Advertise on podcast: Five on Three

On this season-opening episode of "Five on Three", Sophia Smith, Emma Leonardi, Lydia Pirner, Grace McCarron, and Tucker Austin break down the opening handful of games for the Rangers, Islanders, and Devils to kick off the 2026-27 season. The crew touches on the Rangers scoring goals at home (including Igor Shesterkin) and the Isles manhandling the Devils on Long Island. Plus: Tucker starts an argument about Jack Hughes' importance to the Devils success.

On this season finale edition of Five on Three, Grace McCarron, Tucker Austin, and Emma Leonardi break down recent moves from the Rangers, Islanders, and Devils and look ahead to next season. Later, the crew give their thoughts on the Capitals resigning Alex Ovechkin, the Leo Carlsson offer sheet situation, and Connor Bedard's recent shoulder surgery.

On this week's episode of "Five on Three", Tucker Austin, Lydia Pirner, and Grace McCarron break down the Hurricane's cup-clinching Game 6 shutout victory, Jordan Staal's Conn Smythe win, and the future for our NYC-area teams dealing with a new top-dog in the Eastern Conference.

On this week's episode of Five on Three, Tucker Austin, Sophia Smith, and Emma Leonardi look back at what surprised them most in the Stanley Cup Playoffs, break down the first four games of the Final between Carolina and Vegas, give predictions for Game 5 and the rest of the series, as well as provide their takes on Dylan Larkin's request to be traded out of Detroit.

In this episode of Five on Three, Emma Leonardi, Trey Rodriguez and Abby Cristofaro break down the NHL draft lottery results, rounds one and two of the playoffs, and breaking news on the IIHF Canadian World team roster and the Hart trophy nominees.

On this week's episode of "Five on Three", Tucker Austin, Sophia Smith, Emma Leonardi, and Grace McCarron break down all the first round series in this year's Stanley Cup playoffs in progress and give updated predictions for which teams will move on to round two. They also touch on Sunny Mehta's introduction as the next General Manager of the New Jersey Devils.

On this week's episode of "Five on Three", Lydia Pirner, Grace McCarron, Sophia Smith, and Tucker Austin take a moment to remember the Islanders, Devils, and Rangers, who all miss the playoffs together for the first time since the Devils joined the NHL. The crew also lend their thoughts on the first round of the 2026 Stanley Cup Playoffs and give their predictions for which team can win it all.

In this episode of "Five on Three", Trey Rodriguez, Sophia Smith, Felicity Schlosser, and Ethan Bess discuss the Islanders and the upcoming Stanley Cup Playoffs. While also analyzing the Stanley Cup Playoffs, they give their predictions on who will make the Stanley Cup Final and who will get the final wild card spot in the East and West.

On this week's episode of "Five on Three", Grace McCarron, Abby Cristofaro, and Emma Leonardi give their thoughts on the Vegas Golden Knights making a late season change at head coach before checking in on the now-eliminated New York Rangers, the barely still alive New Jersey Devils, and the New York Islanders holding onto a playoff spot with the hardest remaining schedule in the NHL.

On this week's edition of Five on Three, Sophia Smith, Lydia Pirner, and Dominic Sansone, discuss the lack of playoff participation in the Tri-State area, the drastic differences in the Eastern and Western Conference races, and the Sabres still being on a heater.

On this week's episode of Five on Three, Grace McCarron, Sophia Smith, and Tucker Austin check in on the NYC-area squads, give their thoughts on the latest Radko Gudas incident, break down the Oilers' playoff chances with the injury to Draisaitl, and more.

In this episode of Five on Three, Emma Leonardi, Tucker Austin, and Grace McCarron discuss Olympic play thus far as we wait for quarterfinal results!

Trey Rodriguez, Max Spitza, and Abby Cristofaro discuss the upcoming Olympics, the Gavin McKenna assault case, and the typical tri-state teams drama. Max gets incredibly heated talking about his Rangers after the Panarin trade, and Trey commits treason and declares his support for Macklin Celebrini's Team Canada.

In this episode of Five on Three, Sophia Smith, Grace McCarron, Trey Rodriguez and Faris Amin break down the Islanders' series sweep of the Rangers, as well as some recent Metro trades. They also check in on the league standings in the runup to the Olympics.

On this week's episode of Five On Three, Tucker Austin, Lydia Pirner, and Dom Sansone recap the NHL standings and the Sabres new life, along with where that leaves the Islanders and Devils. And, oh yeah... that letter, again.