
Advertise on podcast: Crosstown Cardboard
Rating
4.8from
This podcast has
115 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
Carmine Gerrity-GemeiExplicit
No
Date created
2022/10/05
Latest episode
2026/08/04
Average duration
54 min.
Release period
53 days
Description
Craig and Carmine grew up on opposites sides, crosstown, of New York City and met through making a deal on some cardboard. These two former D3 athletes share sports card stories from the perspective of a high school teacher and sports broadcaster. Those stories involve the cards themselves, what they mean to all of us and the connections they allow us to make. Craig's IG: @newyorkcitysportscards Carmine's IG: @carminescards YouTube: Crosstown Cardboard
Unlock Crosstown Cardboard podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Crosstown Cardboard podcast
Ep. 116: 2026 National Recap
2026/08/04
Craig and Carmine share highlight stories, people, cards and tickets from The 46th National Sports Collectors Convention and break down Carmine's finances from his first time setting up as a dealer at the biggest card show in the world.
Our two guys explain the deals allowing them to bring home Exquisite PC additions and have interesting hobby opinions from the sports card extravaganza.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 115: Celebrating Hobby Championships
2026/07/20
Craig and Carmine celebrate huge wins including the birth of Craig's son and how that's affected his hobbying, the Knicks title and its impact on their Knicks collections, Fanatics Fest first-hand recap, and prep for The National which will be Carmine's first time setting up as a dealer at the hobby Super Bowl.
These two get back on the mic like they never left while sharing sports card stories, market trends they've noticed at recent shows, and new PC additions along the way after 11 months since their last episode of Crosstown Cardboard.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 114: Hobbying Around the Country
2025/08/18
Craig and Carmine share updates from recent shows across the country including Carmine's financial breakdown as a dealer in The Masters territory, how Emmitt Smith made Craig's All-National Team and the deal for Carmine's new favorite card in his entire collection.
Craig also shares the creative ways he funded the newest addition to his Knicks PC and a literally Exquisite card involving a couple GOATs.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 113: The Hobby's in a Healthy Place
2025/06/09
Craig & Carmine are back with a newly completed rainbow, a duplicate collection addition and the biggest PC acquisition in Crosstown Cardboard history.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 112: Hitting for the Hobby Cycle
2025/03/06
Craig & Carmine explain how they've recently hit singles, doubles, triples and home runs with PC cards, lot purchases and other hobby happenings while cycling through different eras of their hobby lives.
Both of them call each other out for contradictory statements on their card philosophies, Carmine goes through specific numbers on his biggest card sale ever, and Craig becomes an NYC card consultant.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 111: Cardboard Chrismukkuh
2024/12/31
Three months after hitting a 'podcast pause,' Craig and Carmine hop back on the mic to celebrate Cardboard Chrismukkah and explain their hobby happenings since the last episode.
Craig has a new part-time job in the hobby, shiny additions to his Knicks PC, an ancient pickup and new Card Club field trips.
Carmine added a couple major PC cards of all-time greats, bought a lot from another country and got a PSA return.
Great time with our guys catching up!
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 110: Podcast Pause
2024/10/02
Craig & Carmine make an important announcement about the future of Crosstown Cardboard and their reasoning behind it.
They also talk about a few of their recent moves including buying into a break, a PSA return, and a PC pickup.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 109: In Our Card Era
2024/09/25
Friend of Crosstown Cardboard Dom @TheCardFather13 explains how being a Taylor Swift fan has influenced his collecting, which includes several 4-figure Swiftie purchases.
Despite Craig not being able to join, Dom channels his inner math teacher to break down the financial numbers of investing in T-Swift cards versus quarterback cards, and he talks about his Ohio sports PC as well.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Dom's Instagram: @TheCardFather13
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 107: Handling Hobby Hype
2024/09/11
Craig & Carmine talk about how they handle hobby hype with specific examples of different players and cards as the NFL season starts up.
Carmine explains his biggest profit ever from timing the market, how it could've gone wrong, and his philosophy on investing into hype.
In classic teacher fashion, Craig provides an 'either-or' example of collection cards he has versus a hyped card that's worth the same amount.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 106: eBay is Still King
2024/09/04
Carmine accepts Craig's challenge by listing cards on eBay for the first time in months and finds out why Craig says eBay is still king.
Our two guys explain what criteria they believe makes a successful eBay card, Craig executes another fluff & stuff and gives the audience a "Thrilla in Manila."
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 105: Waiting To Be Subbed In
2024/08/28
After going on a Greek vacation and preparing for college football season, Craig & Carmine have been subbed back into the card game on a heater.
Craig explains the several moves he's made since returning to the states including designing a showcase at his local card shop, picking up a lot at Bleecker Trading and telling a collector to 'educate yourself.'
Carmine goes through his fourth-ever deal with Craig, a surprising pickup with New York flavor and a new card from a Crosstown Cardboard legend.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 104: The Fluff & Stuff
2024/08/21
Craig & Carmine go in-depth explaining 'The Fluff & Stuff' trade method, coined right here on Crosstown Cardboard, that you can take into your own hobby journey.
Craig provides concrete examples of deals in which he's used the F&S and how he searches for cards that can go from fluff into stuff.
Using purchases he made at The National, Carmine adds qualities he looks for in cards that could provide profit margin in a trade.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 103: Becoming The Plug with @bagels_and_wax
2024/08/14
Vadim, owner of @bagel_and_wax, joins Craig & Carmine to explain the old school way his NY store has become successful combining food & cards.
He also breaks down his role at The National, his favorite part of collecting with his 8-year-old son, and where he sees the retail & consumer aspects of the hobby heading in the future.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Vadim's Instagram: @bagel_and_wax
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 102: Now What?
2024/08/07
Craig & Carmine discuss what has changed and remained the same with their flipping and collecting styles moving forward after The National.
Craig explains why the trend of buying & selling downtowns and kabooms is 'basic.'
Carmine goes through 3 new PC pickups from the big show and observations he made about his own taste in cards.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Ep. 101: The National 101
2024/07/31
Craig & Carmine continue their tradition of handing out awards to influential people in their show experience by naming their 2024 All-National selections with cards connected to them.
They also give their National 101 thoughts with tips they've learned, good aspects of this year's big show and ways it could improve.
YouTube & More: https://linktr.ee/crosstowncardboard
Craig's Instagram: @newyorkcitysportscards
Carmine's Instagram: @CarminesCards
Podcast reviews
Read Crosstown Cardboard podcast reviews
Mailman matt 2024/09/11
Show for the everyday collector
This show is amazing. Two normal working joes taking over the hobby. I love that you include us in your daily collecting journeys! I look forward to e...
Triangle Sandwich 2023/08/29
USMNT
Love the pod, great combination of collectors/friends and philosophies. They do a good job of speaking towards the mentality of a collector and their ...
MyTradeMarkz 2023/01/26
A Nostalgic Cardboard Connection!
Craig and Carmine are two dope human beings, and the way they explore the hobby on multiple levels is fascinating, thought-provoking, and simply educa...
Jvgnzsablb 2023/01/04
Great addition to my card listening
Highly recommended. Great balance between collecting and business and all that makes the hobby great! The guys are relatable, candid, and personal. Yo...
Kindra's Cards 2022/11/09
Gotta add this to your schedule!
I get excited every Wednesday knowing a new episode is dropping… these guys personal take on cards is refreshing, genuine and knowledgeable. I’ve lear...
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Crosstown Cardboard relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.723181975
Timeless Wisdom with Dennis Prager
Salem Podcast Network

4.897061447
The Graham Allen Show
Graham Allen

4.920791189
Toni and Ryan
Toni Lodge and Ryan Jon

4.762632000
The Lawfare Podcast
The Lawfare Institute

4.716492000
Morning Mindset Christian Daily Devotional Bible study and prayer
Carey Green

4.8224831800
The Andrew Klavan Show
The Daily Wire

4.917101565
DarrenDaily On-Demand
Darren Hardy LLC

4.97421819
Despertando
Dudas Media

4.922991190
Dropping Bombs
Brad Lea: CEO, Entrepreneur, and Host of The Bottom Line

4.92488960
The 1000 Hours Outside Podcast
1000 Hours Outside