Advertise on podcast: American Political History

39 men signed the Constitution. 42 were in the room. This is the story of what happened next — and it begins with the three who refused. George Mason turned his copy of the draft over and wrote his objections on the back of it, starting with the sentence that would organize the opposition for two years: “There is no Declaration of Rights.” Meanwhile the document travelled north to a Congress that the Constitution itself abolished, where Richard Henry Lee — the man who had moved American independence eleven years earlier — tried to amend it, demanded a recorded vote, and was outmaneuvered so completely that the entire debate was struck from the official record as the price of a compromise. What survives of it comes from one delegate’s private notes, which nobody read until 1959. It is the story of a word stolen, a record erased, and a question handed to conventions of ordinary men: nine states, or nothing. Send us Fan Mail

4 months of argument, 60 ballots on the presidency alone, 2 walkouts, 1 near-collapse over representation, and a bargain nobody in the room was proud of — and this is what came out of it. The Constitution of the United States, read start to finish exactly as Jacob Shallus inscribed it on the parchment: the original spelling, the original capital letters, the numbers written out in words, the errata note recording where “Thirty” was scraped over an erasure on the first page, and all 39 signatures by state. Every clause in it was fought over in a closed room on Chestnut Street between May and September of 1787, and this season has followed those fights one at a time. Here is the finished machine, with the arguments taken out and nothing left but the text: “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union...” Send us Fan Mail

September 17th, 1787. The parchment is on the table, and 81-year-old Benjamin Franklin has written out the last great speech of the summer — read aloud by James Wilson because the doctor can barely stand: “the older I grow, the more apt I am to doubt my own judgment... I consent, Sir, to this Constitution, because I expect no better, and because I am not sure, that it is not the best.” This is the finale: Gouverneur Morris’s ambiguous signing formula, placed in Franklin’s hands to catch the dissenters; Washington’s only speech of the entire convention — asking for a bigger House — and the erasure it left on the first page of the parchment; Hamilton, who liked the plan less than almost anyone, pleading with the three refusers between anarchy and the chance of good; Mason, Randolph, and Gerry keeping their seats as 38 men sign; Hamilton’s lone signature under New-York. And, as the last members sign, Franklin at the president’s chair, on the sun some painter set there: rising, and not setting. Then the City Tavern, a question at the door about a republic, and Washington alone with the papers of the secret summer — retired to meditate on the momentous work. Send us Fan Mail

Article XIII of the Articles of Confederation required the consent of every state to change anything — and the whole decade died of that sentence, one Rhode Island veto at a time. This is the story of how the Constitution arranged its own birth, its own repair, and its own final shape. Ratification by 9 states, in conventions of the people — the double end-run Madison defended as the difference between a treaty and a constitution. The two clauses armored against amendment itself: the slave-trade bargain shielded to 1808, and the equal Senate entrenched forever by “the circulating murmurs of the small States.” Then the last 10 days: Gouverneur Morris compressing 23 articles into 7 across a single Sunday; the roll-call preamble made impossible by the ratification arithmetic — nobody knew which 9 states would say yes — and “We the People of the United States” written in its place; the word “legally” struck from the fugitive clause so the text would not say slavery was legal in a moral view; the afternoon 10 states said no to a bill of rights, not one aye — and George Mason, on the blank leaf of his printed copy, writing the sentence the next fight would be built on: “There is no Declaration of Rights.” All the states, aye. Ordered to be engrossed. And a clerk with a Sunday’s work ahead of him. Send us Fan Mail

“Religion and humanity had nothing to do with this question. Interest alone is the governing principle with nations.” With those sentences, John Rutledge of South Carolina set the terms for the darkest bargain of the Constitutional Convention. This is August 1787, told in the delegates’ own words: Gouverneur Morris calling slavery the curse of heaven on the states where it prevailed — and 2 weeks later proposing the bargain himself; George Mason, master of hundreds, thundering that every master of slaves is born a petty tyrant and that providence punishes national sins with national calamities; Oliver Ellsworth answering that a man who never owned a slave could not judge — and that Virginia’s morality paid a dividend, since her surplus slaves would rise in value the day the trade closed; the Pinckneys stating South Carolina’s terms as facts of nature. Then the trade itself: 20 years of the open slave trade for New England’s votes, navigation acts by simple majority for the deep south’s — an understanding, as Madison’s own footnote confessed, that had taken place. The fugitive clause slipped through almost without debate. And the mover of the Virginia Plan rose to say he doubted he could sign. Send us Fan Mail

On July 26th the convention handed 4 months of resolutions to 5 men and adjourned. On August 6th it got back a constitution — 7 pages, 23 articles, wide margins for the fight. This is the grind of August, told the way the room actually lived it: everything at once. The taxing power ending 10 years of begging circulars on an ordinary Thursday, while 2 days’ walk of clauses away Gouverneur Morris demands 14 years of citizenship for a senator — “7 years must be applied to learn to be a Shoe Maker” — in a room where the Constitution’s own draftsman was born in Scotland. Franklin’s rogues and prison hulks against the freehold franchise; Wilson telling the convention what it is to face ineligibility under a constitution he shared in making; the placemen fenced out; the war powers split; Pinckney’s buried list with 7 words about the press; Section 9’s wall of nevers written by men who had lived every item on it; the sentries, the shut windows, and “we never once thought of a king.” And on August 30th, 11 quiet words against every religious test in America. Send us Fan Mail

The branch that today holds the power to strike down acts of Congress was born without a fight — “that a national Judiciary be established,” agreed unanimously, in a morning. Then the Constitutional Convention spent a summer on the two questions hiding inside the easy answer. This is the story of the courts: Franklin’s Scottish lawyers, who always nominated the ablest man to the bench in order to divide his practice; the “may, not shall” finesse that mailed the fight over lower courts to the future; the two locks — tenure and salary — that put judges beyond the reach of the politicians they would rule against. And it is the story of the system’s keystone swapping in a single afternoon: Madison’s cherished congressional veto over state laws dying 3 states to 7, and Luther Martin — the loudest states-rights man in the room — rising with the replacement, the supremacy clause, adopted without one state opposed... a shield he built to protect the states, rebuilt by August into a sword pointed at them. Along the way: treason defined so narrowly no American legislature could ever stretch it, the corruption of blood abolished, and a 10-section indictment of Rogue Island written by men who knew exactly which state wasn’t in the room. Send us Fan Mail

No question defeated the Constitutional Convention like the question of how to choose a president. Across the summer of 1787 the delegates balloted on it some 60 times — popular election crushed 9 states to 1 after George Mason compared it to referring “a trial of colours to a blind man”; election by Congress condemned by Gouverneur Morris as “the election of a pope by a conclave of cardinals”; electors adopted in July and unwound 5 days later; a motion for a president serving for life that drew 4 states, Virginia among them; James Wilson reduced to proposing the executive be chosen by lot. Hugh Williamson told the room it was pretty certain America would someday have a king — the only question was how long it could be postponed. Then, in September, a committee chaired by the man who had once proposed erasing the state boundaries handed down a machine nobody had proposed: electors who assemble in 13 places at once, vote for 2 names, and evaporate — a conclave that cannot be corrupted because until election day it does not exist. This is the story of the electoral college, and of the accidental office its arithmetic invented: the vice presidency. Send us Fan Mail

On June 1st, 1787, the Constitutional Convention reached the resolution nobody had wanted to write: a national executive. James Wilson moved that it consist of a single person — and the room went silent, long enough that 81-year-old Franklin had to coax the delegates into speaking. The reason for the silence sat on the dais: every man present was measuring an office for General Washington, in his presence, weighing out loud how much power one man could be trusted with while the man himself said nothing. This is the story of the 4 days that invented the presidency: Randolph calling a single executive “the foetus of monarchy” and Wilson answering that unity was the best safeguard against tyranny; Franklin proposing the office serve without pay, and pointing at the chair — “a Patriot whom I will not now offend by any other praise”; Dickinson praising limited monarchy as the best government on earth and conceding America could never have it; Hamilton and Wilson demanding an absolute veto and losing 10 states to none; and Franklin’s warning that echoes down every administration since: the first man at the helm will be a good one. Nobody knows what sort may come afterwards. Send us Fan Mail

The most notorious fraction in American history did not begin as a claim about personhood. It began as a tax formula — proposed in 1783, in the same Philadelphia room, by James Madison himself, to settle how slave states would be billed for the war debt. In that fight the North demanded the enslaved be counted in full, and the South demanded they barely count at all... because the count meant money. Four years later, James Wilson lifted the dead amendment’s exact words into the plan of the new government — “three fifths of all other persons” — and the incentive silently reversed: the count now meant power, and every argument swapped sides with it. This is the story told through the record alone: Paterson asking whether a single enslaved person would ever cast the votes their count created; Butler and Pinckney demanding the enslaved be counted as whole persons; Gouverneur Morris declaring himself reduced to a choice between injustice to the South and injustice to human nature; the fraction voted dead on July 11th — and welded back the next morning to a tax lock that made every claimed seat a taxed seat. Six words, for 700,000 people. Send us Fan Mail

On June 11th, 1787, Roger Sherman proposed the settlement — population in the House, one vote per state in the Senate — and the Constitutional Convention voted it down without a debate. This is the story of the 5 weeks it cost to walk back: Luther Martin’s 2-day endurance speech; Benjamin Franklin, 81 and unchurched, asking a deadlocked room why it had never once prayed — and the convention adjourning without a vote because it couldn’t afford a chaplain; Gunning Bedford telling the large states “I do not, gentlemen, trust you” and threatening a foreign ally; the July 2nd tie, 5–5–1, decided by an absent bachelor and a Connecticut-born Georgian’s lonely aye; Washington writing that he repented ever having agency in the business; and July 16th — 5 states to 4, Massachusetts divided against itself — when the equal vote of the states carried by the width of a single delegation. Then the large states caucus to plot their answer... and discover, in Madison’s own words, that they have nothing. The Senate was born out of accidents. It never came out. Send us Fan Mail

In the second week of June 1787, the small states stopped losing votes politely. David Brearley proposed erasing every state boundary and redrawing America into 13 equal parts. William Paterson declared New Jersey would never confederate on proportional representation — “I would rather submit to a monarch, to a despot, than to such a fate” — and James Wilson answered that Pennsylvania would never confederate on anything else. This is the story of the counterstroke: the New Jersey Plan, 9 resolutions that stayed inside the congressional commission and quietly contained the seed of the supremacy clause. And it is the story of the most astonishing day of the summer — June 18th, when Alexander Hamilton, outvoted by his own delegation and silent for 3 weeks, held the floor for 6 hours to propose a senate for life, an executive for life, and the British constitution as “the best model the world ever produced”... and sat down to total silence. Praised by everybody, supported by none. Then Madison rises, takes the New Jersey Plan apart disease by disease, and names the rest of the summer: the great difficulty lies in representation. Send us Fan Mail

On May 29th, 1787, Edmund Randolph — 33 years old, governor of Virginia, owner of the finest voice in the room — rose to open the main business of the Federal Convention, and 3 notebooks took him down. Madison recorded a statesman’s autopsy of the Confederation and an exhortation not to let the moment pass. Doctor McHenry caught the raw material Madison left out: “Are we not on the eve of war?” and the maxim that America’s chief danger arose from “the democratic parts of our constitutions.” And Robert Yates, Governor Clinton’s watchdog, heard a confession — “a strong consolidated union, in which the idea of states should be nearly annihilated.” This is the story of the 2 days that set the summer’s course: the polite resolution to “correct and enlarge” the Articles, withdrawn by its own mover and replaced with the doctrine that a union “merely federal” will not do; Gerry’s warning that a convention with this power could annihilate the Confederation; Gouverneur Morris’s answer — a supreme government now, or a despot in twenty years, “for come he must”; the vote, 6 states to 1. And before the day ends, tiny Delaware threatens to walk. Then the first great question of design: who elects the people’s house — Sherman wanting the people to have as little to do as may be, Gerry blaming the excess of democracy, and Mason and Wilson answering with the grand depository and the federal pyramid on the broadest possible base. Send us Fan Mail

4 prisoners from the Walnut Street jail carried Benjamin Franklin to the Constitutional Convention in a sedan chair — the oldest delegate, 81, riding above the cobblestones to sit with the youngest, a 26-year-old former army captain. Jefferson, reading the delegate list in Paris, called them “an assembly of demigods.” William Pierce of Georgia, sitting among them, wrote down what they actually looked like — and his private sketches of every man in the room are the heart of this episode: Madison, whose greatness “every Person seems to acknowledge”; Hamilton, brilliant and vain, caged by the two colleagues sent to outvote him; Wilson, who argued by force of reasoning; Sherman the shoemaker-turned-judge who “seldom fails”; the silent Robert Morris; and a young Charles Pinckney lying about his age. It is also the story of who wasn’t there — Jefferson and Adams an ocean away, and Patrick Henry, refusing his seat because, as Virginians told it, he “smelt a rat.” Meet the demigods... as their own colleague saw them. Send us Fan Mail

James Madison stepped off the New York stage on May 3rd, 1787 — 11 days before the Federal Convention was scheduled to open, and 22 days before it actually could. This is the story of those waiting weeks and the first days of business: the muddy roads that held the delegates back, the Virginia delegation caucusing every afternoon to shape a plan that would speak first, General Washington’s escort into the city, and his apology, from the president’s chair, for his own inexperience. It is also the story of the rules the textbooks skip. Why Rufus King and George Mason demanded that no man’s vote be recorded by name. Why any settled question could be reopened. And why the most argumentative men in America agreed that nothing spoken in that room would reach the outside world — a decision Jefferson called “abominable” from Paris, Madison called prudent, and General Washington enforced with a dropped paper, a bow, and a silence no one ever broke. Before a single idea was debated, they built the room that made the arguing possible. Send us Fan Mail