2026/02/17

Steve Cohens says the Mets will never anoint a captain; Robert Duvall RIP

Hour 2: It Was Almost A Perfect Weekend for the NBA

2026/02/17

All Star weekend was done rather well; However the Anthem was butchered

Hour 3: Golden Toilet; Is It Art or Ego?

2026/02/17

Steve Cohen owns one of two existing golden toilets. Does he actually use it?

Hour 4: Aaron Judge Calls the Yankees Off-Season BRUTAL!

2026/02/17

Tom Seaver's family selling off personal Mets items; Aaron Judge thoughts on brutal winter. Plus Carton claims to be the best free throw shooter in the building

Aaron Judge BLASTS Yankees Offseason?! “BRUTAL” Comments Ignite Carton Show Debate

2026/02/16

Did Aaron Judge just call out the New York Yankees front office?! On this heated segment of the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over Judge’s explosive comments about the Yankees offseason.

Aaron Judge Speaks, Seaver Family STUNS Mets Fans, & Logan Paul Investment Chaos!

2026/02/16

This hour of the Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle covers EVERYTHING from heartbreaking news to heated sports debates and wild money talk.

Nick Bosa’s MOB Family?! Craig Carton Drops SHOCKING History, & Paul McCartney HOT DOG Showdown!

2026/02/16

This segment of the Carton Show goes completely off the rails and you won’t believe where it starts…

Craig & C-Mac GO OFF! Billionaire Spending, Pete Alonso Drama & The WILDEST Ice Cream Debate Ever

2026/02/16

Things spiral FAST on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bounce from serious Mets talk to absolute chaos.

Steve Cohen’s GOLDEN Toilet & Mets Spending Drama Gets WILD!

2026/02/16

Things got completely unhinged on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the biggest question in baseball…If Steve Cohen can spend like the Los Angeles Dodgers, why hasn’t he WON like them with the New York Mets?

Travis Kelce to the Giants?! Wild Rumors, Mets Secrets & Tyreek Hill Debate!

2026/02/16

A packed and unpredictable segment of the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a wild NFL rumor, Mets mystery drama, and even a heated movie debate.

Michael Jordan NASCAR Shock, Mets Money Questions & Wild Sports Weekend!

2026/02/16

A jam-packed opening segment of Carton Show on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a chaotic sports weekend!

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Derek Carr & QB Rumors

2026/02/15

Evan & Tiki discuss the possibility of Derek Carr as the Jets’ next quarterback. Plus, ranking the top five veteran QB choices (14:09); Carton trolls Patriots fans saying the Jets are better run (33:09); Boomer asks ChatGPT about the Jets QB situation (49:44) and discusses with Gio who the Jets best QB options are (59:04); Carton on his plan for the Jets (1:05:36).

Best of the Knicks on WFAN: Assessing the team at the break

2026/02/14

This week's Knicks highlights include praising the team's dismantling of the Sixers to enter the All-Star break on a high note. Plus, Evan and Tiki compare the Mike Brown Knicks to last year's group under Tom Thibodeau, and marvel at the fanbase invading Philadelphia for a road game.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Soto to LF, Lindor to the IL?

2026/02/14

Francisco Lindor is heading for hand surgery, and the Evan and Tiki crew debate if the star shortstop can be ready for Opening Day. Plus, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle wonder how long it will take Lindor to get his power stroke back, and more reactions to Juan Soto moving to left field.

Read The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle podcast reviews

3.9 out of 5

226 reviews

Kenny nyc 2025/11/21

Awesome

Great show great work as yellow cabbie that listens to all shows almost everyday mon-fri I’ve always loved the mid day show. And bt and sal are up the...

4️⃣1️⃣4️⃣ 2026/02/07

I HATE THIS CLOWN SHOW!

I wish Apple podcasts would stop suggesting this show!! I never want to hear it because I've heard enough of Craig Cartoon and Fatty McBarnacle is a Y...

Kicco d 2026/02/02

Thanks for the laughing muscles🤣🤣

Craig “Just leave it there” McGonagle “the difference between a candy bar and braille and I’m the bad guy” Started the show with a six pack now I got...

Grazsoo 2026/01/06

Complete garbage

Don’t waste your time on this. Typical Carton, thinking he knows everything, paired with a guy who doesn’t let anyone speak.

80'sVillager 2025/12/05

Bring on the . . .

Both especially Sal embodied that unfortunate combination of ignorance and arrogance to the very end. And just as you both snorted at the Mark Jackson...

Maggot Woolley Sengat 2025/10/17

Loud Talking Not Always Needed

I had the unpleasant experience of hearing Sal, in his normal octave, telling the audience that the Mets need an ace. His opinion is that you have to ...

Gipp715 2025/10/22

Rage bait

Overly emotional rage bait that no longer resonates with the fanbase. Just go away Sal

chop dml 2025/10/10

Chemistry

Love these two. If I can’t listen on WFAN I download the podcast. Pay no attention to naysayers. All the best fellas and thanks for keeping me enterta...

Tommie Aging 2025/06/07

College radio-level sports talk

Two barely competent dolts who demand perfection from pro players, coaches and management while being subpar at their own jobs. This is why ‘FAN hide...

The Melancholic 2025/05/01

Why?

Whose idea was it to air this?

check all reviews on apple podcasts