
Advertise on podcast: The Path Went Chilly
Rating
4.3from
Categories
This podcast has
314 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
Robin Jules Ashley TPWCExplicit
No
Date created
2021/03/25
Latest episode
2026/11/12
Average duration
47 min.
Release period
7 days
Description
Welcome to The Path Went Chilly where Robin Warder from The Trail Went Cold will discuss his favorite cases with friends Dr. Jules from Riddle Me That! True Crime and Criminologist Dr. Ashley Wellman. This will be a deep dive and a fresh perspective, join us as we descend deeper down the rabbit hole & examine these unsolved cases with compassionate consideration towards the families left behind.
Unlock The Path Went Chilly podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from The Path Went Chilly podcast
Shannon Green: Dewayne Bell & John Reneer Statement Analysis Pt. Two
2026/11/12
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Below is the transcript with my notes in case you would like to follow along:
Transcript of Quotes – 14 NEWS Investigation Source material: 14 NEWS (WFIE) article screenshots. All quoted wording preserved exactly as it appeared. Non-quote narrative text omitted. Ordered as closely as possible to the chronological sequence of events. John Reneer on why he recorded the conversation (two days after Shannon Green’s disappearance) "To be honest with you, I thought the police had probably sent him, and he was probably wired or something. I didn't know, you know, so I wired-up." -Question Reneer’s motivation for the ‘why’, he recorded this, he is potentially being deceptive about his underlying motivation, as he uses the phrase ‘to be honest with you’, why would he need to preface his statement with ‘to be honest’, he is potentially worried about how he will perceived and is trying to convince -The use of ‘probably’ makes me question if he truly believes the police had sent Dewayne Bell, this is further underscored where he takes it a step further and says ‘he was probably wired or something’ this is a very wishy washy statement, if he truly believed that Dewayne was wired, he wouldn’t use such a soft tone ‘probably wired up or something’ -Reneer then goes on to say ‘I didn’t know, you know, so I wired up’ Dewayne may not have known if Dewayne was wired but the language used suggests there is a low probability that he truly believed that, his use of ‘you know’ has the intent of convincing the interviewer -It’s unclear exactly what Reneer is being deceptive about, the initial part of the statement suggests his underlying motive and the latter parts suggest that he potentially did not believe that Dewayne would have been wired and is using that as an excuse or justification for why he chose to proceed with the recording. I also question, if Reneer believed the police had sent Dewayne to record him, was he potentially worried that they would find something, even if it was something completely irrelevant to Shannon Green’s disappearance John Reneer on how police handled the investigation at the time "No one set out to find what happened to Shannon. They set out to find what I did to Shannon. There's a big difference." -The first major red flag I want to highlight here which is unsettling is ‘they set out to find what I did to Shannon’ it should be ‘what they thought I did to Shannon’ this very well could be a leaked confession, again it doesn’t mean that Reneer killed her or made her disappear but there are other options of what he may have done that could be causing this type of statement -Ok, so back to the beginning of the statement, he doesn’t say specifically law enforcement, which is strange, typically when expressing frustration about police not doing an adequate job of investigating, the subject would say ‘police’ not ‘no one’ -‘Set out’ is an odd phrase and he uses it twice, does he believe she left? Sometimes a phrase like ‘set out’ means left or went somewhere, was Reneer aware Shannon went somewhere preceding her disappearance? Did they ‘set out’ somewhere together? These are fair questions to ask based on what could be a leaked confession and the odd use of ‘set out’ -The final point I want to address is that Shannon is missing, the police had theorized she ran away because of the phone call that they received and Reneer is saying ‘what happened to Shannon’ this in and of itself wouldn’t necessarily be cause for pause for me but when coupled with the rest of these few sentences, it makes me question if Reneer has more knowledge of what ‘happened’ to Shannon than he is letting on The recorded conversation (tape) John Reneer: "What's going on?" -What we can’t know is when Reneer turned on the recording device, we would think that at some point he would acknowledge Dewayne by name, especially since his objective was to record him, so for the listener it starts abruptly with ‘what’s going on’, we don’t know what led up to this point and for how long they spoke before Reneer his record -When one doesn’t feel the need to say the first name, it could speak to a sense of familiarity, for example, when I see my sister, I don’t say ‘Hi Shanelle’, I likely wouldn’t use her name, if it was a loose acquaintance, I would likely say their name in an acknowledgement that I knew who they were Dewayne Bell: "Aw, nothing. Got any money I can borrow?" -Here Dewayne answers in a strange manner if we are to believe he needs to go on the run after killing Shannon, he says ‘Aw, Nothing’, the ‘aw’ before he says nothing is a way to draw out speech while one thinks of an appropriate answer. If he would have simply answered ‘nothing’ and said nothing else, I would have believed his statement was truthful, always as Mark Mclish says ‘the shortest sentence is the best sentence’ -He then goes on to say ‘got any money I can borrow’, what we are looking for is ‘do YOU have any money I can borrow’ we have missing pronouns and words, which is very often indicative of deception, even if spoken in the pattern Dewayne was using it should look like ‘Do you got any money I can borrow’, -Also note here he uses the word ‘any’ which would potentially indicate that he would accept any monetary value shared with him
John Reneer: "How much? I might have a few dollars?" -Again we see with Reneer, not ‘how much do you need’ he simply says ‘how much’ which may be the pattern in which he speaks -The use of the word ‘might’ is interesting, he likely does have a few dollars and is potentially playing coy with Dewayne and seeing what he will say in return. -If you only have a few dollars, you are likely very aware of exactly where those few dollars are and how many of them you have
Dewayne Bell: "About a couple hundred anyway." -Again, we don’t see a definitive amount Dewayne needs, he is unclear. If he had a specific amount in mind he may say something to the effect of ‘I need 200 dollars’, the fact that he starts out with ‘about’ weakens his statement and saying a couple hundred is non specific, a couple to me means two but it may mean three to someone else, it isn’t as well defined as two or three -He ends the sentence with ‘anyway’, it’s an unnecessary addition and odd phrasing, which again calls into question the veracity of the statement John Reneer: "S**t. I ain't got no two hundred dollars. I wish I did have." -The grammar here is abysmal, so one thing I will say is it is more difficult at my skill level to cut through the noise of poor grammar, but we will do our best -Reneer starts his statement out with ‘shit’, it is less common for liars to use harsh words or curse words, there is always the exception but the addition of ‘shit’ here when we haven’t seen Reneer curse thus far tells me that he likely doesn’t have a couple hundred dollars or as he puts it ‘I aint got no two hundred dollars’ -We see that Reneer has defined a couple hundred as two, there is a change in dictionary, in that Dewayne has said ‘a couple’ and Reneer has said ‘two hundred’, it could be significant but I would say it’s the most probable scenario that Reneer, like myself has deduced that ‘a couple’ means to him personally, ‘two’ -He also says ‘I wish, I did have’ so, is there a comma or is it all run together? This would change the meaning of the sentence, either way we cannot extrapolate and only analyze what is before us, it’s tempting to add ‘it’ to ‘I did have’ but since we cannot make assumptions of what he potentially meant to say, we must examine the simple phrase ‘I did have’, that tells me that Reneer did have two hundred dollars and now he doesn’t Dewayne Bell: "I need it pretty bad, I need to get out of town." -Dewayne has spoken earlier about the money but rather than saying ‘I need the money pretty bad’ he says ‘I need it pretty bad’, if one needs something badly, they likely would reference exactly what they needed and wouldn’t need to preface ‘badly’ with ‘pretty’ it weakens how badly he needs it. His inability to say exactly the number he needs calls into question how much and for what purpose or objective he needs the money -The next part of the sentence Dewayne says ‘I need to get out of town’, which is clear, concise and succinct, I believe him in that this part of the statement is truthful, or Dewayne believes it to be truthful John Reneer: "Why's that?" -Not much to analyze here, it’s a simple question Dewayne Bell: "I done something the other day. I need to get out of town for a while." -When he says ‘I done something the other day’ this isn’t an untrue statement, he of course did many things, what I can say is what is missing. One would expect a truthful statement of someone who potentially committed murder to say ‘I done something bad’ or something similar. There is an incongruity with the gravity of the situation and the language used -Done vs did, it’s grammatically annoying but we know that Dewayne isn’t a wordsmith and this may be his pattern of speech, either way like I said, we can’t analyze what think he may mean or what he could have said, I believe this part of the statement to be true, he did do something the other day, every day is filled with ‘something’ that would be a true statement for anyone who is conscious -The lack of specificity with ‘the other day’ is standing out to me, if we are to believe that you in
Shannon Green: Dewayne Bell/John Reneer Statement Analysis Pt. One
2026/11/05
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Below is the transcript with my notes in case you would like to follow along:
Transcript of Quotes – 14 NEWS Investigation Source material: 14 NEWS (WFIE) article screenshots. All quoted wording preserved exactly as it appeared. Non-quote narrative text omitted. Ordered as closely as possible to the chronological sequence of events. John Reneer on why he recorded the conversation (two days after Shannon Green’s disappearance) "To be honest with you, I thought the police had probably sent him, and he was probably wired or something. I didn't know, you know, so I wired-up." -Question Reneer’s motivation for the ‘why’, he recorded this, he is potentially being deceptive about his underlying motivation, as he uses the phrase ‘to be honest with you’, why would he need to preface his statement with ‘to be honest’, he is potentially worried about how he will perceived and is trying to convince -The use of ‘probably’ makes me question if he truly believes the police had sent Dewayne Bell, this is further underscored where he takes it a step further and says ‘he was probably wired or something’ this is a very wishy washy statement, if he truly believed that Dewayne was wired, he wouldn’t use such a soft tone ‘probably wired up or something’ -Reneer then goes on to say ‘I didn’t know, you know, so I wired up’ Dewayne may not have known if Dewayne was wired but the language used suggests there is a low probability that he truly believed that, his use of ‘you know’ has the intent of convincing the interviewer -It’s unclear exactly what Reneer is being deceptive about, the initial part of the statement suggests his underlying motive and the latter parts suggest that he potentially did not believe that Dewayne would have been wired and is using that as an excuse or justification for why he chose to proceed with the recording. I also question, if Reneer believed the police had sent Dewayne to record him, was he potentially worried that they would find something, even if it was something completely irrelevant to Shannon Green’s disappearance John Reneer on how police handled the investigation at the time "No one set out to find what happened to Shannon. They set out to find what I did to Shannon. There's a big difference." -The first major red flag I want to highlight here which is unsettling is ‘they set out to find what I did to Shannon’ it should be ‘what they thought I did to Shannon’ this very well could be a leaked confession, again it doesn’t mean that Reneer killed her or made her disappear but there are other options of what he may have done that could be causing this type of statement -Ok, so back to the beginning of the statement, he doesn’t say specifically law enforcement, which is strange, typically when expressing frustration about police not doing an adequate job of investigating, the subject would say ‘police’ not ‘no one’ -‘Set out’ is an odd phrase and he uses it twice, does he believe she left? Sometimes a phrase like ‘set out’ means left or went somewhere, was Reneer aware Shannon went somewhere preceding her disappearance? Did they ‘set out’ somewhere together? These are fair questions to ask based on what could be a leaked confession and the odd use of ‘set out’ -The final point I want to address is that Shannon is missing, the police had theorized she ran away because of the phone call that they received and Reneer is saying ‘what happened to Shannon’ this in and of itself wouldn’t necessarily be cause for pause for me but when coupled with the rest of these few sentences, it makes me question if Reneer has more knowledge of what ‘happened’ to Shannon than he is letting on The recorded conversation (tape) John Reneer: "What's going on?" -What we can’t know is when Reneer turned on the recording device, we would think that at some point he would acknowledge Dewayne by name, especially since his objective was to record him, so for the listener it starts abruptly with ‘what’s going on’, we don’t know what led up to this point and for how long they spoke before Reneer his record -When one doesn’t feel the need to say the first name, it could speak to a sense of familiarity, for example, when I see my sister, I don’t say ‘Hi Shanelle’, I likely wouldn’t use her name, if it was a loose acquaintance, I would likely say their name in an acknowledgement that I knew who they were Dewayne Bell: "Aw, nothing. Got any money I can borrow?" -Here Dewayne answers in a strange manner if we are to believe he needs to go on the run after killing Shannon, he says ‘Aw, Nothing’, the ‘aw’ before he says nothing is a way to draw out speech while one thinks of an appropriate answer. If he would have simply answered ‘nothing’ and said nothing else, I would have believed his statement was truthful, always as Mark Mclish says ‘the shortest sentence is the best sentence’ -He then goes on to say ‘got any money I can borrow’, what we are looking for is ‘do YOU have any money I can borrow’ we have missing pronouns and words, which is very often indicative of deception, even if spoken in the pattern Dewayne was using it should look like ‘Do you got any money I can borrow’, -Also note here he uses the word ‘any’ which would potentially indicate that he would accept any monetary value shared with him
John Reneer: "How much? I might have a few dollars?" -Again we see with Reneer, not ‘how much do you need’ he simply says ‘how much’ which may be the pattern in which he speaks -The use of the word ‘might’ is interesting, he likely does have a few dollars and is potentially playing coy with Dewayne and seeing what he will say in return. -If you only have a few dollars, you are likely very aware of exactly where those few dollars are and how many of them you have
Dewayne Bell: "About a couple hundred anyway." -Again, we don’t see a definitive amount Dewayne needs, he is unclear. If he had a specific amount in mind he may say something to the effect of ‘I need 200 dollars’, the fact that he starts out with ‘about’ weakens his statement and saying a couple hundred is non specific, a couple to me means two but it may mean three to someone else, it isn’t as well defined as two or three -He ends the sentence with ‘anyway’, it’s an unnecessary addition and odd phrasing, which again calls into question the veracity of the statement John Reneer: "S**t. I ain't got no two hundred dollars. I wish I did have." -The grammar here is abysmal, so one thing I will say is it is more difficult at my skill level to cut through the noise of poor grammar, but we will do our best -Reneer starts his statement out with ‘shit’, it is less common for liars to use harsh words or curse words, there is always the exception but the addition of ‘shit’ here when we haven’t seen Reneer curse thus far tells me that he likely doesn’t have a couple hundred dollars or as he puts it ‘I aint got no two hundred dollars’ -We see that Reneer has defined a couple hundred as two, there is a change in dictionary, in that Dewayne has said ‘a couple’ and Reneer has said ‘two hundred’, it could be significant but I would say it’s the most probable scenario that Reneer, like myself has deduced that ‘a couple’ means to him personally, ‘two’ -He also says ‘I wish, I did have’ so, is there a comma or is it all run together? This would change the meaning of the sentence, either way we cannot extrapolate and only analyze what is before us, it’s tempting to add ‘it’ to ‘I did have’ but since we cannot make assumptions of what he potentially meant to say, we must examine the simple phrase ‘I did have’, that tells me that Reneer did have two hundred dollars and now he doesn’t Dewayne Bell: "I need it pretty bad, I need to get out of town." -Dewayne has spoken earlier about the money but rather than saying ‘I need the money pretty bad’ he says ‘I need it pretty bad’, if one needs something badly, they likely would reference exactly what they needed and wouldn’t need to preface ‘badly’ with ‘pretty’ it weakens how badly he needs it. His inability to say exactly the number he needs calls into question how much and for what purpose or objective he needs the money -The next part of the sentence Dewayne says ‘I need to get out of town’, which is clear, concise and succinct, I believe him in that this part of the statement is truthful, or Dewayne believes it to be truthful John Reneer: "Why's that?" -Not much to analyze here, it’s a simple question Dewayne Bell: "I done something the other day. I need to get out of town for a while." -When he says ‘I done something the other day’ this isn’t an untrue statement, he of course did many things, what I can say is what is missing. One would expect a truthful statement of someone who potentially committed murder to say ‘I done something bad’ or something similar. There is an incongruity with the gravity of the situation and the language used -Done vs did, it’s grammatically annoying but we know that Dewayne isn’t a wordsmith and this may be his pattern of speech, either way like I said, we can’t analyze what think he may mean or what he could have said, I believe this part of the statement to be true, he did do something the other day, every day is filled with ‘something’ that would be a true statement for anyone who is conscious -The lack of specificity with ‘the other day’ is standing out to me, if we are to believe that you in
Teresita Basa Pt. Two
2026/10/29
Teresita Basa had immigrated to the United States from the Phillipines and was working as a respiratory therapist at Chicago's Edgewater Hospital. She was murdered on February 21st, 1997, in her Lincoln Park Apartment. She was found naked under a vburning mattress with a butcher knife in her chest after neighbors reported smoke. The Path Went Chilly until months later when coworker Remy Chua, who also hailed from the Philipines, claimed to have been possessed by Basa's spirit in a trance, speaking Tagalog and naming a fellow hospital worker as the murderer. Join us as we go through this bizarre case and see if at the end, you believe in ghosts.
Support the Show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Teresita Basa Pt One
2026/10/22
Teresita Basa had immigrated to the United States from the Phillipines and was working as a respiratory therapist at Chicago's Edgewater Hospital. She was murdered on February 21st, 1997, in her Lincoln Park Apartment. She was found naked under a vburning mattress with a butcher knife in her chest after neighbors reported smoke. The Path Went Chilly until months later when coworker Remy Chua, who also hailed from the Philipines, claimed to have been possessed by Basa's spirit in a trance, speaking Tagalog and naming a fellow hospital worker as the murderer. Join us as we go through this bizarre case and see if at the end, you believe in ghosts.
Support the Show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Zigmund Adamski Pt. Two
2026/10/15
June 11, 1980. Todmorden, England. The body of 56-year old Zigmund Adamski is found on top of a large pile of coal inside a coal yard. Five days earlier, Zigmund had vanished after leaving his home, which is located 25 miles away, but his whereabouts during that time period are unknown. Zigmund’s official cause of death is believed to be a heart attack, but there are a number of strange clues at the scene, including some unexplained burns on his head. Months later, one of the police constables who found Zigmund’s body experiences what he believes to be a bizarre encounter with a UFO, leading to speculation that the two events might be connected. Could alien abduction have played a role in Zigmund Adamski’s death? If not, what did happen to him and how did he wind up dead at that particular location? For this month’s first Halloween-themed episode of “The Path Went Chilly, we will be travelling to the United Kingdom to explore one of the strangest mysteries we’re ever covered.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Godfrey
http://www.bbc.co.uk/insideout/yorkslincs/series2/ufo_alien_abduction_yorkshire_pennine_sighting_adamski_mystery.shtml
https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/unsolved-baffling-case-missing-miner-14150127
http://www.thedefectivespodcast.uk/blog
Close Encounters of the Fatal Kind” by Nick Redfern
“Acknowledged: A Perspective on UFOs, Aliens and Crop Circles” by Andrew Johnson
“The Book of Ghosts, UFOs and the Unexplained” by James Pato
Zigmund Adamski Pt. One
2026/10/08
June 11, 1980. Todmorden, England. The body of 56-year old Zigmund Adamski is found on top of a large pile of coal inside a coal yard. Five days earlier, Zigmund had vanished after leaving his home, which is located 25 miles away, but his whereabouts during that time period are unknown. Zigmund’s official cause of death is believed to be a heart attack, but there are a number of strange clues at the scene, including some unexplained burns on his head. Months later, one of the police constables who found Zigmund’s body experiences what he believes to be a bizarre encounter with a UFO, leading to speculation that the two events might be connected. Could alien abduction have played a role in Zigmund Adamski’s death? If not, what did happen to him and how did he wind up dead at that particular location? For this month’s first Halloween-themed episode of “The Path Went Chilly, we will be travelling to the United Kingdom to explore one of the strangest mysteries we’re ever covered.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Godfrey
http://www.bbc.co.uk/insideout/yorkslincs/series2/ufo_alien_abduction_yorkshire_pennine_sighting_adamski_mystery.shtml
https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/unsolved-baffling-case-missing-miner-14150127
http://www.thedefectivespodcast.uk/blog
Close Encounters of the Fatal Kind” by Nick Redfern
“Acknowledged: A Perspective on UFOs, Aliens and Crop Circles” by Andrew Johnson
“The Book of Ghosts, UFOs and the Unexplained” by James Paton
Shannon Green and Dewayne Bell Pt. 2
2026/10/01
July 6, 1986. Owensboro, Kentucky. 16-year old Shannon Green disappears after leaving her residence to visit a family friend. Days later, Shannon’s mother receives a phone call from someone calling himself “Dewayne”, who claims that he and Shannon ran away together to get married. Shortly thereafter, an 18-year old acquaintance of Shannon’s named David Dewayne Bell also goes missing. A man named John Reneer eventually provides the authorities with a tape of a recording in which Dewayne seemingly confesses to murder. Allegations surface that Dewayne killed Shannon and his father helped him cover the whole up, but if so, what actually happened to Dewayne? Could someone have been responsible for the disappearances of both victims? On this week’s episode of “The Path Went Chilly”, we explore a convoluted saga involving two unsolved missing persons cases from the same town and their alleged connection to each other.If you have any information about the featured cases, please contact the Owensboro Police Department at (270) 687-8888.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Additional Reading:
https://charleyproject.org/case/shannon-rena-green
https://charleyproject.org/case/david-dewayne-bell
https://www.14news.com/story/4067371/14-news-investigates-killer-confession
https://www.14news.com/story/4058011/stefanie-silvey-investigatesowensboro-mystery/
https://www.14news.com/story/4138121/stefanie-silvey-investigates-the-other-side
https://www.14news.com/story/4061386/stefanie-silvey-investigatescaught-on-tape
https://www.14news.com/story/8250791/unsolved-murders-angie-dickens-shannon-green-and-dewayne-bell/
https://echoespath.com/shannon-rena-
green/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/382454414/https://www.newspapers.com/image/381928714/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/381928739/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/381929350/https://www.newspapers.com/image/381929358/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/382197728/https://www.newspapers.com/image/382197748
Shannon Green and Dewayne Bell Pt. One
2026/09/24
July 6, 1986. Owensboro, Kentucky. 16-year old Shannon Green disappears after leaving her residence to visit a family friend. Days later, Shannon’s mother receives a phone call from someone calling himself “Dewayne”, who claims that he and Shannon ran away together to get married. Shortly thereafter, an 18-year old acquaintance of Shannon’s named David Dewayne Bell also goes missing. A man named John Reneer eventually provides the authorities with a tape of a recording in which Dewayne seemingly confesses to murder. Allegations surface that Dewayne killed Shannon and his father helped him cover the whole up, but if so, what actually happened to Dewayne? Could someone have been responsible for the disappearances of both victims? On this week’s episode of “The Path Went Chilly”, we explore a convoluted saga involving two unsolved missing persons cases from the same town and their alleged connection to each other.If you have any information about the featured cases, please contact the Owensboro Police Department at (270) 687-8888.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Additional Reading:
https://charleyproject.org/case/shannon-rena-green
https://charleyproject.org/case/david-dewayne-bell
https://www.14news.com/story/4067371/14-news-investigates-killer-confession
https://www.14news.com/story/4058011/stefanie-silvey-investigatesowensboro-mystery/
https://www.14news.com/story/4138121/stefanie-silvey-investigates-the-other-side
https://www.14news.com/story/4061386/stefanie-silvey-investigatescaught-on-tape
https://www.14news.com/story/8250791/unsolved-murders-angie-dickens-shannon-green-and-dewayne-bell/
https://echoespath.com/shannon-rena-
green/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/382454414/https://www.newspapers.com/image/381928714/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/381928739/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/381929350/https://www.newspapers.com/image/381929358/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/382197728/https://www.newspapers.com/image/382197748
Amy Wroe Betchel Pt. Two
2026/09/17
July 24, 1997. Fremont County, Wyoming. After spending the day running errands, 24-year old Amy Wroe Bechtel never returns home and her abandoned car is discovered on a remote road in Shoshone National Forest. Even though he claims to have an alibi, Amy’s husband, Steve Bechtel, is looked at as a potential suspect by law enforcement, due to his unwillingness to take a polygraph test. However, the investigation eventually focuses on convicted murderer Dale Wayne Eaton, who was supposedly in the area when Amy went missing, but there is no evidence to implicate him and no trace of Amy is ever found. On this week’s episode of “The Path Went Chilly”, we explore the puzzling disappearance of Amy Wroe Bechtel, who has continued to remain a missing person for the past 26 years. If you have any information about this case, please contact the Fremont County Sheriff’s Office at (307) 332-5611.
Support the Show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Amy_Wroe_Bechtel
http://charleyproject.org/case/amy-joy-wroe-bechtelhttps://www.outsideonline.com/1829016/long-gone
http://www.runnersworld.com/runners-stories/long-gone-girlhttp://people.com/archive/into-thin-air-vol-49-no-11/
https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/wyoming/sheriff-believes-amy-wroe-bechtel-was-victim-of-killer/article_5c2b29d9-de5f-54b9-b0cb-a93aff383668.html
https://trib.com/news/state-and-regional/amy-wroe-bechtel-case-timeline/article_f289eca2-a639-5a75-a565-814f41b5249c.html
https://trib.com/news/state-and-regional/officials-killer-said-to-camp-where-wroe-bechtel-vanished-in-wyoming/article_5048323d-d60c-5e4f-ba60-e3536f0701b1.html
https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Amy_Wroe_Bechte
Amy Wroe Betchel Pt. One
2026/09/10
July 24, 1997. Fremont County, Wyoming. After spending the day running errands, 24-year old Amy Wroe Bechtel never returns home and her abandoned car is discovered on a remote road in Shoshone National Forest. Even though he claims to have an alibi, Amy’s husband, Steve Bechtel, is looked at as a potential suspect by law enforcement, due to his unwillingness to take a polygraph test. However, the investigation eventually focuses on convicted murderer Dale Wayne Eaton, who was supposedly in the area when Amy went missing, but there is no evidence to implicate him and no trace of Amy is ever found. On this week’s episode of “The Path Went Chilly”, we explore the puzzling disappearance of Amy Wroe Bechtel, who has continued to remain a missing person for the past 26 years. If you have any information about this case, please contact the Fremont County Sheriff’s Office at (307) 332-5611.
Support the Show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Amy_Wroe_Bechtel
http://charleyproject.org/case/amy-joy-wroe-bechtelhttps://www.outsideonline.com/1829016/long-gone
http://www.runnersworld.com/runners-stories/long-gone-girlhttp://people.com/archive/into-thin-air-vol-49-no-11/
https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/wyoming/sheriff-believes-amy-wroe-bechtel-was-victim-of-killer/article_5c2b29d9-de5f-54b9-b0cb-a93aff383668.html
https://trib.com/news/state-and-regional/amy-wroe-bechtel-case-timeline/article_f289eca2-a639-5a75-a565-814f41b5249c.html
https://trib.com/news/state-and-regional/officials-killer-said-to-camp-where-wroe-bechtel-vanished-in-wyoming/article_5048323d-d60c-5e4f-ba60-e3536f0701b1.html
https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Amy_Wroe_Bechte
Holly Staker Pt. Two
2026/09/03
August 17, 1992. Waukegan, Illinois. While babysitting two children, 11-year old Holly Staker is sexually assaulted and brutally murdered inside their apartment. Two months later, a suspect named Juan Rivera is brought in for questioning and confesses to the murder after four straight days of interrogation. He is subsequently convicted and receives a life sentence, but no physical evidence links Rivera to the crime and the veracity of his confession is called into question. After Rivera serves 19 years in prison, DNA evidence eventually links Holly’s death to another murder… but could another innocent person also be serving time in prison for that particular crime?
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juan_Rivera_(wrongful_conviction)https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Pages/casedetail.aspx?caseid=3850
https://courts.illinois.gov/opinions/AppellateCourt/2011/2ndDistrict/December/2091060.pdf
http://www.law.northwestern.edu/legalclinic/wrongfulconvictions/exonerations/documents/rivera_brief.pdf
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-06-10/news/chi-dna-links-murder-and-rape-of-holly-staker-11-to-second-murder-8-years-later-20140610_1_holly-staker-dna-evidence-dna-match
Holly Staker Pt. One
2026/08/27
August 17, 1992. Waukegan, Illinois. While babysitting two children, 11-year old Holly Staker is sexually assaulted and brutally murdered inside their apartment. Two months later, a suspect named Juan Rivera is brought in for questioning and confesses to the murder after four straight days of interrogation. He is subsequently convicted and receives a life sentence, but no physical evidence links Rivera to the crime and the veracity of his confession is called into question. After Rivera serves 19 years in prison, DNA evidence eventually links Holly’s death to another murder… but could another innocent person also be serving time in prison for that particular crime?
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juan_Rivera_(wrongful_conviction)https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Pages/casedetail.aspx?caseid=3850
https://courts.illinois.gov/opinions/AppellateCourt/2011/2ndDistrict/December/2091060.pdf
http://www.law.northwestern.edu/legalclinic/wrongfulconvictions/exonerations/documents/rivera_brief.pdf
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-06-10/news/chi-dna-links-murder-and-rape-of-holly-staker-11-to-second-murder-8-years-later-20140610_1_holly-staker-dna-evidence-dna-match
Patreon Summer Sampler: Elizabeth Campbell
2026/08/26
Join us for our last installment of our Patreon Summer Sampler, we hope you sign up for our Patreon and have been enjoying these episodes.
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
April 25, 1988. Copperas Cove, Texas. After an argument with her boyfriend, 20-year old college student Elizabeth Campbell storms out of his house and receives a ride to a convenience store. After phoning her boyfriend and making an unsuccessful attempt to convince him to pick her up, Elizabeth vanishes without a trace. Over the next few weeks, there would be multiple sightings of a woman resembling Elizabeth in the company of a possessive man, leading to speculation that she was being controlled by a pimp. Was Elizabeth abducted and murdered, or was she actually kept alive and forced into prostitution?
Additional Reading:
http://unsolved.com/archives/elizabeth-campbell
http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/c/campbell_elizabeth.htmlhttps://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Elizabeth_Campbell
Nyleen Kay Marshall Pt. Two
2026/08/20
June 25, 1983. Jefferson County, Montana. While attending a picnic with her family in Helena National Forest, four-year old Nyleen Kay Marshall goes off to play with some other children until she vanishes without a trace. An extensive search of the forest fails to find her, but other kids report having seen an unidentified man in a jogging suit speaking to Nyleen shortly before she went missing. Over two years later, the authorities receive a series of anonymous letters and phone calls from a man who claims to be raising Nyleen, but he is never identified and Nyleen cannot be found. Was Nyleen Kay Marshall actually the victim of a stranger abduction and, if so, who was responsible? On this week’s episode of “The Path Went Chilly”, we explore a disturbing unsolved missing children’s case which has featured a number of surprising twists and turns these past four decades. If you have any information about this case, please contact the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office at (406) 225-4075.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Additional Reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Nyleen_Marshallhttps://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Nyleen_Marshall
https://charleyproject.org/case/nyleen-kay-marshallhttps://lostnfoundblogs.com/f/nyleen-kay-marshall-statistic-or-sadistic
https://www.newspapers.com/image/393478114/https://www.newspapers.com/image/393478143/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/405882338/https://www.newspapers.com/image/394181486/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/526972062/https://www.newspapers.com/image/526972802/
https://www.newspapers.com/image/409663551/
https://www.kxlh.com/news/2017/02/07/cold-case-what-happened-to-nyleen-marshall/
https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Monica_Bonilla
Patreon Summer Sampler: Patricia Meehan
2026/08/16
The latest episode in our Patreon Summer Sampler:
April 20, 1989. Circle, Montana. While driving on the wrong side of a rural highway, 37-year old Patricia Meehan gets into a collision with another car. After staring blankly at the vehicle’s driver, Patricia walks out onto the prairie and disappears. During the next few months, there would be numerous sightings of a disoriented-woman resembling Patricia. This leads to speculation that the trauma of the car crash caused Patricia to develop amnesia and forget who she was, but she is ultimately never found.
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
Podcast reviews
Read The Path Went Chilly podcast reviews
mrsrouleau 2026/11/13
Just can’t handle Jules anymore
As much as I respect Robin and love TTWC I just can’t stand Jules. She never offers new commentary instead just reiterating what Robin has said.
MTLogic 2026/08/09
Great podcast!
This is a discussion style podcast, which I don’t usually enjoy. But this team does an amazing job discussing these cases. It is one of the most respe...
Ako629 2026/07/31
Love this group and sending so much love to Jules
I’m so sorry to hear the news, Jules and I hope Ash returns soon. Sending you ladies love and thinking of you 💜
the trail went cold fan 2026/07/29
Cheers to the hosts
Long time listener and I enjoy listening to the plus extras on the Ttwc Patreon page. Jules and Ashley mix well with Robin. I enjoy their personal...
SuperBlargle 2026/06/04
Love it overall
I think this is a great companion to The Trail Went Cold. I will say I am sometimes taken aback by Dr Wellman’s frequent comments about adults as babi...
Frangen10 2026/04/10
Great show
Love the show. However, regarding the Misty Murphy case…..No, the parents were not selfless by adopting her. They probably put their own two children ...
Rocking Rick 8185 2025/09/08
Female Hosts Make The Podcast More About Them Than The Subject Podcast
The Karyn Kupcinet podcast was made difficult to listen to as the two female hosts described their experiences while modeling. Forget the subject of t...
Luzimm 2025/05/31
Very professional podcast
I wish they would respond to emails, especially when you have much more to offer regarding a certain case. I’ve written to them several times with no ...
Wigwolf 2025/05/19
Me like
I love the hosts and the subject matter. Great companion to the Trail Went Cold.
Digging4tresure 2025/05/07
This is amazing
I love this podcast it’s really good and I love all three hosts
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on The Path Went Chilly relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.713055379
The Tim Dillon Show
The Tim Dillon Show

4.116097472
The Tucker Carlson Show
Tucker Carlson Network

4.828116459
Huberman Lab
Scicomm Media

4.240683
To Be The Man
Podcast Heat | Cumulus Podcast Network

4.41511762000
The Ben Shapiro Show
The Daily Wire

4.2155648
TENNIS.com Podcast
TENNIS.com Podcast/Tennis Channel Podcast Network

4.510882780
The Joe Budden Podcast
The Joe Budden Network

4.611699506
The Bulwark Podcast
The Bulwark

4.711532393
Matt and Shane's Secret Podcast
Matt McCusker & Shane Gillis

4.72580183
Smosh Reads Reddit Stories
Smosh