
Advertise on podcast: uNILateral Decisions
Rating
5from
Categories
This podcast has
39 episodes
Language
EnglishPublisher
The Stable MediaExplicit
No
Date created
2026/03/05
Latest episode
2026/11/16
Average duration
46 min.
Release period
8 days
Description
Where College Athletics Meets Legal Reality Timely breakdowns of legal decisions and their impact on the NCAA, schools and student athletes.
Unlock uNILateral Decisions podcast Email contact info,
Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details

Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights

Audience details
Podcast Insights

Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from uNILateral Decisions podcast
24-Team Playoff, No Conferences? College Football's Next Big Debate
2026/11/16
With the College Football Playoff expanding to 24 teams, a new question is gaining traction across college athletics: Do we even need conferences anymore?
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Mike Walsh and Sam Ehrlich explore the growing debate over the future of college football conferences and the legal, financial, and competitive consequences of eliminating them.
From Eli Drinkwitz's comments about conference relevance to the SEC and Big Ten's growing influence over the playoff, Mike and Sam examine whether independence could benefit individual programs—or create even bigger problems for college athletics.
The conversation dives into antitrust law, NCAA governance, athlete employment, collective bargaining, and whether the College Football Playoff could eventually become college football's governing body.
Plus, what happens to billion-dollar television deals if conferences disappear? And could college football ever adopt a professional league structure similar to the NFL?
This week's uNILateral Decision: If you were running a major college football program, would you push to eliminate conferences?
Join Mike and Sam as they look beyond the headlines to explore what a conference-free future would actually mean for college sports.
Did the Election Just Kill the Protect College Sports Act?
2026/11/09
The political landscape has shifted dramatically, and the future of the Protect College Sports Act (PCSA) may be hanging in the balance.
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Joe Nickell, Mike Walsh, and Sam Ehrlich break down what the election results could mean for federal legislation governing college athletics, whether the NCAA can push the PCSA through before a new Congress takes office, and what comes next for college sports.
Before diving into Washington, the guys examine two major developments in the ongoing battle over NCAA eligibility. Robbie Avila's legal victory at Saint Louis raises new questions about roster limits, while Arizona basketball player RJ Godfrey takes a different legal approach by suing his own university's governing board rather than the NCAA.
Topics include:
Robbie Avila's eligibility ruling and its implications for NCAA roster limitsRJ Godfrey's lawsuit against the Arizona Board of RegentsThe growing number of eligibility lawsuits and their potential impact on college basketballHow the election results could reshape the future of the PCSAWhether the NCAA can secure federal legislation before the new Congress takes officeWhat a new approach to college sports legislation could mean for athletes and athletic departmentsPlus, in this week's uNILateral Decision, the guys tackle a timely question: If you're an athletic director with an outgoing member of Congress, are you applying pressure to get the PCSA passed before it's too late?
Subscribe for weekly conversations about NIL, NCAA litigation, athlete rights, and the rapidly changing landscape of college athletics.
The Scariest Things in College Sports Right Now
2026/11/02
🎃 What’s the scariest thing happening in college athletics right now?
In this Halloween edition of uNILateral Decisions, Dominic Shelden, Mike Walsh, Joe Nickell, and Sam Ehrlich tackle some of the biggest issues facing college sports.
🏈 Brett Yormark’s reported departure from the Big 12 and what it could mean for the future of conference leadership.
⚖️ The Big Ten’s attempt to implement its own NIL framework ahead of the PCSA, and the legal challenges that could follow.
🏛️ The PCSA’s uncertain future in Congress as the midterm elections approach.
👻 Plus, our Halloween-themed uNILateral Decision: What should college athletics fear most? From unsustainable athletic department budgets and unintended consequences of federal legislation to eligibility lawsuits and the decline of sports journalism, the crew shares what keeps them up at night.
All that and more on this week's episode of uNILateral Decisions!
🎙️ Watch or listen to the full episode now.
#uNILateralDecisions #CollegeAthletics #NIL #CollegeSports #NCAA
The NCAA Sued Ohio’s Governor. Its Argument? Free Speech.
2026/10/26
The NCAA sued Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine after his executive order made Ohio’s class of 2022 athletes eligible, and its argument is the First Amendment. Neal Ternes, a First Amendment scholar and assistant professor of sports management at Northern Illinois University, joins Dominic Sheldon, Mike Walsh, Sam Ehrlich and Joe Nickell to break down the NCAA’s “freedom of association” claim, how it stacks up against the Big 12 and SEC cases built on the same idea, and what’s at stake if conferences can punish schools that back athletes in court.
We also cover NIL deals with vice industries, fan free speech in college stadiums, and whether treating athletes as employees changes the math. In this week’s uNILateral Decision: are college athletes students with constitutional rights, or members of a voluntary association that can limit what they say?
(0:36) Ohio’s executive order
(4:32) Meet Neal Ternes
(6:39) The NCAA’s First Amendment claim
(30:36) Can a conference kick out a school?
(34:18) NIL and athlete speech
(41:51) Free speech in the stands
(56:24) The uNILateral Decision
Can a Governor Override the NCAA? Ohio Just Raised the Stakes
2026/10/19
Ohio Governor Mike DeWine has entered the NCAA eligibility debate, signing an executive order that could give Class of 2022 athletes at Ohio universities another year of competition.
But how much power does a governor actually have over NCAA eligibility rules?
This week on uNILateral Decisions, the crew breaks down Ohio's executive order, its legal implications, and how a recent Ohio Supreme Court decision factors into the ongoing five-for-five eligibility debate.
Could this trigger a domino effect across college athletics? Are we heading back to the early days of NIL, when states created their own rules and regulations? And if governors can intervene in NCAA eligibility decisions, who has the authority to stop them?
The crew also discusses whether other governors will face pressure to follow Ohio's lead, what this could mean for states like Idaho, and how the NCAA might respond.
This week's uNILateral Decision: If you're the governor of a state with universities affected by the five-for-five eligibility rule, do you issue a similar executive order?
Another week, another legal battle reshaping college athletics.
Follow the Money: The Economics of College Athletics with Greg Chick
2026/10/12
Is paying college athletes really causing a financial crisis, or are schools blaming players for problems that existed long before revenue sharing?
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Mike Walsh, Joe Nickell, and Sam Ehrlich welcome Dr. Greg Chick, founder of NILnomics, to take a closer look at the numbers driving the business of college athletics.
The group breaks down the House settlement's salary cap, whether athletic department donations should count toward revenue sharing, and what a recent Government Accountability Office report actually tells us about college sports spending.
They also discuss the Protect College Sports Act (PCSA), skyrocketing coaching salaries, expensive facilities, inconsistent financial reporting, and the growing influence of corporate business models in college athletics.
Plus, Greg introduces a different way of thinking about the financial arms race: What if costs aren't driving the need for more revenue, but instead schools are spending more simply because they have more?
The episode wraps up with each panelist identifying one financial claim in college athletics they'd like to see retired until someone can back it up with the books.
Follow Greg Chick and NILnomics: https://nilnomics.com
Subscribe to uNILateral Decisions for conversations on NIL, college sports law, athlete compensation, and the changing landscape of college athletics.
#NIL #CollegeAthletics #RevenueSharing #NILnomics #SportsLaw #uNILateralDecisions
Is the PCSA Unconstitutional? + The NCAA’s Eligibility Fight Continues
2026/10/05
The NCAA’s eligibility fight isn’t slowing down — and neither are the lawsuits.
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Joe, Mike and Sam break down the NCAA’s transition rule and the growing wave of litigation surrounding the move to the new five-for-five eligibility model.
Why does it matter that the NCAA’s transition rule wasn’t actually included in its bylaws? We look at several major cases across the country and how courts are handling arguments over breach of contract, antitrust law and the Class of 2022. With appeals moving forward and athletes racing against the clock, could we finally be getting closer to some kind of precedent?
The conversation also comes back to the Protect College Sports Act (PCSA) and its potential impact on these fights. Could an antitrust exemption change the landscape surrounding revenue sharing and other NCAA rules? And after doing more research since last week’s episode, Sam has changed his position on one major question: Is the PCSA constitutional?
Plus, the guys debate whether the NCAA should simply stop fighting and grant the Class of 2022 another year of eligibility — or whether, after investing this much into the legal battle, it makes sense to see the fight through.
We cover the NCAA transition rule, five-for-five eligibility, the Class of 2022 lawsuits, contract vs. antitrust claims, the importance of economic evidence, appellate stays, the PCSA’s proposed antitrust protections, private non-delegation concerns and what could finally bring some clarity to college sports eligibility.
The PCSA Could Pass the Senate — What Changed?
2026/09/25
The PCSA is closer than ever to becoming law.
After passing all five procedural votes in the Senate with at least 70 votes each, the bill could be headed for a final Senate vote as early as next week. This week on uNILateral Decisions, the crew breaks down what changed to generate that level of support and what happens next if the bill makes it through the Senate.
They dig into the reported amendments to the PCSA, including provisions surrounding conference expansion, MMRs and associated entities counting against the compensation cap, and questions around potential limits on coaching salaries.
The conversation also covers some of the biggest pieces of the bill for college athletes, including 5-for-5 eligibility, the one-time transfer rule, the athlete compensation pool, and agent registration and certification.
Finally, it’s time for a uNILateral Decision: Fast forward to December. The House has taken up the bill, every vote has been cast except yours, and your vote determines whether the PCSA becomes law.
How are you voting?
The Other Side of the Eligibility Fight
2026/09/18
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Joe Nickell, Mike Walsh, and Sam Ehrlich dig into the other side of the eligibility chaos — the cases where athletes didn’t receive an extra year. While headlines make it seem like every lawsuit leads to a fifth season, the reality is far more complicated, and the hosts break down why certain courts are pushing back.
The conversation centers on the three major categories of eligibility litigation: the massive wave of class‑of‑2022 lawsuits, JUCO‑year disputes inspired by Diego Pavia and Tristan Smith, and the increasingly contentious cases involving former professional athletes. Sam walks through how these categories intersect, why some courts are granting relief, and why others are shutting the door.
They also unpack the “big three” states — Tennessee, Georgia, and Ohio — where appellate courts have issued stays on previously granted injunctions, creating a national split in how judges view breach‑of‑contract claims, property‑interest arguments, and the NCAA’s role as a private association with monopsony power. The hosts explore how personal jurisdiction, shifting plaintiffs between states, and massive multi‑athlete filings are shaping the litigation strategy.
The episode wraps with a look at TROs vs. preliminary injunctions, the NCAA’s perfect record on appellate stays, and what happens next as athletes continue filing, courts diverge, and the Protect College Sports Act adds new layers of uncertainty.
Topics include:The three major categories of eligibility lawsuits: class of 2022, JUCO‑year claims, and former prosWhy Tennessee, Georgia, and Ohio became the “big three” denialsHow appellate stays are reshaping the national landscapeThe evolving breach‑of‑contract argument — and why some courts no longer buy itPersonal jurisdiction battles and moving plaintiffs across statesTROs vs. preliminary injunctions — and why the injunction is the real ballgameThe NCAA’s success in securing appellate staysWhether athletes can refile in more favorable statesHow the Protect College Sports Act complicates eligibility going forwardJoe, Mike, and Sam’s uNILateral Decisions on what should happen next
Subscribe for weekly conversations on NIL, athlete compensation, eligibility, governance, antitrust issues, and the rapidly changing business of college sports.
The Cases That Almost Gave Us Answers
2026/09/11
Some of the most interesting cases in college sports messed around… but stopped just short of finding out.
This week on uNILateral Decisions, we’re looking back at the cases that could have given us real answers to some of the biggest unresolved questions in college athletics, if they had actually made it to a decision.
From the SEC and LSU showdown to Demond Williams, Darian Mensah and Brendan Sorsby, we break down what each case could have decided and the precedent it might have created.
Then we turn to two questions college sports still can’t seem to answer: Are college athletes employees? And will athletes ever successfully unionize?
Finally, for this week’s uNILateral Decision: we were robbed of the chance to find out whether the SEC would actually vote to kick LSU out of the conference. We decide whether that vote needed to happen.
College Football’s All-Litigation Team
2026/09/03
College football has All-America teams, All-Conference teams… and now, apparently, it needs an All-Litigation Team.
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Mike Walsh, Joe Nickell, Dominic Shelden and Sam Ehrlich draft the best and most intriguing players taking the field in 2026 because somewhere along the way, a judge said they could.
From eligibility clocks and JUCO seasons to medical-hardship waivers, transfer restrictions and players attempting to return from the NFL, the guys break down the lawsuits, injunctions and court orders that are reshaping who gets to play college football — including one eligibility battle funded by Lil Wayne.
Then, they turn to College Football’s Market Movers — the players whose decisions, deals and dollars are defining the player market in 2026. Dante Moore, Jeremiah Smith, Darian Mensah, Sam Leavitt, Bryce Underwood and others provide a look at everything from multimillion-dollar retention battles and transfer negotiations to the growing financial incentive for elite players to stay in college.
Finally, the guys make their uNILateral Decision: What is one thing happening in today’s player market that college football should embrace rather than try to regulate away?
How Louisiana Is Changing Athlete Protection with Olivia Nuss
2026/08/27
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Mike Walsh, Joe Nickell, and Sam Ehrlich sit down with Olivia Nuss, Assistant Attorney General in Louisiana, to break down the state’s sweeping new approach to regulating NIL agents — a framework that could reshape athlete protection across college sports. The conversation digs into why Louisiana moved first, what problems the law is designed to solve, and how the absence of national standards has allowed predatory behavior to flourish in the NIL marketplace.
The hosts explore the realities behind NIL deal‑making, including the rise of unregulated agents, the financial risks facing high school and college athletes, and the legal gaps left by outdated federal statutes like UAAA and SPARTA. Olivia walks through the details of Louisiana’s new registration system — from background checks and training modules to disclosure requirements and enforcement powers — and explains why state‑level oversight has become the only viable path while the NCAA remains unable to regulate third‑party actors.
Topics include:
Why NIL agents have operated with little oversight — and how that created space for predatory contractsLouisiana’s new agent‑registration system and mandatory training requirementsHow background checks, disclosures, and public registries aim to protect high school and college athletesThe legal limitations of UAAA and SPARTA in the modern NIL eraWhy the NCAA cannot regulate NIL agents without major antitrust exposureExamples of exploitative NIL deals and long‑term athlete lock‑insThe role of the Attorney General’s office in enforcement, penalties, and athlete remediesHow state‑level regulation could influence future federal legislation
Subscribe for weekly conversations on NIL, athlete compensation, eligibility, governance, antitrust issues, and the rapidly changing business of college sports.
The NCAA Created an Eligibility Disaster
2026/08/20
Dominic Shelden, Mike Walsh, Sam Ehrlich and Joe Nickell are back to break down another chaotic week in college sports.
The NCAA’s new five-years-to-play-five rule has created immediate fallout, with members of the 2022 class fighting for another season of eligibility — and winning in courtrooms across the country. Some players who had already moved on to NFL camps are now being allowed to return to college football, while new lawsuits are challenging transfer restrictions and forcing the NCAA to defend even more of its rulebook.
Sam breaks down why courts continue ruling against the NCAA, what the pending Tenth Circuit decision could mean, and why these cases could have implications well beyond the 2022 class.
The group also discusses how coaches handle players unexpectedly returning at the end of fall camp, the challenges these late roster changes create for the NIL and collectibles industries, whether the NCAA’s transfer portal window could be the next rule to fall, and whether all of this chaos actually improves the chances of federal legislation passing.
Plus, the Unilateral Decision: If you’re a coach with a full roster and a former player suddenly becomes eligible to return, do you make room for them?
Joe has a solution. It gets cold-blooded.
A 6-Star Episode (Because 5 Was Taken) | Jayden Daniels vs LSU
2026/08/15
Jayden Daniels has sent a cease-and-desist letter to LSU, demanding the school stop using his name, image and likeness — and the dispute raises questions that go far beyond one former Heisman Trophy winner.
This week on uNILateral Decisions, the crew breaks down where the line exists between celebrating a former athlete’s legacy and commercially using their NIL. What rights should schools have to historical photos, highlights and facility branding? What happens when those highlights are attached to sponsors? And could former athletes begin challenging how schools, conferences and broadcasters continue to use their likeness years after they leave campus?
The group also digs into the other piece of the Daniels-LSU dispute: No. 5. Should Daniels’ number have been taken out of circulation? Could jersey-number protections eventually become part of player contracts? And how many numbers can a football program realistically retire?
Plus, Mike explains how NIL licensing timelines already work in the trading card industry, Sam examines the right-of-publicity questions behind these disputes, and Joe and Dom look at what athletic departments should be doing now to protect themselves.
Topics include:
Jayden Daniels’ cease-and-desist letter to LSULSU giving No. 5 to another playerNIL rights after an athlete leaves schoolEditorial use vs. commercial use of former athletesHistorical highlights and broadcast NILSponsored content featuring former playersRetired jerseys vs. retired numbersHow schools should handle legacy athletesWhy NIL agreements may need to address these rights moving forwardA 6-Star Episode — because 5 was taken.
:::
The Five‑for‑Five Rule Is Breaking College Sports
2026/08/07
This week on uNILateral Decisions, Mike Walsh, Joe Nickell, and Sam Ehrlich break down the nationwide legal turmoil surrounding the NCAA’s new five‑for‑five eligibility rule—and why the class of 2022 has suddenly become the center of the biggest eligibility fight in college sports.
The conversation digs into how we got here, why courts across the country keep siding with athletes, and how the Colorado class‑action injunction has thrown every compliance office in America into scramble mode. The hosts unpack what the rule was supposed to fix, why it’s now colliding with transfer‑portal restrictions, and how the NCAA’s emergency appeals could reshape the fall sports landscape overnight.
They also examine the practical fallout for coaches and administrators: roster limits, scholarship caps, athletes returning after months away from training, and the looming possibility of new lawsuits if schools can’t accommodate newly eligible players.
And yes—they get into Charlie Baker’s “failed professionals” comment, what he was really trying to signal, and why it matters for Congress, public perception, and the NCAA’s long‑term strategy.
The episode wraps up with another round of uNILateral Decisions, as each host weighs in on what should happen next—and what it would take for the NCAA, conferences, and courts to finally land on a stable eligibility model.
Topics include:
The NCAA’s shift toward eliminating redshirts and simplifying eligibility
Why the class of 2022 is suing—and why judges keep granting injunctions
The Colorado ruling’s national impact after class certification
Confusion around transfer‑portal access vs. eligibility access
How roster limits and scholarship caps complicate fall‑sport planning
The NCAA’s emergency appeals strategy and the 10th Circuit timeline
Charlie Baker’s “failed professionals” remark and its political implications
Whether courts could force roster expansion or further rule changes
The growing tension between judicial authority and NCAA governance
Mike, Joe, and Sam’s uNILateral Decisions on the future of eligibility and athlete rights
Subscribe for weekly conversations on NIL, athlete compensation, eligibility, governance, antitrust issues, and the rapidly changing business of college sports.
Podcast sponsorship advertising
Start advertising on uNILateral Decisions relevant audience podcasts
You may also like to advertise on these Podcasts

4.8167482000
The GaryVee Audio Experience
Gary Vaynerchuk

4.827591720
Earn Your Happy
Lori Harder | YAP Media

4.82494978
The 1000 Hours Outside Podcast
1000 Hours Outside

4.715161997
Thrivetime Show | Business School without the BS
Clay Clark

4.6620172000
The Dan Bongino Show
Cumulus Podcast Network | Dan Bongino

4.98711800
The Adam Mockler Show
MeidasTouch Network

4.824781904
Deck The Hallmark
Bramble Jam Podcast Network

4.916171639
The Kristian Harloff Show
Kristian Harloff

4.847132000
Pat Gray Unleashed
Blaze Podcast Network

4.713452000
The NewsWorthy
Erica Mandy