“Don’t Tell Me About Yourself” is where old-school hiring meets a modern reality check. Hosted by Expert Interviewers Co-Founders Lorna Erickson and Victoria Gates, this show blends their combined 40 years of real-world experience with the unfiltered commentary that made 340K+ people laugh, cringe, and rethink how interviews actually work. Each week, they tackle the biggest news in hiring, from chaotic interview moments to ghost jobs and questions that should have been retired decades ago. Whether you hire, apply, or just love a good interview trainwreck, this show is for anyone who’s ever sat on either side of the interview table. Real stories. Real data. Real talk about how to make interviews actually work for everyone. Because great hiring isn’t luck—it's a skill.
Advertise on Don’t Tell Me About Yourself
Advertise on Don’t Tell Me About Yourself to promote your brand to thousands of podcast listeners
Unlock Don’t Tell Me About Yourself podcast Email contact info, Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details
Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights
Audience details
Podcast Insights
Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from Don’t Tell Me About Yourself podcast
Can You Tell When a Candidate Is Just Good at Interviewing?
2026/11/18
Episode Description:
They were confident. Charismatic. Had an answer for everything. You loved them. But did you actually learn whether they could do the job?
In this episode of Don't Tell Me About Yourself, Expert Interviewers co-founders Victoria Gates and Lorna Erickson unpack why being great at interviewing doesn't always translate to being great at the job. From the "shiny candidate" effect and the bias toward confident, likable people to rehearsed answers and AI-assisted interview preparation, they explore how hiring managers can mistake a great performance for actual competence.
Lorna shares her own experience of interviewing her way into a job she wasn't qualified to do, and they debate whether candidates should receive interview questions in advance, why nervous candidates are often underestimated, and whether every hiring manager deserves a seat at the interview table. You'll learn how to look past charisma, ask better follow-up questions, and make hiring decisions based on evidence rather than chemistry.
Because the person who makes the best impression isn't always the person who will make the biggest impact.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Being good at interviewing and being good at the job are two different skills. A polished interview performance doesn't automatically predict job performance.
Confident, charismatic candidates can create a strong first impression that distracts interviewers from evaluating their actual qualifications.
Nervousness, introversion, or a less polished communication style shouldn't be mistaken for incompetence, especially when those traits aren't relevant to the job.
Personal chemistry and likability can influence hiring decisions, but enjoying a conversation with someone isn't evidence that they'll succeed in the role.
Rehearsed answers aren't automatically dishonest. Candidates should be encouraged to prepare, and interviewers need to know how to evaluate the substance of their answers.
AI-assisted interview preparation isn't inherently a problem. The bigger question is whether interviewers can distinguish well-organized answers from demonstrated experience.
Sharing interview questions in advance could help candidates demonstrate their best thinking instead of rewarding whoever is best at responding under pressure.
Hypothetical questions make it easier for candidates to describe what they would do without proving they've ever done it.
Follow-up questions are essential for moving beyond impressive stories. Asking for specific examples, individual contributions, and actual results helps uncover real experience.
Hiring managers who consistently rely on gut feelings, personality, or vague feedback may be especially susceptible to the "shiny candidate" effect.
Seniority and subject matter expertise don't automatically qualify someone to interview candidates. Interviewing is a skill that requires training and practice.
Structured interviews and clearly defined job requirements help hiring teams evaluate candidates against the actual work rather than their interview performance.
Hiring teams should be able to explain their decisions using job-related evidence. If the only feedback is "I loved them," there's probably more evaluating to do.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – Are they qualified or just good at interviewing?
01:32 – Why hiring managers fall for shiny candidates
04:13 – Lorna's story: Interviewing into the wrong job
06:40 – What our hiring manager survey revealed
08:03 – Confidence, nervousness, and the interview performance gap
10:41 – When chemistry and likability influence hiring decisions
13:15 – Does communication style actually matter for the job?
14:43 – Are rehearsed interview answers a red flag?
17:06 – How hypothetical questions reward impressive answers
18:13 – Follow-up questions that uncover real experience
20:17 – Should candidates use AI to prepare for interviews?
21:22 – Should we give candidates interview questions in advance?
23:07 – How to spot hiring managers who fall for charisma
25:39 – Why interviewers need training, too
26:15 – Should everyone be allowed to interview candidates?
28:31 – The dangers of being the interviewer nobody can impress
29:26 – How to hire for competence instead of performance
31:34 – Holding hiring teams accountable for evidence
KEYWORDS
good at interviewing, candidate interview performance, how to evaluate candidates, hiring manager training, interview bias, confidence bias, charismatic candidates, shiny candidate effect, interview preparation, rehearsed interview answers, AI interview preparation, ChatGPT interview preparation, interview questions in advance, behavioral interview questions, interview follow-up questions, structured interviews, candidate qualifications, interview evaluation, hiring decisions, job performance, hiring manager mistakes, evidence-based hiring, interview skills, candidate assessment
"You Gotta Read the Syllabus" with Kyle Lagunas
2026/11/13
Episode Description:
Live from UNLEASH Paris, we're joined by Kyle Lagunas, founder of Kyle & Co, to talk about what's really happening in HR technology and talent transformation. Kyle shares insights from his latest research, including a talent transformation yearbook that recognizes organizations making meaningful progress, and why business leaders and talent teams may be more aligned on AI than we think. We also discuss the pressure to reinvent work, why most organizations aren't ready for large-scale AI transformation, and why sometimes simply keeping things running is a win worth celebrating.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
HR executives and talent leaders may be more aligned on AI transformation than expected, according to Kyle's research.
Meaningful transformation doesn't always require massive teams. Smaller HR teams are producing measurable business results through technology adoption and process redesign.
Organizations are under pressure to reinvent work with AI, but many aren't ready for the significant changes to roles, responsibilities, and skills.
Restructuring and workforce changes can reflect companies trying to future-proof themselves, not necessarily whether they're performing well or poorly.
HR teams should recognize meaningful progress and celebrate wins instead of feeling like they're constantly falling behind.
Find Kyle on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kylelagunas/
Kyle & Co: https://kyleandco.com/
Get eyes on his latest research: https://kyleandco.com/research/talent-class-of-2026/
KEYWORDS
Kyle Lagunas, Kyle & Co, UNLEASH Paris, HR technology, talent transformation, AI in HR, future of work, workforce transformation, HR research, talent acquisition, AI adoption, HR leadership, work redesign, skills-based transformation, Don't Tell Me About Yourself
"The Best Leaders Don't Have All the Answers "with KeyAnna Schmiedel
2026/11/12
Episode Description:
Live from UNLEASH Paris, we're joined by KeyAnna from Workhuman to talk about how leadership, hiring, and employee development are evolving. We discuss why skills-based hiring is creating new opportunities for talent acquisition, how companies can uncover talent already inside their organizations, and why humility may be one of the most important leadership skills for the future. Plus, KeyAnna shares how Workhuman uses everyday employee recognition to inform performance conversations and development opportunities, and why TA teams should think of themselves as strategic business partners.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Skills-based hiring starts with understanding the work that actually needs to be done, not relying on outdated job descriptions.
Talent acquisition and talent management teams can work together to identify internal employees whose skills transfer into unexpected roles.
Humility is becoming an essential leadership skill as organizations navigate change and leaders learn to admit they don't have all the answers.
Employee recognition should extend beyond exceptional performance to include everyday contributions, collaboration, and teamwork.
Talent acquisition teams have an opportunity to become more strategic business partners by bringing workforce insights into broader organizational decisions.
Find KeyAnna on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/keyannaschmiedl/
Website: www.workhuman.com
KEYWORDS
Workhuman, KeyAnna, UNLEASH Paris, future of leadership, leadership humility, skills-based hiring, internal mobility, talent acquisition, employee recognition, employee development, HR leadership, talent management, hiring managers, future of work, Don't Tell Me About Yourself
"What Got You Here Won't Get You There" with Mark Coleman
2026/11/11
Episode Description:
Live from UNLEASH Paris, we're joined by UNLEASH founder and CEO Mark Coleman to talk about the future of HR, the growing complexity of AI, and why the industry needs to rethink how it operates. We discuss why HR leaders must unlearn outdated approaches, what it means to build a workforce of humans and AI agents, and why in-person connections are becoming more important than ever. Plus, Mark shares why UNLEASH is moving its U.S. event to Miami in 2027 and how he's reimagining the experience to help HR leaders make better decisions.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
HR has an opportunity to lead the transformation of how humans and AI agents work together.
Becoming AI-native requires leaders to unlearn familiar practices and rethink traditional ways of working.
AI adoption is creating confusion and complexity for HR leaders, particularly around governance, legal considerations, and workforce planning.
In-person events are increasingly valuable as distributed teams look for opportunities to connect, collaborate, and learn from one another.
UNLEASH Miami 2027 is designed to bring HR leaders and organizations together for meaningful connections and better decision-making, not just networking.
Find Marc on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/marccoleman/
Learn more about Unleash: https://www.unleash.ai/events/unleash-miami
KEYWORDS
future of HR, Mark Coleman, UNLEASH Paris, UNLEASH Miami 2027, artificial intelligence in HR, AI-native workforce, HR leadership, future of work, AI agents, HR transformation, workforce planning, HR technology, talent acquisition, HR conferences, Don't Tell Me About Yourself
“Are We Punishing Real Candidates to Catch Fake Ones?” with Nathan Perrott
2026/11/10
Episode Description:
Live from UNLEASH Paris, we're joined by Nathan Perrott from Radancy to talk about the growing challenges of AI-driven applications, candidate fraud, and trust in the hiring process. We discuss why AI-optimized resumes are making it harder for recruiters to identify qualified candidates, how companies may be creating unnecessary barriers in an effort to prevent fraud, and why protecting the hiring process shouldn't come at the expense of genuine candidates. Plus, how ChatGPT and other AI tools are changing employer branding and what companies need to know about how they're being represented to job seekers.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
1. AI-optimized resumes are making it harder for recruiters to distinguish candidates based on traditional application screening alone.
2. Candidate fraud isn't one-size-fits-all. Using AI to improve a resume and intentionally misrepresenting someone's identity are very different issues.
3. Adding unnecessary barriers to prevent fraud can hurt legitimate candidates and damage the candidate experience.
4. Trust is breaking down on both sides of hiring, with candidates questioning employers and employers questioning candidate information.
5. Employers need to understand how AI assistants like ChatGPT are presenting their jobs, employer brand, and reputation to potential candidates.
Find Nathan on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/nathanperrott/
Website: www.radancy.com
KEYWORDS
AI in hiring, candidate fraud, fake candidates, AI resumes, candidate experience, Radancy, recruitment technology, employer branding, ChatGPT job search, AI visibility, talent acquisition, hiring process, UNLEASH Paris
"Everyone's Waiting for Someone Else to Figure Out AI" with Sondra Maher
2026/11/09
Episode Description:
Live from UNLEASH Paris, we're joined by Sondra Maher of CoderPad to talk about why companies are still looking to each other for answers on AI instead of experimenting themselves. We discuss the shift from treating AI as cheating in technical interviews to actually assessing how candidates use it, why hiring assessments should reflect the real job, and how transparency can help companies navigate candidate fraud concerns. Plus, why Sondra believes we're all learning AI together, regardless of experience or seniority.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Companies need to stop waiting for others to figure out AI and start experimenting.
AI use in interviews is shifting from something companies want to prevent to a skill they actively want to assess.
Hiring assessments should reflect how employees will actually use AI on the job.
Clear expectations about AI usage can help reduce confusion and candidate fraud concerns.
Organizations can accelerate AI adoption by encouraging experimentation and sharing what employees learn.
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sondramaher/
Website: https://coderpad.io/
KEYWORDS
AI in hiring, AI skills assessment, CoderPad, technical interviews, AI fluency, candidate fraud, AI cheating, skills-based hiring, hiring assessments, UNLEASH Paris, Don't Tell Me About Yourself
Are These the Worst Job Interviews on the Internet?
2026/10/28
Episode Description:
An iced coffee gets you judged. A CEO makes you wait an hour. A hiring manager plants trash on the floor to test your character. And somehow, these are real job interview stories.
In this episode of Don't Tell Me About Yourself, Expert Interviewers co-founders Victoria Gates and Lorna Erickson break down some of the worst viral job interview stories on the internet and debate what these situations actually reveal about candidates and the people interviewing them. From controversial dress codes and secret hiring tests to interviewers yelling at candidates, asking inappropriate questions, and rejecting people over unwritten rules, they explore where professionalism ends and personal bias begins. You'll hear why seemingly harmless preferences can turn into unfair hiring decisions, how bad interviewer behavior damages the candidate experience, and why social media is changing accountability in hiring. Because sometimes the biggest red flag in an interview isn't the candidate. It's the person asking the questions.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Bringing iced coffee to an interview shouldn't determine whether someone gets hired. Personal preferences and unwritten expectations aren't reliable measures of job performance.
Professionalism is subjective. What one interviewer considers inappropriate, another might see as completely acceptable.
Candidates shouldn't be penalized for dress code expectations that were never communicated, especially when interviewers aren't held to the same standards.
Secret hiring tests, like the coffee cup test or deliberately leaving trash on the floor, often reveal more about an interviewer's judgment than a candidate's qualifications.
A candidate's willingness to clean up a coffee cup or pick up garbage doesn't necessarily predict their initiative, character, or ability to perform a job.
Evaluating whether you'd enjoy spending time with a candidate can introduce personal chemistry and bias into hiring decisions, even when collaboration is an important part of the role.
Interviewers who yell at candidates, criticize their own employees, or show up excessively late without apologizing are giving candidates a preview of the company's culture.
Candidates and interviewers should be held to similar standards of professionalism, preparation, and respect.
Questions about pregnancy, age, retirement, or a candidate's ChatGPT history can cross important personal and professional boundaries.
Candidates are increasingly willing to end interviews when employers reveal unreasonable expectations or behaviors that don't align with their values.
Social media has given candidates a platform to expose bad interview experiences, creating more transparency and accountability in the hiring process.
Hiring managers can unintentionally adopt ineffective interviewing practices after seeing viral stories or advice online without understanding whether those methods actually predict performance.
The goal of an interview isn't to catch candidates doing something wrong. It's to determine whether they can do the job, want to do the job, and whether the company is somewhere they'd want to work.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – When the interviewer is the biggest red flag
01:27 – The viral iced coffee interview debate
04:42 – Should candidates be rejected for what they wear?
08:55 – Secret hiring tests and the coffee cup test
12:04 – The crumpled paper test and judging candidate character
14:31 – United Airlines and the four-day trip test
19:09 – When interviewers yell at candidates about professionalism
22:22 – Hiring managers who trash their own employees
24:17 – When the CEO shows up an hour late
26:34 – Inappropriate interview questions and ChatGPT history
27:58 – Why candidates are calling out bad interviews online
28:57 – When candidates decide to end the interview
30:47 – Has social media made interviewing better or worse?
31:58 – Which interview red flags would make us walk away?
33:20 – The interviewing practices we'd ban forever
34:34 – Why interviewers need to meet candidates' standards, too
KEYWORDS
worst job interviews, interview red flags, bad interview experiences, interviewer red flags, viral interview stories, hiring manager mistakes, interview professionalism, iced coffee interview, coffee cup test, secret interview tests, inappropriate interview questions, interview bias, candidate experience, hiring manager training, interview etiquette, interview dress code, job interview horror stories, candidate rejection, structured interviews, hiring decisions, social media and hiring
Does Every Candidate Deserve Interview Feedback?
2026/10/21
Episode Description:
Everyone says candidates deserve feedback. But what happens when the hiring manager can't actually explain why someone was rejected?
In this episode of Don't Tell Me About Yourself, Expert Interviewers co-founders Victoria Gates and Lorna Erickson debate whether every job candidate deserves interview feedback, why companies are so hesitant to provide it, and what candidates should realistically expect after being rejected. From ghosting and generic rejection emails to legal concerns, gut-feeling hiring decisions, and poorly documented interviews, they explore the difference between communication, transparency, feedback, and coaching. You'll learn how much feedback candidates should receive at different stages of the hiring process, why internal candidates need additional consideration, and how recruiters and hiring managers can give more useful, evidence-based feedback. Because if you can't explain why you rejected someone, the bigger problem might be how you made the hiring decision in the first place.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Not every candidate needs personalized interview feedback, but candidates deserve clear communication about where they stand in the hiring process.
Candidates often want closure more than coaching. A timely update or rejection can prevent unnecessary confusion, frustration, and speculation.
Companies hesitate to give interview feedback because of time constraints, legal concerns, uncomfortable conversations, poor documentation, and unclear hiring decisions.
Poor feedback doesn't necessarily mean poor candidate performance. It may indicate that interviewers lack the evidence needed to explain their decisions.
Communication, transparency, feedback, and coaching are different levels of candidate engagement. Communication is the baseline, while personalized feedback and coaching require more time and investment.
The further a candidate progresses through the hiring process, the more specific and individualized their feedback should become.
Applicants and candidates completing initial recruiter screens should receive timely updates and clear decisions, even when personalized feedback isn't practical.
Final-round candidates deserve meaningful, job-related feedback that explains how their experience and interview responses aligned with the role's requirements.
Internal candidates may need additional feedback and development guidance because rejection can affect their ongoing working relationships and future career opportunities.
Generic rejection explanations like "we went in another direction," "you weren't a fit," or "we needed someone more senior" provide little useful information without specific context.
Effective interview feedback should connect directly to predefined job criteria, observable evidence, and the skills or experience required for the position.
Hiring managers must be able to explain why they selected or rejected a candidate. If the decision was based primarily on gut feeling or personal chemistry, meaningful feedback becomes difficult.
Feedback is valuable, but communication is non-negotiable. Silence should never be a company's rejection strategy.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – Does every candidate deserve interview feedback?
01:41 – Why candidates want feedback after rejection
02:54 – Why candidates are left without answers
03:50 – Interview feedback versus basic communication
05:16 – Why companies hesitate to give feedback
07:53 – How poor documentation prevents useful feedback
09:17 – When hiring managers can't explain their decisions
10:38 – Communication, transparency, feedback, and coaching
13:15 – The bare minimum every candidate deserves
15:37 – How much feedback should candidates receive?
16:37 – Giving honest feedback during recruiter screens
18:17 – What candidates deserve after an interview
19:24 – Why finalists need personalized feedback
20:24 – Should internal candidates receive more coaching?
22:41 – What to say instead of generic rejection phrases
25:22 – Why good feedback starts before the interview
26:34 – Feedback is valuable, communication is non-negotiable
KEYWORDS
candidate feedback, interview feedback, interview rejection, why companies don't give feedback, how to give interview feedback, candidate experience, candidate ghosting, rejection email, hiring manager feedback, recruiter communication, candidate rejection, internal candidate feedback, structured interviews, evidence-based hiring, hiring decisions, interview scorecards, hiring manager training
How Many Interviews Is Too Many?
2026/10/14
Episode Description:
Five rounds. Nine interviewers. Six weeks. And the final hiring decision still comes down to a “good feeling.” Sound familiar?
How many interview rounds does it actually take to make a good hire? In this episode of Don't Tell Me About Yourself, Expert Interviewers co-founders Victoria Gates and Lorna Erickson break down why hiring processes become unnecessarily long, whether more interviews actually improve hiring decisions, and how recruiters and hiring managers can design a more efficient interview process. From recruiter screens and panel interviews to executive approvals and hiring debriefs, they explore how to eliminate redundant interviews without sacrificing hiring quality, candidate experience, or confidence in the final decision.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
1. Why interview processes get longer: Fear of making the wrong hiring decision, groupthink, unnecessary approvals, and poorly defined evaluation criteria can all contribute to interview bloat.
2. More interviews don't automatically mean better hires: Google's research on its own hiring process found diminishing returns after four interviews, demonstrating why adding rounds doesn't necessarily improve decision-making.
3. Every interview round needs a purpose: Recruiter screens, hiring manager interviews, panel interviews, and executive conversations should each evaluate something specific rather than repeat the same questions.
4. Panel interviews can improve efficiency: When structured properly, panels bring different perspectives together, reduce repetitive questions, and allow interviewers to evaluate the same evidence.
5. The right number of interviews depends on the role: Hourly, entry-level, individual contributor, management, and executive positions require different levels of evaluation.
6. Internal candidates still deserve a structured process: Familiarity, previous performance, and internal reputation shouldn't replace consistent, evidence-based evaluation.
7. Uncertainty isn't a reason to add another round: Before scheduling an additional interview, identify exactly what information is missing and how the next conversation will uncover it.
8. Structured interviews need structured decisions: Interview scorecards and independent evaluations help prevent hiring debriefs from becoming exercises in groupthink.
9. Hiring teams need clear responsibilities: Each interviewer should understand what they're evaluating, what evidence to collect, and how that information contributes to the final decision.
10. The goal isn't fewer interviews at any cost: It's fewer pointless interviews and a hiring process that respects everyone's time while producing better-informed decisions.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – Five rounds, nine interviewers, and one gut feeling 01:25 – Why interview processes become unnecessarily long 04:03 – What should each interview round actually evaluate? 07:38 – Are panel interviews helpful or just intimidating? 11:13 – Does adding more interviews improve hiring decisions? 13:31 – How many interviews are needed for different roles? 19:35 – Should internal candidates follow the same process? 21:28 – How to design a more efficient interview process 23:20 – Why structured debriefs and scorecards matter 25:20 – How to eliminate unnecessary interview rounds
KEYWORDS
interview process, interview rounds, hiring process efficiency, structured interviews, hiring decisions, candidate experience, panel interviews, interview scorecards, hiring managers, recruitment best practices
Did Anyone Actually Teach You How to Interview? with Danielle Farage
2026/10/07
Episode Description: We train managers on leadership, performance, and compliance, but when it comes to interviewing, many are handed a resume and expected to figure it out. In this episode, we’re joined by future of work expert Danielle Farage to talk about why interviewing is still treated like an assumed skill, what happens when new managers are not given the tools to hire well, and how poor interviews affect hiring decisions, candidate experience, employer brand, and manager confidence. We also share what every new hiring manager should know before interviewing their first candidate and officially launch the New Hiring Manager Playbook, a practical guide built to help managers prepare, interview, and make better hiring decisions without needing years of experience first.
Get the New Hiring Manager Playbook for $29.99:https://expert-interviewers.mykajabi.com/new-hiring-manager-playbook
Created by Expert Interviewers in collaboration with Danielle Farage and delivered through Adobe PDF Spaces, the Playbook includes practical guidance, checklists, scripts, and interactive support designed for first-time interviewers and hiring managers who were never formally taught how to interview.
Key Takeaways:
Becoming a manager does not automatically make someone a skilled interviewer.
Interviewing is often treated as an assumed skill instead of something managers need to learn and practice.
Many interviewers inherit their approach from previous managers, outdated question lists, or their own experiences as candidates instead of receiving formal training.
A poor interview process can lead to bad hiring decisions, cause companies to lose strong candidates, damage employer brand, and hurt a new manager’s confidence.
Candidates are evaluating the company and hiring manager during the interview just as much as the company is evaluating them.
Hiring managers should prepare before every interview by understanding the role, reviewing the candidate’s background, knowing what they are responsible for assessing, and preparing useful questions.
Interviews should be treated as a two-way conversation rather than an interrogation or test of whether a candidate knows the unwritten rules.
The interviewer owns the meeting and is responsible for asking good questions, following up, and collecting enough evidence to make a hiring decision.
A candidate who interviews well is not automatically the candidate who will perform best in the job.
New hiring managers need practical support they can use before, during, and after an interview.
The New Hiring Manager Playbook was created to give first-time and undertrained interviewers the most important tools they need to get started.
Your first few interviews should not have to be your training. Interviewing is a skill, and skills can be learned.
Timestamps
00:00 Why managers are expected to interview without training
04:15 What happens when a new manager makes a bad hire
06:12 Why interviewing is treated like an assumed skill
09:28 What’s at stake when managers interview poorly
13:40 Signs an interviewer needs more support
18:20 Why “I’ll just wing it” is a problem
21:38 What every new hiring manager should know
22:36 Why interviewing should be a two-way conversation
26:34 The interviewer’s responsibility in the conversation
28:22 Why we created the New Hiring Manager Playbook
33:10 What’s inside the Playbook + Adobe PDF Spaces
34:17 The New Hiring Manager Playbook launch
Keywords
hiring manager training, new manager training, interview training, how to interview candidates, interview skills, hiring manager interview questions, candidate experience, interview preparation, structured interviews, New Hiring Manager Playbook
Is Your Interview Panel Just a Group Vibe Check?
2026/09/23
Episode Description:Interview panels are supposed to bring more perspectives, reduce bias, and lead to better hiring decisions. But adding more interviewers does not automatically create more structure. In this episode, we break down why panel interviews often turn into repeated questions, conflicting standards, loud opinions, and groupthink. You’ll learn how to prepare interviewers before a panel, assign clear areas of evaluation, improve the candidate experience, score candidates independently, and run a debrief that focuses on evidence instead of who liked the candidate most.
Key Takeaways:
Adding more interviewers does not automatically make an interview process more structured or objective.
A successful panel should not be five people interviewing the same candidate. It should be five people collecting different pieces of evidence.
Interviewers should know exactly which skills or competencies they own before the candidate enters the room.
Repeating the same questions wastes interview time and prevents the team from evaluating other important job-related criteria.
Candidates notice when interviewers are unprepared, distracted, contradicting each other, or unclear about their role in the process.
A panel interview can become a candidate’s first preview of how meetings, communication, and decision-making work inside the company.
Interviewers should score candidates independently before discussing them with the rest of the panel.
The first or loudest opinion in a debrief can influence everyone else, especially when interviewers have different levels of seniority.
Disagreement between interviewers can be useful when the team goes back to the evidence instead of averaging scores or trying to reach immediate consensus.
Having a structured interview process is not the same as having a structured hiring decision process.
Calibration means interviewers are using the same definitions and standards to evaluate evidence, not that everyone has to give the candidate the same score.
Good panel interviews define success before the interview, focus on job-related evidence during it, and use independent scoring followed by an evidence-based debrief afterward.
Timestamps
01:21 Why interview panels make companies feel safer03:20 Why more interviewers do not mean more structure05:09 Why a successful panel starts before the interview05:59 The problem with repeated interview questions07:21 How candidates know a panel is unprepared09:27 When the debrief becomes a group vibe check10:21 What hiring managers told us about debriefs11:29 Why interviewers should score candidates independently12:41 How seniority and loud opinions influence decisions15:09 Why disagreement can improve a hiring debrief16:48 Structured interviews versus structured hiring decisions18:22 What a good panel looks like before, during, and after21:28 Are panel interviews actually bad?
Keywords
panel interviewinterview panelpanel interview questionshow to conduct a panel interviewpanel interview best practicesinterview debriefhiring debriefinterview scorecardstructured interviewsgroupthink in hiringhiring manager interview traininginterview biascandidate evaluationinterview calibration
Did You Really Ever Have A Shot At That Promotion?
2026/09/16
Internal interviews can be harder to evaluate fairly than external interviews because managers already know the candidate, their reputation, their past mistakes, and their current performance. In this episode, we explain how to interview internal candidates fairly, how to avoid predetermined promotion decisions, why strong performance in a current role does not automatically predict success in the next one, and how to give useful feedback when an employee does not get promoted. You will also learn how structured interviews, clear job criteria, and neutral interviewers can improve internal hiring decisions.
Key Takeaways:
If the hiring decision is already made and no interview could change the outcome, do not put employees through a performative interview process.
Having a frontrunner for an internal role is different from having a predetermined winner.
Internal candidates can have both advantages and disadvantages because managers already know their strengths, weaknesses, reputation, and past performance.
Being successful in a current role is not evidence that someone will automatically succeed in the next role.
Internal promotions should be based on the requirements of the new job, not tenure, likability, loyalty, or whose turn it seems to be.
Familiarity and personal chemistry can easily replace job-related evidence when managers evaluate internal candidates.
Internal candidates need specific feedback when they are not selected so they understand what skills, competencies, or experience they need to develop.
Feedback like “you are not ready yet” or “someone else was stronger” is too vague to help an employee improve.
Internal and external candidates should still be evaluated against the same job-related standards and structured interview criteria.
A neutral interviewer can help hiring teams separate familiarity, internal history, and bias from evidence about whether someone can do the job.
Timestamps
01:22 Was the internal job actually open?
02:27 Frontrunner versus predetermined promotion
03:04 When an internal interview is already decided
06:09 Why internal interviews become awkward
07:22 Why high performance does not guarantee promotion success
09:11 Internal candidate advantages and disadvantages
11:29 How gut feeling affects internal hiring
16:45 Why internal candidate feedback matters
19:41 How to give useful promotion feedback
24:49 How to reduce bias in internal interviews
Keywords
internal interviewinternal candidate interviewinternal promotionpromotion interviewhow to interview internal candidatesinternal hiring processinternal candidate feedbackstructured interviewspromotion decisionshiring manager interview training
Can You Believe These Interview Questions Still Exist?
2026/09/09
Some interview questions refuse to die. We break down why hiring managers still ask questions like “Tell me about yourself,” “What’s your greatest weakness?” and “Where do you see yourself in five years?” even when they often provide very little useful evidence about whether someone can do the job. You’ll learn what these questions are actually measuring, what to ask instead, why structured interviewing leads to better decisions, and why the best interviewers focus less on finding the perfect question and more on asking better follow-ups.
Key Takeaways
Many outdated interview questions survive because they are familiar and easy to ask, not because they are effective.
“Tell me about yourself” is often too broad to produce consistent, job-related information.
Questions about weaknesses commonly produce rehearsed answers instead of useful evidence.
Understanding what candidates liked and disliked about past roles can reveal more than asking where they see themselves in five years.
“Sell me this pen” and other hypotheticals are weaker than asking about real past experience.
Animal questions, brain teasers, and other non-qualifying questions add little value to hiring decisions.
Structured interviews help hiring teams evaluate candidates more consistently.
The best interviewers are not the ones with the most creative questions. They know when to follow up.
When candidates speak generally, ask them to walk you through a specific situation.
A good interview is about collecting evidence you can actually use to make a hiring decision.
Timestamps
01:04 The interview questions that won’t die 02:21 Why outdated interview questions survive 03:55 What to ask instead of “Tell me about yourself” 06:50 Why the weakness question misses 10:04 The problem with five-year questions 12:25 Why “Sell me this pen” fails 15:31 Retiring animal and brain-teaser questions 18:35 Why structured interviews work better 19:27 The interviewing skill that matters most 20:59 How to ask better follow-up questions
Keywords
interview questions to avoid best interview questions how to interview candidates structured interviews behavioral interview questions hiring manager interview training better interview questions interview follow-up questions
Do Recruiters & Hiring Managers Need Couples Therapy?
2026/09/02
Season 2 is back, and we’re starting with one of the relationships that can make or break the entire hiring process: recruiters and hiring managers. We break down why the two sides so often end up frustrated with each other, where the partnership starts to fall apart, and how that disconnect impacts candidates. You’ll learn how to define success together, set clearer expectations, improve communication, clarify ownership, and turn hiring from a handoff into an actual partnership.
Key Takeaways
Recruiters and hiring managers often want the same outcome but blame each other when the process breaks down.
Many hiring problems start in the initial intake meeting when expectations are vague or assumed.
Recruiters and hiring managers need to define what success looks like before candidates enter the process.
Changing requirements or scorecards mid-process makes hiring slower and less consistent.
Candidate motivation matters just as much as whether someone can technically do the job.
Candidates feel internal misalignment through delays, repeated questions, and poor communication.
Clear boundaries and proactive communication build stronger hiring partnerships.
Recruiters bring market knowledge, candidate pipelines, and candidate communication expertise.
Hiring managers own interview quality, decision quality, and meaningful feedback.
Hiring works best when recruiters and hiring managers treat success as shared responsibility.
Timestamps
00:52 Why recruiters and hiring managers clash 01:44 The biggest recruiter frustrations 04:33 What hiring managers complain about 07:03 How candidates feel the disconnect 08:40 Where hiring partnerships break down 11:00 Why candidate motivators matter 15:26 Coaching hiring managers in real time 17:48 Trust, boundaries, and communication 22:35 What recruiters and managers each own 28:10 How to run a better kickoff meeting
Keywords
recruiter hiring manager relationship recruiter hiring manager partnership hiring process alignment hiring manager responsibilities recruiter responsibilities recruiting intake meeting candidate experience hiring process communication interview process alignment recruiting collaboration
You’re Losing Candidates and Customers with Daniel Birkholm
2026/05/20
In this live episode, you’ll learn why most companies are overlooking the biggest risk in their hiring process: candidate experience. Daniel Birkholm shares how focusing only on hired candidates ignores the majority of people interacting with your brand and why that can hurt both hiring outcomes and business performance. This is a practical look at how to measure candidate experience, improve hiring quality, and build a more sustainable recruiting strategy.
Key Takeaways:
Most companies reject 95% of candidates and ignore their experience
Poor candidate experience can damage your brand and revenue
Happy candidates are more likely to become customers
Negative experiences spread faster than positive ones
Candidate experience impacts quality of hire
Feedback loops are critical to improving hiring
Many teams focus too much on efficiency over experience
Data-driven hiring leads to better outcomes
Candidates can still have a good experience even if rejected
Measuring experience helps create more sustainable hiring
Keywords: candidate experience, hiring metrics, candidate NPS, recruitment feedback, employer brand impact, hiring strategy data, talent acquisition metrics, candidate journey, recruitment analytics, hiring experience improvement
Follow Daniel at https://www.linkedin.com/in/danielbirkholm/
Sponsored by @shakerrecruitmentmarketing
Podcast reviews
Read Don’t Tell Me About Yourself podcast reviews
5 out of 5
8 reviews
★★★★★
20yearrecruiter 2026/02/16
AI
Great points on how to use AI rather than rely on AI in the hiring process!
★★★★★
victoriaamore 2026/02/09
10/10
Great topics great gals!
★★★★★
Angela8040 2026/01/30
Amazing
Such a good listen!!
★★★★★
Sean61675 2026/01/30
10/10
These ladies are the best!
★★★★★
LDooneE4 2026/01/29
Hiring experts!
It’s a refreshing take and practical skills on how hiring managers can improve! Candidates can breathe, easier, knowing that these two are out there ...