Advertise on podcast: WFAN Daily

Craig slams the New York Giants for naming J.J. McCarthy the starting quarterback, labeling the move a 'desperate train wreck.' He and Big Mac analyze the decision to bench Jameis Winston right before a difficult matchup against the Houston Texans. They also reflect on the Knicks' opening night banner ceremony and loss. (00:01:02) Craig's Tardy Arrival (00:01:33) Giants Name McCarthy Starter (00:04:52) Knicks Banner Ceremony Reaction (00:07:06) McCarthy vs Winston Debate (00:15:21) Caller Defends McCarthy

Big Mac reacts to the New York Yankees press conference where Hal Steinbrenner announced the return of Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone. He criticizes Steinbrenner for pinning the team's postseason failures entirely on the players while shielding management from any accountability. (00:01:00) Opening And Knicks Recap (00:01:46) Yankees Retain Brian Cashman (00:03:40) Steinbrenner Blames Yankees Players (00:07:16) Management Accountability Discussion (00:18:46) J.J. McCarthy And Giants

Aaron Boone faces a brutal line of questioning about the Yankees' continued postseason failures, and even he admits he hasn't proven himself at the highest level. After another October disappointment, Boone is challenged on why his teams consistently struggle against elite competition and whether he's capable of finally delivering a championship. His response? The Yankees still have to prove they can get over the hump. Boone also pushes back against Anthony Rizzo's criticism of the organization's repeated failures, defends his leadership style and refusal to publicly embarrass players, and addresses the Yankees' offensive struggles. Plus, why he believes the Brewers and Rays have an athleticism advantage, whether the hitting staff needs changes, and how the Yankees plan to avoid another disappointing October in 2027.

Hal Steinbrenner is putting the blame squarely on the Yankees' players after another October disappointment, while Brian Cashman gets an extension and Aaron Boone appears safe. Despite spending more than $300 million on payroll, the Yankees still haven't delivered another championship, and Steinbrenner faces tough questions about why the same leadership continues to get opportunities. Is ownership holding the wrong people accountable?

The Knicks raised their championship banner, celebrated their title, and then lost their season opener to the 76ers. But Evan Roberts has a stunning admission: even as a Knicks hater, he couldn't enjoy their defeat! Evan and Tiki Barber explain why the emotional ring ceremony mattered far more than the final score and why Knicks fans shouldn't lose a second of sleep over ugly performances from Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and Karl-Anthony Towns. But the celebration also sparks an unexpectedly emotional moment for Evan. Watching legends from the Knicks' 1973 championship team participate in the ceremony makes him think about Joe Namath and the Jets. With time running out to reunite the franchise's Super Bowl III heroes with a future championship team, Evan shares why the Knicks' special night left him feeling jealous, emotional, and genuinely sad about the Jets' championship drought.

RIght off the bat we ask Phil who he thinks it going to start in Houston and he answers. We talk more Giants and Jets and the QB situation for the Eagles.

The Knicks raised the championship banner last night, but lost to LeBron and the Sixers. We also talked about the championship rings and which employees also get rings.

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' decision to release Najee Harris following his public comments about the team's backfield rotation. They debate John Harbaugh's strict coaching style and look forward to the championship banner ceremony for the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden. (00:01:00) Tuesday Show Introduction (00:02:25) Najee Harris Release Analysis (00:08:06) Giants Quarterback Controversy (00:12:02) Knicks Championship Celebration

The Giants are in first place, but John Harbaugh's quarterback dilemma is threatening to become a major distraction! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber both believe Jameis Winston should remain the starter over J.J. McCarthy, especially with a difficult road matchup against the Houston Texans looming. Tiki warns that the uncertainty could create anxiety inside the locker room, while Evan questions why a division-leading team is even considering a quarterback change. With reports of an uneasy atmosphere surrounding the Giants, the guys debate which quarterback the players actually trust, whether McCarthy's impressive fourth quarter changes the equation, and if Harbaugh could switch back to Winston if the experiment fails. Plus, the Giants still haven't settled their running back situation, and Tyrone Tracy may have earned his chance to take control. Despite all the injuries and uncertainty, Evan and Tiki believe the Giants can still win the NFC East.

The NBA season starts today as the Knicks face the Sixers. A long season ahead. What can we expect?

Craig and C-Mac vent their frustrations regarding the Jets’ embarrassing loss to the Patriots, specifically targeting the play-calling of Frank Reich and Aaron Glenn. They also dive into the New York Giants' backfield issues and the confusing lack of touches for Cam Skattebo. (00:01:06) Jets Coaching Failures (00:05:33) Frank Reich Playcalling (00:09:16) Giants Performance Issues (00:10:14) Skattebo Benchgate Controversy

Joe Benigno is absolutely LIVID after the Jets' latest loss to the Patriots! Joe joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for a fiery rant about the controversial penalty that wiped out a touchdown, Frank Reich's disastrous play-calling, Geno Smith's lack of mobility, and a defense that continues to make costly mistakes. Joe is fed up with the Jets wasting opportunities and demands that they beat the Dolphins and Raiders to keep their season alive. Plus, Joe blasts the media for trying to get Garrett Wilson to turn on the Jets, while Evan wonders whether Wilson actually needs to become more vocal about demanding the football. Could Cade Klubnik get his chance if the Jets fall to 2-6? Joe wants to see what the young quarterback can do before another lost season slips away.

The Giants have a quarterback controversy after J.J. McCarthy nearly pulled off an unbelievable comeback against the Saints! With New York trailing 34-10 in the fourth quarter, McCarthy brought the Giants within one play of a stunning victory. But was his performance really as impressive as the numbers suggest? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy has earned the starting job over Jameis Winston. Tiki goes throw by throw through McCarthy's roller-coaster performance, exposing several dangerous mistakes before a stretch of exceptional passing. Evan makes a surprising comparison, calling McCarthy a younger, more athletic version of Winston. Plus, Tiki breaks down the Giants' final offensive play and explains why Malik Nabers appearing wide open doesn't mean McCarthy missed an easy game-winning touchdown.

Boomer is all for giving JJ McCarthy a shot since we know what Jameis Winston is at this point. Regarding Cam Skattebo, Boomer said there has to be more problems there than just the fumbles.

Buck Showalter discusses the potential lockout and more with Pete Hoffman.