Advertise on podcast: Stab in the Back

Better keep an eye on that au pair! This episode is all about nannies who definitely don't reduce the parental workload.  First, Benton tells the tale of Christine Banfield's murder by her husband and nanny.  Then, Anna shares the horrible crimes of Yoslyn Ortega. Finally, the two settle in for a British documentary, profiling the notorious trial of Louise Wooodward. Our TV doc this week is What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward.

Have you ever wondered where people go when they disappear? We do, too! For Episode 117, we dive into mysterious disappearances that just have no explanation.  First, Benton tells the tale of Blimp L-8, whose two crew members disappeared from without a trace near San Francisco, and Anna relays the tragic story of the missing Sodder children. Lastly, the two enjoy a classic episode of Crime Stories with Nancy Grace, profiling the disappearance of Brian Shaffer. Our TV doc this week is the Jan 21, 2025 Episode of Crime Stories with Nancy Grace, "Where's Brian?".

Have you ever wondered how safe it is to be a beauty queen? Then episode 116 is for you, because they get murdered, too!  First, Benton tells of the complicated murder of Russel Douglas. Then, Anna relays the story of the stalking murder of Nona Dirksmeyer. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the murder of local beauty queen Tana Wooley. Our TV doc this week is Season 4: Episode 11 of Cold Case Files(first story), "Beauty Queen Killer".

Have you ever wanted revenge, but knew it was a bad idea? These people let their feelings get the best of them! First, Benton tells the strange tale of John and Lorena Bobbitt. Then, Anna relays the horrific murders of Amy Bishop. Finally, the two watch an iconic episode of American Justice, profiling the murder Thurman Martin. Our TV doc this week is Season 11: Episode 18 of American Justice, "Justifiable Homocide?".

Do wives kill their husbands? Some do! and Episode 114 profiles a few who definitely didn't honor their vows. First, Benton tells the tale of Omaima Nelson and the murder of her husband Bill, and Anna gives us the details of Susan Wright, who stabbed her spouse 193 times. Then, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Filles, profiling the black widow, Stacey Castor. Our TV doc this week is Forensic Files Season 14: Episode 7, "Freeze Framed".

Hey, Backstabbers!  Have you ever had a bad experience with a police officer? You'll be glad that it wasn't by one of these dirty cops.  First, Benton tells of the infamous Jon Burge, who elicited false confessions with torture. Then, Anna gives us a look at the "Dirty 30", who ran their own crime empire in Brooklyn. Finally, the two get comfortable and watch a classic case of City Confidential, profiling the life of Laurie Bembenek. Our TV doc this week is Season 4: Episode 2 of City Confidential, "Milwaukee: The Legend of Bambi Bembenek".

Grow up in a small town? You might be surprised at what kind of carnage can take place in such quiet corners of the world!   First, Benton relays the story of Katherine Knight, Australia's most famous female murderer. Then, Anna recounts the quadruple homicide that changed Keddie, California in 1981. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of City Confidential, profiling the attempted murder of Darlene Summerford. Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 4 of City Confidential, "Foul Play in the Bible Belt".

Have you ever wondered how a coverup takes place? It can be a small action that snowballs into something much more public than ever expected. First, Benton tells the tale of Sandy Berger, who destroyed classified documents on behalf of the Clinton Administration, and Anna relays the tragic story of the Hillsborough disaster. Lastly, the two enjoy a classic episode of American Greed, profiling the rise and fall of WeWork. Our TV doc this week is Season 15: Episode 3 of American Greed, "How WeWork Went Wild".

Does money matter when a crime has been committed? Oftentimes wealth can spare an offender from taking real responsibility! First, Benton tells the rags to riches to murder tale of Parisian courtesan Marguerite Alibert. Then, Anna shares the story of Cameron Terrell's aquittal of murder. Lastly, the two watch a classic episode of Dominick Dunne's Power, Privilege and Justice, profiling Alex Kelly's run from the law. Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 5 of Dominick Dunne's Power, Privilege and Justice, "Run From Justice".

Strap in, we're discussing copycat killers of all kinds! They say there are no original ideas, anymore.  First, Benton tells the tragic tale of the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart. Then, Anna recounts the chilling case of the Yorkshire Ripper, Peter Sutcliffe. Finally, the two watch an episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murders of Eddie Seda. Our TV doc this week is Season 8: Episode 25 of Forensic Files, "Sign of the Zodiac".

Get ready for another creepy and disturbing Mother's Day episode of Stab in the Back!  First, Benton shares thee infamous story of Susan Smith and the murders of her two children, Michael and Alex. Then, Anna tells the horrible tale of Debra Jeter's deadly. attack on her two daughters. Finally, the two settle in for an episode of Dateline, profiling the con artist Sante Kimes. Our TV doc this week is Season 33: Episode 13 of Dateline, "The Devil Wore White".

How many celebrities have done some horrible things in the past that we've all forgotten about? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how many that question applies to. First, Benton tells the tale of Woody Allen's questionable relationship with his former daughter, Soon-Yi Previn. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of Matthew Broderick and Jennifer Grey's deadly car accident inn Ireland.  Finally, the two discuss an episode of Cursed Films, profiling the fatal on set accident during the filming of The Twilight Zone: The Movie.  Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 5 of Cursed Films, "The Twilight Zone: The Movie"

Sometimes you know someone who is always sick, always getting tests done, needing you to acknowledge their struggle. It could be plain ol' Munchausen Syndrome!  First, Anna gives a rundown of the type of behaviors exhibited by this type of personality, and Benton tells o the mysterious skin disorder, Morgellon's Disease. Then, Anna relays the life story of disgraced wellness influencer Belle Gibson, who faked her cancer diagnoses for financial gain. Finally the two watch an episode of Something's Killing Me, profiling the Munchausen syndrome case of Hope Ybarra. Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 1 of Something's Killing Me, "Hope". 

Hey, Backstabbers!  Welcome to our 4th annual Folie à Deux episode. As it is our 4th time around, please indulge us as we play fast and loose with the topic. First, Benton tells of the infamous torture and murder of Sylvia Likens. Then, Anna gives us a look at the shared psychosis of the Tromp family in southeastern Australia. Finally, the two get comfortable and watch a classic case of Cold Case Files, profiling the murder of Jack Irwin. Our TV doc this week is Season 5: Episode 18 of Cold Case Files, "The Girls".

Have you ever wondered if the roller coaster your'e on is safe? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how often the answer is no!. First, Anna shares some information about theme park accidents and the various injuries that can occur any day, and Benton tells the tale of the tragic death of Deborah Stone. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of the Battersea Park Funfair disaster.  Finally, the two discuss a Youtube Disasterthon video, profiling the death of James Young.