Advertise on podcast: You've Lost Me: A Lost Rewatch Podcast

Three burnt muffins, Caroline Kidwell, Natalie Santoro, and Anna Seibert, discuss calling all of your ex's contacts. Plus, we learn which box office hit is neither good nor fun.

Two silent baristas, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, close out season two (!!!) by discovering what Lost might have to do with Watchmen, and which popular movie is too long/too boring/too pretentious. It was g'nice to see you!

Two tactless real estate agents, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, argue about whether this one is good, worry about our small ashtrays, prattle on about Michael's motivations, compare Phi Beta Kappa keys, and then decide who we think is out for revenge. Email us at [email protected] if you've ever been caught in a net. #memycarandmyplane

Two bassists for Foghat, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, count how many hatches we've accumulated, reflect on John Locke's useless pathetic life, & decide for sure that Rihanna stans Bernard & Rose. Email us if you've ever been "between places". Why don't you come on over, Valerie? [DON'T LISTEN TO THEIR LIES. THIS IS PERSEPHONE. I DON'T HAVE MUCH TIME--NONE OF US DO. IF YOU WANNA KNOW THE TRUTH ABOUT "YOU'VE LOST ME POD", THE REAL STORY BEHIND THEM, A LIE PULLED TIGHT ENOUGH WILL ALWAYS SNAP UNDER THE BREAKING STRAIN.............................THEY'RE COMING!]

Three nonplussed rock gods, Anna Seibert, Caroline Kidwell, and Andre Colin, discuss book-burning, and our one-year anniversary. The moral of the story is: If you're going to take someone out on a date, do it f*****g right.

Two restaurant violinists, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert, talk groping (cuddling?) your way out of a situation, healing energy, Ian Somerhalder, sleepy Locke, and what song you probably shouldn't sing on The Voice.

Two silly geese, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, take a dip into Descartes, and check in with some heated movie reviewers. Later, we discover what an absolute gem Ron Bottitta is. Which do you think is the horniest treatise?

Two struggling Etsy artists, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, find out who's dumb and strong, talk out John Locke's timeline, and kick ourselves for not recognising Nadia. Then we discuss the white version of The Wiz, and catch some wry little quips in our Actor spotlight! Who is and is not mad at Sawyer!?

Two ESL teachers, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, discuss a devastating banana scarcity, the likelihood that Jennifer exists, & Jae Lee's function on the show. Plus, we raise our eyebrows at Daniel Dae Kim & Yunjin Kim/try to think of anyone Sun would sleep with, all the while wondering if Henry Gale is evil. Could this entire show be a dream? Does anyone remember where we've heard the name Widmore Labs before?

Two blue-eyed teens, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, identify the BRAND NEW island shit-starter!! Then we discuss child indoctrination and try to forget about all the screaming.

Two purveyors of fine wine, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, discuss Babar, Sayid's box of yuckies, & which wars we've heard of. Plus we get into which museum you absolutely must visit in Grand Rapids, Minnesota, Sayid's short hair, and shooting frogs with guns. Tune in to find out how many dogs it takes to make a Disney movie. #ItsPonytailTime

Two experienced pumpkin-eaters, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, talk fake abduction attempts, a celebrity dad lookalike, & that persistent coconut business. Then we really break down who was conning who, & chat about deceptive Hollywood people. Come for Ana Lucia's army, stay for Charlie's blocking in that last scene.