Advertise on podcast: Crime and Conjure

Throughout the 1970s, several people in North Carolina suddenly became violently ill before dying under what initially appeared to be unrelated circumstances. For years, no one realized there was a connection. But after one final death revealed arsenic, investigators began looking backward and discovered that the victims had more in common than anyone realized.

When we think of serial killers, we usually think of angry men, who grew up in terrible abusive households, harboring dark, sadistic fantasies that they eventually unleash on the innocent public. The case we have for you today, flies against that stereotype in every way. This killer unleashed a sudden violent rampage no one saw coming.

On a cold February morning in 1960, one of Colorado’s most prominent businessmen left his home for work. He never made it there. Hours later, his vehicle was found abandoned on a quiet bridge, still running, with the radio playing and no sign of him. At first, no one knew exactly what had happened. But the evidence left behind made one thing clear: whatever happened on that bridge was no accident.

Racism in America, especially the American south is a well known issue. Not just a historical issue, a modern day issue. The case we have for you today takes place in the 1980’s and is by no means unique, unfortunately. Like in this case, when the organizations designed to protect are corrupt, justice can be delayed until someone is willing to stand up and do the right thing.

When we think about serial killers, we often picture someone who stands out. Someone charismatic. Someone who commands attention the moment they walk into a room. But not every killer fits that image.Some spend their entire lives blending into the background. They're overlooked, underestimated, and forgotten almost as quickly as they're noticed. They work ordinary jobs, live in ordinary neighborhoods, and move through everyday life without anyone suspecting the darkness they're carrying.

Some cold cases feel impossible to solve. Whether due to lack of physical evidence, no reasonable suspects or deterioration over time. Then there are cases like this one, that likely could have been solved with some basic diligence and integrity on the part of the initial investigators. Unfortunately, the story investigators weaved took a more bizarre turn instead.

Today's case takes us to Cleveland, Ohio, during one of the darkest periods in American history. The Great Depression had left thousands without jobs, homes, or hope. It was in one of those forgotten places that a killer began hunting society's most vulnerable. Over four years, headless and dismembered victims were discovered across the city. This is the story of one of America's most infamous serial killers.

This case is a wild ride of death, experimentation, suspicious circumstances, government cover-ups, and one family’s refusal to believe the story they were told about their loved one. I’m sure they were told they were crazy, or called conspiracy nuts along the way, but they refused to stop digging. In the end, they helped expose one of the biggest American conspiracies we have ever seen.

Tonight's case begins inside a quiet East Texas home, where years of resentment, family conflict, and hidden grievances were quietly building behind closed doors. To the outside world, it looked like an ordinary family struggling through ordinary problems. But beneath the surface, frustrations were turning into plans, and plans were turning into something far more dangerous.

There are currently more than 26,000 active long-term missing person cases in the U.S. Approximately 40% of those are children and teenagers under the age 18. The most common circumstances that lead to long term missing children cases are endangered runaways and family abductions stemming from custody disputes. Those statistics are devastatingly high. While today’s case is included in those numbers, there is one unique aspect that sets it apart. The last person to see the victim alive, insists that bigfoot is to blame.

Some cases are terrifying because of the violence involved. Others are terrifying because of how long someone can hide in plain sight. Sometimes, the most dangerous people aren’t the ones drawing attention to themselves. They’re the ones who know how to blend in. The ones who move through everyday life unnoticed. This case is about someone who managed to do exactly that for years. Whose crimes stretched across the early 1980s, leaving families searching for answers while pieces of the truth remained buried beneath silence, fear and time.

We have all been through the idiodic teenage years fueled by hormones and a lack of real life experience. Most of us can look back and laugh at the poor decisions we made as angsty, insecure teens. Some let their underdeveloped brains lead them down a path with far more serious consequences. However, being young and stupid is no excuse to ignore the difference between right and wrong entirely, like the two young men in today's case did.

There are certain crimes where, once you know what happened, it feels obvious in hindsight. You can trace the warning signs, connect the dots, and point to the moment everything should have been questioned. This is not one of those cases because in this story, nothing looked urgent. Nothing felt immediate. There was no single moment where everything suddenly shifted. Instead, it unfolded slowly, in pieces, hidden inside routines that felt completely normal. And that’s what makes this case so unsettling, because by the time anyone realized something was wrong…it was too late.

As mothers, today's story is a mystery that keeps us up at night. It would take a truly horrifying event to cause us to leave our child alone on the side of the road. Likely nothing short of abduction or death could drag us away from our babies. I have no doubt that the young mother we are about to tell you about felt the same.

This case did not unfold in dark alleys or abandoned buildings. It didn’t involve forced entry, masked attackers, or dramatic crime scenes. Instead, it unfolded quietly, behind closed doors, in places meant to represent safety, dignity, and care... This is the story of how silence became a weapon, and how one of the most prolific serial killers in modern American history was allowed to operate in plain sight.