Advertise on podcast: Stories Still to Tell

Mothman is the Chad of cryptids

"Let's get to the bottom of this: did you stick googly eyes on a radioactive rock?" We finally get an answer to what happened at Falcon Lake

In episode two of our series on the Falcon Lake incident, we catch back up with Michalak in the immediate aftermath of his encounter. The story breaks, and his life is ruined. People call him a liar, but he thinks he can prove them wrong. He just needs to find the evidence first...

This week we dive into Canada's most infamous UFO encounter - the Falcon Lake incident. In May 1967, Stephen (Stefen) Michilak encountered two strange crafts, that ended in him getting burned on his chest. This week we talk about the encounter itself, and why this might be the most believable case of all time. 

This is by far the worst year we've covered yet. We've got riots, the war in Vietnam, and a small town in Wisconsin seceding from the United States and declaring war on the country - yes, you read that right. We also have expanded our year coverage to explore some of the most intriguing true crime cases as they happened. Also, Creed won a Grammy in 2001 for Best Rock Song for their hit "With Arms Wide Open."

First off, sorry for the long absence! We explain it all in this episode. This week, we've got a short story episode where Greg describes how he paid money to solve a murder while telling the story of a missing man going all the way back to 1966. Hope you packed your swim trunks, cause we're going to Miami!

The underbelly of Great Bend, Kansas runs deep - and it's all controlled by the...square dance society? Sebastian and Greg do their best Hardy Boys impression and try to solve this case. FYI if another man is banging your wife, it's generally a bad sign. Also, maybe it's a good idea to have a pathologist that doesn't cite picture books as part of his "expertise." F E A R  T H E  P U M P E R P.S. Thx 4 all tha reviewz :* ^_^

1966 was super sick. Inflation? Through the roof. Civil rights? Yup, people are still getting murdered for it. Vietnam? How about a quarter of a million boys getting sent over? But hey, the Chicago Bulls were created and hippie culture started around now! This episode we'll talk about how hard it is for women to date, all the best true crime cases of the year - including spree killers and an unsolved murder, LSD, and the great state of Kansas before getting into our case for the year.

 In 1965, a horror house that went beyond even the darkest of your imagination existed, and a group of neighborhood kids decide to participate. You are really going to hate us after this episode :( But we offer our sincerest Indiana Thank You in return for your listenership :) Special Indiana Thank You's to anyone who has reviewed us! It's the easiest way for us to get feedback on what you think and for us to grow. You're the best!

1965 ended up being a pretty important year. From the Civil Rights movement to a further escalating war in Vietnam, the political landscape in the United States was certainly tumultuous. Meanwhile, the Beatles continued to get knuckle deep into American pop culture, while the worst show of all time debuted on NBC. Seriously though, do submarines come up for air? Sebastian and Greg answer all your questions (while also coming up with a TV show idea of our own) as we break down the year 1965 before we get into the case next episode. Special thanks to anyone who has reviewed us! Seriously, it means more than you could imagine :) All the platforms we publish on heavily rely on the A L G O R I T H M overlords, and reviews are what feed it, so thank you again!

Welcome to 1964. The day after the Cleveland Browns win the NFL Championship, a brutal scene is discovered that leaves cops so startled they have to bring in the big city cops. There are creeps lurking in suburban Cleveland, but you already knew that didn't you? Just be sure to lock your doors...

It's another hard-hitting episode, as Sebastian and Greg discuss: poetry, skyjackings, is 9/11 funny, Beatlemania, a handful of murders, the best Christmas movies, and more before we get into the case for 1964!