REAL DEAL with Tony Reali is a sports culture podcast built around one irresistible moment at a time. A play. A clip. A photo. A legend. The cultural touchstones of sports that never leave us. Every episode starts small and goes deep into the story behind the story, the feeling behind the moment, and the human truth that explains why it's still living rent-free in our heads years later.
Hosted by longtime ESPN personality Tony Reali, REAL DEAL blends storytelling, humor, nostalgia, emotional insight, and unpredictable energy with guests who complete the story. Athletes, broadcasters, superfans, comedians, journalists and the people nobody else would think to call.
This is neither a debate show nor a recap show. It’s an evergreen sports culture format built around the moments, stories, and emotional chaos that keep sports alive, always.
Advertise on REAL DEAL with Tony Reali
Advertise on REAL DEAL with Tony Reali to promote your brand to thousands of podcast listeners
Unlock REAL DEAL with Tony Reali podcast Email contact info, Listeners & Audience details
Email contact information
Direct podcast contact details
Listeners
Audience numbers & engagement insights
Audience details
Podcast Insights
Podcast episodes
Check latest episodes from REAL DEAL with Tony Reali podcast
PTI Reunion Pt. 2: Stat Boy Brings Back One of Kornheiser and Wilbon’s Favorite Games
2026/10/23
Kornheiser. Wilbon. Stat Boy. One more game.
The PTI reunion continues as Tony Reali brings back Food Chain with Tony Kornheiser and Mike Wilbon to rank the greatest TV duos of all time. From Siskel and Ebert to Madden and Summerall, Muhammad Ali and Howard Cosell to the guys doing the ranking, everybody has a case. And Kornheiser would very much like to go home.
Then, Tony takes you behind the reunion, answers your comments and shares what it felt like to pick up right where they left off. There’s a perfectly reasonable explanation for the Stat Boy stool, the story behind Wilbon’s colorful language, and a little more on the friendship that keeps Kornheiser and Wilbon talking even when the cameras are off.
Finally, Tony ranks PTI’s games, from Good Cop, Bad Cop and Oddsmakers to Food Chain and Role Play. Which ones worked? Which ones didn’t? And how did an enormous cutout of Shaq’s big toe become part of the show?
Twenty-five years of arguments, friendship and finding ways to make each other laugh. That’s worth a little more time. Even if Kornheiser disagrees.
Welcome to Episode 023 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
00:00 Kornheiser would like to go home
00:13 PTI reunion, Part 2
01:03 Food Chain returns: Ranking TV’s greatest duos
03:00 Muhammad Ali, Howard Cosell and an unforgettable insult
04:33 Where do Kornheiser and Wilbon belong?
06:02 How Siskel and Ebert showed them what was possible
08:05 Welcome to REAL DEAL
09:02 About that Stat Boy stool…
10:15 Being a kid again around Kornheiser and Wilbon
11:38 Simply Irresistible: How many games has PTI played?
12:29 Mail Time: Hearing Wilbon swear
13:52 Growing up with PTI
16:12 What Tony hoped to learn about their friendship
18:38 A correction for Stat Boy
19:37 Why Kornheiser and Wilbon still matter
21:32 An Around the Horn reunion?
23:05 Ranking PTI’s games
24:33 Fortune Teller, Time Machine and the games that didn’t last
25:29 Word Up! and Oddsmakers
26:24 Food Chain vs. Role Play
28:48 Coming next: Sarah Spain and the Cubs’ World Series win
Subscribe to REAL DEAL with Tony Reali for new episodes every Tuesday and Friday, celebrating the most irresistible moments in sports.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Kornheiser. Wilbon. Stat Boy. The PTI Reunion You’ve Been Waiting For
2026/10/20
Tony Kornheiser. Mike Wilbon. And the kid they called Stat Boy. Back together, with a few things to clear up.
Before Pardon the Interruption, there was press row. Typewriters. Deadlines. A Washington Post newsroom full of extraordinary writers who could argue about anything and make each other laugh doing it. Kornheiser and Wilbon spent years in that world before anyone put a television camera in front of them. I wanted to know how their friendship began. They wanted me to stop trying to turn it into a screenplay.
As PTI turns 25, I’m back with two people who helped shape my life, revisiting the stories they’ve been telling for as long as I’ve known them. We go back to the 1988 Olympics, a knockout Wilbon saw coming and Kornheiser didn’t, and the Marvin Gaye national anthem that Tony decided was more important than the All-Star Game itself. There’s also the night Mike slipped away from his own engagement party to shoot a television pilot. Tony was supposed to help cover for him. You can imagine how that went.
Then there’s PTI: why Tony thought it would be off the air in three weeks, why they let a 22-year-old correct them on television, and what they make of the sports debate industry today. Through all of it, they keep coming back to the work, the newsroom and the people who made them better. After 25 years on television, they still describe themselves the same way: newspaper sportswriters.
They also reveal that they rarely go more than two days without calling each other. Usually because they’re watching the same game and have something to say. Naturally, I have one more question: If PTI ended tomorrow, would you two actually see each other?
Welcome to Episode 022 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
03:50 Before PTI, there was the newsroom
05:01 REAL DEAL, Stat Boy and the nickname dispute
06:21 Kornheiser and Wilbon’s old photos
08:40 The 1988 Olympics and the knockout Wilbon saw coming
10:48 The Great Wall, a flight home and a face in the soup
13:46 Simply Irresistible: Their Washington Post bylines
15:10 Is PTI an old married couple?
16:37 How did Kornheiser and Wilbon actually become friends?
19:37 The Washington Post newsroom that shaped them
22:55 Do they hang out? Have they ever really fought?
26:48 Sharing the spotlight and welcoming Stat Boy
27:43 Why PTI let a 22-year-old correct its hosts
31:05 Marvin Gaye’s anthem and Kornheiser’s column
32:54 Why Kornheiser thought PTI wouldn’t last
35:27 Wilbon left his engagement party to shoot a TV pilot
37:14 “We are newspaper sportswriters”
38:48 Kornheiser’s clock and Wilbon’s arrival time
40:06 The phone calls that never stopped
41:23 Darko, LeBron and getting predictions wrong
43:12 PTI, hot takes and the state of sports debate
46:14 Fatherhood, grandfatherhood and who’s gotten angrier
48:11 “It’s not my world”: Getting older as everything changes
49:47 If PTI ended tomorrow, would they still see each other?
Subscribe to Tony Reali’s channel for more REAL DEAL: unforgettable sports moments and the people who bring them to life. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Did Carlos Beltrán Really Choke in the 2006 NLCS? Frank the Tank’s Answer Might Surprise Mets Fans
2026/10/16
Bases loaded. Two outs. Game 7. Carlos Beltran at the plate, with a trip to the World Series still within reach. Adam Wainwright throws a curveball, Beltran never swings, and an entire stadium goes silent.
Twenty years later, Mets fans are still looking at that pitch. And looking for someone to blame.
Frank “the Tank” Fleming joins me to relive the final out of the 2006 NLCS, and if you think you know what he’s going to say about Beltran, you might want to hear him out. We watch the at-bat, revisit Endy Chavez’s incredible catch, and get into the missed opportunity Frank thinks really cost the Mets the game. For a man with a list of his most hated Mets, he has a surprising amount of understanding for the guy who kept the bat on his shoulder.
Then we climb the Mets misery ladder. Tom Glavine and the 2007 collapse. Kenny Rogers walking in the winning run. Luis Castillo dropping the pop-up that sent Frank’s kitchen table flying. Matt Harvey going back out for the ninth. And yes, Frank has thoughts about letting Pete Alonso walk.
But we also talk about the kid who carried the burden of the Mets’ 1988 NLCS loss for years, the life Frank has built around being a fan, and whether he would trade any of it to make the frustration go away.
Welcome to Episode 021 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
00:00 Intro
01:34 Carlos Beltran caught looking
02:34 Frank the Tank joins REAL DEAL
03:16 Where Frank watched Game 7
04:40 The injuries that changed the 2006 Mets
06:09 Simply Irresistible: Wainwright’s curveball
08:32 The other side of the story: Wainwright and Molina
10:08 Endy Chavez’s catch and the opportunity the Mets wasted
12:01 Why wasn’t Billy Wagner pitching the ninth?
15:25 Bases loaded, two outs, Beltran at the plate
17:27 Rewatching Beltran’s final at-bat
18:39 Why Frank doesn’t blame Beltran
19:15 Beltran, Gary Carter and retiring Mets numbers
22:08 A great pitch or a hitter choking?
22:47 Piazza, Clemens and the 2000 World Series
25:32 Frank on Mets fandom: “I’m beyond anger”
26:50 Why letting Pete Alonso walk infuriates Frank
28:20 The Mets misery ladder
29:17 Tom Glavine and the 2007 collapse
30:39 Was sending Matt Harvey back out the right call?
31:20 Kenny Rogers walks in the winning run
32:24 Luis Castillo’s dropped pop-up and Frank’s flipped table
33:27 Trading Tom Seaver and the Generation K disappointment
35:46 Frank called the Pete Crow-Armstrong trade
36:30 Pete Alonso, “Pink Pony Club” and Edwin Diaz
37:09 The childhood Mets loss that still hurts
39:18 Would Frank trade away his Mets fandom?
40:16 Frank’s wish for Edwin Diaz and the Dodgers
41:08 How Frank’s life and relationship with sports have changed
42:31 Frank’s weight loss and feeling better at 50
43:30 Frank’s REAL DEAL gift
43:45 Tony’s final thought: Who gets the blame?
Subscribe to Tony Reali’s channel for more REAL DEAL. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
How the Eagles Pulled Off the Philly Special and More Incredible NFL Stories with Peter King
2026/10/13
February 4, 2018. Fourth and goal. Thirty-eight seconds before halftime. Nick Foles walks over to Doug Pederson and asks, “You want Philly Philly?” His proposal: let a tight end throw a touchdown pass to a backup quarterback who has never caught a ball in his NFL career. In the Super Bowl. Against Bill Belichick. Pederson stares at him for 2.23 seconds. Then he says yes.
The great Peter King joins me to relive the Philly Special and the little details that made something so preposterous possible. Why Foles couldn’t smile in the huddle. Why Trey Burton had to keep his glove on. And why Foles turned down $150,000 before playing the greatest game of his life. Tom Brady threw for 505 yards that night. Nick Foles went home with the trophy. Eventually, even Mick Jagger had something to say about it.
Peter’s new book, THE GAME, which is out today, brings together stories from 40 years covering the NFL, and we get into a few more of them: Peyton Manning’s tanning-bed preparation for the combine, the inside help Dak Prescott got before his Cowboys interview, and the quarterback San Francisco picked instead of Tom Brady who became an actual goat farmer. Plus, Peter makes his case for the perfect football career. Brady? Manning? Madden? His answer might surprise you.
Welcome to Episode 020 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
Subscribe to REAL DEAL with Tony Reali for more unforgettable sports moments and the people who bring them to life.
0:00 The Philly Special0:52 Peter King joins REAL DEAL2:11 Why this play still amazes Peter4:35 Doug Pederson’s 2.23-second decision7:24 Don’t smile. Don’t take off the glove.9:26 How the Eagles fooled the Patriots11:04 Nick Foles’ focus and the $150,000 he turned down13:55 Mick Jagger’s shoutout to Nick Foles15:44 How the NFL became a year-round obsession18:17 Peter’s case against an 18th game20:12 The trust between quarterback and coach22:58 Mahomes and Reid vs. Brady and Belichick24:26 What fans don’t know about the NFL26:46 Story time: Picking up Boomer Esiason27:59 Peyton Manning’s bizarre combine preparation29:33 How Dak Prescott got the answers to the test31:00 The 49ers picked a future goat farmer over Tom Brady32:53 The Seahawks’ prank on Marshawn Lynch34:22 Peter’s favorite story: Paul Tagliabue after 9/1137:53 Who had the perfect football career?42:03 Peter’s Philly Special gift43:18 Tony’s final thought on Peter King
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Did This Umpire Cost the Braves a World Series? | Baseball Doesn’t Exist
2026/10/09
Fifteen strikeouts. A playoff win. And a strike zone that still makes you wonder what, exactly, you’re watching.
Let’s go back to Game 5 of the 1997 NLCS. Livan Hernandez is on the mound for the Florida Marlins, Greg Maddux is pitching for the Atlanta Braves, and Eric Gregg is behind home plate. As the game goes on, pitches outside become strikes, Braves hitters start swinging at balls they can barely reach, and Hernandez finishes with 15 strikeouts. Then comes the final pitch to Fred McGriff. Watch it and tell me: HOW is that a strike?
Joey Duffield from Baseball Doesn’t Exist joins me to relive one of the most baffling games in baseball history. We watch the calls, debate how much credit Hernandez deserves, and argue over whether the Braves choked or got absolutely hosed. Joey has some conspiracy theories. I have some objections.
Then we take on a bigger question: Is baseball actually better with mistakes? From Jeffrey Maier’s catch to Armando Galarraga’s stolen perfect game and George Brett’s pine tar eruption, we revisit the calls that got it wrong and gave us stories we’ll never forget.
Welcome to Episode 019 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
Were the Braves robbed? And which blown call in baseball history still bothers you? Tell us in the comments.
00:00 Intro01:34 The Pitch That Still Makes No Sense02:34 Joey Duffield from Baseball Doesn’t Exist Joins03:57 Setting the Scene: The 1997 NLCS04:38 The Numbers Behind Livan Hernandez’s 15 Strikeouts07:33 Growing Up a Braves Fan10:47 Rewatching the Infamous Eric Gregg Game12:58 Eric Gregg’s Strike Zone and Career Fallout14:00 Can an Umpire Have His Own Strike Zone?15:04 The Theories Behind the Eric Gregg Game18:14 How Much Credit Does Livan Hernandez Deserve?20:07 Why Didn’t the Braves Argue More?21:32 Were the Braves Robbed?23:26 The Braves Dynasty That Could Have Been28:05 Is Baseball Better with Mistakes?28:20 Jeffrey Maier’s Controversial Catch29:53 Armando Galarraga’s Stolen Perfect Game32:05 Did Matt Holliday Touch Home Plate?32:58 George Brett’s Pine Tar Eruption34:33 Don Denkinger’s Blown World Series Call35:59 Joey’s Final Verdict on Eric Gregg37:18 Joey’s REAL DEAL Phone Case37:42 Tony’s Final Take: Leaving Room for Human Error
Subscribe to Tony Reali’s channel for more REAL DEAL. You can also listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Reliving One of the Most Exciting Moments in Steelers History with Joey Mulinaro
2026/10/06
February 1, 2009. The Steelers and Cardinals met at Raymond James Stadium for Super Bowl XLIII.
And just before halftime, James Harrison made history.
He picked off Kurt Warner at the goal line and rumbled 100 yards the other way for a touchdown. The longest pick-six ever. This is a man who looks like he cools down at the gym by deadlifting a Toyota Sequoia, but in the span of one play, Harrison looked both superhuman and human. He had just done something no one had ever done, on the sport's biggest stage, and needed an oxygen mask just to make it to the third quarter.
The Steelers won that night, and a 15-year-old Joey Mulinaro celebrated with a Steelers cookie cake, soaking in a memory that would forever be burned into his temporal lobe.
Now Joey joins me to relive the moment and remember the Pittsburgh legends who made it happen.
Welcome to Episode 018 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
00:00 James Harrison's legendary 100-yard pick six
00:54 Joey Molinaro joins REAL DEAL
03:43 Joey remembers watching Super Bowl XLIII
07:20 Simply Irresistible: How long did Harrison's return take?
10:28 Remembering the 2008 Steelers
15:28 Rewatching James Harrison's pick six
20:09 Harrison makes the interception
23:02 How did Harrison actually make it 100 yards?
27:28 The massive Super Bowl swing
30:33 What if Harrison never makes the play?
34:00 Who is the ultimate "Steelers Steeler"?
45:27 Joey Molinaro calls the play as Gus Johnson
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Trying To Wrap Our Heads Around Two of the Most Absurd Play Calls in New York Giants History
2026/10/02
The 2021 Giants were a rough team to watch. Not much went right. There were injuries, tons of losses and, to cap off the season, one of the most baffling and embarrassing sequences in team history.
Jake Fromm was at QB, and the Giants were backed up at their own five-yard line. They ran a QB sneak on 2nd-and-11. Then, on 3rd-and-9, they ran it...again?
That’s the moment we’re covering on today’s REAL DEAL with comedian and die-hard Giants fan John Franklin. John joins me to try to explain the Joe Judge-era Giants, while also revisiting some of the other head-scratching and confounding moments in team history.
We laughed, we cried, and then we laughed again.
Welcome to Episode 017 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
00:00 Intro
03:27 The Giants' Infamous Back-to-Back QB Sneaks
04:22 John Franklin Joins the Show
06:35 WHY Did the Giants Do That?!
09:59 The Longest QB Sneak in NFL History
12:24 Remembering the 2021 Giants
17:28 Breaking Down the First QB Sneak
19:32 The Unbelievable 3rd-and-9 QB Sneak
20:55 Is There ANY Defense for This Play Call?
23:59 Ranking the Giants' Biggest "WHY?!" Moments
24:28 Jaxson Dart's Injury
25:25 The Giants' Coaching Carousel
26:20 Ben McAdoo's Infamous Suit
27:16 Daniel Jones' $160 Million Contract
27:40 The Saquon Barkley Hard Knocks Call
28:37 Benching Eli Manning
29:42 Punting to DeSean Jackson
30:43 The Infamous Giants Boat Photo
31:14 One Medium Pepsi
32:12 John's Final Giants Ranking
33:28 John's REAL DEAL Phone Case
34:26 The Giants Surrender
34:45 The Greatest Giants QB Sneak Ever?
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
How Laremy Tunsil's Draft Night Gas Mask Video Changed the Last Decade of NFL Football
2026/09/29
Let's go back 10 years to the 2016 NFL Draft.
Fourteen minutes before the first pick, it's a normal draft night full of excitement, hope and anticipation. Thirteen minutes before, everything changes. A video of Ole Miss offensive tackle Laremy Tunsil smoking from a gas mask bong hits his own Twitter account, and chaos ensues.
Tunsil's stock plummets, and the Miami Dolphins take him 13th overall. Three years later, after he's turned a disastrous draft night into a Pro Bowl career, Tunsil is at the center of a blockbuster trade to Houston. The fallout from that trade reshaped the NFL for years.
The great Bill Barnwell was gracious enough to join me for this one! He remembers watching the drama unfold in real time, walks me through the full butterfly effect, explains how the leak might play out today, and makes the case that the biggest winner of the whole thing was...Laremy Tunsil.
Welcome to Episode 016 of REAL DEAL. I'm Tony Reali, and I'm so happy you're here.
0:00 The Laremy Tunsil Gas Mask Photo
4:00 How Many NFL Players Did This Moment Affect?
7:00 Bill Barnwell Remembers Watching It Unfold Live
9:13 Why the NFL Draft Broadcast Couldn’t Address It Yet
11:11 Just How Good Was Laremy Tunsil as a Prospect?
14:27 NFL Teams React to the Photo in Real Time
17:47 Who Leaked the Laremy Tunsil Video?
21:14 How Much Money Did Tunsil Lose?
25:09 Would the Same Photo Matter Today?
26:13 The Butterfly Effect Begins
30:13 How the Tunsil Trade Changed the NFL
32:25 From Trey Lance to Jaylen Waddle and Micah Parsons
33:58 How Tyreek Hill Became Part of the Tunsil Tree
35:43 Bradley Chubb and Sean Payton Join the Chain
37:20 The Most Bizarre Images in NFL History
42:04 The 36-Player Laremy Tunsil Family Tree
44:16 The Ultimate Winner: Laremy Tunsil
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Josh Allen’s Iconic Hurdle: Was it the Moment He Became JOSH ALLEN? | Brandon Perna
2026/09/25
Welcome to Episode 015 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
00:00 Josh Allen’s Iconic Hurdle
02:27 Was This the Moment Josh Allen Became Josh Allen?
04:35 Simply Irresistible: Josh Allen Trivia
07:00 What Did We Think of Rookie Josh Allen?
10:26 Breaking Down the Hurdle
13:42 What the Hurdle Told Us About Josh Allen
15:13 Is Josh Allen’s “Hero Ball” a Feature or a Bug?
17:02 What’s Still on the Line for Josh Allen?
20:03 More or Less: Josh Allen Edition
23:14 Brandon Perna’s REAL DEAL Gift
23:45 Does the Josh Allen Hurdle Still Hold Up?
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Rams 54, Chiefs 51: Does This Hold Up as the Greatest Regular Season Game in NFL History?
2026/09/22
Rams 54 Chiefs 51.
This game had everything.
There was a change of venue, from Mexico City to LA, there was a young Patrick Mahomes, slinging it all over the field, there was an ascending Jared Goff, there were touchdowns in the air, there were touchdowns on the ground, there were fumbles, there were interceptions, and there was a whole lot of Samson Ebukam!
It’s a classic NFL regular season game, one that many have dubbed the greatest regular season game of all-time.
To help me determine where this game belongs in the annals of history, I’m joined by Football 301’s Nate Tice. He broke everything down, and shared some mind-blowing insights, about how this game influenced the modern NFL, along the way.
What do you think? Is it the BEST regular season game ever played on an NFL field?
Welcome to Episode 014 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
The Night Vanderbilt Beat Alabama and Took a College Football Tradition to Another Level
2026/09/18
There’s nothing like fan traditions in sports, especially when it comes to college football.
This episode of REAL DEAL takes us back to October 5th, 2024, down in Nashville, where an unranked Vandy was taking on number one-ranked Alabama. Everyone knew how this game was supposed to go. Alabama wins by a bunch, uneventful night, maybe some hot chicken as a late-night snack, and we all go home.
But that’s not what happened.
Vandy won! For one night, and one night only, Diego Pavia was the most famous Commodore, briefly supplanting Lionel Richie.
The fans went nuts and, as is tradition, stormed the field and ripped down the goalposts. But it didn’t end there. They marched the goalposts out of the stadium, all the way down Broadway, and hurled them into the Cumberland River!
Fan tradition at its finest.
College Football Happy Hour’s Lucy Rohden joins us this week to relive all the madness from that night and talk through some of the best traditions in all of college football.
Welcome to Episode 013 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
NFL Week 1 and the Helmet Throw That Cost the Cleveland Browns a Game
2026/09/15
A new NFL season is underway and, just like that, Week 1 is in the books. How are you feeling? Riding the high of a huge win? Proclaiming that the season is over and throwing your team’s jersey in the nearest trash can?
Overreacting to losses, especially in the NFL, is a time-honored tradition. In reality, nothing is ever quite as good or as bad as it seems…yet.
In some cases, though, losses really can be as bad as they seem. That was certainly the case for the Cleveland Browns in Week 1 of the 2002 season, when an over-exuberant Dwayne Rudd threw his helmet in celebration and helped snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.
On today’s show, I relive that infamous moment with Nick Kostos, along with a bunch of other seismic NFL losses. Some were every bit as devastating as they seemed at the time. Others, as Nick points out, aren’t as bad once you add a little bit of context.
What’s the worst NFL loss you’ve ever experienced? Let me know in the comments!
Welcome to Episode 012 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Was Peyton Manning’s 7-TD Game the Greatest NFL Season Opener Ever?
2026/09/11
Seven touchdowns. Zero interceptions. 462 yards.
Peyton Manning, then the Broncos’ quarterback, opened the 2013 NFL season with one of the most ridiculous performances ever, torching the defending Super Bowl champion Ravens and kicking off what would become a record-setting season.
Was it the best start to a season by a quarterback ever? Or maybe by any player ever?!
With Week 1 finally upon us, Tony is joined by Underscore Media’s John Jastremski to relive Peyton’s perfect start and ask a bigger question: How much should we actually believe what we see in Week 1?
Tony and JJ look back at some of the greatest season-opening performances ever, debate Peyton Manning vs. Tom Brady at their absolute peaks, and look at some hypothetical Week 1 overreactions for the 2026 NFL season.
Welcome to Episode 011 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Sam Darnold’s Journey From Jets Meme to Super Bowl Champion
2026/09/08
Out Indefinitely: Mononucleosis.
This phrase instantly evokes a memory of an ESPN graphic that was immediately added to the file of embarrassing things that have happened to the New York Jets. The graphic in question featured Sam Darnold looking locked in, if not menacing, while the text next to him announced that he was out with…mono.
The moment was a microcosm of Darnold’s career as a Jet, and everyone assumed that mononucleosis and “seeing ghosts” would be the most memorable parts of what was supposed to be a storied career.
Then, over time, the worm turned.
A successful season in Minnesota, a move to Seattle, a miraculous season out west and boom: Sam Darnold was a Super Bowl Champion.
Today I’m joined by my old friend Mina Kimes, who’s going to help me figure out if Sam Darnold’s second act is one of the most impressive in NFL history. If it isn’t the best, it’s certainly close.
Welcome to Episode 010 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Could an App State-Michigan Upset Ever Happen Again in College Football? | The Solid Verbal
2026/09/04
On September 1st, 2007, the Big Ten Network made its debut, airing what should have been a relatively uneventful game between Michigan and Appalachian State. Instead, it turned into one of, if not the biggest, college football upsets of all time!
A back-and-forth battle ended with a dramatic blocked field goal, a moment that hasn’t left my mind since it happened. And it begs the question: are upsets of that magnitude dead? Has the disparity between teams made it nearly impossible for an App State to head into the Big House and take down Michigan? Will we ever see something like this again?
To help me relive this moment and explain the viability of a shocking upset in modern college football, I’m joined by Ty Hildenbrandt and Dan Rubenstein of The Solid Verbal. We remember some guys, talk about what an upset would look like in the 2026 college football landscape, and get in our time machines to go back to 2007, when NFL legends were still in college and people were watching games on Sony WEGA televisions.
Welcome to Episode 009 of REAL DEAL! I’m Tony Reali, and I’m so happy you’re here.
Subscribe for new episodes of REAL DEAL every Tuesday. You can also listen on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Thanks The Solid Verbal. If you don’t already listen tot heir show, check it out wherever you get podcasts. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-solid-verbal-college-football/id270037732
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Podcast reviews
Read REAL DEAL with Tony Reali podcast reviews
4.8 out of 5
43 reviews
★★★★★
humkydory 2026/07/15
The Real Deal!
Good to have Tony back! Excited for this
★★★★★
spatz1090 2026/07/15
Refreshing
Tony was outstanding as host of Around The Horn. Now he’s back with a terrific new podcast. It’s great to have him back on the sports scene.
★★★★★
MPR317 2026/07/15
Happy I found this
There’s always so much negativity- happy to hear someone who is positive