
Advertise on podcast: Proof Over Precedent
Rating
5from
This podcast has
80 episodes
Language
EnglishExplicit
No
Date created
2025/06/13
Latest episode
2026/11/17
Average duration
30 min.
Release period
8 days
Description
The Access to Justice Lab at Harvard Law School discusses the work of bringing credible evidence to lawyers, judges, and decision makers, to transform the U.S. justice system into an evidence-based field. We bring you weekly one-on-one interviews with experts in the area of access to justice -- researchers, lawyers, professors, law students, data analysts, research participants, and anyone who has an interesting role in this growing area.
Unlock Proof Over Precedent podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Proof Over Precedent podcast
Episode 76: Keeping Courts Open and Secure
2026/11/17
In this week's Proof Over Precedent episode, Shay Cleary of the National Center for State Courts talks about the risks facing state and local courts in balancing openness and transparency amid cybersecurity threats. Legacy systems, open-records requirements, limited funding, and reliance on outside vendors all contribute to a vulnerable security system. Cleary and HLS J.D. candidate Ashil Jhaveri share security that may support both access to justice and secure, trustworthy courts.
Episode 75: Navigating Justice Amid Consumer Contract Complexities
2026/11/09
Doing business may mean doing risky business when it comes to sharing data. But consumers may not realize or notice the cost of paying for practices like price discrimination with their data. In this week's episode of Proof Over Precedent, NYU Law Professor Oren Bar-Gill discusses how consumer misperceptions and inattention support the status quo of complexity amid consumer contracts. He also shares the surprising role AI could play in supporting consumers, though not without backlash.
Episode 74: The Path to an Independent, Accessible, and Accountable Judiciary
2026/11/02
How to lose public trust in a few easy steps: Take a trusted branch of government, give it the heady authority to maintain independence apart from public oversight, and limit access to records that would offer accountability. The lack of transparency would crack the foundation of any well-intentioned agency. This week's Proof Over Precedent episode addresses the state of the judiciary that has led to a decline in public trust and a call for stronger transparency requirements.
Episode 73: Does Modernizing PACER Mean Overlooking Pro Se Litigants?
2026/10/26
When law students have difficulty navigating the federal court records platform PACER, it's time to incorporate universal design. That's the suggested solution in this week's Proof Over Precedent episode. It's also a warning for the Case Modernization Effort currently underway: Pro se litigants represent a sizeable population using PACER, but their user experience has been overlooked in favor of representing the majority user experience by lawyers and court administrators. The result, thus far, has been problematic with a court records system that has become unwieldy in scale and unusable by those most in need of understanding it.
Episode 72: Building Judiciary Trust Through Open Court Data
2026/10/19
The seven-year-old Open Government Data Act has supported accessible, and useable, data from federal agencies, but it did not extend to the judiciary. This week's Proof Over Precedent episode discusses the massive amounts of data in federal, and particularly state, courts that serve as a missed opportunity to provide transparency, notice court trends, and foster collaboration, all in the name of building trust.
Episode 71: When and How to Study Attorney Influence in Asylum Cases
2026/10/13
It helps to have a lawyer in court, no question. But in immigration court, where the vast majority of individuals are self-representing and not enough immigration lawyers exist to represent them all anyway, is there a point in asylum proceedings where an attorney could be most effective at supporting due process for clients?
Episode 70: Exploring a Lawyer's Impact on Immigration Proceedings
2026/10/06
No counsel, worse outcomes in immigration proceedings? This week on Proof Over Precedent, Access to Justice Lab Faculty Director and occasional podcast host Jim Greiner interviewed two Vera Institute of Justice researchers, Jacquelyn Pavilon and Neil Agrawal, about their study measuring the effect of a lawyer in detained 240 removal proceedings in Chicago Immigration Court. Did individuals with legal representation see a greater likelihood of relief, temporary relief, or bond hearings and releases than those without lawyers? The discussion follows both research methodology and adherence to due process.
Episode 69: Study Interrupted—In-Person v. Remote Hearing Modalities
2026/09/28
We like to use Proof Over Precedent as a platform to highlight our evidence-based findings, as well as others' studies, from randomized control trials in the field of law. This is not one of those times. In this week's episode, Professor Jim Greiner talks with the A2J Lab researcher and data analyst who spent years working on our Online Courts study about the disappointment, frustration, and lessons learned from a flawed RCT. They still managed to glean a takeaway from comparing remote and in-person hearings for self-represented litigants in family court.
Episode 68: Evaluating Procedural Fairness in Court and on Zoom
2026/09/21
Self-represented litigants primarily measure procedural justice by whether they had a voice, were listened to, and were treated fairly in court. Do these basic marks of overall satisfaction differ between the mode in which the hearing took place though? This week's Proof Over Precedent episode features an interview with justice reform consultant Emily LaGratta and Nathanael Player, former director of the Utah State Court Self-Help Center, about a study looking at litigants' perception of fairness in their respective experiences with either remote or in-person court.
Are Death-Qualified Juries Qualified?
2026/09/14
Jury selection should aim for a balanced and thoughtful panel; in capital cases, that balance is further underscored. This week's "Student Voices" post argues that "death-qualifying juries"--the practice of excluding jurors who oppose the death penalty--disrupts that balance. Those constitutional guarantees of impartiality, equality, and reliability? Not so ensured with practice. Reform options, however, are not so simple.
Episode 67: Capital Jury Selection's Hidden Biases
2026/09/14
Serving as a juror fulfills one's civic duty to ensure a system of checks and balances in the U.S. In capital cases, however, "death qualification" ensures that prospective jurors opposed to the death penalty will not have the opportunity to perform this civic duty. This week's Proof Over Precedent episode features a "Student Voices" interview with Megan Byrne of the ACLU's Capital Punishment Project to discuss the shortcomings of less diverse juries due to race, gender, and religious differences. It also looks at a capital case in Kansas in which the courts examined the problems associated with death qualification and the death penalty overall.
Episode 66: Heirs' Property's Fragile Hold on Land Ownership and Justice
2026/08/17
Just because an individual may own property, does not guarantee that the person may keep that property—that’s the warning stemming from this week's podcast episode featuring an interview with Dr. Kara Woods, research analyst at Alcorn State University’s National Policy Research Center. Issues may arise from heirs property—co-owned land in which the name of the original, and now deceased, owner is still on the deed. Land loss due to heirs property issues affects groups disproportionately by race and class, and the policy protections against it are inconsistent across states. The ensuing legal hurdles mark a barrier that some families cannot overcome. One takeaway: Communicate with your family members!
Episode 65: Access vs. Efficiency—Supreme Court Weighs Frivolous Filings
2026/08/10
"Martinizing", the controversial Supreme Court practice of denying court fee waivers for indigent litigants, is meant to reduce frivolous filings, but at what cost? This episode looks at the January 2026 Howell order in which Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the sole dissenting voice against Martinizing indigent prisoners. Her argument reignites the perspective that access to justice and the potential for future meritorious claims should outweigh workload relief.
Episode 64: Can AI Resolve Brazil's Judicial Backlog?
2026/08/06
More than 100 million pending cases await Brazil courts, so it may not be surprising that the country's Supreme Court Justice has a reportedly rosy view of AI in the court system, especially in time-sensitive civil and criminal matters. The potential for AI to help alleviate the backlog and potentially bring more balance and less bias may brush over the possible system errors and human rubber-stamping that come with it. This "Student Voices" podcast discusses Brazil's use of AI in the court system and the areas ripe for more scrutiny--evaluations through RCTs and metric-based learning models.
Episode 63: Texas Two-Step Bankruptcy--Corporate Restructuring or Legal Loophole?
2026/08/04
The Texas Two-Step is a fairly simple dance, but in the world of corporate bankruptcy, it's the name of a sophisticated maneuver that some profitable companies employ to stop mass tort liabilities and limit the settlements due to victims. It splits a company and strategically divides its assets and liabilities. In this manner, the companies win and the tort victims, by comparison, lose. But there may be reason for cautious optimism. Proof Over Precedent interviews bankruptcy scholar and law professor Melissa Jacoby about the practice, the reasons courts allow it, and the avenues under consideration for making bankruptcy a more just and exceptional option for corporations.
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on Proof Over Precedent relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.890681612
Fearless with Jason Whitlock
Blaze Podcast Network

4.913561987
Wholesaling Inc with Brent Daniels
Find distressed properties for pennies on the dollar and turn them for huge profits!

4.831561386
The Late-Round Fantasy Football Podcast
iHeartPodcasts

4.858251939
Sara Gonzales Unfiltered
Blaze Podcast Network

4.917121579
DarrenDaily On-Demand
Darren Hardy LLC

4.6221772000
Mark Levin Podcast
Cumulus Podcast Network

4.922471858
The Ten Minute Bible Hour Podcast
Matt Whitman

4.6254042000
The Glenn Beck Program
Mercury Radio Arts

4.6652752197
The Charlie Kirk Show
Charlie Kirk

4.736091328
The Bonfire with Big Jay Oakerson and Robert Kelly
SiriusXM