
Advertise on podcast: Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power
Rating
3.9from
This podcast has
27 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
John WilliamsonExplicit
No
Date created
2025/04/02
Latest episode
2026/10/30
Average duration
54 min.
Release period
37 days
Description
Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power is an investigative podcast exploring the rise of the Vineyard movement - from a humble network of churches to a sprawling global empire. Through in-depth research and firsthand accounts, this series examines how power, influence, and ambition shaped the movement's evolution, often at the expense of those who trusted it most. From its early days under John Wimber to its modern-day scandals, Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power uncovers the hidden costs of empire-building within evangelical Christianity and the well-meaning individuals caught in the crossfire.
Unlock Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power podcast
Accountability on Trial | A Spoiled Fruit Update — Revised Edition
2026/10/30
Accountability on Trial | A Spoiled Fruit Update — Revised Edition
Who takes responsibility when allegations of abuse reach beyond a local church?
In this revised update, John Williamson revisits the Duluth litigation, two Anaheim lawsuits, and the Kansas case involving Vineyard Church of Overland Park. We examine efforts to end claims before trial and distinguish allegations, legal defenses, and court decisions.
One Duluth case was brought after a woman's death by suicide. Her family alleges that the abuse and resulting trauma caused her death. We explain why her representative faced a different legal deadline from the one that would have governed her own claim had she lived.
This edition also incorporates the full Safeguarding by Design investigation report concerning a former Ohio pastor. We discuss its findings, his responses, the boundaries between pastoral care and clinical counseling, and failures of institutional oversight identified by investigators.
Individual case participants are unnamed in this edition. The general docket review is dated October 20, with an October 30 update confirming a settlement notice in the first Anaheim case and checking the Kansas released-decision database. Exact settlement parties, insurers, and terms remain unverified. The Ohio investigation report is dated August 10, 2026. Investigative findings are distinct from court judgments.
Content note: Discussion of sexual abuse allegations, death by suicide, pastoral misconduct, and institutional responses. No graphic descriptions.
Hosted by John Williamson. A John Williamson Productions LLC production.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
An Update on Spoiled Fruit - and What Comes Next
2026/08/11
A quick update on the future of Spoiled Fruit.
John shares what’s currently in development, including a new episode revisiting the events and stories covered in Season One and bringing listeners up to date on what has happened since.
Then, Season Two will widen the lens beyond the Vineyard movement to explore evangelical Christianity in America at large — examining power, leadership, accountability, institutional culture, celebrity, and the systems that have shaped modern evangelicalism.
John also introduces a new project currently in development: Who We Become, a podcast about life-changing moments and the people who emerge from them.
If the human stories behind Spoiled Fruit have resonated with you, there’s a good chance you’ll connect with what comes next.
Learn more and join the mailing list at thisiswhowebecome.com.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Doug Warburton
2025/11/03
While production continues on Season Two of Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power — which takes a broader look at evangelical movements beyond the Vineyard — John shares a full, uncut conversation with Pastor Doug Warburton, his own pastor and a leader within the ELCA Lutheran Church.
In this episode, Pastor Doug offers valuable perspective from a tradition that’s been refining its systems of governance, accountability, and pastoral care for centuries. Together, John and Doug explore how institutional structure can be both protective and redemptive when it’s rooted in transparency, shared authority, and a deep respect for congregational voice.
Doug also helps frame what healthy oversight looks like in contrast to the failures uncovered throughout Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power, showing how lessons learned from long-standing denominations might guide newer movements toward maturity and integrity.
Pastor Doug Warburton serves within the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) and brings decades of experience in congregational leadership, pastoral care, and denominational governance. His insight offers a grounded, practical contrast to the free-church structures explored throughout Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power, highlighting what institutional wisdom can offer to movements still finding their way.
About the Series
Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power is an investigative series examining how good intentions within church movements can curdle into systems of power and silence. Season Two expands beyond the Vineyard to explore how these same dynamics appear across evangelicalism — and how faith communities can build healthier, more accountable futures.
Follow & Support
Stay connected for updates on Season Two:
Website: spoiledfruitpodcast.comInstagram: @spoiledfruitpodcastX / Twitter: @spoiledfruitpod
If you found this conversation meaningful, please rate, review, and share the episode — your support helps keep these stories alive and heard.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Brian Metzger
2025/10/27
While Season Two of Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power is in production, John shares one of his full, uncut interviews — this time with Pastor Brian Metzger, one of the most outspoken critics of Vineyard USA’s handling of cases like Duluth Vineyard.
In this candid and deeply personal conversation, Brian reflects on his years within the Vineyard Movement, what led him to speak out, and how his faith has evolved in the aftermath. Together, John and Brian discuss systemic leadership failures, accountability gaps, and the difficult balance between loyalty to a movement and loyalty to one’s convictions.
Brian’s courage and clarity have made him a respected voice among those calling for reform, and this interview provides essential context for understanding how Vineyard USA’s internal culture allowed harm to persist unchecked.
About the Guest
Pastor Brian Metzger is a former Vineyard pastor and one of the most vocal advocates for transparency, justice, and reform within the movement. His willingness to speak publicly about systemic failures — and to stand with survivors — has made him a key voice in the broader conversation about accountability within modern evangelicalism.
About the Series
Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power investigates the rise, fall, and reckoning of the Vineyard Movement — and what its story reveals about evangelicalism as a whole. Season Two will expand the lens beyond the Vineyard, exploring how power, silence, and institutional loyalty shape movements across the broader church landscape.
Follow & Support
Stay connected for updates on Season Two:
Website: spoiledfruitpodcast.comInstagram: @spoiledfruitpodcastX / Twitter: @spoiledfruitpod
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Melody Winderweedle
2025/08/18
Episode Summary:
In this powerful and unfiltered conversation, former Vineyard pastor Melody Winderweedle shares her story of being quietly removed from leadership—not for misconduct, but for daring to lead with integrity, inclusion, and pastoral care. In the wake of a high-profile abuse scandal, Melody pushed for transparency, advocated for LGBTQ inclusion, and called out systems of control and exclusion. The response? Silence. Retaliation. And a door quietly closed behind her.
Her story is not unique—but it is rarely told so publicly. This interview is part of a continuing effort to surface the voices that churches like to bury.
We also contextualize this episode with recent developments at Duluth Vineyard—including internal concerns about new council appointments, allegations of spiritual coercion, power alignment, and a past relationship involving a minor. Despite public promises to be trauma-informed, the church’s actions suggest a troubling return to platforming loyalty over accountability.
Meanwhile, when asked for comment, Vineyard USA National Director Jay Pathak declined to respond—deferring instead to regional leaders. Once again, responsibility is passed down rather than taken up.
This is the first of two new interviews in this mini-series. The voices may have been pushed to the margins—but they are speaking louder than ever.
Guest Bio:
Melody Winderweedle is a current pastor and former Vineyard pastor. Known for her compassion, integrity, and spiritual leadership, Melody served faithfully until she was removed for supporting LGBTQ inclusion and speaking up about systemic issues within the church. She continues to advocate for safer, healthier expressions of Christian community.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
BONUS: Q&A
2025/07/23
Thank you to everyone who submitted questions! If you have additional questions not answered in this episode please send them to [email protected] or via our contact form on www.spoiledfruitpod.com
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Ken Wilson
2025/06/30
In this full-length interview, Spoiled Fruit sits down with Ken Wilson, founding pastor of Vineyard Church of Ann Arbor and one of the movement's earliest and most respected leaders.
For decades, Ken was known as a thoughtful, compassionate voice within the Vineyard - until he did something few pastors dared to do: publicly express support for LGBTQ+ inclusion. Despite years of faithful service, Ken was quietly pushed out, his legacy downplayed, and the church he founded taken over by those unwilling to even speak his name.
This is the first time Ken has publicly shared the full story of how his journey with the Vineyard ended - not because he left, but because he was no longer welcome.
Ken Wilson is the founding pastor of Vineyard Ann Arbor and the author of A Letter to My Congregation, a landmark book in the conversation around faith and LGBTQ+ inclusion. Recently retired from the ministry, Ken continues to write, teach, and advocate for a more expansive and inclusive expression of Christian faith.
Resources & Links:
www.spoiledfruitpodcast.com
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: JT Meyer pt. 2
2025/06/27
In Part 2, JT Meyer recounts the aftermath of his decision to speak out. Despite his loyalty to the movement and attempts to engage in good-faith dialogue, JT was met with silence, isolation, and ultimately, exile from the Vineyard. He reflects on what he learned, the pastors who quietly supported him, and what a healthier, more just church could like.
This is a powerful look at the human cost of speaking the truth - and the hope that remains on the other side.
Content Warning: Includes themes of spiritual abuse, theological conflict, and pastoral isolation.
Resources: www.spoiledfruitpodcast.com
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: JT Meyer pt. 1
2025/06/25
In Part 1 of this two-part interview, former Vineyard pastor JT Meyer shares his journey into the Vineyard movement - from his early pastoral calling to his commitment to creating a more inclusive and honest spiritual community. JT walks us through the formative experiences that shaped his theology and pastoral style, and the growing tension he felt as he began advocating for LGBTQ+ inclusion within a system that demanded silence.
This is a story of integrity, isolation, and the cost of refusing to compromise your values.
Content Warning: This episode contains discussions about church exclusion, spiritual abuse, and LGBTQ+ marginalization.
Resources & Links:
www.spoiledfruitpodcast.com
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview - The Anderson Family
2025/06/23
In this emotional and unfiltered interview, we hear from Heidi Anderson and her children - former members of Mile High Vineyard, led by current Vineyard USA National Director Jay Pathak. When two of Heidi's children bravely came forward to report abuse, they went to one of the people they felt safest with: their youth group leader.
But that leader failed to immediately report. And instead of care or accountability, the church responded by protecting its own - funding legal support for the youth pastor and eventually removing the Anderson family from the community entirely.
This conversation is about what happens when institutional preservation is prioritized over pastoral responsibility - and what it costs the families left behind.
Content Warning: This episode contains discussions of sexual abuse, spiritual abuse, and institutional betrayal involving minors. Listener discretion is strongly advised.
Resources & Links:
www.spoiledfruitpodcast.com
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Dr. Paula Swindle
2025/06/19
In this powerful and eye-opening conversation, Dr. Paula Swindle helps us put words to the pain many have experienced but struggled to name. A scholar, psychologist, and trauma-informed spiritual care provider, Dr. Swindle brings deep insight into how religious systems - like Vineyard USA - can engage in spiritual bypass, silence dissent, and retraumatize survivors in the name of unity or divine authority.
We talk about how spiritual abuse often masquerades as "pastoral care," why some institutions confuse conflict avoidance with peacekeeping, and how survivors are often labeled as "gossips" or "divisive" simply for telling the truth.
If you've ever been made to feel like you're the problem for questioning abusive systems - this conversation is for you.
Guest Bio:
Paula Swindle is a licensed clinical mental health counselor/supervisor, an associate professor of counseling and the Hickory campus program coordinator for the counseling program.
Swindle’s more than 24 years of clinical work includes founding and providing counseling and consultation through the Center for Healing Religious Harm, youth and family therapy, private practice, inpatient and partial psychiatric services and designing and implementing mental health programs in medical settings such as cardiac rehabilitation, pulmonary rehabilitation and oncology services. She is passionate about interdisciplinary work in medical settings.
She serves as Vice President of the Catawba Valley Association of Counselors and Therapists and provides clinical supervision services for provisionally licensed counselors in North Carolina. Her research interests include counseling in medical settings and counseling and spirituality, particularly in religious abuse. She is also a co-host of the podcast “Sacred Intersections” with local pastor Reverend Jill Isola, which focuses on the intersection between religion and mental health, particularly in the area of religious trauma and spiritual abuse.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Chapter 8: The God Card - Power, Control, and the Death of Accountability
2025/06/17
In the season finale of Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power, we examine the final stage of Vineyard USA's transformation from grassroots revival to centralized authority. This chapter traces how real crisis - like the abuse scandal in Duluth - were used to justify a long-planned internal reorganization, giving a small group of leaders near-total control of the movement.
We explore how spiritual bypassing, gaslighting, and vague accusations of "gossip" were used to silence dissenters. Through the insights of Dr. Paula Swindle and Pastor Doug Warburton, we define these patterns for what they are: psychological and spiritual manipulation.
We honor the survivors - especially those in Duluth - and remember the young woman who lost her life. Because this story is about more than bylaws and policy. It's about people.
We conclude with a call to Vineyard's largest churches. If even a few demand change, the future could look different. But with 90% of churches already signed onto the new structure, the silence is deafening. Is this the version of Vineyard you still want?
Content Warning: This episode discusses spiritual abuse, systemic retraumatization, and suicide. Listen discretion is advised.
Call to Action:
Share this episode.
Contact your local Vineyard pastor.
Demand Accountability.
Call local and national media and ask them to pick up this story.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Mandy Cavoto
2025/06/12
This is the full interview with Mandy Cavoto who, along with her husband Matt, were a part of the worship team at Mile High Vineyard in Denver, Colorado.
Many opens up about the spiritual abuse, the patterns of manipulation, and gaslighting she experienced there. She also reflects on her deep grief for the community she once loved, the cost of staying silent, and what healing has looked like in the aftermath. This conversation is raw, unflinching look at what happens when loyalty is weaponized and vulnerable staff members are left without protection or support.
Whether you've been following the story or are just tuning in, Mandy's story provides essential insight into the systemic failures explored throughout Spoiled Fruit.
Content Warning: This episode contains discussion of emotional, spiritual, and institutional abuse, as well as references to traumatic experiences within faith communities. Listener discretion is advised.
For resources go to www.spoiledfruitpodcast.com/resources
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Full Interview: Reagan Waggoner
2025/06/11
In this extended interview, former Vineyard pastor Reagan Waggoner shares his deeply personal journey from trusted leader to outspoken critic of Vineyard USA's handling of spiritual abuse, institutional accountability, and the controversial ReOrg process.
Reagan candidly discusses:
The troubling dynamics he observed in Vineyard's national leadershipHis direct challenges to Jay Pathak and the chilling responseThe emotional toll of being investigated for asking difficult questionsWhy transparency, repentance, and reform matter more than institutional perservation
This conversation pulls back the curtain on a movement in crisis - and a leader who chose truth over silence, even at great personal cost.
Content Warning: This episode contains discussion of spiritual abuse, institutional betrayal, and emotional distress. Listener discretion is advised.
Legal Disclaimer: The views expressed in this interview are those of the speaker and do not necessarily reflect the position of this podcast or its producers. All individuals mentioned are presumed innocent until proven otherwise in a court of law.
Resources Mentioned:
Spoiled Fruit Website: www.spoiledfruitpodcast.com ReOrg Memo Analysis: Guidpost Report Summary:
Follow us on:
Instagram: @spoiledfruitpod
TikTok: @spoiledfruitpodcast
Email us: [email protected]
Subscribe, rate, and share to help bring these stories to light.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Chapter 7: Crisis as Currency
2025/06/09
Chapter 7: Crisis as Currency — How Vineyard Leveraged Collapse to Consolidate Power
Content Warning: This episode includes references to spiritual abuse, institutional manipulation, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised.
In Chapter 7, we examine how Vineyard USA used crisis—real and perceived—to reshape its power structures under the banner of reform. As major scandals unfolded in Duluth and Anaheim, national leaders capitalized on the chaos to push through a sweeping reorganization process known simply as the “ReOrg.”
We trace National Director Jay Pathak’s rise to power, exploring how his formation under leaders like Rich Nathan and Michael Gatlin shaped his leadership style—and how patterns of control, suppression of dissent, and spiritual bypassing followed him into his national role.
We also break down:
• The striking similarities between the 2020 internal ReOrg memo and the Guidepost Solutions assessment used later to justify structural change.
• How a flawed survey, a narrow assessment scope, and a potentially compromised investigator created the illusion of consensus.
• Why many pastors now believe the ReOrg wasn’t just reform—it was a strategic seizure of control, engineered by those already in power.
Finally, we ask: what happens when a movement founded on revival becomes obsessed with survival? And who pays the price when reform is built on the backs of the abused?
💬 Connect:
• 💻 Website: spoiledfruitpodcast.com
• 📧 Email: [email protected]
• 📱 Instagram / TikTok / X: @spoiledfruitpod
📰 Media inquiries and tips:
Contact John Williamson at [email protected]
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/spoiled-fruit-faith-and-power/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Podcast reviews
Read Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power podcast reviews
Listener_E_E 2025/11/15
Listen to survivors
As a victim of Vineyard abuse and follower of stories coming out for years now, this podcast was a disappointment. Whistleblowers have shared the trut...
ddjajeicjensnxj 2025/11/14
Former Vineyard member
I have found this podcast both interesting and eye opening. I attended the Vineyard (Cambridge, MA and Arvada, CO) for 15 years. While I met many wond...
Inspiring and Eye-Opening 2025/11/13
Hard truth
Spoiled Fruit: Faith and Power is a thoughtful and engaging podcast that explores faith, identity, and power with honesty and heart. The stories and e...
mamaschneid 2025/11/13
An honest look
An honest look at how we can do better in caring, not just for one another, but the community in which we share life with. As human beings we are com...
Vcarpavich 2025/11/12
Hits home
Hard to call a series ‘great’ that retells in vivid detail the slow trainwreck on which you were a willing passenger, but it is indeed a great podcast...
Ambutler 2025/11/12
Great listen
This is an eye opening podcast showing the ways that Vineyard USA often failed to address issues and protect victims within its organization. The podc...
wan john 2025/11/11
Important
John is doing good work in asking for accountability and handling the stories of victims of Jackson Gatlin and his family with care.
dwarburton 2025/11/11
Important work
Abuse that gets covered up for power and reputation is so destructive. Unfortunately the Church isn’t immune for this. John does thoughtful and sensit...
2 Funky 2025/11/11
Accurate as It Is Devastating
This podcast gives voice to victims of abuse by Vineyard pastors and leaders of the Vineyard USA organization. I had similar experiences to the ones c...
.:tropicalwave:. 2025/10/14
Trying too hard
This podcast sounded like it’d be interesting…but it’s not. Really disappointed in the lack of facts, interviews and concrete information provided. It...
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Spoiled Fruit: Faith & Power relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.98711800
The Adam Mockler Show
MeidasTouch Network

4.824781901
Deck The Hallmark
Bramble Jam Podcast Network

4.619842891
All Ears English Podcast
Lindsay McMahon and Michelle Kaplan

4.82494975
The 1000 Hours Outside Podcast
1000 Hours Outside

4.916171639
The Kristian Harloff Show
Kristian Harloff

4.847132000
Pat Gray Unleashed
Blaze Podcast Network

4.6620132000
The Dan Bongino Show
Cumulus Podcast Network | Dan Bongino

4.91585838
Allen Jackson Ministries
Pastor Allen Jackson of World Outreach Church

4.921801100
The Carl Jackson Podcast
Salem Podcast Network

4.89781791
The Unmistakable Creative Podcast
Srinivas Rao