Advertise on podcast: Rothman & Ice

Happy Friday! You're in the office baby! It's Ohio State-Indiana Eve. Urban Meyer appeared on T-Bone and Tyvis to outline what OSU needs to do to secure the victory. We play Overs and Unders. Todd Monken is unbothered by the history involved in this upcoming matchup with the Ravens. We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Voice of the Hoosiers Don Fischer joins the show. And we Tell the Truth about Notre Dame's schedule and lock in our game picks.

Happy Thursday! We got a concerning injury report for the Buckeyes last night heading into the Hoosier game on Saturday. Does Shedeur Sanders signing an agent indicate that he wants out of Cleveland? We make our NFL Picks. The Guardians are going in Game 3 of the ALCS live while we're on the show. A Hall of Famer is set to become a free agent, and he gives some semi-revealing comments about it. What do the Buckeyes need to do offensively to beat Indiana on Saturday? Spencer Holbrook of Lettermen Row joins the show. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! Yesterday's investigation has been completed. We're inching closer to Saturday's big game with Indiana. Adam Schefter joins the show. We play Real or Fake: NFL edition (sorta). Jayden Daniels not knowing how much time was on the clock somehow created a debate about whether or not current athletes should be podcasting while playing. We do Tuesdays w/ Tyvis on a Wednesday. Tampa Bay took Game 2 of the ALCS. Rick Bowness raised the stakes for the Blue Jackets roster after last night's terrible loss. Zach Werenski joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! AR & Matty are out at The Schott for Buckeye Basketball Training Camp. We begin the show with Ryan Day and Julian Sayin taking the podium. We take a look at Indiana heading into this weekend's game. Former CBJ HC Brad Larsen joins the show to talk hockey. We play Fool's Paradise. John Mobley Jr. joins the desk. The Guardians took a 1-0 lead in the ALCS last night! Jake Diebler joins the desk. Austin Ward joins the show for Day Trippin'. And we perform a live investigation in Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! The Buckeyes took care of business against the Terps. Now that we've arrived at Indiana week, does it feel as big as we thought it'd feel in the preseason? Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. The Floor is Yours. Adam King joins the show for A-dumb's King-dumb. Jensen Lewis joins the show on short notice to talk Guardians in the ALCS. The Bengals won, and the Browns almost won. Ian Fitzsimmons hits with a double walk-off. And we fact check Ian's history intellect in Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! You're in the office baby! The news of Mike Ditka's passing breaks right before the show. Ryan Day makes Maryland sound like the Greatest Show on Turf. Stephen Means of Cleveland.com joins us in-studio. We play Overs and Unders. Joe Burrow clarifies some comments he made about the offense earlier in the week. We play Under Pressure and make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Browns and Jets go at it on Sunday. We wrap up our NFL Picks. Jeff Ermann of InsideMDSports joins the show. And we Tell the Truth about Guardians and White Sox.

Happy Thursday! A Hall of Famer turned his back on Cleveland, and this show is split on whether or not it was appropriate. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. We make our NFL picks. We talk Browns and Bengals. We give our NFL quarterly report. And we Tell the Truth about some of the newly proposed rules in Major League Baseball that would make the playoffs super interesting.

Happy Wednesday! You the people gave us your feedback on whether or not you think the Browns are going to the playoffs this year, and we react. Adam Schefter joins the show. Todd McShay gives an update on this 2027 QB class from the gods. Is Jeremiah Smith the best college football wide receiver ever? We play In or Out. Dane Sanzenbacher makes his way into the studio to give us more information about his encounter with Jeremiah Smith. We update our Super Bowl picks. Are the Guardians done? Damon Severson joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! We begin the show with Ryan Day and Luke Montgomery at the podium. Rothman recognizes that Ryan Day missed a golden opportunity to light the press conference on fire. Former CBJ HC Brad Larsen joins the show to talk hockey as we workshop name ideas for this weekly segment. We play Fool's Paradise. We do Tuesdays w/ Tyvis. We talk about Jeremiah Smith's draft stock. Bobby Carpenter joins us in-studio. We go Day Trippin' w/ Austin Ward. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! The Buckeyes beat the Hawkeyes in Iowa City. Jeremiah Smith is next level in case you didn't know. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. The Floor is Yours. The Bengals may not be who we thought they were. We do A-dumb's King-dumb. The NFL's officials are on trial. Brenden Deeg of The Score joins the show to talk NFL. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! You're barely in the office baby! The Browns are first place in the AFC North, WHAT?! Rodgers and McCarthy are already beefing. Stephen Means of Cleveland.com joins us in-studio to talk Buckeyes. We play Overs and Unders. The CBJ are undefeated! We play Under Pressure and make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. The Bengals have a big game coming up this weekend. We wrap up our NFL Picks from yesterday. Gerry DiNardo of BTN joins the show for Big Game Preview. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Thursday! It's a big day in Ohio sports with the Jackets opening their season at home against Buffalo at the same time the Browns are hosting the Steelers on Thursday Night Football. We make our NFL Picks. Urban Meyer is dead set on Jeremiah Smith winning the Heisman Trophy. Jensen Lewis returns with some MLB playoff Chin Music. And an adopted son meets his celebrity birth father in Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! Ben Roethlisberger insults the Bengals by comparing them to the Browns. Adam Schefter joins the show. What is the Blue Jackets leadership going to look like this year? The Browns and Steelers are just a couple of first place teams getting ready to square off! We find out who is and who isn't neighborly in In or Out. Ryan Roberts of A to Z Sports joins the show to talk CFB and NFL Draft prospects. We talk NFL. Zach Werenski joins the show for the season debut of Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! We begin the show with Ryan Day and Julian Sayin taking the podium, plus our reaction. Former CBJ HC Brad Larsen joins the show to talk Jackets and the Marchenko trade. We play Fool's Paradise. We do Tuesdays w/ Tyvis. The Bengals looked like the Bengals of old on Sunday. Bobby Carpenter joins us in-studio. We go Day Trippin' w/ Austin Ward. And we reveal the official winners and losers of the Dinger Draft in Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! Jeremiah Smith torched Illinois. The Browns have a winning record!!! Jim Lachey joins the show to talk Buckeyes. We play Party Like a Rothstar. The Floor is Yours, and we have a bank full of callers. Adam King joins the show for A-dumb's King-dumb, and he's none too pleased with the behavior of Ohio State fans on Twitter following the Illinois game. Ryan Day was a little bit of Brian Kelly Lite in the postgame presser. News breaks mid-show that the Blue Jackets are very close to trading Kirill Marchenko. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. And we Tell the Truth.