Advertise on podcast: New Girl, Old Guy

Rating

★★★★★

4.8

from

377 reviews

Description

Ali (@lashtweets) introduced Akiva (@Keev26) to New Girl, one episode at a time. And then they finished. Now they're watching "The Paper "on Peacock. Not a rewatch, just a regular watch.

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from New Girl, Old Guy podcast

The Paper Season 2: Episodes 6 and 7

2026/10/02

Hold on to your kettle bells! This week, we're talking about 125 Years Young and Tornado Watch. ⁠⁠Send us your comments and questions!

The Paper Season 2 Episodes 4 & 5

2026/09/25

This week, we take on Impressing a Cop and Dueling Pencils. ⁠Send us your comments and questions!

The Paper Season 2 Episode 3: Hearst's Mistress

2026/09/18

We managed to cover one episode of The Paper and also NFL picks, how clean your house should be, High Holiday recaps, and so much more. Send us your comments and questions!

The Paper: Season 2 Episodes 1-2

2026/09/11

Against all odds, Ali and Keev are back to catch up and discuss the first two episodes of season 2 of The Paper: The Best of Us and Weekend Ned. Send us your questions for the podcast here!

NGOG x DAR: Beth's Dead

2026/01/29

Dr. Amanda joins Ali and Keev to debrief the latest podcast sensation: Beth's Dead.

NGOG x 32 Fans: The Traitors (Eps 1-3)

2026/01/09

Ali, Alex and Keev discuss The Traitors! *This pod contains spoilers for episodes 1-3 of The Traitors.*

The Paper Episode 10 (Part 2): The Ohio Journalism Awards

2025/11/18

Looks like we made it!

Episode 10 (Part 1) The Paper: The Ohio Journalism Awards

2025/11/10

This podcast is brought to you by onions. ⁠Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper - here!

The Paper Episode 9: Matching Ponchos

2025/10/31

⁠Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper - here!

The Paper Episode 8: Church and State

2025/10/24

There's no separation of us and The Paper. Leave your questions/comments about the pod - here!

The Paper Episode 7: I Love You

2025/10/17

This is unhinged. Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper - here!

The Paper Episode 6: Churnalism

2025/10/13

We're a little late but we're here. Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper - here!

The Paper Episode 5: Scam Alert!

2025/10/03

It's not a scam! Akiva and Ali are back 5 weeks in a row to talk about season 1 episode 5 of The Paper! ⁠Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper! ⁠⁠⁠

The Paper Episode 4: TTT vs. The Blogger

2025/09/26

Like this episode, this podcast could have also aired in 2005. ⁠Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper! ⁠⁠⁠

The Paper Episode 3: Buddy and the Dude

2025/09/19

Buddy and Buddy are back to recap episode 3 of The Paper. ⁠Send us your thoughts, comments and questions about The Paper! ⁠⁠

Podcast reviews

Read New Girl, Old Guy podcast reviews

4.8 out of 5

377 reviews

★★☆☆☆

Rebecca VF 2025/11/26

So great

You know what would be so great? If they talked about the show. And not 25 minutes on national newspapers. And Akiva didn’t even know them. Ugh.

★★★★★

ChrisMa12345 2025/11/10

Fun Listen

I loved The Office and finally binge watched The Paper over the last few days. I love your commentary and chats!

★★★★★

Emily098765 2025/08/11

Love It!

Been listening since day one and have loved them all!

★★★★★

Steph_Casper 2025/01/13

Still listening!!

Fun listen! I kind of love that this gets dropped very randomly because it’s a fun surprise added to my queue. I laugh every time!

★★★★★

JR___Mn 2024/12/08

Disclosure date 🤣

I just started seeing someone new and I legit was wondering what date should you disclose some stuff. Your discussion was absolutely perfect this week...

★★★★★

pickles y 2024/09/20

Love the pod

I’m still here and I still haven’t given up! I will see it though and love the convos always even if we miss a few weeks! I love the New Girl convos a...

★★★★★

kicccr 2024/06/03

Great on a binge

Hi 👋 I’ve been trying to get through the last couple seasons of new girl so I started listening to this podcast and then the last three days I’ve go...

★★★★★

Doug Reiser 2024/05/21

Great show but…

Keev, please stop clicking!!!!!

★★★★★

GrahamFam87 2024/04/17

Love you both!

I binged every episode of NGOG over the past couple months and love it. I feel like I’ve gotten to know Ali and Akiva, and find them to be so oddly en...

★☆☆☆☆

Loveatfirstglow 2024/04/07

Multiple Episodes

You all need to do better staying on topic or just rename the podcast. You all talk about everything except the New Girl.

check all reviews on apple podcasts