Advertise on podcast: Vanished: True Crime and Historical Events

George and Kathryn Kelly: A Chronological True-Crime Story of “Machine Gun Kelly” traces the real lives behind one of the most intimidating names of the Depression-era underworld. Beginning with Kathryn’s early connection to Asher in Pottawatomie County, Oklahoma, this episode follows George Kelly Barnes from failed student and struggling family man to bootlegger, bank robber, and convicted kidnapper. It explores how Kathryn helped transform her husband into the legendary “Machine Gun Kelly,” promoting a fearsome reputation that was often more fiction than fact. At the center of the story is the 1933 kidnapping of Oklahoma oilman Charles F. Urschel. Blindfolded and held for nine days, Urschel quietly memorized sounds, travel times, weather patterns, and the schedule of airplanes passing over his Texas prison. Those observations—combined with marked ransom bills and an expanding federal investigation—helped authorities dismantle the Kelly conspiracy. From Asher and the back roads of Pottawatomie County to Paradise, Texas, Alcatraz, and Kathryn’s final resting place in Tecumseh, this chronological account separates documented history from newspaper mythology. It reveals not only the crimes of George and Kathryn Kelly, but how ambition, publicity, law enforcement, and popular culture created the enduring legend of “Machine Gun Kelly.”

These sources explore the historical records of unidentified aerial phenomena in Oklahoma, beginning with the post-World War II flying saucer craze of 1947. The text highlights documented cases such as that of Byron Savage, a technically trained engineer whose early sighting preceded national media trends and triggered federal intelligence investigations. The narrative examines the roles of the FBI and J. Edgar Hoover, who monitored civilian UFO organizations and conducted credibility assessments to distinguish potential foreign technology from public hysteria. These archives reveal that the military took such reports seriously, integrating them into formal programs like Project Blue Book. Ultimately, the documents illustrate a period of intense Cold War anxiety where official agencies and private citizens alike struggled to categorize unexplained objects in the sky. Together, they provide a detailed historical account of how Oklahoma became a focal point for early government inquiries into the unknown.

This podcast recounts the significant contributions of Etta Ray Beard, a pivotal figure in the early development of Shawnee, Oklahoma. It highlights her role in the Land Run of 1889, where she staked a claim that became a foundational part of the town. The text emphasizes that Etta and her father constructed the very first house in Shawnee, and she later became the town's inaugural postmistress. Furthermore, it describes how Etta and her husband, Henry Beard, became influential community leaders, even having the town of Henryetta named in a way that commemorated their combined names. The account also traces the historical journey of their original cabin, a symbol of Shawnee's beginnings.

This episode focuses on Chisholm Springs, located in Pottawatomie County, Oklahoma, was a significant 19th-century trading post established by Jesse Chisholm. The post, featuring a stockade built by Auguste Pierre Chouteau, served as a crucial supply point during the California Gold Rush. Its historical importance is underscored by its inclusion of a blacksmith shop, fur warehouse, and its recent addition to the National Register of Historic Places. Washington Irving's 1832 visit predates the post's founding, offering early descriptions of the area. Chisholm Springs' legacy reflects the interplay of Indigenous, French, and American cultures in Oklahoma's early development. 💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

This episode details the life and death of Shawnee, Oklahoma Police Chief Marion Farrall in 1907, focusing on his murder by John Curtis Barber. Sources describe Shawnee's burgeoning growth as a city at the time of Oklahoma's statehood, highlighting its economic activity and social fabric. The murder, its aftermath—including Farrall's large funeral and Barber's trial and conviction—and the community's response are thoroughly documented. Additional sources provide background on Shawnee's history and development, including its establishment and the significant role of railroads. Finally, a timeline of events surrounding the murder and a list of key figures involved are presented. 💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

This episode recounts the early history of Tecumseh, Oklahoma Territory, focusing on its establishment in 1891 and the prominent role of Judge W.R. Asher. The text details the land run, the town's initial development, and the activities of its early business owners and residents. It highlights Judge Asher's involvement as probate judge and town trustee, his subsequent career in law and politics, and his eventual departure from Tecumseh. The narrative draws upon land deeds, newspaper articles, and other historical records to reconstruct the town's growth and its key figures.  💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

This episode details the history of Pottawatomie County, Oklahoma, in the early 1900s, focusing on its demographics, economic development driven by agriculture and railroads, and the significant role of Native American tribes like the Citizen Potawatomi Nation. The sources also extensively profile Judge William S. Pendleton, a prominent lawyer and public servant who shaped the county's legal system during its transition to statehood. His career, spanning both Texas and Oklahoma, is highlighted as a testament to his dedication to public service and legal expertise. The growth and challenges of Shawnee, a major city in the county, are also explored within this historical context. 💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

This episode recounts the history of the Carnegie Public Library in Shawnee, from its humble beginnings as a small association in 1901 to its growth and eventual destruction by fire in 1927. The library's development involved securing funding from Andrew Carnegie, moving to various locations, and providing vital community services, such as story hours and school partnerships. Despite facing setbacks, including the devastating fire, the library persevered, quickly relocating and continuing its services. The account highlights the library's significant role in the community, its innovative programs, and its impact on the lives of many, including notable individuals like author Burton Rascoe. 💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

This episode details the history of the Sheriff's office, tracing its origins from Anglo-Saxon England through its evolution in America, with a particular focus on Sidney Schram's career as a deputy sheriff in Iowa and sheriff in Pottawatomie County, Oklahoma. Several sources describe the long history of the office, its role in maintaining law and order, and its transition to an elected position in the United States. Biographical information about Schram is presented, along with demographic data for Pottawatomie County around 1900. 💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

This episode details the December, 24th, 1904 killing of Justice of the Peace Lee Ginn in Macomb, Oklahoma Territory, by constables Wesley Yandell and Ben Mitchell, focusing on the conflicting accounts of self-defense versus premeditation. Newspapers significantly shaped public opinion, and the ensuing trial, though resulting in Mitchell's release on bond, left the ultimate verdicts unclear. Separate notes mention a later, unrelated mystery surrounding the death of Yandell, whose body was reportedly found in a train car, though its identification was disputed. The sources collectively explore themes of frontier justice, media influence, and the challenges of uncovering truth in historical cases. 💵 Support our podcast by making a donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/swhawkinsd

An introduction to our podcast.