Advertise on podcast: Pretty Scary

Rating

★★★★☆

4.2

from

474 reviews

Description

True crime, conspiracy theories, ghosts, aliens, and things of that sort. Hosted by comics Adam Tod Brown, Kari Martin, and Cindy Aravena. Part of the Unpops Podcast Network! Current theme song courtesy of Sliceberg Slim: https://slicebergslim.bandcamp.com/ Theme song for episodes 1 - 210: "Under a Nightmare" by Pandacetamol - https://unpops.co/3NNigJO Creative Commons License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/

Unlock Pretty Scary podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details

Email contact information

Direct podcast contact details

Listeners

Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details

Podcast Insights

Social media

Check Pretty Scary social media presence

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from Pretty Scary podcast

The Lost Episodes - Operation Snow White

2026/10/27

n the first of a two-part joint op with the Conspiracy! The Show podcast, Adam welcomes comedians Hana Michels and Kym Kral to discuss a Scientology scheme to infiltrate the American government that worked way better than you’d expect. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Crush

2026/10/27

Adam and guest co-host Heather Marulli talk about the Itaewon Halloween crushing disaster by way of the Paramount+ documentary Crush Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - The Disappearance of Johnny Gosch

2026/10/27

Adam and guest co-hosts Andy Sell and Jessica Singer discuss the awfully strange disappearance of an Iowa paperboy in the 1980s. The CNN Article: https://www.cnn.com/interactive/2023/12/us/johnny-gosch-missing-iowa-boy-cec-cnnphotos/ Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - The Legend of Boggy Creek

2026/10/20

Adam and special guest co-host Olivia Haidar review the seminal 1972 "documentary" The Legend of Boggy Creek. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - The Blackout Experiments

2026/10/20

Adam and guest co-host Andy Sell review the 2016 documentary The Blackout Experiment, which covers the notorious "immersive horror experience" known as Blackout. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Do You Believe? Bigfoot, Ghosts, Atlantis, and More!

2026/10/20

Adam welcomes special guest Hana Michels for an unscripted chat about Bigfoot, ghosts, Atlantis, the Mothman and so much more! Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Phantom Rider

2026/10/20

Adam and guest co-host Olivia Haidar discuss the absolutely thrilling conclusion of the Sir No Face documentary trilogy, 2020's Phantom Rider. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Scream: The True Story

2026/10/13

Adam and Cindy discuss a documentary about Danny Rolling, aka the Gainesville Ripper, the killer who (very loosely) inspired the horror movie Scream Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Roommate: Not In My House

2026/10/13

Adam and special guest Kym Kral recap the season one finale of Investigation Discovery's Fear Thy Roommate Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Possessed Pets Pt. 2: Vincent and Nitro

2026/10/13

Adam and Kari recap the third and fourth episodes of Eli Roth Presents: My Possessed Pet Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Zak Bagans Wrote A Movie

2026/10/13

Adam and Kari review the Travel Channel film "Haunted Museum: 3 Ring Inferno." It's a horror movie written by Ghost Adventures host Zak Bagans! Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Joyce Carol Vincent

2026/10/06

Adam and Cindy review the documentary "Dreams of a Life", which tells the story of Joyce Carol Vincent, a 30-something British woman who went missing for three years inside her own apartment. The documentary: https://www.amazon.com/Dreams-Life-Zawe-Ashton/dp/B00B0I5TYS Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Neighbor: Feud On the Frontier

2026/10/06

Adam and Kari recap what IMDB claims is the highest rated episode ever of the Investigation Discovery series Fear Thy Neighbor. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Who Do You Believe? What The Sisters Saw

2026/10/06

Adam and Cindy recap an episode of the ABC show Who Do You Believe? This episode covers the murder of a man named Steven Beard, allegedly at the hands of his wife, Celeste. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

The Lost Episodes - Last Seen Walking

2026/10/06

Adam and Cindy discuss an episode of ABC's 20/20 about a cold case that proves our justice system is irreparably broken. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks

Podcast reviews

Read Pretty Scary podcast reviews

4.2 out of 5

474 reviews

★★★★★

Taterzzzz3227 2026/10/27

Please stop having guest hosts

This is the third time Kari and Caitlyn have Irish goodbye’d a podcast

★☆☆☆☆

akerney 2026/10/09

Too many side conversations

The hosts would go on side tangents that got too off topic for too long. It was hard to follow the story to the point I didn’t know what they were ta...

★★★★★

Silverkay24 2026/03/17

Same episodes?

I think these are all the same episode…

★★★★★

ButterSideDown 2024/12/11

I must know tho

Is Jeff still a non-believer of the paranormal? I loved hearing all of your voices together again. This show always puts a big smile on my face

★☆☆☆☆

itwasntmesir45 2024/06/07

No. Hosts are dolts who have no redeeming qualities. Hard Pass.

★★★★★

dank jammin learhL 2024/03/05

Great show

Adam always does great research and has guests who are entertaining and able to contribute to the topic being discussed.

★★★★★

tomnickles 2023/11/05

This is the best show

I started listening to this after I found Conspiracy the show. I love this show. I hope it goes on forever and ever. I started from the beginning so w...

★★★★★

Paisleylovesgooddogs 2023/05/25

Best overall network

This unpops network is my favorite thing in the world, right next to my two children. I can credit my chemical engineering degree to them, I like to l...

★★★★★

AlixDN 2023/03/12

Pretty scary (BOO!)

Love this pod, entertaining and well researched

★☆☆☆☆

Deadendgraphics 2023/01/23

Label it

If you think labeling is funny then this is the show for you.

check all reviews on apple podcasts