Advertise on podcast: Overbooked

Rating

★★★★★

4.8

from

48 reviews

Description

Welcome to Overbooked, your go-to podcast for all things literary! Longtime friends Paige and Kelsey host a book club, bringing you candid discussions on the latest releases. Whether you're a casual reader or a devoted bookworm, join us to get the scoop on which new titles deserve a spot on your nightstand. New Episodes Twice Monthly: • Book Club (with spoilers): 1st of each month • Extra Credit (spoiler-free): 15th of each month

Unlock Overbooked podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details

Email contact information

Direct podcast contact details

Listeners

Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details

Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes

Check latest episodes from Overbooked podcast

Fruit Fly

2026/10/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the September book club pick, "Fruit Fly" by Josh Silver. After being paralyzed for years by a bad case of writer's block, Mallory meets Leo and exploits his tragic story. (Spoilers begin at 8:00) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 3.5 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #43 - Phoebe Berman's Gonna Lose It

2026/09/15

It's time for another episode of Extra Credit! In this spoiler-free chat, Paige & Kelsey discuss Phoebe Berman's Gonna Lose It by Brooke Averick. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Whistler

2026/09/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the August book club pick, "Whistler" by Ann Patchett. Daphne reconnects with her step-father after 40+ years, unlocking a history of memories. (Spoilers begin at 10:00) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 4.75 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #42 - Into the Blue (with Emily Indigo!)

2026/08/15

Extra Credit returns with a spoiler-free discussion of Emma Brodie's novel, Into the Blue. Join hosts Paige and Kelsey as they dive into this epic love story, accompanied by special guest Emily (@emilyindigo.books)! Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Yesteryear

2026/08/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the July book club pick, "Yesteryear" by Caro Claire Burke! A tradwife influencer wakes up one day in 1855, forced to live the "traditional" pioneer life that she performs on social media. (Spoilers begin at 14:00) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 4.125 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #41 - Chit Chat!

2026/07/15

It's time for another episode of Extra Credit! In this spoiler-free chat, Paige & Kelsey catch up on the books they've read and the shows they've watched in the first half of 2026. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Dogs, Boys, and Other Things I've Cried About

2026/07/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the June book club pick, "Dogs, Boys, and Other Things I've Cried About" by Isabel Klee! This memoir follows a young woman's journey to find love and the rescue dogs she fosters along the way. (Spoilers begin at 8:30) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 2.625 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #40 - Strangers (with Lit Club NYC!)

2026/06/15

Extra Credit returns with a spoiler-free discussion of Belle Burden's novel, Strangers: A Memoir of Marriage. Join hosts Paige and Kelsey as they dive into this chilling true story, accompanied by special guest Kelly - founder of Lit Club NYC. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Mad Mabel

2026/06/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the May book club pick, "Mad Mabel" by Sally Hepworth! When a neighbor dies, Elsie is forced to confront her childhood history filled with mysterious deaths. (Spoilers begin at 10:30) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 1.875 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #39 - The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion

2026/05/15

It's time for another episode of Extra Credit! In this spoiler-free chat, Paige & Kelsey discuss The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion series by Beth Brower. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Theo of Golden

2026/05/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the April book club pick, "Theo of Golden" by Allen Levi! Theo moves to the town of Golden and integrates himself in the community with a mysterious gift giving scheme. (Spoilers begin at 12:30) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 2.25 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #38 - Culpability

2026/04/15

It's time for another episode of Extra Credit! In this spoiler-free chat, Paige & Kelsey discuss Bruce Holsinger's novel, Culpability. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Half His Age

2026/04/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the March book club pick, "Half His Age" by Jennette McCurdy! Waldo forms an unlikely and passionate connection with her high school creative writing teacher. (Spoilers begin at 11:00) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 3 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Extra Credit #37 - Heated Rivalry (Book vs. TV Show)

2026/03/15

It's time for another episode of Extra Credit! In this spoiler-free chat, Paige & Kelsey discuss both Rachel Reid's novel, Heated Rivalry, and the HBO Max adaptation. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Heart the Lover

2026/03/01

Tune in to hear Paige & Kelsey discuss the February book club pick, "Heart the Lover" by Lily King! Casey is caught in a college love triangle between best friends, Sam & Yash. (Spoilers begin at 7:45) OFFICIAL OVERBOOKED RATING: 4.625 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @overbooked_pod

Podcast reviews

Read Overbooked podcast reviews

4.8 out of 5

48 reviews

★★★★★

TGlasgow92 2026/10/01

Book Club

I love listening to Paige and Kelsey discuss books. Their format really helps listeners dive into the book of the month and get a deeper appreciation ...

★★☆☆☆

1967cla 2026/08/24

Childish

I could not get past the one girl having the put on vocal fry. That, plus her immature take on book were a real turn off to me. She sounded very unin...

★★★★★

EmmyEH 2026/02/05

Great New Listen

Love this podcast !!! They cover something for everyone and are so knowledgeable and engaging. Meant to host !

★★★★★

lhn613 2025/10/25

Excellent

This is my favorite book podcast, by far. Great discussions, vibes are always immaculate.

★★★★★

EmMyers1025 2025/10/23

My favorite book podcast

I’ve listened to a handful of book podcasts and this one is my absolute favorite. Every episode I feel like I’m just sitting down with my friends just...

★★★★★

Stasha12 2025/10/23

A 5 star podcast

I love everything about this podcast. The dynamic of Paige and Kelsey is my favorite part. They were born for this and the way they structure their re...

★★★★★

Cavvmich 2025/10/23

Book club in your ears!

Love Overbooked! Such a fun podcast! Love this duo, they give honest reviews of their reads and it feels like attending your favorite book club!

★★★★★

SR Clar 2025/08/13

Fun to Listen To

I love this show! Paige and Kelsey’s analysis is fun and often funny, and I find myself nodding my head a lot. I like the way they break down their ra...

★★★★★

HellKitty11 2025/02/11

Fun conversations for book lovers

Love reading with these Gals. We don’t always love the same books (but often we do!) and I like the casual book club vibe.

★★★★★

Elizabeth Norman 2025/02/10

Best Book Club Award Goes to…

I am a member of a few book clubs, but dare I say Overbooked is the best?! The thoughtful commentary, honest opinions, and personalities of Paige and ...

check all reviews on apple podcasts