Advertise on podcast: Rothman & Ice

Happy Thursday! We have an abbreviated show following The Ryan Day Show. Ohio State is launching a campaign for Jeremiah Smith's award candidacy, including the Heisman Trophy. Did a CBS sideline reporter go out of her way to make Shedeur Sanders look bad? We make our NFL Picks. Curt Cignetti is complaining about the CFP committee for the second consecutive week. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Veterans Day Wednesday. The CBJ got beat last night at home. Todd Monken announced that Deshaun Watson will return to the starting lineup now that he's healthy again. Adam Schefter joins the show. We're at the midway point of the NFL season, so we analyze where the AFC North, the MVP odds and the Super Bowl odds stack up. Urban Meyer is livid that people are just throwing OSU away as if they don't have any playoff hopes left. We play In or Out. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. Zach Werenski joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! Ryan Day, Matt Patricia and Arthur Smith all face the media today after Ohio State's second consecutive loss, and we air it all. Tyvis Powell joins the show. It's NFL trade deadline day, and a couple moves happen mid-show, including one Bengals trade that falls through. Former CBJ HC Brad Larsen joins the show to talk hockey. Austin Ward joins the show. And we Tell the Truth.

Monday. Not happy, just Monday. Ohio State's season is essentially over. We pretty much just talk about that and nothing else. Jim Lachey, Adam King and Ian Fitzsimmons join the show.

Happy Friday! You're in the office baby. It's Oregon Eve for the Buckeyes. Luke Fahey is preparing ahead of Start #2. Stephen Means of Cleveland.com joins the show. We play Overs and Unders. The Bengals will be saying hola en Madrid, Espana en Domingo. We play Under Pressure and make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Jared Verse calls out his teammates for not having his back vs Mason McCormick and the Steelers last week. Marcus Freeman now has a co-conspirator in the Malachi Toney injury dispute. And we Tell the Truth.

Rothman & Ice Replay

Happy Wednesday! The initial CFP rankings are out, and the Buckeyes are ranked 12th. Deshaun Watson is in the concussion protocol, so how confident should Browns fans be in a Shedeur-led offense? Adam Schefter joins the show. The CBJ destroyed the Avalanche in gray uniforms last night. Ryan Day didn't exactly express much confidence in the team during his press conference yesterday. We play In or Out. Bobby Carpenter joins us in-studio. There's a QB shuffle going on in the NFL right now. Damon Severson joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! We begin the show with a brutally honest press conference from Ryan Day followed by some words from Austin Siereveld. The first batch of 2026 CFP Rankings are revealed tonight. We get some Top Shelf Analysis from former CBJ HC Brad Larsen. We play Fool's Paradise and do Tuesdays w/ Tyvis. Buckeye basketball loses their season opener after allowing 60 points in the 2nd half. A 2-loss Notre Dame and multiple 3-loss SEC teams could make for a really messy CFP picture. Bill Belichick gets asked breakup with Jordon Hudson. We go Day Trippin' w/ Austin Ward. And we Tell the Truth.

Monday. Not happy, just Monday. Ohio State gets picked apart by USC and had to spend the whole game playing catch-up. We play the Blame Game with the defeat. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. We got a bank full of callers for The Floor is Yours to discuss the loss. Adam King joins us in-studio with his firsthand takeaways from the game. What does this loss do for their playoff hopes? The Browns also got smoked, to whom it may concern. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! You're in the office baby! It's USC Eve, and there's still no official word on who is the starting QB for the Buckeyes. Stephen Means of Cleveland.com joins the show from LA. We play Overs and Unders. The Steelers are looking for revenge on the Browns this weekend. We play Under Pressure and make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Lincoln Riley talked about preparing for Jeremiah Smith. Joe Buck vs Troy Aikman is getting even worse. NBC's Yogi Roth joins the show to help us preview OSU vs USC. And Rothman tries to guess Matty's Halloween costume in Tell the Truth.

Happy Thursday! We have an abbreviated show following The Ryan Day Show featuring Ross Bjork. The Brewers are World Series champions. A big trade goes down in the NFL that immediately helps the Bengals. Dabo Swinney jokes about retiring to focus on his stellar fantasy football team, although some Clemson fans may actually prefer he be serious when saying that. If there were ever a year for a 12-team playoff, this is the year. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. And we Tell the Truth, kinda.

Happy Wednesday! The CBJ blew their lead and then won in OT last night. The results are in from our Twitter poll about whether or not the Browns should be interested in extending Deshaun Watson. Adam Schefter joins the show. We talk Bengals. Austin Ward gave us a little tidbit about Tavien St. Clair on our show yesterday that may have flown over some people's heads in the moment. We play In or Out. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. Is Todd Monken already a resounding success of a hire? Zach Werenski joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! AR and TLC are back, so the gang is back together for USC week. We begin the show with Ryan Day and Carson Hinzman at the podium. USC limps into this game following their loss against Wisconsin. Brad Larsen joins the show for Top Shelf Analysis. We play Fool's Paradise. We do Tuesdays w/ Tyvis. Dante Moore is out for the year at Oregon. The Browns are shockingly 5-2. We go Day Trippin' w/ Austin Ward. And we Tell the Truth.

Rothman & Ice Replay

Rothman & Ice Replay