
Advertise on podcast: Extinguished
Rating
1.5from
This podcast has
68 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
McClam/HumphreyExplicit
No
Date created
2023/10/12
Latest episode
2026/09/01
Average duration
19 min.
Release period
23 days
Description
Join us for this long form podcast about the murdered and missing. Long form because we will do one case in 4 weeks. Make sure to tune in each and every week so you do not miss an episode of the case.
Unlock Extinguished podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Extinguished podcast
The Disappearance of Dennis Lloyd Martin
2026/09/01
On June 14, 1969, six-year-old Dennis Lloyd Martin vanished during a Father’s Day weekend camping trip in Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Dennis was only six days away from his seventh birthday when he disappeared near Spence Field, a remote mountain meadow located along the Appalachian Trail. More than five decades later, no confirmed trace of him has ever been found.
Dennis had traveled into the mountains with his father, grandfather, older brother, and other family members. Camping in the Smokies had become a family tradition, and there was nothing unusual about the outing until a playful plan among the children turned into one of the most enduring missing-child mysteries in American history. Dennis and several other boys intended to hide and surprise the adults. The other children returned, but Dennis did not.
His father began looking for him almost immediately. What began as a family search quickly expanded into a massive operation involving park rangers, law-enforcement agencies, volunteers, military personnel, trackers, and experienced outdoorsmen. Approximately 1,400 people ultimately participated, making it the largest search effort in the history of Great Smoky Mountains National Park.
The search was complicated by heavy rain, fog, steep terrain, dense vegetation, swollen streams, and the sheer number of people moving through the area. Searchers covered miles of unforgiving wilderness, yet they found no definitive clothing, remains, or physical evidence explaining what happened to Dennis. The unsuccessful operation later influenced changes in the National Park Service’s approach to missing-person searches.
In this episode, we examine the circumstances surrounding Dennis’s disappearance, the immediate response from his family, and the enormous search that followed. We also consider the questions that have persisted for decades, including whether Dennis became lost in the wilderness, suffered an accident or animal encounter, or was taken from the park.
One of the most debated elements of the case involves a family visiting another area of the park who reportedly heard a disturbing scream and later saw a rough-looking man moving through the woods with something draped over his shoulder. The sighting occurred several miles from Spence Field, and investigators were never able to establish that it was connected to Dennis. Nevertheless, it has continued to fuel the possibility that Dennis may have encountered another person after leaving his family’s sight.
Dennis’s father reportedly believed his son had been abducted. Others involved in the search believed that Dennis may have become disoriented and succumbed to exposure in the vast wilderness. Neither explanation has ever been proven, and the lack of physical evidence has allowed speculation and competing theories to surround the case for more than 57 years.
Dennis remains listed as missing through the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children. His age-progressed image shows what he might look like as an adult, but behind that image remains the little boy last seen wearing a red shirt, green trousers, and low-cut shoes during what should have been a joyful family weekend. Anyone with information is asked to contact the National Park Service or submit a tip through the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children.
Dennis Lloyd Martin was a child, a son, a brother, and a deeply loved member of his family. His disappearance is more than a wilderness mystery or a piece of national park history. It is the story of a family that left the mountains without one of its children and never received a definitive answer about where he went.
Listen as we revisit the disappearance of Dennis Lloyd Martin, the search that mobilized more than a thousand people, the theories that continue to divide those familiar with the case, and the unanswered questions still lingering in the Great Smoky Mountains.
If you have information concerning the disappearance of Dennis Lloyd Martin, contact the National Park Service at 865-436-1230 or the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at 1-800-THE-LOST.
Please follow, subscribe, rate, and share this episode. Sharing missing-person cases keeps their names and faces in front of the public and may reach someone who has information they have never previously reported.
Episode topics: Dennis Lloyd Martin, Great Smoky Mountains National Park, Spence Field, missing children, national park disappearances, unsolved disappearances, cold cases, search and rescue, missing-person investigations, Appalachian Trail mysteries, Tennessee missing persons, and wilderness cases.
The Disappearance of Asha Degree: What Happened on Highway 18?
2026/08/24
On February 14, 2000, nine-year-old Asha Jaquilla Degree disappeared from her home near Shelby, North Carolina, beginning one of the most haunting missing-child investigations in the United States.
Asha shared a bedroom with her older brother. According to the FBI's reconstruction of that night, her father checked on the children at approximately 2:30 a.m. and found them asleep. Around 6:30 that morning, Asha's mother went to wake the children for school and discovered that Asha was gone. There were no obvious signs of forced entry. Investigators would later determine that Asha's book bag and some of her belongings were missing as well, leading authorities to believe she had packed before leaving the house.
What happened next has puzzled investigators for more than twenty-six years.
Multiple motorists reported seeing a young girl walking south along North Carolina Highway 18 at approximately 4:00 a.m. One witness reportedly became concerned enough to turn around and check on her, but the child left the roadway and disappeared into the woods before the driver could reach her. Investigators have described these sightings as credible and believe the girl was Asha.
The circumstances seem almost impossible to understand. Asha was nine years old. It was dark, early on a February morning, and she was walking along a rural highway away from home. Why did she leave? Was she meeting someone? Had someone convinced her to leave? Was the person who ultimately became responsible for her disappearance already waiting for her, or did Asha encounter that person after she was on the road?
Investigators have never publicly established why Asha left her home.
More than a year later, on August 3, 2001, construction workers approximately thirty miles north of where Asha was last seen discovered her book bag. The discovery created another enduring mystery. Inside the bag were items that did not belong to Asha, including a New Kids on the Block T-shirt and a copy of the Dr. Seuss book McElligot's Pool that had come from the library at Asha's elementary school. Investigators later released information about those objects in hopes that someone would recognize them and explain how they came to be inside Asha's belongings.
Another potentially important lead emerged when investigators announced that someone matching Asha's description may have been seen getting into a distinctive older vehicle along Highway 18. Authorities described it as a dark green 1970s-model Lincoln Continental Mark IV or Ford Thunderbird, possibly with rust around the wheel wells.
For decades, Asha's family has refused to give up on finding her. Neither have investigators. The Cleveland County Sheriff's Office, FBI and North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation have continued working the case, and the FBI has emphasized that Asha's disappearance was never simply placed on a shelf and forgotten.
Then, in September 2024, the case took a dramatic turn.
Law enforcement executed multiple search warrants at properties associated with members of the Dedmon family in Cleveland County and surrounding areas. The warrants revealed previously undisclosed details about the investigation and demonstrated that investigators were pursuing a specific new direction nearly twenty-five years after Asha vanished.
Those developments generated enormous public interest, but they also require caution. A search warrant is an investigative tool, not a conviction, and allegations contained within warrant materials should not be confused with proven facts. As of this episode, Asha's disappearance remains unresolved, and the existence of investigative interest in particular people or properties does not establish criminal responsibility.
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey examine the disappearance of Asha Degree from the beginning: the final hours inside the Degree home, the Highway 18 sightings, the mysterious book bag, the unexplained items found inside it, the possible vehicle sighting, the decades of investigative work and the developments that brought renewed national attention to the case.
David and LaDonna also confront the question at the center of everything: what could make a nine-year-old child leave the safety of her home in the middle of a February night?
Was Asha planning an adventure known only to her? Had someone been communicating with her without her parents knowing? Was she expecting to meet someone? Did something happen after she began walking Highway 18 that changed the course of the night entirely? And after more than a quarter-century, could the evidence investigators are pursuing finally explain what happened to the little girl known in her community as "Shelby's Sweetheart"?
Behind every theory is a family that has spent more than twenty-six years without Asha.
Asha was not born to become the subject of a mystery. She was a fourth grader who loved basketball, played with her brother and was remembered by those who knew her as happy, friendly and eager to make others happy. She was nine years old when the world last saw her, and somewhere between her bedroom and Highway 18, something happened that has kept her from coming home ever since.
Someone may still know why.
If you have information concerning the disappearance of Asha Degree, contact the Cleveland County Sheriff's Office at 704-484-4822 or the FBI at 1-800-CALL-FBI. Information may also be submitted to the FBI online. Tips can be provided anonymously.
Extinguished is hosted by David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey and examines missing-person cases, unsolved murders and the lives behind cases that should never be forgotten.
If you have information about Asha Degree, please contact law enforcement rather than approaching or publicly accusing individuals associated with the investigation.
The Murder of Nona Dirksmeyer
2026/06/18
In December 2005, nineteen-year-old college student Nona Dirksmeyer was found brutally murdered inside her apartment in Russellville, Arkansas. What followed was one of the most controversial and debated homicide investigations in Arkansas history.
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey examine the life of Nona Dirksmeyer, the events leading up to her murder, and the years of investigations, prosecutions, and courtroom battles that failed to deliver justice. Listeners will hear the complicated timeline of the case, the scrutiny surrounding Nona's boyfriend Kevin Jones, the evidence that led to his arrest and eventual acquittal, and the later investigation into Gary Dunn, whose DNA was linked to the crime scene but whose prosecutions ended in mistrials.
The case remains unsolved nearly two decades later, leaving behind lingering questions, divided opinions, and a family still searching for answers. Was the wrong suspect targeted in the beginning? Did investigators miss critical opportunities? Or does the truth remain buried somewhere within the evidence that has been debated for years?
More importantly, this episode remembers the victim at the center of the story. Nona was more than a headline. She was a daughter, a student, a volunteer, and a young woman with dreams, ambitions, and a future that was stolen from her.
Join us as we explore one of Arkansas's most haunting unsolved murders and discuss why the pursuit of truth continues even when the courtroom fails to provide answers.
Topics Covered• The life and background of Nona Dirksmeyer
• The discovery of the crime scene
• The investigation into Kevin Jones
• Evidence presented at trial
• Kevin Jones' acquittal
• The emergence of Gary Dunn as a suspect
• DNA evidence and forensic controversies
• Multiple mistrials and dismissed charges
• Why the case remains unsolved
• The lasting impact on Nona's family and community
About ExtinguishedExtinguished is hosted by David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey and explores cases involving homicide, missing persons, predators, and unresolved mysteries. Through careful research and victim-centered storytelling, the podcast seeks to keep the focus where it belongs—on the lives that were lost and the families left behind.
If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, leave a review, and share the podcast. Every share helps keep these stories alive and honors the victims whose voices can no longer be heard.
Back By Six: The Unsolved Disappearance of Christopher Kerze
2026/06/10
On April 20, 1990, seventeen-year-old Christopher Kerze woke up with a headache and asked to stay home from school. His mother agreed, gave him medication, and left for work expecting to see her son later that evening. Instead, when she returned home, Christopher was gone.
What began as an ordinary Friday in Eagan, Minnesota, quickly transformed into one of the most baffling missing-person cases in modern American history.
Christopher left behind a handwritten note assuring his mother that he would be "back by six." He never returned.
The following day, a second letter arrived in the mail. The contents suggested Christopher had planned his disappearance and intended to take his own life. Yet nearly every aspect of his life seemed to contradict that explanation. Christopher was an honor student, a National Merit Scholar semifinalist, a competitive swimmer, a musician, and a young man widely described as intelligent, responsible, and driven.
Days later, the family's Dodge Caravan was discovered abandoned near remote wilderness in northern Minnesota. Search teams deployed tracking dogs, volunteers searched the surrounding forests, and investigators pursued every available lead. The trail eventually disappeared, leaving behind more questions than answers.
Over the years, reported sightings, strange anonymous phone calls, and conflicting theories have kept the mystery alive. Some believe Christopher died shortly after abandoning the vehicle. Others believe he intentionally started a new life. Still others suspect circumstances investigators have never uncovered.
More than three decades later, Christopher Kerze remains missing.
In this episode, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey examine the timeline, the letters, the abandoned van, the unexplained phone calls, and the enduring questions that continue to surround one of Minnesota's most perplexing disappearances.
In This Episode:
Christopher Kerze's background and achievementsThe morning he disappearedThe handwritten note left on the kitchen tableThe troubling letter mailed from DuluthThe disappearance of the family vehicleDiscovery of the abandoned van in northern MinnesotaSearch efforts in the George Washington State ForestThe significance of the missing shotgunReported sightings after Christopher vanishedStrange phone calls received by family and friendsThe emotional toll on Christopher's parentsCompeting theories surrounding the caseWhy the mystery remains unsolved more than 30 years laterIf you have information regarding the disappearance of Christopher Kerze, contact local law enforcement or the appropriate Minnesota authorities.
Follow Extinguished for more stories examining unsolved disappearances, crimes against children, cold cases, and the families still searching for answers.
#ExtinguishedPodcast #ChristopherKerze #MissingPerson #ColdCase #Minnesota #UnsolvedMystery #DavidMcClam #LaDonnaHumphrey
The Boy Who Vanished From the Pool: The Disappearance of Angelo "Andy" Puglisi
2026/06/02
In August 1976, ten-year-old Angelo “Andy” Puglisi walked into Higgins Memorial Pool in Lawrence, Massachusetts, just like countless other children on a hot summer afternoon. He never came home.
Nearly fifty years later, Andy's disappearance remains one of New England's most haunting unsolved mysteries. Despite one of the largest search efforts in Lawrence history involving thousands of volunteers, law enforcement, search dogs, divers, and the National Guard, no trace of Andy was ever found.
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey examine the events surrounding Andy's final known day, the massive community search that followed, and the decades-long quest for answers. They explore the witness accounts, investigative theories, and controversial individuals whose names have become linked to the case over the years, including Wayne Chapman and Charles Pierce.
The episode also highlights the extraordinary work of Melanie Perkins, Andy's childhood friend, who dedicated years of her life to keeping his story alive through research, interviews, and documentary work. Her determination helped ensure that Andy would not become just another forgotten name in an old missing persons file.
At its heart, this is not simply a story about suspects or theories. It is a story about a little boy who vanished, a family left without answers, and a community that has refused to forget.
Nearly five decades later, the questions remain:
What happened to Andy after he left the pool?
Who knows the truth?
And will the answers ever be found?
If you have information regarding the disappearance of Angelo "Andy" Puglisi, please contact law enforcement in Massachusetts.
Because every missing child deserves to be remembered, and every family deserves answers.
The Oakland County Child Killer: The Predator No One Saw Coming
2026/05/30
Episode Show Notes:
Between 1976 and 1977, four children vanished from suburban communities in Oakland County, Michigan. They were not taken from isolated roads or dangerous neighborhoods. They disappeared while doing ordinary things that millions of American children did every day—walking home, riding a skateboard, visiting a convenience store, or running a simple errand.
Nearly fifty years later, the murders of Mark Stebbins, Jill Robinson, Kristine Mihelich, and Timothy King remain unsolved.
In this episode of The Extinguished Podcast, hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam examine one of the most haunting child murder investigations in American history. More than a cold case, the Oakland County Child Killer investigation became a turning point in how America viewed child safety, stranger danger, and the hidden realities of predator behavior.
The discussion explores the disturbing evidence suggesting the victims were held captive before their murders, the investigative failures that complicated the case, and the psychological impact these crimes had on an entire generation of parents and children.
Listeners will learn about:
• The disappearances of Mark Stebbins, Jill Robinson, Kristine Mihelich, and Timothy King
• The evidence indicating the children were held, fed, and cared for before being killed
• The extensive investigation that generated more than 18,000 leads
• The controversy surrounding suspects, theories, and organized abuse allegations
• The connection investigators explored involving North Fox Island and child exploitation networks
• Crime scene contamination and investigative mistakes that may have affected the case
• How these murders changed American parenting forever
• The role trust, familiarity, and grooming play in child victimization
• Why predators often thrive within ordinary communities rather than outside them
• The lessons this case still offers nearly five decades later
This episode is not simply an examination of an unsolved serial murder case. It is a conversation about predator behavior, community blind spots, institutional failures, and the devastating consequences of underestimating those who use trust as a weapon.
The Oakland County Child Killer has never been identified. The questions remain. The grief remains. And for the families of four children who never came home, the search for answers continues.
Because these victims were more than headlines.
Mark was a boy walking home.
Jill was a young girl navigating family changes.
Kristine still believed in Santa Claus.
Timothy was a bright, athletic child loved by everyone who knew him.
Their lives mattered then, and they matter now.
Listener Discretion Advised: This episode contains discussions of child abduction, child murder, grooming behavior, sexual exploitation, violence against children, and investigative failures.
Sources & Research:
This episode draws from historical reporting, law enforcement records, investigative findings, and decades of public information surrounding the Oakland County Child Killer investigation.
Follow The Extinguished Podcast for in-depth discussions on unsolved crimes, missing persons, crimes against children, survivor-centered storytelling, institutional accountability, and the hidden systems that allow predators to operate in plain sight.
Because some stories disappear with time. Others disappear because silence helped bury them.
The Places Predators Hide: Trust, Silence, and the Communities That Look Away
2026/05/30
Episode Show Notes:
For decades, Americans were taught that danger came from strangers lurking in the shadows. Children were warned about suspicious vans, unknown faces, and threats that existed somewhere outside their trusted circles. But the reality revealed by decades of abuse investigations tells a very different story.
In this powerful season premiere of The Extinguished Podcast, hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam explore one of the most uncomfortable truths in modern crime prevention: most predators do not appear dangerous. They appear familiar. They are often trusted members of the community, individuals who position themselves where children naturally gather and where adults are least likely to question their intentions.
This episode marks the beginning of a new chapter for The Extinguished Podcast. Rather than focusing solely on individual crimes, the show now turns its attention toward the environments, institutions, cultural blind spots, and systemic failures that allow abuse and exploitation to flourish undetected.
Drawing from research on child abuse, grooming behavior, victim vulnerability, and institutional silence, LaDonna and David examine how predators gain access to victims, why communities frequently fail to recognize warning signs, and how societal assumptions about trust have left generations of children vulnerable.
LaDonna also reflects on her own childhood experiences connected to Hilltop Lanes in western Oklahoma and discusses how revisiting those memories led her to examine broader patterns involving predator behavior, community denial, and the long-term impact of silence.
The conversation explores:
• Why most child predators are known and trusted by their victims
• The psychology of grooming and manipulation
• How churches, schools, youth programs, sports organizations, and community spaces can become environments predators exploit
• Why vulnerable children are often overlooked or dismissed
• The disparities faced by Indigenous victims, runaway youth, children living in poverty, and those connected to addiction or unstable homes
• How communities often prioritize comfort, reputation, and stability over accountability
• Why silence remains one of the most powerful tools predators rely upon
• The responsibility of ethical true crime storytelling
• The new direction and mission of The Extinguished Podcast
This episode is not about sensationalism. It is about understanding the systems that allow abuse to persist and the difficult truths society must confront if meaningful change is ever going to occur.
Because predators rarely survive in darkness alone. More often, they survive because trust shields them, institutions protect them, and communities convince themselves that danger exists somewhere else.
Listener Discretion Advised: This episode contains discussions of crimes against children, child abuse, grooming behavior, institutional failures, and long-term trauma.
Follow The Extinguished Podcast for investigations, survivor-centered storytelling, discussions on crimes against children, forgotten victims, institutional accountability, rural crime, and the hidden systems that allow violence and exploitation to continue.
Because some stories disappear with time. Others disappear because silence helped bury them.
Why We're Back—and Why Everything Has Changed
2026/05/30
After a period of reflection and reevaluation, The Extinguished Podcast returns with a renewed purpose and a deeper mission.
In this special relaunch episode, hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam discuss why they stepped away from the microphone, what they learned during their hiatus, and why they believe true crime must evolve beyond sensational headlines, viral theories, and performative outrage.
Rather than focusing solely on individual crimes, this new season will examine the systems, environments, and institutional failures that allow violence, abuse, exploitation, and injustice to thrive. The conversation explores how vulnerable victims are often overlooked, why some cases receive national attention while others fade into obscurity, and how communities sometimes prioritize protecting reputations over protecting people.
LaDonna shares how researching her own childhood experiences led her to examine the environments that predators historically exploited and the societal conditions that allowed abuse to remain hidden. David discusses the recurring patterns that emerge when studying cases involving institutional failure, crimes against children, and predators who operated in plain sight.
Together, they explain why future episodes will focus on:
• Crimes against children and vulnerable populations
• Institutional abuse and systemic failures
• The psychology of silence and community denial
• Rural crime and forgotten communities
• Missing and murdered Indigenous persons
• Ethical true crime reporting
• Survivor advocacy and long-term trauma
• The ripple effects of crime long after public attention fades
• The responsibilities of creators in an era of social-media-driven investigations
The hosts also address growing concerns about misinformation, online speculation, and the increasing commercialization of tragedy within the true crime genre. Rather than chasing clicks or controversy, The Extinguished Podcast aims to create thoughtful, evidence-based conversations that place victims, survivors, and families at the center of every story.
This episode serves as both a reflection and a promise: a commitment to ethical storytelling, meaningful investigation, and remembering those whose voices were ignored, dismissed, or extinguished.
Because some stories disappear with time. Others disappear because silence helped bury them.
Subscribe now and join us as we explore forgotten victims, hidden histories, institutional failures, survivor experiences, and the difficult truths that continue shaping communities long after the headlines are gone.
Follow The Extinguished Podcast for upcoming investigations, deep-dive discussions, and conversations dedicated to truth, accountability, and justice.
Justice Denied: Teresa Bier’s Unsolved Disappearance Pt. 4
2025/12/07
This episode revisits the unsettling disappearance of Teresa Beer, a 16-year-old whose case became a bizarre Bigfoot myth. David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey explore the failed investigation, the man last seen with Teresa, and how a fantastical story overshadowed a tragic reality, nearly 40 years later.
Take Aways
Investigate the breakdown of the initial legal proceedings against the man last seen with Teresa.Examine the suspect’s behavior and personality, including his history of instability and unusual fixations.Discuss how the Bigfoot theory served as a distraction from the victim and the potential crime.Analyze the three main theories surrounding Teresa’s disappearance: the Bigfoot theory, the suspect’s culpability, and a connection to the “Speed Freak Killers.”Consider the lasting impact of the unsolved case on Teresa’s family and the broader implications for similar cases.DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBEJOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA BY FOLLOWING THE LINKTREEFollow Our Family Of True Crime Shows. Every podcast is important. We hope you join us on our important missions!Lost Girls
True Crime,Authors & Extraordinary People
Beneath The Red Sky
Justice Denied: Teresa Bier’s Unsolved Disappearance Pt. 3
2025/11/29
Teresa Bier vanished almost four decades ago, leaving behind a chilling mystery overshadowed by an unbelievable tale of Bigfoot. This episode unravels the disturbing reality behind the myth, exposing a troubled man, a botched investigation, and the enduring questions that haunt her family.
Takeaways
“We’re here to dig up the truth, case by case, victim by victim.” – David McLam“When you strip away the folklore, you’re left with an older man who took a teenage girl into the woods and returned alone. That’s not mythology. That’s predation.” – David McLam“Teresa deserved to be remembered as a person, not a headline.” – LaDonna HumphreyBehind the Story:
The episode revisits the case of Teresa Beer, a 16-year-old girl who disappeared during a camping trip with a much older man, Welch. When Welch claimed Bigfoot took her, the story captured headlines, diverting attention from the true circumstances of her vanishing. Police built a circumstantial case against Welch, including evidence of drug use and inconsistent stories, but charges were eventually dropped due to insufficient evidence. Welch, described as unstable and prone to wild tales, died years later without confessing, leaving Teresa’s family without answers.
DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBEJOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA BY FOLLOWING THE LINKTREEFollow Our Family Of True Crime Shows. Every podcast is important. We hope you join us on our important missions!Lost Girls
True Crime,Authors & Extraordinary People
Beneath The Red Sky
Justice Denied: Teresa Bier’s Unsolved Disappearance Pt. 2
2025/11/24
This episode of Extinguished revisits the strange disappearance of Teresa Ann Beer, a 16-year-old girl who vanished during a 1987 camping trip. David McCLam and LaDonna Humphrey examine the bizarre Bigfoot story given by Russell Skip Welch and how it overshadowed the search for truth, hindering justice for Teresa.
Takeaways
Examine the impact of sensationalized media on missing persons cases.Discuss the legal challenges in prosecuting cases without a body or physical evidence.Understand how initial false narratives can complicate investigations.Consider the pattern of cases where victims are marginalized and forgotten.Anticipate future discussions about Welch’s involvement and new evidence.
Justice Denied: Teresa Bier’s Unsolved Disappearance Pt. 1
2025/11/17
This episode pulls back the curtain on the disappearance of Teresa Ann Bier, a vulnerable 16-year-old whose life was marked by instability and abuse. Her story culminates in a mysterious camping trip with an older man and a bizarre claim of a Bigfoot encounter, leaving her family with an enduring mystery and no justice.
Featured Quotes:
“We’re here to dig up the truth, case by case, Victim by victim. Because they mattered, they still matter, and someone somewhere knows what happened.” - David McClam“This was a middle-aged man living mostly off of disability checks who had a reputation for drug use, specifically methamphetamines. He was erratic, paranoid, and fascinated with conspiracy theories.” - LaDonna Humphrey“But this wasn’t folklore. This was a missing 16 year old girl.” - LaDonna Humphrey
MMIW Pt. 4: A Modern Trail Of Tears
2025/11/09
This episode of Extinguished confronts the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women (MMIW), calling it a modern genocide. David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey discuss the systemic failures, jurisdictional complexities, and historical oppression that allow this crisis to continue across the United States, particularly in states like Oklahoma. They advocate for urgent action and awareness.
TimeLine
00:00 A Modern Trail of Tears01:34 Oklahoma’s Crisis and Systemic Issues03:52 Historical Context & MMIW Hotspots05:06 Inadequate Federal Response & Grassroots07:23 Confronting the Systems & Call to Action
Key Takeaways
Examine the systemic roots of the MMIW crisis, linking it to historical oppression and modern-day neglect.Understand the fragmented jurisdictional issues between state, federal, and tribal authorities that hinder investigations.Recognize the alarming statistics: Indigenous women face violence at rates far higher than any other demographic.Identify MMIW hotspots, including areas impacted by fracking operations and “man camps.”Support grassroots Indigenous-led efforts that are working to fill the void left by inadequate federal responses.
MMIW PT.3 Say Their Names!
2025/10/26
In this compelling episode of Extinguished, hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey explore the ongoing crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW). They delve into the historical and systemic roots of the issue, discuss the fragmented jurisdictional responsibilities, and highlight the grassroots efforts by Indigenous communities to seek justice. Through personal stories and expert insights, the episode calls for systemic change to address the root causes of this crisis.
TimeLine
Introduction to the MMIW CrisisHistorical Context and Systemic FailuresPersonal Stories and Grassroots EffortsFederal Response and LegislationCall to Action and Conclusion
Featured Quotes
"A modern trail of tears.""It's about genocide, a modern form of it.""Oklahoma ranks among the top states for MMIW.""The system is not just broken, it's fragmented by design.""Indigenous women are murdered at 10 times the national average."
MMIW PT.2 Statistics
2025/10/19
In this episode of Extinguished, hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey delve into the crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW), highlighting the often-overlooked urban aspect of this issue. They discuss alarming statistics, systemic failures in data collection, and the urgent need for community action and advocacy to address these injustices. The conversation emphasizes the importance of recognizing the humanity behind the statistics and calls for better tracking and support for Indigenous communities.
Time Line
00:00 Introduction to MMIW Crisis
00:58 Urban Crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women
03:10 Data Discrepancies and Human Stories
06:09 Call to Action and Community Involvement
Featured Quotes
MMIW is not just a reservation issue; it's an urban crisis.
The FBI's data on missing Indigenous women is alarming.
Many cases of MMIW are underreported or misclassified.
Victims range from infants to elders, with an average age of 29.
Domestic violence and human trafficking are significant factors in MMIW cases.
Law enforcement agencies often fail to provide accurate data.
Families and communities are often left in the dark about missing persons.
There is a need for better coordination and resources for Indigenous-led organizations.
Community involvement is crucial in demanding justice and accountability.
Every missing woman represents a family and a community loss.
Behind the Story: Statistics
In this episode of "Extinguished," hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey delve into the heart-wrenching crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW). This isn't just a story of statistics; it's a narrative of systemic failures and overlooked tragedies that have persisted for centuries.
David and LaDonna guide listeners through the layers of this crisis, revealing how it extends beyond reservations into urban areas, where systems designed to protect and deliver justice are failing. They highlight the staggering discrepancies in data collection and the lack of media coverage, which often leaves these stories untold and these women forgotten.
The episode draws on a landmark report from the Urban Indian Health Institute, which uncovers hundreds of cases of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls, emphasizing that these numbers are likely undercounts. The hosts stress the importance of accurate data and the need for systemic change, urging listeners to support Indigenous-led organizations and demand better from law enforcement and media outlets.
This episode is a call to action, reminding us that every missing woman is more than a statistic. It's about names, faces, and families. David and LaDonna's passionate storytelling ensures that these voices are heard, and their stories are told, until justice is served.
Subscribe now to stay informed and join the fight for justice.
Podcast reviews
Read Extinguished podcast reviews
Caitlin CC. 2025/08/24
Shockingly bad
This may be the worse podcast I’ve ever listen to. Entirely unfounded, disorganized and boring. Big skip.
jgc__ 2025/02/20
yikes
should hang up podcasting and try prison instead
True Crime Listener 75 2025/02/19
Serial Harassers Abusers and Thieves
Ladonna is a full blown con artist who harasses her victims daily. She steals and burns multiple non profits so she can profit off them. Stay away fr...
NicKLVy 2024/12/31
Fake reviews
All of their podcasts are littered with fake 5-star reviews.
amanda41808 2024/10/09
Remove!!!!!
Liars! Don’t bother with these liars.. David, shame on you! Ladonna you are pathetic!
ldro323! 2024/10/05
Beware!
These two are something else. They harass victims, interview predators (and side with them), and threaten hate crimes. They have no business having a ...
TheNewD 2024/09/21
Beware! The host is a fraud
And that’s putting it mildly!
Hdhdhhhdbdbf 2024/08/27
Podcast hosted by abuser
Give “Who’s Afraid of Ladonna Humphrey” a listen on the Pretend podcast if you’re even thinking about listening to this garbage. Provides proof about...
MCKallDAY 2024/07/28
Liars, thieves, stalkers, and predators
Go to Pretend’s podcast “Who’s Afraid of LaDonna Humphrey” for all the info.
Jimmy Neutronic 2024/06/11
Terrible
Two people on a church pew talking about the youth group vibes.
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Extinguished relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.8258691482
Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey
Blaze Podcast Network

4.858221907
Sara Gonzales Unfiltered
Blaze Podcast Network

4.922301819
The Ten Minute Bible Hour Podcast
Matt Whitman

4.824771860
Deck The Hallmark
Bramble Jam Podcast Network

4.916161609
The Kristian Harloff Show
Kristian Harloff

4.917101543
DarrenDaily On-Demand
Darren Hardy LLC

4.549032000
The Daily Stoic
Daily Stoic | Backyard Ventures

4.6221632000
Mark Levin Podcast
Cumulus Podcast Network

4.737121980
The Eric Metaxas Show
Metaxas Media

4.682401276
The Daily Beast Podcast
The Daily Beast, Joanna Coles