Advertise on podcast: Befumbled: A Bachelor Nation Podcast

Due to Hailey complete lack of commitment to this season (which the girls get into), Annie is in charge of recounting Fantasy Suites and allll the Susie drama. The girls discuss if Clayton or Susie was in the wrong or if these are just two people with different expectations. Of course, the girls yet again speculate how this show will end, and if they’ll finally receive a break from this never ending franchiseAlso, if you’re looking for a recap of the women tell all - this ain’t the place. We couldn’t even bring ourselves to watch it.

Hello our Befumbled folks! Today we chatted through Hometowns — well, a little. Mostly we talked about our childhoods and our love of Disney and Nickelodeon. We swear we eventually got to the actual Bachelor content but... it took a while.

The ladies are so excited to present their first ever episode recorded in the same room! Join Hailey and Annie in Annie's apartment as the girls discuss the last few weeks of Clayton's season. They finally feel like they're getting to the meat and potatoes of Clayton's season, and they make their predictions for how the rest of his season plays out. The girls talk about Sara drama, Hannah Ann's Instagram behavior, and Brendan Quinn's idiocy. And the girls use their investigative genius to make their predictions for future drama! Plug in your headphones and pretend you're hanging out with us!

Hailey and Annie are back and it’s ABSOLUTE chaos. If you don’t want to listen to their amazing banter, skip ahead to 11:00 for bachelor content.The girls discuss Chatty Broads’ new direction and debate the ultimate question: Is Clayton aware of what he’s doing, or is just a himbo? The girls talk about Bachelor’s blatant corporate sponsorships, including… the fishing industry? And of course, they break down shrimp, Shanae, and their predictions for the rest of his season.

Hello, Befumbled nation! This week Annie is on with her pal Stephanie to discuss himboism, Dancing with the Stars thievery and the ill-fated Shrimpcident of Clayton's season.

Hello, team! Today we brought on our favorite future lawyer to ask her all her hot Ivy League goss, what libel/slander really is and so much more. Oh, and we also talked about the latest episode of Colton's — I mean Clayton's — season.

It's a new year, and a new season of this god forsaken franchise. The girls get into their 2022 goals before diving into gossip. They discuss Befumbled's new Twitter account (are you following???) and C*lton's new house with his boyfriend before they dive into Clayton's journey as The Bachelor. Annie gives her best shot at befumbling Hailey. Here we go again...

Hailey and Annie are back, and somehow they don't know the names of one of this season's main characters. In our defense, we've seen 50+ people compete for love this past year... so we are excused. On this ep, we discuss Michelle's finale!

It's Fantasy Suites week, folks! And despite what is normally a juicy-filled episode, the girls are BURNT OUT. Bachelor Nation, we can't keep doing this... and you expect us to watch a whole new season one week after Michelle's?! The things we do for this pod. Hailey is here to befumble Annie this week, but in reality, it's Hailey recapping the episode thanks to a recap article on Vulture--thanks Ali Barthwell! That's what happens when you don't confirm details of your episode before recording. The girls speculate on the finale and continue to sing Michelle’s praises.

Welcome to the shortest episode yet--all thanks to that boring Men Tell All. The girls rehash what little drama there was, including Tayshia's "painful" break up. Annie successfully befumbles Hailey on the bizarre content that there was in this episode--sculptures??? Streaking???? A lawyer??? There isn't much to talk about, but the girls do their best!

Hello hello! We have returned with a guest and we're about to spill to her all the Olivia Rodrigo "Sour"-esque details about the John/Katie situation, along with an episode rundown of Michelle's hometowns! Will our guest be fooled? You'll have to listen to find out.

It's episode 30 and Annie and Hailey decide they should maybe have some sort of podcast introduction? Annie successfully befumbles Hailey, while the girls reflect on what it means to bring someone home to your parents. The girls are still obsessed with Michelle and also confused why Clayton was picked as the next Bachelor. All in a day's work!