Advertise on podcast: Nashvillains

SHOW NOTESFive days after Tammy Wynette was pulled out of her own car and beaten, every camera in America was pointed at the Grand Ole Opry House. Johnny Cash hosted. Dolly Parton won Entertainer of the Year. Country music was having the biggest year it had ever had. Tammy Wynette's name wasn't on the ballot in a single category. This episode is about what happened four miles away, five days earlier — and about the three years leading up to it that most retellings skip. Between her 1975 divorce from George Jones and that October evening, somebody waged a sustained campaign against her. Intruders got into her house fifteen times in one nine-month stretch. The family came home from bowling one night to find every faucet in the house running and slurs written across every mirror and television screen. The house caught fire with her youngest daughter asleep in the back bedroom. Her phones were wiretapped. Her tour bus burned.  A week before the abduction, a stranger walked into her eight-year-old's school and tried to leave with her. Then came the parking lot. A man she said she never saw. A ligature. A broken cheekbone. Eighty miles of back roads and a second car waiting at the drop. He didn't rob her — she still had forty dollars and thirty credit cards. He didn't assault her. He hurt her, and then he was gone. Nashville decided it had theories. Publicity. An affair. George Jones, who didn't help himself by hinting he knew who was behind it. Twenty-two years later, two of Wynette's daughters offered a fifth theory in print — one that pointed inside the house, at a Music Row songwriter she'd married ninety days before. He denied it until he died in 2010, was never charged with anything, and his family is in court over his reputation to this day. Tammy Wynette never changed her story. Not once, in twenty years. In this episode: The 12th CMA Awards, and the ballot her name wasn't on Three years of break-ins, fires and threats before anyone laid a hand on her What she said happened in that car, in her own account Why detectives called it puzzling — and why the crime doesn't work as a kidnapping or a robbery The songwriter she married ninety days earlier, and the hits he'd written for her ex-husband 1998, the exhumation he requested himself, and what the autopsy found The theory her daughters published, and the timeline problem it answers FURTHER READINGTammy Wynette: Tragic Country Queen by Jimmy McDonough (Viking, 2010) — the major biography, built on original interviews. Stand By Your Man by Tammy Wynette with Joan Dew (1979) — her own account, written the year after. Tammy Wynette: A Daughter Recalls Her Mother's Tragic Life and Death by Jackie Daly with Tom Carter (2000). The Three of Us: Growing Up with Tammy and George by Georgette Jones (2011). Contemporary coverage: The Tennessean, October 5, 1978; People; the Washington Post; and Newsweek's "Country Music Mystery," July 18, 1999. Note: One voice heard in this episode is a dramatized recreation. No recording of the 1978 incident exists.

Marcia Trimble was nine years old, a fourth-grader working on her Girl Scout cookie sales in one of the safest, wealthiest neighborhoods in Nashville. Thirty-three days after she disappeared, on Easter Sunday, her body was found in a neighbor's garage, hidden in a plastic wading pool about 150 yards from her home. She had been strangled. What followed became Nashville's most notorious unsolved murder. Investigators fixed early on Jeffrey Womack, a 15-year-old neighbor who was among the last people to see Marcia alive. He passed two polygraph tests, including one given by the police department's own examiner, and still couldn't shake the suspicion. In August 1979, officers in SWAT gear arrested him at two in the morning. The case against him was dismissed on August 11, 1980, for lack of evidence, but the cloud followed him for nearly three more decades. Meanwhile, Jerome Sidney Barrett had been arrested in March 1975 for a separate sexual assault and was still in custody when Marcia's body was found. He was never investigated in her death. According to research for The Suspect, wiretapped calls from a police informant pointing investigators in another direction never made it into the case file. In 2007, while investigating Barrett in the 1975 murder of Vanderbilt student Sarah Des Prez, Metro's cold case detectives found that his DNA also matched evidence from Marcia's clothing. On July 18, 2009, a Davidson County jury convicted Barrett of second-degree murder. He was sentenced to 44 years, on top of the life sentence he was already serving for killing Des Prez. Marcia's mother, Virginia Trimble Ritter, told reporters simply: "After 34 years, it's over." In this episode: The afternoon walk through Green Hills and the last confirmed sightings Easter Sunday, 1975, and the wading pool in the garage How a 15-year-old boy became the city's forever suspect, and what it cost him The informant, the mosque, and the phone calls that never made the file The man who was already in police custody the whole time A DNA match at six trillion to one AUDIO CREDITSpecial thanks to Demetria Kalodimos and Genuine Human for sharing research audio from their work on the Marcia Trimble case. Kalodimos spent more than three decades covering this story in Nashville, first as an anchor and investigative reporter at WSMV-Channel 4 and later as a documentary filmmaker. Her Emmy-winning film Indelible: The Case Against Jeffrey Womack examines the thirty-plus years Womack spent as the only suspect Metro Police ever seriously pursued in a murder he did not commit. Genuine Human: https://genuinehuman.comFURTHER READINGThe Suspect: A Memoir — Surviving Three Decades of Accusation in Nashville's Most Infamous Murder (2012) By Jeffrey Womack and John Hollins Sr., with an introduction by E. Thomas Wood and a foreword by John Seigenthaler. Womack's own account of the investigation, told alongside that of Hollins, the attorney who represented him for more than three decades without charging him a fee. Former Nashville District Attorney Torry Johnson called it "a cautionary tale for law enforcement." Some voices in this podcast were created with Fish Audio AI

In August 1996, Janet March vanished from her Forest Hills home the night before she was scheduled to meet a divorce attorney. Her husband said she'd taken a vacation. It took ten years, an international manhunt, a murder-for-hire plot, and testimony from the killer's own father to prove otherwise — in a case prosecuted without ever finding a body.   Portions of this episode include audio from Off The Record: On The Air — featuring retired Nashville homicide detective Pat Postiglione and reporter Dennis Ferrier in conversation with private investigator Sheila Wysocki — used with permission from the Without Warning Podcast®.  Listen to the full Janet March episode: https://www.tapesearch.com/episode/off-the-record-on-the-air-the-janet-march-case/EJGd93LAGwTnDCKe9V59zp  Without Warning Podcast®: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/without-warning-podcast/id1414584931

Dreamers come to Nashville every day chasing that country music dream. A tiny percentage actually make it. The rest find their own way—some playing for smaller crowds because it's more about the music than fame, some becoming songwriters, some heading back home knowing they gave it everything. And then there's Paul Dennis Reid. He chose a completely different path—one that started with reinventing himself from the ground up. Paul didn't come to Nashville with dreams. He came with certainty. He knew he was going to be the next Garth Brooks. No doubt in his mind. But when reality slammed into his glaring lack of talent, something inside him broke. And instead of working harder to develop his craft, or taking the L and heading back to Texas, Paul made a choice. He got angry. He decided Nashville owed him. And he intended to collect—no matter who had to die in the process.

Kevin Hughes came to Nashville to count the hits — a small-town numbers man who rose to run the charts at Cash Box magazine, right in the heart of Music Row. But the charts were rigged, the payola ran deep, and Kevin had started asking the wrong questions. On the night of March 9, 1989, a masked man with a strange, stiff run stepped out of the dark on 16th Avenue and shot him dead in the street, wounding the young singer walking beside him. Then the trail went cold — for fourteen years. And when the answer finally came, it didn't come from Music Row at all. It came from a wiretap, a drug dealer down in Georgia, and thirteen spent bullets buried in a backyard.Nashvillains uncovers the darkest true crimes in Music City's history — Real crimes. Real villains. One unforgettable city.New episodes drop regularly. Subscribe so you never miss a case, and if this one got under your skin, leave a rating and review — it helps more listeners find the show. CreditsA Hey Dad Productions presentation. Written and produced by Jerry Broadway. Some voices generated with Fish Audio AI.  Musical Score created using Suno. . © 2026 Hey Dad ProductionsThis episode includes AI-generated content.

In November 2013, Nashville gathered to give George Jones the send-off of a lifetime — and when the arena emptied, the after-party rolled down to Second Avenue, to a bar called the Pit and Barrel, freshly made over for a reality show set to air the very next day. Among the last men standing were outlaw singer Wayne Mills — an Alabama football player who'd walked away from the game to chase his musical dreams down the highway — and his friend, the bar's owner, Chris Ferrell. The next morning, one of them would be hours away from death. The how, when and where of the case were obvious.  It was the "why" that absolutely stunned the investigators.Nashvillains uncovers the darkest true crimes in Music City's history — Real crimes. Real villains. One unforgettable city.New episodes drop regularly. Subscribe so you never miss a case, and if this one got under your skin, leave a rating and review — it helps more listeners find the show. CreditsA Hey Dad Productions presentation. Written and produced by Jerry Broadway. Some voices generated with Fish Audio AI.  Musical Score created using Suno. . © 2026 Hey Dad Productions

David "Stringbean" Akeman was a Grand Ole Opry legend and an original Hee Haw star — a banjo man who came up through the Great Depression and never trusted a bank again, keeping his money close and hidden inside his little cabin north of Nashville. Everyone in those hills had heard the rumors of what he kept there. On the night of November 10, 1973, two young men were waiting in the dark when Stringbean and his wife, Estelle, drove home from a performance at The Grand Ole Opry. What happened next shattered Music City's sense of safety and made a whole town start locking its doors. But the cruelest twist of all wouldn't surface for another twenty-three years.Nashvillains uncovers the darkest true crimes in Music City's history — Real crimes. Real villains. One unforgettable city.New episodes drop regularly. Subscribe so you never miss a case, and if this one got under your skin, leave a rating and review — it helps more listeners find the show. CreditsA Hey Dad Productions presentation. Written and produced by Jerry Broadway. Some voices generated with Fish Audio AI.  Musical Score created using Suno. . © 2026 Hey Dad ProductionsThis episode includes AI-generated content.