Advertise on podcast: Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast

Six members of the DeFeo family were murdered in their beds at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, in November 1974. Thirteen months later, the Lutz family moved into that house, knowing what had happened there. They stayed 28 days. On this episode of the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan work through the police record, then the legend built on top of it. What Ronald DeFeo Jr. did on the night of November 13, 1974, why six people were found face down with no sign of a struggle, and how his account moved from a mob hit, to a confession, to a claim of voices in the house. Then the other half of the story: what George and Kathy Lutz said happened to them in those 28 days, and how a murder case became the most retold haunting in America. Two questions hold the episode together. What actually happened inside that house — and did the Lutzes survive a haunting, or walk into a story they could not get out of? Both get worked, side by side, on the evidence. New episodes of the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast every Tuesday. Follow the show so you don't miss the next case. Hosts: Brian Scott and Jill Egan

On Halloween night 1974 in Deer Park, Texas, 8-year-old Timothy O'Bryan died after eating a cyanide-laced Pixy Stix. His father, Ronald Clark O'Bryan, handed out five poisoned candies that night to cover up one murder for insurance money. In this episode of the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan walk through the minute-by-minute timeline of Halloween night, the race to recover the remaining candy, how investigators cleared the wrong house, the insurance motive that exposed the plan, the key evidence from the trial, and why O'Bryan became the first man executed by lethal injection in Texas on March 31, 1984. A classic true crime case with new breakdowns and theories from Brian and Jill. Follow the show for new investigations every Tuesday.

Christa Pike is still alive after Tennessee's failed lethal injection on September 30, 2026. Brian Scott and Jill Egan break down what went wrong inside the death chamber and America's long history of botched executions.Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Pike for the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer. Officials spent more than an hour trying to establish IV access, then administered two doses of pentobarbital. She was transported to a hospital where she remained unconscious for days.Her attorneys say she has now been discharged and returned to prison, with ongoing trauma and issues with concentration and memory. Governor Bill Lee has paused executions pending an independent review. Can Tennessee try again?In this Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast episode, we cover the Christa Pike execution timeline hour by hour, why Tennessee uses single-drug pentobarbital instead of the three-drug cocktail, why that older protocol collapsed, and what happens legally after a failed execution - competency, double jeopardy, and cruel and unusual punishment. We also cover historic failed executions including Willie Francis, Clayton Lockett, Romell Broom, Kenneth Smith, and the halted IV attempt for Tony Carruthers earlier this year.New episodes of the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast every Tuesday. Subscribe and turn on notifications so you never miss an episode. Tell us in the comments: did you know anyone had survived an execution attempt before this case?

What the grand jury saw in the case of Nolan Wells that led to no trial — and what the family's investigators uncovered. On July 4th on Horn Island, 18-year-old Nolan Wells went missing after a group boat trip. Two days later he was found on the island. A grand jury reviewed 132 subpoenas and 43 witnesses and found his death consistent with drowning, with no charges filed. Brian Scott and Jill Egan walk through both tracks side by side: what the state's findings concluded about the Nolan Wells autopsy and the Nolan Wells grand jury decision, and what independent investigators documented about the timeline, head injuries, phone data and Snapchat messages. The Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast breaks down classic and new true crime cases and presenting theories with timelines and evidence comparisons. Follow the show for weekly deep dives.

Daily Scaries: Crime After Crime! This week, we are unpacking a wild lineup of true crime stories and bizarre events that you simply won't believe actually happened. We dive deep into the dark and disturbing allegations surrounding The Cornell 7, and break down a completely bizarre high-speed police chase where the suspect decided to make it rain cash. Plus, we explore a shocking family betrayal that led to a murder in broad daylight, a terrifying discovery made by a toddler... and much more! Grab a seat, and let's get into it. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and let us know in the comments which story shocked you the most this week!

Inside Philadelphia's house of horrors, police found a home lab, a 55-gallon drum plumbed into the water lines, and more than one million files showing 58 people, five of them women who appear deceased. Seven missing women are now linked to the West Chew Avenue home in Olney, owned by Eugene Horsch and shared with his late father, Raymond "R.C." Horsch. It all started with an illegally parked BMW carrying fake DEA credentials and a missing woman's ID. Brian Scott and Jill Egan break down the 2017 videos, what investigators can prove, and why there are still no bodies and no homicide charges. If you have information, call Philadelphia police at 215-686-TIPS (8477).

At 18, Christa Pike became the youngest woman sentenced to death in America. 30 years later, she’s still Tennessee’s only woman on death row — and the state has set her execution for September 30, 2026. In this episode of the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan pull back the veil on a classic case that still shocks Knoxville to this day: the 1995 Job Corps murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer. What really happened on that wooded hilltop off Moody Avenue? Why did a dispute over a boyfriend turn into a planned, brutal attack involving Christa, her 17-year-old boyfriend Tadaryl Shipp, and Shadolla Peterson? And what did investigators find in Christa’s pocket that became one of the most disturbing pieces of evidence in Tennessee history? Brian and Jill walk through the timeline, the trial that led to a death sentence in 1996, the failed appeals, and the theories around motive, manipulation, and mental health that defense teams have argued for decades. If the execution proceeds, Pike would be the first woman executed in Tennessee in more than 200 years. Press play for the full deep dive into the crime, the case against her, and what happens next.

On New Year's Day 2023, Ana Walshe — a mother of three from Cohasset, Massachusetts — was last seen at home. She never returned. What investigators recovered from her husband's digital trail turned a missing-person case into a murder investigation that gripped Massachusetts for two years. This week on the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan walk through the Ana Walshe case in full: the timeline of that New Year's weekend, the search history that became the backbone of the prosecution, and the evidence a Norfolk County jury weighed before convicting Brian Walshe of first-degree murder. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole. This is how the case was built — and what it took to close it. New episodes every Tuesday. Follow the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast so you never miss a case.

Daily Scaries: Crime After Crime brings you under 30 minutes of true crime, shocking videos, current cases, and dark stories—one after another.Brian Scott and Jill Egan take a conversational look at the crime stories making headlines today, along with fascinating cases from the past that you may have forgotten—or never heard about.From breaking crime news and unsolved mysteries to cold cases, bizarre crimes, and stories that leave you asking “How did this happen?”—we move from crime after crime without the long, drawn-out deep dives.🎙️ Daily Scaries: Crime After Crime🕵️ Current crime • Cold cases • Unsolved mysteries • Crime historyNew episodes weekly .Subscribe to Daily Scaries on YouTube and follow us on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

She was found dead at Lumber River State Park on April 27, 2024. Officials ruled it a suicide. Those close to her say that ruling doesn't explain what happened. On this episode of Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan pull back the veil on the Mica Miller case and present the theories around it. We break down her marriage to pastor John-Paul Miller, the control allegations raised by family members, why they continue to question the suicide ruling, and the separate federal case where prosecutors allege cyberstalking and false statements. This is a procedural deep dive into entrapment, power, and the questions still unanswered in Lumber River. Follow Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast for new investigative deep dives every Tuesday.

She predicted her own murder — and named her killer in a letter. On December 3, 1998, Julie Jensen was found dead in her Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin home, poisoned by ethylene glycol. Antifreeze. In the months before her death, she had been quietly documenting her fear: emails to police, and a letter handed to a neighbor with one instruction — open it only if I die. In it, she named her husband, Mark. In this episode, Brian Scott and Jill Egan pull back the veil on one of Wisconsin's most haunting murder cases: a marriage unraveling in silence, a murder weapon sold at any hardware store, and a letter the courts fought over for twenty-five years. It took a decade for the first conviction, a Wisconsin Supreme Court reversal over the letter itself, and a second trial in 2023 to finally put Mark Jensen behind bars for life. No witnesses. No confession. Just a woman who saw it coming — and made sure the truth would outlive her. 🎧 Subscribe to Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast for new investigations every Tuesday — and turn on notifications so you never miss a case. This is Daily Scaries — classic and new true crime cases, and the theories behind them, pulled apart piece by piece.

On July 18, 1984, a gunman walked into a McDonald's in San Ysidro, California, and carried out the deadliest mass shooting in American history at that time. In 77 minutes, James Huberty took 21 lives and wounded 19 others — and left a nation asking how a man's warning signs were missed. In this episode of the Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan pull back the veil on the San Ysidro McDonald's massacre of 1984 — the case that changed how America understood public safety. We break down: The life of James Huberty and the red flags in the weeks leading up to the attack A minute-by-minute timeline of the 77 minutes inside the restaurantThe police response, the standoff, and how the shooting finally ended The victims, the aftermath, and the theories that still linger four decades later 🔴 Viewer discretion is advised.🎧 Listen and Watch the full episode on Spotify, apple podcasts, You Tube , or wherever you get your podcasts. Subscribe and turn on notifications so you never miss an episode. #TrueCrime #SanYsidro #McDonaldsMassacre #JamesHuberty #TrueCrimePodcast #MassShooting #CrimeDocumentary #DailyScaries

Nolan Xavier Wells was 18 when he boarded a boat for Horn Island, Mississippi with friends and never came back. Seven people left the island. Only six returned. This episode breaks down the Nolan Wells update everyone is asking about: why the state autopsy was sealed, what the "undetermined" finding actually means, and why three strangers are now facing federal charges for witness intimidation and hoax bomb threats —charges that have nothing to do with Nolan's disappearance. Brian and Jill separate what's verified from what's spreading online, walk through the full timeline, and lay out the theories investigators are still chasing. If you enjoyed this episode, hit follow so you never miss a story! We drop new episodes every Tuesday. Thank you!

On November 9, 1971, John List murdered his wife, his mother, and his three children inside their home at Breeze Knoll in Westfield, New Jersey — then vanished without a trace. For nearly 18 years, investigators searched for a man who had erased himself completely, building a new name, a new life, and a new identity hundreds of miles away. It took an America's Most Wanted tip — and a forensic sculptor's uncanny prediction of what List would look like nearly two decades later — to finally bring him to justice. In this episode of Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, Brian Scott and Jill Egan dig into the financial pressure and religious justification behind the murders, the meticulous planning that let List escape undetected, and the theories that still surround why he did it.

On this episode of Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast, hosts Brian Scott and Jill Egan dig into the Lane Bryant murders — one of the coldest, most debated unsolved crimes in recent memory. Brian and Jill work through the leading theories together, examine the suspects who were never charged, and lay out what the evidence actually says versus what the internet has assumed for years. This isn't a recap. Brian Scott and Jill Egan walk through the case side by side, weighing the competing explanations and asking the questions that never got answered. Subscribe to Daily Scaries True Crime Podcast for new true crime breakdowns from Brian and Jill. New Episodes drop every Tuesday.